ACCESSING the HEALING POWER
of the VAGUS NERVE
EFTA00809967
I I
EFTA00809968
ACCESSING the HEALING POWER
of the VAGUS NERVE
SELF-HELP EXERCISES FOR ANXIETY,
DEPRESSION, TRAUMA, AND AUTISM
Stanley Rosenberg
North Atlantic Books
Berkeley. California
EFTA00809969
Copyright 0 2017 by Stanley Rosenberg. All rights reserved. No portion of this book, except
for brief review, may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form
or by any means—electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise—without
the written permission of the publisher. For information contact North Atlantic Books.
Published by
North Atlantic Books
Berkeley, California
Cover art by jasmine Hromjak
All other illustrations by Sohan Mie Poulsen; 0 Stanley Rosenberg .211
Photographs by Tau Bjorn Rosenberg
Cover design by Nicole Hayward
Book design by Suzanne Albertson
Printed in the United States of America
Accessing the Healing Power of the Vagus Nerve: Self-Help Exercises for Anxiety, Depression,
Trauma, and Autism is sponsored and published by the Society for the Study of Native
Arts and Sciences (dba North Atlantic Books), an educational nonprofit based in Berkeley,
California, that collaborates with partners to develop cross-cultural perspectives, nurture
holistic views of art, science, the humanities, and healing, and seed personal and global
transformation by publishing work on the relationship of body, spirit, and nature.
North Atlantic Books' publications arc available through most bookstores. For further
information, visit our wcbsite at www.northadanticbooks.com or c
MEDICAL DISCLAIMER: The following information is intended for general information
purposes only. Individuals should always see their health care provider before administering
any suggestions made in this book. Any application of the material set forth in the following
pages is at the reader's discretion and is his or her sole responsibility. The author takes full
responsibility for representing and interpreting the ideas related to the Polyvagal Theory. The
author's interpretations and representations of the Polyvagal Theory may vary in intent and
accuracy from the writings and presentations by Dr. Stephen W. Purges.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Rosenberg, Stanley, 1940—
Accessing the healing power of the vagus nerve : self-help exercises for anxiety,
depression, trauma, and autism I Stanley Rosenberg.
pages cm
ISBN 978-1-62317-024-0 (Trade paperback) — ISBN 978-1-62317-025-7 (Ebook)
I. Depression, Mental—Alternative treatment 2. Anxiety—Alternative treatment.
3. Autism—Alternative treatment 4. Vagus nerve. 5. Self-care, Health. I. Title.
RC537.R63844 2016
616.85'27—dc23 2015028780
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 printer 23 22 21 20 19 18
North Atlantic Books is committed to the protection of our environment. We partner with
FSC-certified printers using soy-based inks and print on recycled paper whenever possible.
Printed on recycled paper.
EFTA00809970
To Linda Thorborg
EFTA00809971
I I
EFTA00809972
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Foreword by Stephen Porges, PhD xi
Foreword by Benjamin Shield, PhD xv
Acknowledgments xvil
Preface xix
Introduction: The Autonomic Nervous System iocir
PART ONE: Anatomical Facts Old and New: The Polyvagal Theory 1
Overcoming Health Challenges: Are You Fighting the Heads
of the Hydra? 1
The Heads of the Hydra: Common Problems Related to Cranial-
Nerve Dysfunction 3
Chapter 1:Get to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System...__....__....__...._ 7
The Twelve Cranial Nerves 7
Cranial Nerve Dysfunction and Social Engagement 13
Treating the Cranial Nerves 21
The Spinal Nerves 22
The Enteric Nervous System 26
Chapter 2: The Polyvagal Theory__....__....__....__....__.__....__....__....__....__ 29
The Three Circuits of the Autonomic Nervous System 29
Goldilocks and the Three ANS States 30
The Five States of the Autonomic
Nervous System 33
The Vagus Nerve 36
Two Branches of the Nerve Called "Vagus" 39
=Stress: and the Sympathetic Nervous System 49
EFTA00809973
Chapter 3: Neuroception and Faulty Neuroception 57
Faulty Neuroception and Survival 57
Other Causes of Faulty Neuroception 61
The Story of Antacus 62
Chapter 4: Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve 65
Simple Evaluation from Facial Observation 65
Objectively Evaluating Vagal Function through Heart Rate
Variability (HRV) 69
Testing for Vagal Function: Early Experiences 71
Discovering the Polyvagal Theory 73
Testing for Vagal Function: Cottingham, Porges, and Lyon 78
A Simple Test of the Pharyngeal Vagus Branch 81
How to Test for Pharyngeal Ventral Branch Function 82
Therapists can Test for Vagal Function without Touching.... 84
Chapter 5: The Polyvagal Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care? 87
A Polyvagal Approach for Psychological and
Physical Conditions 88
The Healing Power of the Polyvagal Theory 91
Relieving COPD and Hiatal Hernia 91
Treating a Hiatal Hernia 98
Diaphragmatic Breathing 101
Shoulder, Neck, and Head Pain: CN XI, Trapezius, and SCM 102
The Levator Scapulae Muscle 104
The "Trap Squeeze Test" for Shoulder and Neck Problems 115
Health Problems Related to Forward Head Posture 117
Relieving Migraine Headaches 123
Chapter 6: Somatopsychological Problems. 131
Anxiety and Panic Attacks 135
Phobias 141
Antisocial Behavior and Domestic Violence 143
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) 151
EFTA00809974
Depression and the Autonomic Nervous System 156
Bipolar Disorder 157
ADHD and Hyperactivity 161
Chapter 7: Autism Spectrum Disorders 163
Hope for Autism: The Listening Project Protocol 166
The Role of Hearing in Autistic Spectrum Disorders 171
Treating Autism 177
Technique for Rounding a Flat Back of the Head 178
Concluding Remarks 183
PART TWO: Exercises to Restore Social Engagement 185
The Basic Exercise 186
Neuro-Fascial Release Technique for Social Engagement 195
The Salamander Exercises 199
Massage for Migraines 204
SCM Exercise for a Stiff Neck 206
Twist and Turn Exercise for the Trapezius 208
A Four-Minute Natural Facelift, Part 1 212
A Four-Minute Natural Facelift, Part 2 217
Severing all the Heads of the Hydra 219
Appendix 219
Notes 221
Index 233
About the Author 235
EFTA00809975
I I
EFTA00809976
FOREWORD
I met Stanley in June 2002, when I spoke at the United States Association
for Body Psychotherapy Conference in Baltimore. The evening before
my talk I received a message from Jim Oschman asking if he and Stanley
could attend. Jim explained that I would enjoy meeting Stanley and
learning about his work. After my talk, Stanley explained his desire to
identify objective measures, such as heart rate variability, that could be
used to conduct research to validate the clinical work he was doing.
I was curious and wanted to learn more about his work, his approach,
and why he was interested in measurements of vagal function. I mentioned
to him that I had spondylolisthesis, a condition in which a vertebra slides
forward over the bone below it. He casually responded, "I can fix it." I
asked him how long he thought it would take. He said about ten to fifteen
seconds! At this point I was trying to figure out what he could do in ten
to fifteen seconds. I had assumed, based on his training in Rolfing and
craniosacral techniques, that his treatment would require several sessions.
Given my history with an orthopedic specialist, I was curious if a somatic
therapy could be effective. The suggestion that it could be rehabilitated
in a few seconds was outside my worldview.
My diagnosis was based on a slippage in the lower spine at the junction
of lumbar and sacral vertebrae. The slippage caused back pain and possibly
a progressive deterioration that would lead to surgery. I was diagnosed by
an orthopedic surgeon, who imposed on me a fear of surgery to motivate
progress in physical therapy. Following my graduation from physical
therapy, I went to a sports medicine physician who prescribed a back
brace to limit mobility. From this portfolio of health care professionals,
I received contradictory instructions; the physicians encouraged me to
immobilize the lower back, while the physical therapists encouraged me to
move and work on flexibility. By the time I met Stanley, it was not dear to
me how to treat my condition to minimize symptoms and avoid surgery.
Wh t Stanley generously offered tom,"welcomed the
opportunity. Stanley instructed me to go on my hands and knees, and
xi
EFTA00809977
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
to relax and keep my spine relatively level. Then, with the fingers from
both hands going in opposing directions, he moved the tissue over the
vertebrae that had slipped. As he did this, the vertebrae immediately
and effortlessly slipped into position. For fifteen years I have used a
modification of his procedure to remain pain free.
I understood immediately what he was doing. The physical
manipulation, which gently moved the upper levels of tissue, signaled
the body to relax. The relaxation was sufficient to reorganize the neural
muscular regulation that supported the spine, allowing the vertebra to
gently fall into place. Thus Stanley was transmitting signals of safety to
the neuromuscular system that enabled the system to immediately shift
from a defensive state of contraction, in which it attempted to protect
the vulnerability of the lower spine, to a state of safety in which a gentle
touch would functionally allow the system to find its natural position.
Stanley's method confirmed that a metaphor of safety is manifest
throughout the body and not merely in the social engagement system
via the muscles of the face and head, or in the viscera via ventral vagal
pathways. In all aspects of the human anatomy, safety is expressed
by the down regulation and the constraint of defense. When safety
occurs, the structures can retune themselves to support health, growth,
and restoration. Functionally, Stanley's work is based on his implicit
understanding that when the nervous system is manifest in a state of
safety there is a welcoming to touch, which can be used to align bodily
structures and optimize autonomic function.
Our first meeting captured Stanley's essence and brilliance. It
captured his passionate desire to alleviate pain and suffering. It captured
his compassionate approach that supports states of safety through
gentle co-regulation. And it captured his intuitive understanding of the
integrated systems of the body.
Stanley and I have now been good friends for fifteen years. In multiple
visits we have discussed how his manipulations shift autonomic state to
promote health, growth, and restoration. As this book conveys, he has
brilliantly integrated features of the Polyvagal Theory with features from
craniosacral and other somatic therapies. To do this, he artfully extracted
xii
EFTA00809978
Foreword
the primary principle of the Polyvagal Theory: the structures of the body
become welcoming to touch and manipulation when in a state of safety.
According to the Polyvagal Theory, the body, including the neural
regulation of skeletal muscle, functions differently when in a state
of safety. In the state of safety, ventral vagal pathways coordinate the
autonomic nervous system. In this state, the defensive features of the
autonomic nervous system are constrained, and the body is welcoming
not only to the social engagement behaviors of prosodic vocalizations and
facial expressions, but to touch. Underlying Stanley's clinical successes
is his ability to connect and co-regulate the client through interactions
between the client's social engagement systems, and to convey cues of
trust and concern that trigger the beneficial attributes of the ventral vagal
circuit in promoting a state of safety through the entire body.
Stanley is not a traditional therapist trained within a discipline. His
training crosses disciplines, and his approach is more consistent with
the traditions of a healer. Healers enable the body to heal itself, and
Stanley functions in this role. He co-regulates his clients, enabling and
empowering them to heal through the body's own mechanisms. His
interest in the Polyvagal Theory comes from his implicit understanding
that when states of safety are manifest in the structures of the body, the
body is poised to serve as a platform for healing.
Accessing the Healing Power of the Magus Nerve is Stanley's personal
expression of his insight into and appreciation of the role that vagal
pathways play in the healing process by calming the body and enabling
the body to welcome touch. By intuitively understanding this integrated
process, Stanley has developed a system of manipulations that promote
states of safety, allowing the body to retune the nervous system, thus
optimizing behavior, mental health, and physiological homeostasis.
As a scientist, I do not experience the world of the therapist. As a
therapist, Stanley does not experience the world as a scientist. However,
Stanley's gift lies in his ability to implicitly organize information from
science and to apply it therapeutically in an intuitive, insightful, and
helpful manner. Stanley's contributions as a creative therapist are unique
within the complex health care environment. Fortunately, his powerful
EFTA00809979
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
insights, metaphors, and treatment models are beautifully conveyed and
archived in Accessing the Healing Power of the Vagus Nerve.
Stephen W. Porges, PhD,
Distinguished University Scientist, Kinsey Institute,
Indiana University, and professor of psychiatry,
University of North Carolina
xiv
EFTA00809980
FOREWORD
There are times in history when need is met with equal brilliance. We are
blessed with one of these rare moments. Stanley Rosenberg's Accessing the
Healing Power of the Vagus Nerve gives the reader tools to navigate and
treat some of the most complex of maladies.
Stanley brings forward this new wave of thought with the foundation
of his almost half-century of clinical experience, trainings, and teaching.
Accessing the Healing Power of the Vagus Nerve provides insights into
the genesis of physical and emotional conditions, the reasons why they
often have not been successfully treated with conventional methods, and
effective tools to resolve them.
Our well-being is dependent on a functional and adaptive nervous
system. At the heart of our adaptability, especially to stress, is the vagus
nerve. This cranial nerve is integrated into our entire physical and
neurological matrix. The vagus nerve is central to every aspect of our life.
It can provide us with deep relaxation as well as offer immediate response
to life-and-death situations. It can be both the cause and the resolution of
countless disorders. Additionally, the vagus nerve can provide us with the
needed deep personal connection to others and our environment.
I have had the privilege of knowing Stanley for over thirty-five years.
I have studied together with him, learned from him, and taught for the
Rosenberg Institute. I know of no other practitioner more qualified to
bring together all the essential elements that are presented in this book.
Accessing the Healing Power of the Vagus Nerve unlocks the mysteries
of chronic disorders. There are many books published that explain these
conditions, but none so successfully delves into the underlying basis of
how and why these conditions develop.
Whether for therapists, sufferers, or simply readers who wish to
learn more about themselves and others, Accessing the Healing Power
of the Vagus Nerve is a must-read. We owe Stanley Rosenberg a debt of
xv
EFTA00809981
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
gratitude that he has woven his decades of insight into a fascinating
and unforgettable work.
Benjamin Shield, PhD,
author of Healers on Healing, For the Love of Cod,
Handbook for the Soul, and Handbook for the Heart
xvi
EFTA00809982
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Thanks to Stephen Porges, who formulated the Polyvagal Theory—his
teaching and writings opened a world of understanding and have allowed
me to help many people in my clinic and to teach other clinicians. He
has been a friend for more than a decade and an inspiration in my for-
mulating and writing of this book. He also reviewed an early draft of this
manuscript and helped to clarify important points.
Thanks to Alain Gehin, my friend, mentor, and primary teacher in
osteopathy and craniosacral therapy for more than twenty-five years. I also
extend my gratitude to Professor Pat Coughlin at Geisinger Commonwealth
School of Medicine (formerly known as the Commonwealth Medical
College), who has been my main teacher of anatomy and physiology and
who helped to edit the anatomical references in this text. Linda Thorborg
was an inspiration in the development of many aspects of my hands-on
techniques and has co-taught optimal-breathing courses with me.
Thanks to Kathy Glass, my developmental editor, who took my chaotic
notes and shaped them into this book. I have been living in Denmark and
speaking Danish for thirty-five years, and my English language, especially
my written language, has suffered. Looking back, I see that Kathy took
on a near-impossible task of helping me to formulate my thoughts—and
completed it with style. Benjamin Shield and Jacqueline Lapidus also
helped me with the editing of early drafts.
Also, thanks to Mary Buckley and Erin Wiegand, editors from North
Atlantic Books, who helped put my manuscript into its final shape.
Thanks to some of my other teachers, including Jim Oschman, who
wrote the book Energy Medicine; Tom Myers, author of the book
Anatomy Trains; my four teachers in tai chi and chi gung: John Chung Li,
Ed Young, Professor Cheng Man-Ch'ing, and Hans Finne; my teacher in
mindfulness and Vipassana meditation, Joseph Goldstein; my teachers in
Rolfinge: Peter Melchior, Peter Schwind, Michael Salveson,,Louis Schului
and Timothy Dunphy, Ann Parks, and my other teachers in healing,
massage, and other body therapies over the years.
xvii
EFTA00809983
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
Thanks also to my colleagues at the Stanley Rosenberg Institute, as
well as all of my students, patients, and my many friends over the years,
especially Ira Brind, Benjamin Shield, Anne and Philip Neess, Lise Pagh,
Charlotte Soe, Mohammed Al Mallah, Gordon Enevoldson, DeeDee
Schmidt Petersen, Trine Rosenberg, and Donna Smith. Thanks to Filip
Rankenberg and my other colleagues at Manuvision.
Also, thanks to Sri Sri Ravi Shankar for his interest in our form of
craniosacral therapy and for his support over the years.
Thanks to my children, Annatrine, Erik, and Tau; my grandchildren;
my mother and father; and my brothers, Jack, Allen, and Arnold.
xviii
EFTA00809984
PREFACE
Stanley Rosenberg, an American-born body therapist living in
Denmark. This book proposes a new approach to healing based on
my experiences as a body therapist working within the framework of a
completely new understanding of the function of the autonomic nervous
system—the Polyvagal Theory, developed by Dr. Stephen Porges.
The autonomic nervous system not only regulates the workings of our
visceral organs (stomach, lungs, heart, liver, etc.) but is closely tied to our
emotional state, which directly influences our behavior. Thus the proper
working of our autonomic nervous system is central to our emotional as
well as physical health and well-being. Dr. Porges's Polyvagal framework
has allowed me to achieve positive results with health issues as far-ranging
as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), migraine headaches,
and autism—to name just a few.
I have been doing various forms of body therapy for more than forty-
five years. That career was a far cry from Swarthmore College, from which
I graduated in 1962 after majoring in English literature, philosophy, and
history, participating in an intensive honors program. When I go to
college reunions, I find that most of my friends became college professors,
doctors, lawyers, psychologists, and other professionals. I am the only
body therapist out of the two hundred and fifty students from my class.
BEHIND THE SCENES:THE PHILOSOPHY OF ACTING
During my time at Swarthmore I became interested in theater, and
Japanese theater in particular. That led me to a graduate program in
theater at the University of Hawaii, where we put on plays from Japan,
China, India, and Thailand. After two years, I left the sandy beaches of
Honolulu and moved to the crowded, dirty, noisy streets of the Lower
East Side of Manhattan along with other young theater hopefuls.
From time to time, I helped Ellen Stewart, the producer of La MaMa, a
popular off-off-Broadway theater where aspiring actors and directors put
xix
EFTA00809985
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
on new plays by hopeful but as yet undiscovered playwrights. I do not know
whether it was my fate, my good luck, or my nose for finding good people
to work with, but I was blessed that Ellen took me under her wing. After
touring with her and a small theater troupe through Europe, Ellen insisted
that I visit the Odin Theater, a small experimental venue in Denmark
On Ellen's recommendation, I ended up as assistant to Eugenio Barba,
director of the Odin Theater. Barba wanted the actors to create something
new in every detail of their performance. On one occasion, Barba and
his actors spent two days rehearsing one small scene—trying variations
of staging, expressive body movements, and unusual patterns of vocal
expression—that took only ninety seconds when it was finally finished
and incorporated into the play.
Barba had been trained for three years as an assistant director at a
Polish theater directed by Jerzy Grotowski, who had a reputation for
doing some of the most exciting theater performances in the world
at that time. Grotowski was both an innovative theater director and a
theorist of the connections between mental, physical, and emotional
processes. Grotowski's actors explored the physical and emotional aspects
of extreme moments in the lives of their characters. They went into a
world that was halfway between reality and fantasy, exploring dreamlike
states invoked by traumatic experiences.
After three years as Grotowski's assistant. Barba also spent a year in
India studying classical Kathakali dance theater, which uses extraordinary
forms of stylized expression including masks, costumes, makeup, and
frequent use of mime. To attain the high degree of flexibility and muscle
control required for this art's body movements and footwork, Kathakali
dancers undergo a strenuous course of training. To help them meet these
challenges and achieve the necessary flexibility, they receive sessions of
body massage.
All of these experiences influenced Barba and the Odin Theater; the
acting training that I experienced there had its origins in Grotowski's work,
and included acrobatics, yoga, and freestyle movement improvisation. I
stayed at Barba's theater for an entire year, taking part in the daily training
in voice, movement, and emotional expression.
)C(
EFTA00809986
Preface
In his "Statement of Principles," Grotowski wrote, "The main point
then is that an actor should not try to acquire any kind of recipe or build
up a "box of tricks." This is no place for collecting all sorts of means of
expression:" My exposure to this philosophy at the Odin Theater shaped
my approach to everything I did for the rest of my life, including learning
and exploring body therapy.
In voice training, for example, we did not sing a song with a melody
and text written by someone else. We did not try to imitate anything
that we heard someone else do, but to explore the world of sounds that
we generated in our own imagination—sounds that we had never heard
anyone make before. This could take hours, days, or sometimes a week
or more before I felt I had succeeded in making the exact sound I had
imagined—and there was no one else who could judge whether I had
made the "right" sound or not. Once I had made that sound, I never
repeated it. I went on to the next sound that appeared in my imagination,
and worked toward expressing that.
This same approach has manifested itself in my approach to bodywork.
Main Gehin, my primary teacher and mentor in craniosacral therapy,
visceral massage, and osteopathic techniques, once said something very
similar to what learned at Odin Theater: "You learn techniques to
understand principles. When you understand the principles, you will
create your own techniques." He also continually emphasized one
principle: "Test, treat, and then test again."
TAI CHI
Body therapy came naturally into my work of teaching actors. As a teacher
and director, I pushed actors out of their comfort zones and beyond the
usual limitations of their movement and vocal expression. We worked,
for example, with mime and acrobatics. Along the way I found a short
book on shiatsu massage, and I included that as part of our training to
help the body move better.
While I was exploring the world of experimental theater in New York
City, I also learned tai chi from Ed Young, a student and translator of
xxi
EFTA00809987
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
Professor Cheng Man-Ch'ing, one of the great tai chi masters of the
twentieth century. Tai chi is unparalleled as a source of knowledge about
natural ways of moving the body. Practicing the tai chi form every day is
the kung fu of knowing yourself, similar to deeper forms of meditation
in other traditions.
The movements of tai chi are continuous, spiraling, and "soft"
compared with those of "hard" styles of self-defense such as karate,
where the movements are in straight lines, fast, and with definite
beginning and ending points. The goal of tai chi as a martial art is not
to become stronger and faster than your opponent but to use your own
body awareness, flexibility, and kinesthetic sense to find where your
opponents are tense—and then "help" the opponents use their own force
against themselves.
The ideal of tai chi is to use "a force of four ounces to deflect a thousand
pounds." This concept has become an integral part of my body therapy.
Some people doing massage and body therapies push hard into their
client's body, with the intention of going deep. By contrast, I try to find
the exact center of tension and the exact angle for me to push to increase
the tension, and then use the minimum amount of force necessary to get
the body to release itself. I often use no more than a few grams of pressure.
ROLFING AND OTHER INSIGHTS
After five years in New York, I moved back to Denmark and taught acting
at the National Theater School for a year. Being a foreigner and trying
to make headway in the Danish theater world without any network was
harder than I had thought. So I decided to leave my work in theater and
to support myself teaching tai chi and giving body therapy sessions.
In Denmark I kept hearing about Rolfinge, a form of hands-on body
therapy created by Ida Rolf' that had the reputation at that time of being
the gold standard of body therapy. (Rolling is a form of "structural
integration," the generic name for a form of connective-tissue massage
that has the goal of helping clients have better posture, breathing, and
movement.)
EFTA00809988
Preface
The idea of working from an inner intention, as we had done in our
voice training at Odin Theater, came up in my discussions with Siegfried
Libich, a German Rolfer. When he mentioned "working with intention"
as an important element of Ida Rolf's teaching, I decided to take a series
of ten Rolfing sessions with him. The effect of those sessions on me was
so profound that I decided to learn the approach myself I became one of
the first of three Rolfers in Denmark, and I have now been working with
this form of bodywork for more than thirty years.
In theater, actors usually take on the physical tensions of their
characters, but in Rolfing we work to release the typical physical
characteristics and habitual emotional patterns that limit our clients,
restrict their movements, and cause pain and discomfort. The focus is
on balancing tensions in the connective tissues of the body rather than
"relaxing" the muscles, which is the usual approach to body therapy. The
result is that they can move in new ways and have greater emotional
flexibility. They can liberate themselves from cliches that have previously
limited their freedom of expression, and move toward a more creative
and authentic version of themselves.
Rolfers not only work with their hands; they also learn to read the
body. Movement and postural analysis are an important part of the
training that other modalities of body therapy had not yet begun to teach.
Rolfers ask,"Where is the body out of balance? Where is the flow broken
in a movement? What needs to be done to bring it back into `shape'?"
After I had been Rolfing for a few years, I began to hear other Rolfers
talking about craniosacral therapy as a new frontier in body therapy. I
went on to study that too, as well as other forms of osteopathic techniques
including visceral massage and joint manipulation. During the following
twenty-five-year period, I kept on learning from the best teachers I could
find, attending advanced classes and trainings at least thirty days a year.
In Denmark I was able to develop my skills as a body therapist
slowly, over more than four and a half decades. I am currently in my
mid-seventies, and I believe that my life has moved more slowly here in
Denmark than if I had followed a similar path doing body therapy in
the United States, where financial opportunities are greater and more
Erin
EFTA00809989
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
tempting, so that many successful therapists outgrow their practices
and move on to other more lucrative endeavors. Also, I believe that the
fashions regarding, which therapy is "in" and which is "out" change
more quickly in the United States than in Denmark. I have been blessed
to be able to follow my own path at my own tempo. Alain Gehin, my
craniosacral teacher, said that becoming a skilled body therapist is not
so much "knowing about" something intellectually but "learning how
to do something with your hands." He claimed that a body therapist
first begins to attain what the French call savoir faire-"know-how"—
after giving ten thousand sessions. I have an image of myself, despite
my American roots, as having apprenticed to become an Old-World
European craftsman. I have had time to study, to practice, and to develop
skills. I have had the luxury to be able to keep reaching for a greater level
of finesse, sensitivity, and creativity with my hands.
All these ingredients were in the mixing bowl when I met Stephen
Forges and was blown away by his new interpretation of how the auto-
nomic nervous system functions—which I will explain later in this book.
xxiv
EFTA00809990
INTRODUCTION:
THE AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM
A discovery is said to be an accident meeting a prepared mind.
—Albert Szent-Gyorgyi, Hungarian-born biochemist
(1893-1986) who won the Nobel Prize for his discovery
of Vitamin C in 1937'
It doesn't matter how much you drive around, you will never
get to where you want to go if you don't have the right map.
—Stanley Rosenberg
I practiced various forms ofbody-oriented therapies for more than thirty
years, but I eventually realized that I was using the wrong map. When
I learned about Stephen Porges's Polyvagal Theory, his ideas expanded
my understanding of how the autonomic nervous system functions, and
immediately I had a better map.
The autonomic nervous system is an integral part of the human
nervous system, monitoring and regulating the activity of the visceral
organs—heart, lungs, liver, gall bladder, stomach, intestines, kidneys,
and sexual organs. Problems with any of these organs can arise from
dysfunction of the autonomic nervous system.
Before the Polyvagal Theory, there was a widely accepted belief that the
autonomic nervous system functioned in two states: stress and relaxation.
The stress response is a survival mechanism activated when we feel
threatened; it mobilizes our body to prepare to fight or flee.' So in the
stress state, our muscles are tense, thus enabling us to move faster and/or
exert more power. The visceral organs work to support this extraordinary
effort by our muscular system.
When we have won the fight and neutralized the threat, or when we
have gotten far enough away so that we are no longer in danger, our
relaxation response kicks in. We remain in this relaxed state until the
EFTA00809991
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
next threat appears. In the old view of the autonomic nervous system,
relaxation was characterized as the "rest and digest" or "feed and
breed" state. This state was attributed to the activity of the vagus nerve,
also known as the tenth cranial nerve, which, like all cranial nerves,
originates in the brain or the brainstem. In this old, universally accepted
interpretation, our autonomic nervous system vacillated between states
of stress and relaxation.
However, problems arise when we get stuck in a stress state even when
the threat or danger has passed, perhaps because our work or lifestyle
is continually stressful. For many decades, chronic stress has been
recognized as a health problem, with an enormous amount of scientific
research devoted to understanding the harmful effects of long-term stress.
Attempts to treat and manage chronic stress spawned a widespread
movement on the part of health-care practitioners, who wrote (and
continue to write) a vast number of popular articles for a general audience
in newspapers, magazines, books, and blogs. The pharmaceutical industry
also began to provide a wide range of anti-stress drugs that have netted
the corporations handsome profits as the use of these medications has
soared. Yet, in spite of all these resources, many people continue to feel
that they have not been helped sufficiently. They still feel stressed. Many
believe that our society is getting more and more stressful every year, and
that individuals are more stressed out as a result.
Perhaps the problem is that we have been using the wrong map. With
the old understanding of the autonomic nervous system, we have not yet
been able to find truly effective methods of stress management.
Like almost everyone working in the medical world and the alternative-
therapy scene, I shared existing beliefs about the way that I thought the
autonomic nervous system worked. Every day in my clinical practice,
I used what I had learned about the old stress/relaxation model of the
autonomic nervous system. The fact that my treatments worked served as
a confirmation that this understanding of the autonomic nervous system
was correct.
I enjoyed passing on what I had learned to students who wanted
to acquire the various skills of body therapy that I had been using
xxvi
EFTA00809992
Introduction: The Autonomic Nervous System
successfully. I taught the old model of autonomic nervous system function
in all my courses in body therapy. As my classes filled, I founded a school,
the Stanley Rosenberg Institute in Silkeborg, Denmark. In 19931 invited
a few of the therapists I had trained to teach some of the introductory
courses so that 1 could concentrate on teaching the more advanced
courses. Eventually other teachers took over the more advanced courses
as well.
The specialty of our school was craniosacral therapy, which has its
origins in the work of William Garner Sutherland (1873-1954), an
American osteopath and the founder of osteopathy in the cranial field
(OCF). (Osteopaths in the United States are licensed, with the same
basic training and privileges as medical doctors.) While exploring dried
cranial bones in an anatomy dissection lab, Sutherland found that he
could fit the sawtooth edges of adjacent cranial bones together—but he
noticed the possibility of slight movement between two adjacent bones.
At the time, the belief was that if something existed in nature, there
must be a reason for it. Sutherland postulated that the movement of the
bones facilitated circulation of the cerebrospinal fluid, and he gathered
techniques into what has become "craniosacral therapy."
CRANIAL BONE MOVEMENT
The cranial bones are held together by a system of elastic membranes
that allow for slight movement between the individual bones. When
Sutherland carefully palpated the bones of his patients' skulls, he was
able to sense a slight but perceptible movement of the individual bones
of the cranium in relationship to each other.
Sutherland noticed that many of his patients with medical problems
originating in their nervous systems had restricted movement between
the bones of their cranium. By releasing some of those tensions, he felt
that the subtle movement of the bones was increased. This approach
enabled him to help several of his patients with a wide variety of health
issues that had not been helped by the usual medical treatments of
medicine or surgery.
made
EFTA00809993
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
Whereas medical doctors tend to prescribe medicines to treat stress
and other medical conditions, the craniosacral approach is a hands-on
therapy that has proven to be particularly effective in improving the
function of the nervous system. It can reduce chronic stress, release
tensions in the muscular system, and bring better balance to the hormonal
(endocrine) system. Sutherland developed therapeutic techniques in three
areas: 1) releasing tension in the membranes; 2) releasing restrictions
between the individual cranial bones; and 3) improving the flow of the
cerebrospinal fluid.
THE BRAIN-BODY BARRIER
There is a physical structure made up of epithelial cells that envelop the
brain and spinal cord. These cells form what is called the blood-brain barrier.
There is no direct circulation of blood directly to the neurons of
the brain and spinal cord. Instead, the tissues of these structures are
surrounded by colorless cerebrospinal fluid, which circulates to deliver
necessary nourishment to the cells of the brain and spinal cord and to carry
away waste products of cellular metabolism before returning to the blood.
The cerebrospinal fluid is found in small amounts in the blood
throughout the entire body, but it is finer than the rest of the blood. It
contains no red or white blood cells, and fewer impurities than blood.
In the brain the cerebrospinal fluid is filtered out of the blood and
circulates through the cranium in the spaces surrounding the brain
and spinal cord. After circulating around the brain and spinal cord, the
cerebrospinal fluid returns to the jugular veins, where it rejoins the blood
returning to the heart from the rest of the body. Then it is circulated from
the heart and freshened by the lungs and kidneys.
The blood supply to the brainstem and the nerves arising there is crucial
to the function of the five cranial nerves whose function is necessary for
the state of social engagement, which includes the ventral branch of the
vagus nerve.
Removing restrictions to this blood supply is at the core of successfully
improving the function of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve and the
owlii
EFTA00809994
Introduction:The Autonomic Nervous System
other four cranial nerves necessary to social engagement. Some of the best
ways to achieve this are found in the domain of craniosacral osteopathy.
For decades, craniosacral education was the exclusive domain of
osteopathic physicians. They traditionally restricted attendance in their
courses to licensed osteopaths and students enrolled in osteopathic
medical schools. However, some of the hands-on disciplines were
eventually taught to non-osteopathic physicians and students. Because
many of those techniques were so effective, an eager market for them
developed among practitioners of alternative and complementary
therapies.
One American osteopath, John Upledger, broke with tradition
and began teaching craniosacral techniques to non-osteopaths. Much
of the focus of Upledger's work was on unwinding the tension in the
membranes. He founded the Upledger Institute, where I took my first
course in craniosacral therapy in 1983. Craniosacral therapy has now
become popular with alternative therapists all over the world.
In 1995, after I had been successfully practicing what I had learned
from the Upledger Institute, I went on to study with Main Gehin, a French
osteopath who specialized in biomechanical craniosacral therapy. His
focus was on releasing tension in the connective tissue spanning adjacent
cranial bones, thereby allowing them to move more freely.s
A few years after that I took introductory courses in biomechanical
craniosacral therapy, which focuses on increasing the circulation of
the cerebrospinal fluid. All three approaches have the same goal that
Sutherland espoused—to improve the function of the craniosacral system.
MY OWN CLINICAL PRACTICE
In my own practice I preferred biomechanical craniosacral therapy, which
reminded me of my work with Rolfing. BC' is specific; it helped me find
the exact places in the cranial joints that needed releasing and provided
me with more than 150 specific techniques to release these tensions. This
powerful approach often effectively restores the function of the cranial
nerves in a short period of time.
EFTA00809995
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
In my clinic, in addition to treating clients with craniosacral therapy,
I gave individual sessions in Rolfing, which balances the myofascia
(myo- means "muscle"; fascia refers to connective tissue). I also offered
sessions in visceral massage to improve the function of the digestive and
respiratory systems. As I worked with techniques from these various
modalities, I observed changes in the client's nervous system in terms of
stress and relaxation during the course of a hands-on treatment.
My work with patients was extremely successful. As time went on,
more and more people wanted to learn my techniques, and the Stanley
Rosenberg Institute grew to employ twelve teachers working on a part-
time basis. Courses were taught in Danish. In Denmark alone we educated
several hundred students over several years. These therapists in turn
treated thousands of patients. My reputation spread beyond the borders
of Denmark, and I taught in several other countries as well.
The idea of the two-state (stress and relaxation) function of the
autonomic nervous system played a prominent role in our curriculum. I
taught about it in my classes on craniosacral therapy, visceral massage, and
connective-tissue release. Together with an American neurologist, Ronald
Lawrence, MD, I even wrote a book, Pain Relief with Osteomassage,‘ about
pain relief and hands-on treatment, based on this interpretation of the
autonomic nervous system.
When I first heard Stephen Porges lecture about his Polyvagal Theory
in Baltimore in 2001,1 had been working successfully with body-oriented
therapies for almost thirty-five years. Porges's theory, however, was right
up my alley, and it gave me a whole new outlook on the autonomic
nervous system. This in turn gave me a new and more effective way to
help my patients.
Porges's Polyvagal Theory brought about a revolutionary advancement
in my understanding of the autonomic nervous system. According to this
theory, five cranial nerves (CNs) must function adequately in order to
attain the desirable state of social engagement. These five nerves are CN
V, VII, IX, X, and XI, and they all originate in the brainstem.
Before I heard Porges speak, I had studied anatomy with Professor
Patrick Coughlin, who taught us about each of the twelve cranial nerves,
EFTA00809996
Introduction: The Autonomic Nervous System
including the vagus nerve (CN X), and how to test their function. I
had also learned specific biomechanical hands-on techniques from my
craniosacral teacher Alain Gehin to improve the function of the twelve
cranial nerves. So I was well prepared for an infusion of insight offered
by the Polyvagal Theory. I adapted the techniques I had learned to
successfully address a wide range of maladies with this new paradigm.
I believe that the information and exercises in this book can be
usefully implemented by almost anyone, from beginner to experienced
craniosacral therapist, to improve cranial-nerve function in themselves
and their patients, and to obtain relief from many unpleasant symptoms,
conditions, and health issues—especially those that have been difficult
to diagnose and heal.
THE NEUROLOGY OF SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
Spinal nerves originate in the brain, make up part of the spinal cord,
exit the spinal cord between adjacent vertebrae, and then go to various
areas throughout the body. A spinal nerve is a mixed nerve, carrying
motor, sensory, and autonomic signals between the spinal cord and
corresponding regions of the body.
Some of the fibers of the spinal nerves weave together to make up the
sympathetic chain, which runs the length of the spine from vertebrae
Ti to L2. (Ti is the first thoracic vertebrae and L2 is the second lumbar
vertebra). This chain supports the activity of the visceral organs and
muscles when a person is mobilized by a threat of danger into a "fight or
flight" response.
Cranial nerves, except for cranial nerves I (olfactory) and II (optic),
originate in the brainstem, at the base of the brain. (See the illustrations
"Brain" and "Cranial Nerves" in the Appendix.) They then make their way
to various structures in both the cranium and the rest of the body. Some
cranial nerves, for instance, innervate the muscles of facial expression,
while others go to the heart, lungs, stomach, and other organs of digestion.
Some cranial nerves go to the muscles that move the eyes, while others
connect to cells in the nose to enable our sense of smell.
EFTA00809997
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
According to the Polyvagal Theory, when a person is feeling safe—not
threatened or in danger—and if her body is healthy and functioning
well, she can enjoy a physiological state that supports spontaneous social
engagement behaviors. Social engagement, neurologically speaking, is a
state based on the activity of five cranial nerves: the ventral branch of
the vagus nerve (cranial nerve X), and pathways within cranial nerves V,
VII, IX, and XI.
When working together properly, the activity of these five nerves
supports a state that enables social interaction, communication, and
appropriate self-soothing behaviors. When we are socially engaged, we
can experience feelings of love and friendship. And when individual
members of a group can come together and cooperate with others, it
enhances everyone's chances for survival.
Other inherent values derive from social engagement: we bond
with each other, develop friendships, and enjoy intimate sexual rela-
tionships; we communicate, talk with each other, care for each other,
work together, raise families, tell stories, play sports, sing together, dance
together, and entertain one another. We enjoy sitting at a table and shar-
ing a meal or a drink with friends and loved ones. Social engagement
might arise when a parent puts a child to sleep, lying close and reading
a book or telling a story until the child drifts off, or in the intimate
moment experienced by two lovers lying close to each other after they
have made love. These are some of the important experiences that make
us human beings.
Social interaction is not reserved for our relations with other people.
We love our pets, we feed them, and we go for walks with our dogs.
We often talk to our pets, and we are quite sure that they understand
what we are saying. When they reciprocate with signs of affection, we
feel happy. Almost anyone recognizes these activities, experiences, and
qualities arising from the state of social engagement. However, these kinds
of activities and interactions are neither described nor explained by the
old model of the autonomic nervous system.
EFTA00809998
Introduction: The Autonomic Nervous System
Being together with others in positive ways is not only facilitated by
the social engagement circuit of the autonomic nervous system; positive
experiences with others also help us to regulate our autonomic nervous
system. When we are together with other people who are socially engaged,
we feel better. On the other hand, when we do not have enough positive
social interactions with others, we can easily become stressed, depressed,
asocial, or even antisocial.
This new understanding of the multifaceted roles of the cranial nerves,
and particularly their connection with the state of social engagement,
enabled me to consistently help more people with an even wider range of
health issues. MI I had to do was to determine whether these five cranial
nerves functioned well and, if not, to use a technique to get them to
function better.
This made it possible for me to achieve far greater success in my
practice and to treat intransigent conditions such as migraine headaches,
depression, fibromyalgia, COPD, post-traumatic stress, forward head
posture, and neck and shoulder problems, among others.
This book is an introduction to the theory and practice of Polyvagal
healing. After describing basic neurological structures, I will list some of
the physical, psychological, and social issues caused by dysfunctions of
those five cranial nerves.
According to the Polyvagal Theory, the autonomic nervous system
has two other functions in addition to those of the ventral branch of the
vagus nerve: the activity of the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve, and
sympathetic activity from the spinal chain. This multiple (poly-) nature
of the vagus nerve gives the theory its name.
The differences between the functions of the ventral and dorsal
branches of the vagus nerve have profound implications for physical
and behavioral health and healing. Throughout the book, I propose a
new approach to healing that includes self-help exercises and hands-on
therapeutic techniques that are simple to learn and easy to use. It is my
hope that this knowledge will continue to spread and enable many more
people to help themselves and others.
bcxiii
EFTA00809999
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
RESTORING SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
I have written this book to make the benefits of restoring vagal function
available to a broad range of people, even if they have no prior experience
with craniosacral or other forms of hands-on therapy. Readers can
acquire a unique set of easy-to-learn and easy-to-do self-help exercises
and hands-on techniques that should enable them to improve the func-
tion of these five nerves in themselves and others. I used the principles
behind Main Gehin's work to develop these techniques.
The exercises and techniques restore flexibility to the functioning
of the autonomic nervous system. They can help eliminate the general
adverse conditions of chronic stress, which arises from the overstimul-
ation of the spinal sympathetic chain, and depressive behavior and shut-
down, which arise from activity in the dorsal vagal circuit. The exercises
are noninvasive and do not involve medicine or surgery. The improve-
ments in ventral vagus nerve function from doing the exercises help to
regulate the visceral organs involved in breathing, digestion, elimination,
and sexual function.
I tested the exercises with more than a hundred patients in my clinic
before introducing the techniques to closely monitored groups in my
classes and lectures. My conclusion was that my new approach using
the exercises in this book will enhance most people's health and their
capability for social engagement. The positive effects may last for a
surprisingly long time.
However, life is challenging, and nothing is permanent. While our goal
is to help make the autonomic nervous system resilient, social engagement
is not a permanent condition. Nor can we always prevent a person from
encountering threatening circumstances or dangerous situations.
The body, the nervous system, and the emotions continually adapt
to help us respond to changing conditions. If we are threatened, or in
physical or emotional danger, it is appropriate for our autonomic nervous
system to respond physiologically with a temporary state of sympathetic
activity in the spinal chain, or with dorsal vagal activity. These changes
mciv
EFTA00810000
Introduction:The Autonomic Nervous System
help us to survive. Once the actual threat or danger is over, it is best if we
can bounce back into a state of social engagement.
Because nothing in the body lasts forever, though, the nervous system
may slide back from social engagement into a state of activity of the
spinal sympathetic chain or the dorsal vagal circuit. In this case, repeating
the exercises should quickly restore ventral vagal function and leave the
person in a socially engaged state again. It may be necessary to repeat
these exercises or techniques occasionally or regularly.
The positive effects are cumulative. Our autonomic nervous system
becomes more resilient each time we can restore a state of social
engagement following activation of the spinal sympathetic chain or the
dorsal vagus branch. We can do so by using the Basic Exercise, a very
simple self-help technique described in Part Two. Our long-term goal is
to encourage the autonomic nervous system to return naturally, on its
own, from a state of stress (spinal sympathetic activation) or depression
(activity in the dorsal vagal circuit) to a state of social engagement, as soon
as conditions change for the better and we return to feeling physically and
emotionally safe.
The techniques and exercises in Part Two help to improve movement
of the head, neck, and shoulders, and to correct some of the postural
and functional issues that we attribute to aging: forward head posture,
kyphosis, dowager's hump, flat lower back, reduced breathing capacity,
etc. Every time that you utilize the techniques in this book, you will notice
improvement.
EFTA00810001
I I
EFTA00810002
PART ONE
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW:
THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Overcoming Health Challenges:
Are You Fighting the Heads of the Hydra?
Many people struggle with health issues. Often their stories are reminis-
cent of the contest portrayed in Greek mythology between Hercules, the
strongest of all men, and the water beast named Hydra. Hercules was
half god and half human; his father was Zeus, god of the sky and thun-
der, who ruled all the other gods on Olympus. Greatest of all heroes,
Hercules was sent on a mission to kill Hydra, a snake-like water beast
with many heads.
Hercules had a golden sword that had been given to him by Athena.
In Greek mythology, Athena—the patron of the city-state of Athens—
was the goddess of wisdom, civilization, just warfare, strength, strategy,
female arts, crafts, justice, and skill, who often accompanied heroes in
their battles.
Hydra was a dangerous opponent—even her breath was poisonous.
For each of Hydra's many heads that Hercules cut off with his sword,
the seemingly immortal Hydra grew two new heads. Realizing that he
could not defeat Hydra by cutting off her heads one at a time, Hercules
summoned his nephew lolaus for help. lolaus came up with the idea of
using a blazing firebrand to scorch the neck stumps after each decapita-
tion, making it impossible for two heads to grow back in the same place.
Luckily for Hercules, Hydra had one weak spot: one of her heads was
mortal. When Hercules found Hydra's mortal head and cut it off, Hydra
finally died.
EFTA00810003
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
The mythical Hydra is a metaphor for the frustration of treating one
symptom only to have one or more others crop up in its place. Like the
multiple heads of Hydra, multiple health issues plague many of us, and
chasing symptoms one at a time with a medicine or an operation for each
may give temporary relief but does not necessarily root out the source.
We might take a pill for one health problem, another pill for another
problem, and a third to counteract the side effects of the first two pills.
We may even take multiple different pills every day. But often the pills
only help temporarily, if at all, and sometimes we have to continue to take
them for the rest of our lives.
Our society primarily relies on two approaches in conventional
medicine: biochemical (drugs) and surgical. These powerful tools are
valuable in some cases and helped many people, including myself.
Surgical operations can be lif ng. But even the best of operations leave
scar tissue, which can restrict movement by making it more difficult for
layers of muscles and connective tissue to slide freely on adjacent layers.
Also, there are many symptoms, conditions, and health issues that are
not debilitating or life threatening; often, lacking viable alternatives, we
try to treat these issues with the usual medical approach of prescription
drugs and/or surgery. These may not be the best solutions, however. In
many cases they do not work as effectively as we wish, and often they
produce undesirable side effects.
Like fighting the Hydra, our symptom-suppression often just results in
more symptoms popping up. For achieving lasting health, by contrast, there
is a largely untapped potential in understanding how the nervous system
works and approaching difficult health issues in a new way. Simply stated: if
the ventral branch of the vagus nerve is not functioning, make it functional.
Since the autonomic nervous system regulates important functions of the
body such as circulation, respiration, digestion, and reproduction, a wide
range of consequences can ensue if the vagus and other cranial nerves are
not working properly.
Below is a partial list of common problems that can arise from the
autonomic nervous system. These are symptoms that affect many people.
Have you experienced any of these symptoms or know people who suffer
2
EFTA00810004
Overcoming Health Challenges: Are You Fighting the Heads of the Hydra?
from them? If so, read on, because working with the cranial nerves can
bring relief.
The Heads of the Hydra:
Common Problems Related to Cranial-Nerve Dysfunction
Chronic physical tensions
• Tense/hard muscles
• Sore neck and shoulder muscles
• Migraines
• Back pain
• Tightly clenched teeth
• Grinding teeth at night
• Eye or facial tensions
• Cold hands and feet
• Unwarranted sweating
• Tenseness after exertion
• Arthritis
• Nervousness
• Dizziness
• Lump in the throat
Emotional issues
• Irritability, anger
• Feeling "down"
• Feeling of hopelessness
• Lack of energy
• Tendency to cry easily
• General anxiety
• Feeling of heaviness
• Extended periods of depression
• Fearfulness
• Nightmares
3
EFTA00810005
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
• Restlessness
• Difficulty sleeping
• Excessive worries
• Difficulty concentrating
• Forgetfulness
• Frustration
• Excessive daydreaming and fantasizing
Heart and lung problems
• Chest pains
• Asthma
• Hyperventilation
• Shortness of breath
• Irregular heartbeat
• High blood pressure
Visceral-organ dysfunctions
• Poor digestion
• Constipation
• Irritation of the large intestine
• Diarrhea
• Stomach problems
• Hyperacidity, ulcer, heartburn
• Loss of appetite
• Excessive eating
Immune-system problems
• Frequent influenza
• Minor infections
• Allergies
Behavioral problems
• Frequent accidents or injuries
• Increase in drinking or smoking
4
EFTA00810006
Overcoming Health Challenges: Are You Fighting the Heads of the Hydra?
• Excessive use of medicine with or without prescription
• Autism, ADHD, Asperger's syndrome
Interpersonal relationships
• Excessive or unreasonable distrust
• Difficulty in reaching agreements
• Loss of interest in sex
Mental Issues
• Excessive worrying
• Difficulty concentrating
• Difficulty remembering
• Difficulty making decisions
Other problems
• Excessive menstrual pains
• Skin problems
Given the challenges and stresses that we face in our lives, everyone is
troubled by one or more of these symptoms from time to time. At first
glance, this list seems to include unrelated problems—we could classify
some of them as "physical," some as "mental," others as "emotional,"
and still others as 'behavioral?' Making such distinctions by grouping
symptoms is not helpful in this context, however, and distracts from
the observation that the underlying physiological cause is essentially
the same.
Usually people have more than one of these symptoms at the same
time. The scientific term for this is cornorbidity. The symptoms can disap-
pear and recur at irregular intervals. If the symptoms occur rarely and
are not debilitating, they are not so much of a problem. However, if the
problems occur often, or most of the time, it is advisable to address them.
Rather than treating individual symptoms as separate issues with a pill
to be taken for each one, it would be preferable to find a common thread
that links them. Perhaps we can we find a simple, effective treatment that
5
EFTA00810007
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
can mitigate or terminate these many seemingly separate issues—perhaps
we can find the Hydra's mortal head.
The common thread may be a fairly simple one: All of the problems in
this list occur at least partly from dorsal vagal activity or activation of the
spinal sympathetic nervous system, and can be addressed by reinstating
normal function of the ventral vagus nerve branch and other nerves
required for social engagement.
The idea that cranial nerves play a role in any of these health issues is
almost universally overlooked by contemporary medicine. Most people
do not know much about the brainstem, where these nerves originate,
nor about the cranial nerves themselves.
I believe, and have repeatedly confirmed, that if we can get the five
nerves that support social engagement to function properly, there is a
good chance of alleviating or eliminating many of the symptoms on
the list. This belief is based on my own clinical experience over several
decades, and the experiences of the hundreds of therapists that I have
trained at the Stanley Rosenberg Institute.
6
EFTA00810008
CHAPTER 1
Get to Know Your Autonomic
Nervous System
The human nervous system has one primary function: to ensure the
survival of our physical body. The nervous system is composed of the
brain, the brainstem, the cranial nerves, the spinal cord, the spinal nerves,
and the enteric nerves. The focus of our attention here is the autonomic
nervous system, which is made up of elements of the brainstem, some of
the cranial nerves, and some parts of some of the spinal nerves.
The Twelve Cranial Nerves
Writing about the function of the twelve cranial nerves for a range of
readers with extensive to zero knowledge about them has been a chal-
lenge. How can I introduce the subject to readers hearing about these
nerves for the first time, while also helping knowledgeable people to
understand cranial nerve function in a new and useful way?
For readers new to the subject, I will present a simple description
of the function of each of the twelve cranial nerves. If you are already
familiar with the cranial nerves, I hope to present a new perspective and
some new information about their function.
Cranial nerves are different from spinal nerves. Some cranial nerves
connect the brainstem with organs and muscles of the head such as the
nose, eyes, ears, and tongue. The brainstem extends from the brain; it
lies on the underside of the brain and is the beginning of the spinal cord.
(See "Brain,""Cranial nerves," and "Spinal cord" in the Appendix.) Other
cranial nerves go through small openings in the cranium to reach the
throat, face, neck, thorax, and abdomen. Each of the twelve cranial nerves
has pathways on both the right and left sides.
One of the cranial nerves "wanders" through the body, coursing from
the brainstem into the chest and abdomen to regulate many of the visceral
7
EFTA00810009
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
organs. It innervates the muscles of the throat (pharynx and larynx),
and the organs of respiration (lungs), circulation (heart), digestion
(stomach, liver, pancreas, duodenum, small intestine, and the ascending
and transverse sections of the large intestine), and elimination (kidneys).
Because this nerve is so long and has so many branches, it was named the
"vagus" nerve, from the Latin word vagus, meaning "vagrant, wanderer?'
The vagus nerve helps to regulate a vast array of bodily functions
necessary for maintaining homeostasis. Whereas the sympathetic chain
extends from the spinal nerves and supports the state of stress and
mobilization for survival, several of the cranial nerves support non-stress
states. One of the primary functions of the cranial nerves is to facilitate
rest and restitution. They also enable the senses of sight, smell, taste, and
hearing, as well as the sense of touch on the skin of the face. In mam-
mals, some of the cranial nerves work together to facilitate and promote
social behavior.
Each cranial nerve is numbered with a Roman numeral; for example,
the olfactory nerve is also called CN I, meaning "first cranial nerve Note
that although the nerves are paired, the singular term is usually used, so
that "CN I" actually refers to a pair of nerves.
The cranial nerves are numbered based on their location. They extend
from a half-circle on each side of the brain; an early anatomist assigned
the number CN Ito the topmost nerve, CN II to the next nerve down in
the hal ircle, and so on.
THE VARIOUS FUNCTIONS OF CRANIAL NERVES
As the fibers within a conduit often have different functions, a cranial
nerve may have multiple functions as well. When we first look at the
various cranial nerves, their functions seem to be unrelated. For example,
one of the nerves helps us swallow, another tightens a muscle that rotates
the eyeball toward the midline, and a third helps to regulate blood
pressure.
However, though it is not usually noted in the study of anatomy, all
twelve cranial nerves have one thing in common: they are all involved in
8
EFTA00810010
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
helping us to find food; chew, swallow, and digest; and eliminate undigested
food as waste.
Cranial nerves control the secretion of enzymes and acids in the mouth
and stomach, the production of bile in the liver and storage of bile in the
gall bladder, and the production and storage of digestive enzymes in the
pancreas. They monitor and regulate the movement of undigested food
all the way from the stomach to the transverse colon. They control the
release of gall and pancreatic enzymes into the duodenum, in appropriate
amounts and at appropriate times, to digest the food and break down
its composition. After the proteins, carbohydrates, and fats have been
sufficiently broken down, these nutrients can be absorbed through the
walls of the small intestine.
We will start this discussion of the individual cranial nerves by noting
how each one contributes to the digestive process. Then we will look at
some additional functions of the cranial nerves that are not related to
food, such as regulation of the kidneys and bladder, the heart and respi-
ration, and sex and reproduction.
If you have never heard of cranial nerves before, do not worry about
remembering which nerves have which functions; you can always come
back to this section and refresh your memory with the table on page
12. What will be most useful is to get a general impression of the kinds
of functions regulated by these nerves, including the state of social
engagement. If you have studied the twelve cranial nerves before, the
following will present a somewhat different approach to help broaden
your understanding.
The olfactory nerve, or CN I, enables our sense of smell. In terms of
evolution, CN I was the first of the cranial nerves to develop. The sense
of smell is vital to human beings and all other mammals; it is crucial
in first finding food and then determining whether a morsel is edible.
Smells create an immediate response of attraction or repulsion—does
my mouth water when I bring the morsel closer, or do I turn my head
away in disgust?
Our response to smells is powerful, primitive, and instinctual, so
various smells have strong emotional impacts on us. It is important for a
9
EFTA00810011
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
baby to recognize the smell of its mother, and for sexual partners to smell
each other in order to intensify their arousal.
The nerve fibers of CN I originate in sensory organs in the nose and have
a direct pathway to the forebrain. CN I is the only cranial nerve with direct
transmission from the sensory organs to the brain without intermediary
synapses. (A synapse is a structure that permits a neuron, or nerve cell, to
pass an electrical or chemical signal to another cell, neural or otherwise.)
The olfactory nerve is thus the only cranial nerve that transmits infor-
mation (smell) directly to the cerebral cortex without relaying it through
another part of the central nervous system. Interestingly, this part of our
"old brain" is instrumental in the formation of memory, which makes
sense from the standpoint of survival. This is why smells make up some
of our strongest and most evocative memories.
Other cranial nerves enable our vision, and sight of course plays a
critical role in helping us to find food. CN II, the optic nerve, also origi-
nates in the forebrain. It transmits signals from the rods and cones in the
retina of the eye to a synapse, and across that synapse to the visual centers
in the back (occipital) lobe of the cerebral cortex. The brain interprets
these nerve impulses into what we see.
We might be searching for something to eat, and see something
interesting. Can we recognize it from past experience? Does it look like
food? Does it look fresh? Is it free from mold and discoloration? If it looks
good, we then might decide to bring it closer to our face so that we can
smell it, and then we might put it into our mouth to taste it.
Moving our eyeballs in different directions expands our field of vision.
The small muscles that move the eyeballs are controlled by three other
cranial nerves: CN III (oculomotor), IV (trochlear), and VI (abducens).
These allow us to roll our eyes up, down, right, or left.
We can extend our field of vision even further if we use the neck
muscles to move our head. CN XI, the spinal accessory nerve, controls
the trapezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles. These muscles move our
head so that we can look up, down, and to the sides. This allows our search
for food to include bringing a morsel closer to smell it and, if it does not
smell good, to turn our head away.
10
EFTA00810012
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
However, sight and smell alone do not tell us for sure that something
is edible. We take the next step and put it into our mouth: does it taste all
right? In order to taste properly, we need to mix the food with saliva. The
secretion of saliva is controlled by the CN V (trigeminal), CN VII (facial),
and CN IX (glossopharyngeal) nerves that innervate the salivary glands.
Saliva not only increases our ability to taste things, it also initiates the
digestive process by beginning starch breakdown and moistening food,
making it easier to swallow.
To mix the food with saliva, we use CN V (the trigeminal nerve) to
innervate the muscles of mastication, opening and closing the jaw and
grinding the food with a side-to-side movement. We use CN XII (the
hypoglossal nerve) to move our tongue to shift the food around in the
mouth, and on and off the surfaces of our teeth. We use CN VII (the facial
nerve) to relax and tighten the muscles of the cheeks, creating a pouch for
the food and emptying it to move food back onto the grinding surfaces
of the teeth. We also help move the food around with the muscles of the
lips, which are also innervated by CN VII.
For the actual tasting of food, we use the taste buds on the tongue,
which connect to branches of three cranial nerves: CN VII (the facial
nerve), CN IX (the glossopharyngeal nerve), and CN X (the vagus nerve).
Does the food taste all right, or is there a strange taste signaling that the
morsel might be dangerous to eat? If the food does not taste good, we
can easily spit it out before we swallow it, and avoid becoming sick or
poisoned.
If we decide to swallow, the tongue flips this chewed food mixed with
saliva to the top of the esophagus, at the back of the mouth. The esophagus
is a muscular tube that moves food from the throat to the stomach, con-
tracting rhythmically in the same way that the intestines do. We swallow
food with muscles in the throat that are innervated by CN IX, the gloss-
opharyngeal nerve, and tongue muscles innervated by CN XII, the hypo-
glossal nerve, as well as other muscles innervated by CN V and CN VII.
The upper third of the esophagus is innervated by the ventral branch
of the vagus nerve, while the rest of the esophagus is innervated by the
dorsal vagus branch.
11
EFTA00810013
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
If we sense that something is wrong with the food once it reaches
the stomach, the old (dorsal) vagus branch gives us one last chance to
regurgitate it before it continues into the small intestine. Our gag reflex is
controlled on both ends of the esophagus, by the glossopharyngeal nerve
(CN IX) at the top and the vagus (CN X) lower down. It's easy to see how
complicated the act of swallowing actually is, requiring the coordinated
function of many cranial nerves!
The cranial nerves assist in the search for food in other ways. Many
animals locate possible prey using their finely attuned sense of hearing.
Most anatomical sources consider CN VIII, the auditory nerve,' to be
the only cranial nerve that facilitates hearing. However, in mammals, the
trigeminal (CN V) and facial (CN VII) nerves also have important roles
to play in listening and in understanding human speech by regulating the
middle-ear muscles. Tightening or relaxing tension levels in the eardrum,
with the help of these nerves, changes the loudness of specific acoustic
frequencies that pass through the eardrum to the inner ear. When the
levels of sound are too strong for the fine mechanism of the inner ear,
the stapedius muscle dampens the vibrations. (For more about hearing,
see Chapter 7.)
Major Functions of the Cranial Nerves
CN I Olfactory nerve Smell; helps to locate food
CN II Optic nerve Vision; makes it possible to see
CN III Oculomotor nerve Looking; controls some eyeball muscles
CN IV Trochlear nerve' Looking; controls some eyeball muscles
CN V Trigeminal nerve Chewing and swallowing
Hearing; tensor tympani muscle
CN VI Abducens nerve Looking; controls some eyeball muscles
CN VII Facial nerve Chewing; some facial muscles and salivary
secretions
Hearing; stapedius muscle
CN VIII Acoustic nerve Hearing; translates sound waves into nerve
impulses
CN IX Glossopharyngeal Swallowing
nerve
12
EFTA00810014
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
CN X New vagus nerve The new (ventral) vagus branch innervates
Old vagus nerve and controls the upper third of the esophagus
and most of the pharyngeal muscles, and it
regulates the heart and bronchi.
The old (dorsal) vagus branch innervates the
lower two-thirds of the esophagus; it regulates
stomach function, digestive glands and
organs such as liver and gall bladder, and
movement of food through the intestines
(except the descending colon).
CN XI Spinal accessory Innervates the trapezius and stemocleidomas
nerve toid muscles, which turn the head and expand
the visual field
CN XII Hypoglossal nerve Moves the tongue
In addition to eating, several other functions are performed by the cranial
nerves. The visceral afferent (sensory) branches of cranial nerves V, VII,
IX, X, and XI gather information from our visceral organs: Are we safe,
threatened, or in mortal danger? Does our body feel healthy, or is there an
imbalance, pain, dysfunction, or illness? If we are safe and healthy, these
nerves facilitate the desirable state of social engagement.
Cranial Nerve Dysfunction and
Social Engagement
We consider "normal" human behavior to be an expression of positive
social values. Our actions should be beneficial for our own survival and
well-being, as well as for the well-being of others.
When we are socially engaged, it is easy for other people to under-
stand our behavior, and what we do makes sense to others; most of us are
socially engaged most of the time. However, sometimes we temporarily
drop into a state of chronic activation of the spinal sympathetic chain
system (fight or flight) or of dorsal vagal activity (withdrawal, shutdown).
Then, if our autonomic nervous system is resilient, we will soon bounce
back up to a state of social engagement.
13
EFTA00810015
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Unfortunately, some of us are not socially engaged most of the time;
if we lack the necessary resilience to spontaneously come back to a state
of social engagement, we become stuck in sympathetic-chain or dorsal
vagal states. In these states it is often hard for other people to understand
our values, motivation, and behavior. Our actions seem irrational, often
run counter to our own best interests, and can be destructive to ourselves
and others. If we are not socially engaged, it makes life difficult not only
for ourselves but for those around us.
Let's take a look at the five cranial nerves necessary for social engage-
ment, and what kinds of problems can arise when they are not function-
ing properly. These symptoms provide a clue that someone is not socially
engaged; a person with these symptoms might benefit from treatment of
the affected nerve(s).
THE FIFTH AND SEVENTH CRANIAL NERVES
CN V, the trigeminal nerve, has several motor functions including control
of the muscles of mastication that move the jaw when we chew. CN V also
has sensory functions, and it receives impulses from the sensory nerves
of the skin of the face.
CN VII, the facial nerve, also has several motor functions. It controls the
tensing and relaxing of the individual muscles of the face. Changes in the
pattern of tensions in our facial muscles create our facial expressions, which
not only communicate different emotions but also reflect our internal
states in terms of health or illness. Ideally, changes in facial expressions
are spontaneous and reflect the flow of changing emotions and thoughts.
Is someone's face deadpan, lacking animation? This is usually a sign
of CN VII dysfunction. We can make faces voluntarily—for example,
putting on a smile or opening our eyes wide. But these are not the same
as spontaneous facial expressions.
Spontaneous small changes in facial expression (or lack thereof) in
this transverse stripe from the corners of the eyes to the corners of the
lips, whether consciously or unconsciously noticed by others, can reveal
whether or not we are socially engaged.
14
EFTA00810016
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
In addition to these separate functions, CN V and CN VII have inter-
related functions. CN VII innervates the muscles of the face, and CN V is
a sensory nerve to the skin of the face. When we change facial expression,
this gives us the "feel of the face." Both nerves play a role in listening to
and understanding what is being said, enabling us to take part in a con-
versation. This is also crucial to facilitating social engagement.
The stapedius, the smallest muscle in the body, is innervated by CN
VII. This muscle protects the inner ear from high noise levels, primar-
ily the volume of your own voice. The roar of a lion can be deafening,
striking terror in other animals to the point of paralyzing them. The
lion protects itself from the sound of its own voice by tightening its own
stapedius muscle an instant before it roars, so that it is not affected by
the loud noise.
By reducing the volume of sounds above and below the frequency
of the human female voice, the stapedius muscle allows a baby to more
clearly hear her mother's voice. If you are easily disturbed by background
noises, your stapedius muscle might not be doing its job of reducing the
volume of the low-frequency sounds, making it hard for you to hear what
someone else is saying in a noisy room.
Hyperacusis, another hearing problem, can result from dysfunction
of the stapedius as well as another muscle in the middle ear, the tensor
tympani, or eardrum muscle, innervated by CN V. As this muscle tightens,
it increases the tension, which diminishes sound. This is a useful function
when we eat, reducing the level of noise from chewing. (For more about
hyperacusis and stapedius dysfunction, see Chapter 7.)
Dysfunctions of CN V and CN VII are quite common in adults, often
coming as an undesirable side effect of tooth extractions or orthodontic
braces. I have observed in several of my clients who have had dental work
that the pterygoid process of their sphenoid bone and the palatine bone
(one of the small facial bones) in their hard palate arepulled out of joint"
in relationship to each other. As part of my training in biomechanical
craniosacral therapy, I learned to look at the shape of the hard palate to
see whether the palatine bone has been displaced laterally, and to perform
a technique to bring this bone back to its proper position.
15
EFTA00810017
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Some of the branches of CN V and CN VII meet in this area. A very
slight misalignment of the facial bones in the joint between the sphenoid
and palatine bones can put pressure on both nerves. I sometimes treat
clients who have had problems in these two nerves after having had a
tooth pulled. When I ask dentists about pain in a tooth and misalignment
of these two bones, most of them know exactly what I mean. They often
respond that they are very careful not to pull a tooth just on the basis of
pain if there is no sign of infection.
However, I also meet people whose dentist did not learn this, or per-
haps forgot it. One woman had a pain in a tooth after an extraction
of a different tooth. Her dentist pulled the second tooth, but this did
not alleviate the pain. He did not seem to know that the nerves in this
joint could be compressed from a displacement of these two bones in
relationship to each other. This dentist was persistent in his attempt to
help the woman to be free of pain; he pulled another tooth, and then
another. When she came to me, she had almost no teeth left in her
mouth—and still had the same pain.
I presently have another client who started to grind his teeth at night
after a tooth was pulled out. Many dentists do not recognize the problem,
or perhaps do not have the skills to address it.
In my first session, I generally ask all my clients if they have had a tooth
extracted, or if they wore orthodontic braces. Either of these can cause
chronic spinal sympathetic stimulation or a chronic dorsal vagal state.
The sphenoid bone is the most centrally located bone in the cranium.
The outer surfaces of the sphenoid bone make up what we commonly
call the temples. If a boxer takes a punch on one of the temples, he risks
being knocked out cold. Many boxers know this, and target the temples
of their opponent. If they hit the temple, they will almost surely win by
knockout. It is also why baseball batters wear a cap with flaps that protect
their temples from injury if they are hit by a ball. The innermost part of
the sphenoid bone has a saddle-like depression in which the pituitary
gland rests.
When one branch of a cranial nerve is under direct physical pressure,
not only that branch but other branches of that nerve can become
16
EFTA00810018
Getting to KnowYour Autonomic Nervous System
dysfunctional. Thus a dislocation between the sphenoid and palatine
bones can result in dysfunction of the nerves to the face and middle ear;
this is enough to block the entire social-engagement nervous system.
Cranial nerve V goes to the skin of the face, while cranial nerve VII
goes to the muscles of the face. To correct some of these dysfunctions
and to give yourself a natural "facelift," Part Two of this book includes
a technique that stimulates both the fifth and seventh cranial nerves.
Although you should notice an improvement in reducing facial tensions
the very first time you do the exercise, it is a good idea to repeat it
occasionally, especially if you have lost your natural smile because of
being in a dorsal vagal or spinal-sympathetic state.
Two other muscles innervated by CN V are the medial and lateral
pterygoids, which arise on the sphenoid bone and help to open and close
the jaw. A slight displacement of this bone can cause irregularities such
as overbite, underbite, or crossbite.
THE NINTH, TENTH, AND ELEVENTH CRANIAL NERVES
One of the two branches of the tenth cranial nerve (the ventral vagus)
arises in a structure called the nucleus nnibiguus in the brainstem, along
with the ninth and eleventh cranial nerves.
The dorsal branch of the vagus nerve originates on the floor of the
fourth ventricle near the back of the brainstem. (A ventricle is not a
physical structure but a space between the lobes of the brain, filled with
cerebrospinal fluid. There are four of these ventricles, interconnected with
each other via small canals.)
Both branches of the vagus nerve, along with the ninth and eleventh
cranial nerves and the jugular vein, pass through the jugular foramen,
a small opening in the base of the skull between the temporal and
occipital bones.
Fibers of both the ninth and eleventh cranial nerves weave themselves
into the fibers of the tenth cranial nerve. My anatomy teacher, Professor
Pat Coughlin, told our class that in modern interpretations of anatomy,
an increasing number of teachers consider CN IX and CN X to be two
17
EFTA00810019
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
parts of the same nerve. Just as the fibers of the nerves are woven together,
their functionality seems to be interrelated as components of the social
engagement nervous system.
For clinical purposes of bringing the nervous system into a state
of social engagement, I find it simplest to approach the ninth, tenth,
and eleventh cranial nerves as if they were one nerve. When a patient
presents symptoms indicating a dysfunction in one, there is almost
always a dysfunction in the other two. If, after treatment, the patient
shows improvement in the test for vagal (CN X) function, the symptoms
attributed to dysfunction of the ninth and eleventh cranial nerves usually
disappear as well.
MORE ON THE NINTH CRANIAL NERVE
The ninth cranial nerve is called the glossopharyngeal nerve (glossa-
refers to the tongue, and pharyngeal to the pharynx, the back of the top of
the throat). This nerve has both afferent (sensory) and efferent (motor)
fibers. The efferent branch innervates a single muscle, the stylopharyn-
geus, which is involved in swallowing.
The ninth cranial nerve receives sensory information from the tonsils,
the pharynx, the middle ear, and the posterior third of the tongue. It is
also part of the mechanism for regulating blood pressure: it has afferent
branches in the carotid sinus, located in the base of the neck near the
carotid arteries, and its sensory fibers monitor blood pressure in order
to influence the heart and the tons of the muscle cells in the arteries.
This nerve also monitors oxygen and carbon dioxide levels in the blood,
to adjust the breathing rate. It is also responsible for stimulating secretion
from the parotid gland, the large salivary gland in front of the ear.
THE TENTH CRANIAL NERVE (THE VAGUS)
The tenth cranial nerve is a vital part of the autonomic nervous system.
Before Stephen Porges presented the Polyvagal Theory, the vagus was
assumed to function as a single neural pathway. However, we now know
18
EFTA00810020
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
that the two branches of the vagus nerve—ventral and dorsal—arise
at different places and have very different functions, and this book was
written to elucidate those differences and their implications.
An understanding of the two pathways of the vagus nerve provides
treatment options for a wide variety of health conditions, discussed later
in this book.
THE SUB-DIAPHRAGMATIC (DORSAL) VAGUS BRANCH
The dorsal branch of the vagus nerve has motor fibers that innervate
the visceral organs below the respiratory diaphragm: the stomach, liver,
spleen, kidneys, gall bladder, urinary bladder, small intestine, pancreas,
and the ascending and transverse segments of the colon. Therefore, this
branch has sometimes been called the "sub-diaphragmatic branch of the
vagus nerve."
However, this description is only partly accurate, since some fibers
originating in the dorsal motor nucleus in the brainstem also affect the
heart and the lungs, which lie above the diaphragm. Similarly, although
the ventral vagus primarily provides motor pathways to the organs above
the diaphragm, some fibers influence organs below the diaphragm. All
three parts of the autonomic nervous system—the dorsal and ventral
branches of the vagus nerve, and the spinal sympathetic chain—affect
the vital functions of breathing and blood circulation. Each of the three
circuits affects the heart and lungs in different ways.
The Appendix includes two drawings of the visceral organs. (See
"Ventral vagus" and "Dorsal vagus.") One shows those innervated by the
ventral vagus, and the other shows those innervated by the dorsal vagus.
OTHER FUNCTIONS OF THE VENTRAL BRANCH
OF THE VAGUS NERVE
The ventral branch of the vagus nerve originates in the brainstem, at the
top of the spinal cord under the brain. (See "Brain" in the Appendix.)
It stimulates rhythmic constriction of the bronchioles, facilitating the
19
EFTA00810021
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
extraction of oxygen, while the brainstem area controlling dorsal vagal
activation may result in chronic constriction of the airways, making
it difficult for air to get through. (This is part of the mechanism that
is activated in a state of shutdown or shock. This narrowing of the
bronchioles also occurs in COPD, chronic bronchitis, and asthma.)
When we feel safe, the ventral branch of the vagus nerve supports
rest or calm activity. There is a rhythmic vacillation of the opening of
the airways; they are moderately open on the inbreath and moderately
closed on the outbreath.
The ventral branch of the vagus nerve innervates many of the small
muscles in the throat, including the vocal cords, larynx, pharynx, and
some muscles at the back of the pharynx (the levator veil palatini and
uvular muscles).
THE ELEVENTH CRANIAL NERVE
The eleventh cranial nerve, or "accessory nerve," is one of the keys to the
well-being of the entire musculoskeletal system. Because it innervates
the trapezius and sternocleidomastoid (SCM) muscles, which enable the
movement of the head and neck, tension in either of these muscles on one
side pulls the shoulder, spine, and entire body out of alignment.
Both the trapezius and the sternocleidomastoid muscles originate on
the bones of the cranium. (The trapezius attaches to the mastoid process
of the temporal bone, and the sternocleidomastoid to the occipital bone.)
Together they make up the outer ring of muscles in the neck, shoulders,
and upper back.
If the eleventh cranial nerve is dysfunctional, it results in a lack of
proper tonus in these muscles. This in turn can cause acute or chronic
shoulder problems, stiff neck, migraines, and difficulties rotating the
head from side to side. (See Chapter 5 for more information about these
muscles. Part Two also contains a treatment for relieving migraines by
reducing excessive tensions in these muscles.)
Rather than simply massaging a chronically tense or flaccid trapezius
or SCM muscle, it is better for a therapist to first improve the function
20
EFTA00810022
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
of the eleventh cranial nerve using the Basic Exercise (see Part Two), and
then massage the muscles after the nerve is functional again.
Treating the Cranial Nerves
We need different techniques to treat the cranial nerves than those
generally used to treat spinal nerves. To treat spinal-nerve dysfunction
some therapists use chiropractics or chiropractic-like mobilizations
(short, high-velocity thrusts). A physical therapist may stretch and
strengthen the muscles of the neck and back in order to reposition the
vertebrae, thereby reducing pressure on spinal nerves. If these modalities
fail, we sometimes resort to orthopedic surgery.
However, if we want to manually improve or restore function in the
cranial nerves, we need a different approach. Since 1920, there has been
a form of treatment for addressing dysfunctions of the cranial nerves,
called "cranial osteopathC"craniosacral therapy (CST)," or "osteopathy
in the cranial field (Oar
In the United States, doctors of osteopathy (DOs) have the same
training as medical doctors. Like their MD counterparts, they are licensed
to perform surgical operations, write prescriptions, and work in psychiatric
hospitals. An important difference between osteopaths and MDs is that
osteopaths have additional training in hands-on treatment techniques.
William Garner Sutherland, DO (1873-1954) founded cranial osteop-
athy. His student and colleague Harold Magoun, DO (1927-2011),
wrote the seminal book Osteopathy in the Cranial Field,' which was first
published in 1951 and is still used today by osteopathic physicians who
elect to learn the cranial techniques. Magoun's book describes three
approaches to cranial work. One is biomechanical, in which the therapist
holds two adjacent cranial bones for the purpose of mobilizing them
in the sutures (where two or more skull bones come together). This
can reduce mechanical pressure on the cranial nerves where they come
through the various openings in the skull.
The biomechanical approach demands a detailed study of cranial
anatomy as well as extensive hands-on experience to get the feel of the
21
EFTA00810023
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
work and use the techniques effectively. The French osteopath Main
Gehin further developed the system of biomechanical techniques as
described by Sutherland and Magoun, and he has taught his approach
to students in many countries.
Another cranial treatment approach involves stretching the soft-
tissue membranes within the skull and spine. The Jura mater is a tube of
connective tissue extending from the skull to the tailbone and containing
the brain, spinal cord, and cerebrospinal fluid. The fa& cerebri and the
tentorium are connective-tissue sheets that hold the bones of the skull
together and are collectively referred to as the "dural membranes?'
All of these dural structures become less flexible with aging, ill-
ness, certain kinds of antibiotics, and physical trauma. Harold Magoun
described these membranes and how to release tension in them. Later,
this work was developed further by John Upledger, DO, and is now taught
worldwide by the Florida-based Upledger Institute. His approach includes
stretching the dural membranes as well as allowing them to "unwind?'
The third approach is called biodynamic craniosacral therapy. Its goal
is maximizing movement of the cerebrospinal fluid that circulates around
the brain and spinal cord, bringing nourishment to the tissues and help-
ing to eliminate metabolic waste products.
Biodynamic techniques facilitate release by using the flow of the cere-
brospinal fluid contained within the dural membranes of the skull and
spine. The therapist holds the client's head with an extremely light touch,
combined with a keen awareness of the tiny, subtle movements of the
cranial bones?
The Spinal Nerves
Most people have heard about problems arising from dysfunctions of
the spinal nerves. Many people suffer from a herniated disk that presses
on the spinal cord, or a bone growth (spinal stenosis) that can press on
a spinal nerve and cause pain, loss of sensation, or loss of function (for
example, bladder control). Spinal nerve dysfunction can also cause local
paralysis (inability to use a specific skeletal muscle).
22
EFTA00810024
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
Some people use chiropractic or osteopathic treatments to alleviate
spinal-nerve compression. Chiropractors usually use high-velocity,
short-thrust techniques intended to reposition a vertebra, bringing it
into better alignment and taking pressure off of the pain-causing nerve.
Osteopaths have the same goal but usually use a more gentle approach.
Other popular "conservative" treatments for the spine include yoga
and stretching, strengthening the back muscles with calisthenics, weight
training, physical therapy, and massage to balance the tonus of the back
muscles. If these methods fail to keep the spine in shape, we may feel
invalidated, despondent, and inclined to choose radical treatments such
as surgery.
Back surgery is a booming business. About 500,000 Americans
undergo surgery each year for lower-back problems alone. According
to the US Agency for Health care Research and Quality, we spent more
than $30.7 billion in 2008 alone on hospital procedures for back pain.10
Unfortunately, surgery doesn't always buy relief. And studies show that
most backaches go away by themselves in time. The hospital in my town
in Denmark has stopped using surgery for back pain.
For decades, orthopedic surgeons have treated back problems by cut-
ting away part of a bulging disk, chiseling away a bone spur, or even
inserting a metal plate and screws to stiffen adjacent vertebrae. In spite of
the widespread use of surgery, the effectiveness of such operations is not
scientifically documented. On the contrary, there is a growing body of
research showing that such operations are not effective in the long run.".12-13
One important function of the spinal nerves is to allow us to use
our arms, legs, and trunk to move our body by contracting and relaxing
various muscles. Spinal nerves also innervate some of the visceral organs.
Messages to the spinal nerves originate in the brain and travel through
the spinal cord, a tube-like nerve bundle that exits the cranium through
a large opening in the base of the skull called the foramen magnum (Latin
for "large hole").
After exiting the cranium, pairs of spinal nerves emanate from the
spinal cord, emerging through spaces between adjacent vertebrae to serve
the muscles, joints, ligaments, tendons, internal organs, and skin. Human
23
EFTA00810025
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
beings have thirty-three pairs of spinal nerves, with one nerve of each pair
going to the right side of the body and the other to the left.
Each pair of spinal nerves corresponds to a segment of the vertebral
column. There are thirty-three vertebrae in all: seven in the neck,
twelve in the chest, five in the lumbar region, five in the sacrum, and
four in the tailbone. The spinal nerves, which include both motor and
sensory nerves, carry signals back and forth between the brain and
rest of the body. Two important exceptions are the trapezius and the
sternocleidomastoid muscles in the neck and shoulder, which receive
their innervation from the eleventh cranial nerve; implications of this
are discussed elsewhere in this book, including Chapter 5.
There is always more than one branch of one spinal nerve going to any
given muscle. This provides insurance that, if one of the spinal nerves is
damaged, the muscle can still function (albeit less efficiently) using the
signals from other available nerves.
Every spinal nerve also affects several muscles. Often the muscles are
part of a chain of movement—for example, muscles in the shoulder,
upper arm, forearm, wrist, and fingers work together as a unit to control
the basic movements of the arm or hand.
The motor pathways of a nerve signal a muscle to contract. The spi-
nal sensory nerves gather various kinds of information from the body
and feed it back to the brain: they carry sensations of pain, positions of
the body parts in relationship to each other, movement, tension in the
muscles or fascia, and the sense of touch for all of the body except the
face (which is innervated by cranial nerves).
Branches of the spinal and cranial nerves are traditionally categorized
into motor and sensory functions, but this is an oversimplification. If we
look more closely at the individual "motor nerves," we observe that some
of their fibers are motor fibers—but that they also contain sensory fibers
that report the state of tension in a muscle back to the brain. We now
know that the majority of fibers in "motor nerves" are actually sensory.
This combination of sensory and motor nerve fibers provides a
feedback loop that allows us to use the motor fibers to tense a muscle
while sensory fibers simultaneously send information back to the brain
24
EFTA00810026
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
regarding the changing level of tension in the muscle. This allows us to
calibrate the tensing of the muscle—a much more powerful and efficient
approach than if the muscle could only tense fully or not at all, which
would be the case if we had no sensory-fiber feedback.
Under normal conditions, the spinal nerves facilitate easy, well-
coordinated, graceful movements, and the muscles fire using the
minimum amount of energy to achieve the desired movement. However,
if the body is in a state of stress and all the muscles are more tense than
necessary, this natural coordination is often lost, and movements become
uncoordinated, awkward, or weak.
THE SPINAL SYMPATHETIC CHAIN
Branches of the spinal nerves go to specific bodily structures: the
skin (dermatomes), the muscles (myotomes), the visceral organs
(viscerotomes), and the ligaments, fascia, and connective tissue
(fasciatomes). Rather than a single spinal nerve innervating only one
muscle, there is some overlap, so that branches of several spinal nerves
may innervate the same individual muscle. This creates a backup system
so that if one part of a nerve is damaged, other parts can still contract
the same muscle, and it can still function, though it works less efficiently.
Some of the spinal nerves go to the internal organs. For example, the
nerves from thoracic vertebrae TI and T4 go to the heart, the nerves from
T5 and T8 go to the lungs, T9 goes to the stomach, and Tt0 goes to the
kidneys. Other nerves serve other structures including the bladder, genital
organs, and intestines.
Upon exiting the spinal cord, some thoracic and upper-lumbar spinal
nerve fibers (T1—L2) extend laterally a short distance. While some of these
stay in the same area, others join fibers from vertebrae above and below
to form part of the sympathetic chain. The sympathetic chain extends the
length of the vertebral column between Tl and L2, connecting to these
spinal nerves. Most of the sympathetics, which project to visceral organs
and to the head, are accompanied by arteries to their destinations.
25
EFTA00810027
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
When we face a threat to our survival, there is a surge in the activity
of the entire sympathetic chain, spreading the fight-or-flight response to
mobilize the resources of the entire body. This response is immediate and
total, which is appropriate if we are threatened or in danger. The muscles
tense to prepare for movements needed to fight or flee; this is described
in weight-lifting circles as getting "pumped up."
Some organs innervated by these sympathetic nerve fibers increase
their level of activity in order to support this mobilization. For example,
the heart beats faster to supply more blood to the muscular system.
The blood pressure increases to be able to pump more blood into tense
muscles. The liver releases stored-up sugars into the blood to make extra
energy available for the muscles to burn. The survival stress response from
the sympathetic chain causes the muscles of the airways to open to the
maximum, improving our breathing capacity and taking in the maximum
amount of oxygen in order to be fully mobilized to fight or run.
At the same time, other organs (primarily those involved in digestion)
are slowed or stopped. There is a loss of appetite, the movement of food in
the intestine slows or stops, and the person might experience a sensation
of "butterflies" in her stomach.
In cases of threat or challenge, the stress state created by the sympa-
thetic response affects the whole body, and it can involve the muscles of all
the segments simultaneously. Activation of the spinal sympathetic chain
in the "fight or flight" response is one of the three possible states of the
autonomic nervous system, to be discussed in more detail later.
The Enteric Nervous System
The enteric nervous system is a network of nerves interconnecting the
visceral organs. We know next to nothing about these nerves; because they
are so interwoven with each other, with the visceral organs, and with the
connective tissue between the organs, it has been impossible so far for
anatomists to fully trace the pathways of the enteric nerves. Therefore, we
do not find them well represented in most anatomy books.
26
EFTA00810028
Getting to Know Your Autonomic Nervous System
Furthermore, we know almost nothing of how the enteric nerves
function. At best we can guess that the enteric nerves in some way help
the different visceral organs to communicate with each other in order to
coordinate the very complex process of digestion.
The enteric nervous system is even sometimes referred to as "the
second brain," possessing an intelligence that operates beyond our
conscious awareness." We can neither consciously know what is going
on in our digestive process nor regulate it voluntarily.
27
EFTA00810029
I I
EFTA00810030
CHAPTER 2
The Polyvagal Theory
Whether you can observe a thing or not depends on the theory
you use. It is the theory that decides what am be observed.
—Albert Einstein
The Three Circuits of the
Autonomic Nervous System
Traditionally the autonomic nervous system was recognized for its
regulation of the various visceral automatic" functions, such as digestion,
respiration, sex drive, reproduction, etc. The old model of stress-or-
relaxation was based on recognizing only two circuits—the sympathetic
and the parasympathetic.
In the old model, the sympathetic nervous system was seen as active
in stress response to threats and danger. The parasympathetic nervous
system, by contrast, expressed itself in the relaxation response and was
associated with the function of the vagus nerve. This older, almost
universally accepted model of the autonomic nervous system assumed
that there is a single vagus nerve, and it did not take account of the fact
that there are actually two quite different neural pathways that are both
called "vagus."
The Polyvagal Theory begins by recognizing that the vagus nerve has
two separate branches—two separate, distinct vagal nerves that originate
in two different locations. We get a more accurate representation of the
workings of the autonomic nervous system if we consider that the auto-
nomic nervous system consists of three neural circuits: the ventral branch
of the vagus nerve (positive states of relaxation and social engagement),
the spinal sympathetic chain (fight or flight), and the dorsal branch of
29
EFTA00810031
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
the vagus nerve (slowdown, shutdown, and depressive behavior). These
three circuits regulate our bodily functions in order to help us maintain
homeostasis.
The Polyvagal Theory also presents another dimension to our under-
standing of the autonomic nervous system. The autonomic nervous sys-
tem not only regulates the function of our inner organs; these three circuits
also relate to our emotional states, which in turn drive our behavior.
People who give massage know from experience that one person's
body might be too tight, another might be too soft, and a third can feel
"just right." Usually, when therapists are trained to give massage, they
learn to release tension in a tense muscle. However, this approach does
not work on a body that lacks sufficient tone.
Goldilocks and the Three ANS States
A good metaphor for the three states of the autonomic nervous system
can be found in the fairy tale "Goldilocks and the Three Bears."
Goldilocks was wandering alone in the woods when she came to the
cabin belonging to the three bears. She knocked on the door, but no one
answered. Being tired and hungry, she decided to go inside and wait until
someone returned.
Goldilocks noticed three bowls of porridge on the table. When she
tasted them, she found that the first was too hot, the next was too cool,
and the third was just right
After she ate that third bowl of porridge, she saw three beds and
decided to take a nap. The first bed was too hard, and the second too
soft—but the third one was just right, so she lay down on that one and
fell asleep, contented.
The quality of the tone of the musculature in the three autonomic
states can be described as one of the following: too hard or hot (in the
fight or flight state of spinal sympathetic activity), too soft or cold (in
the shutdown state of dorsal vagal activity), and just right (in the state
of social engagement, based on the activity of the ventral branch of the
vagus and the other four cranial nerves related to social engagement).
30
EFTA00810032
The Polyvagal Theory
Activity supported by the spinal sympathetic chain enables us to fight in
order to meet a threat, or run away in order to avoid it. This is because
hard, tense muscles allow us to move the entire body more quickly. Higher
blood pressure is also needed to get the flow of blood into muscles that
are tensed and hard.
Low levels of muscle tonus are found when the dorsal vagal circuit is
activated, when there is no need to tense the muscles to fight or flee (or, in
some cases of extreme danger, when the body's survival response is to shut
down). Low blood pressure is sufficient to get the blood into soft, limp
muscles. In its extreme form, this low blood pressure may cause people
to lose consciousness and faint. The medical term for this is "syncope:'
Normal blood pressure is appropriate for muscles that are neither
tense nor flaccid—muscles that feel just right. In states of social engage-
ment, there is generally no threat or danger in our environment or body.
Our nervous system registers this fact, so we do not have to do anything;
we can truly relax and enjoy being with others. In terms of the Polyvagal
Theory, we can be immobilized without fear, anger, or depressive activity
when we are in a state of social engagement. Our blood pressure, blood
sugar, and temperature are all normal. We can be still, yet awake and alert.
A handshake gives us a good indication of the state of another person's
autonomic nervous system. An overly tight body usually results from a
chronic state of activity in the spinal sympathetic chain, where the entire
muscular system is continually prepared to fight or flee. Such a person
characteristically has an overly forceful handshake, squeezing harder than
necessary. The opposite is true for someone lacking muscular tonus—
usually a sign of overactivity in the dorsal vagal circuit. This person gen-
erally has a limp, damp, and sometimes cold handshake.
If our handshake is just right, it is the ventral branch of the vagus
nerve that is predominant. We may have some tensions in individual
muscles, but the tense muscles relax very quickly, and a massage therapist
will notice that our body also feels right.
The tonus of the muscles is only one of many ways to monitor the
state of the body's nervous system.
31
EFTA00810033
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
HOMEOSTASIS AND THE ANS
The neural circuits controlling the nerves regulating visceral-organ func-
tion can be compared to a thermostat linked to both a heater and an air
conditioner. When the thermostat registers that the air is too cold, it turns
on the heater, and if the air is too warm, it turns on the air conditioner.
Mammals similarly need to maintain body temperature within upper
and lower limits, and their sensory nerves provide feedback about body
temperature to their "thermostat:'
Behavioral patterns as well as physiological functions help the body to
regulate temperature. For example, if we are cold, we can move around
to produce heat through the activity of our muscles, or we can put on
more clothes to insulate ourselves and reduce the loss of body heat. The
blood vessels of the skin constrict to conserve heat. When we are very
cold, our bodies start to shiver uncontrollably, producing heat from the
action of the muscles.
When we are warm, we lie down or sit still in order to reduce muscular
activity and thereby avoid further overheating. The blood vessels dilate,
allowing more heat to reach the skin surface where it can be dissipated.
We take off layers of clothing, and we sweat; when our sweat evaporates,
it cools the body.
When people are angry, we sometimes say that they are "hot under
the collar." We might admonish them to "cool it:' When people do not
like something, they may withdraw, and we say that they are "cool" to it.
We think of ways to "warm them up" to the idea. Both heat and coolness
are sensed as reflections of emotional states.
The three parts of the autonomic nervous system work together to
control the activity of the organs, bring about homeostasis, and help us
continue to appropriately meet environmental situations and balance
conditions within the body.
We can also apply the model of the Polyvagal Theory to problems and
diagnoses in many physiological areas such as digestion or reproduction,
which we might otherwise consider to be physical issues beyond our con-
trol or influence.
32
EFTA00810034
The Polyvagal Theory
For example, there is a growing body of scientific research that
uses heart rate variability (HRV) to measure ventral vagal activity by
quantifying a spontaneous rhythm in heart rate known as respiratory
sinus arrhythmia. These studies find that low levels of ventral vagal
activity are linked to a wide range of health issues, such as obesity, high
blood pressure, heart fluctuations, etc.1S There are also some speculations
that HRV is a potentially useful measurement to help predict the onset of
cancer, cancer metastasis, or the likely mortality of people with cancer."
(For more about HRV, sec Chapter 4.)
The Five States of the
Autonomic Nervous System
BIOBEHAVIOR: THE INTERACTION OF BEHAVIOR
AND BIOLOGICAL PROCESSES
Unlike the old model of the autonomic nervous system, which focused
exclusively on its regulation of the function of the visceral organs, the
new model of the autonomic nervous system includes three distinct neu-
ral pathways, as described above, and relates each of these three neural
circuits with an emotional state, which drives our behavior. In addition
to these three states, we have two hybrid states, each of which combines
two of the individual circuits, for a total of five possible conditions of our
autonomic nervous system.
One hybrid state supports the experience of intimacy: the dorsal vagus
is engaged to slow down our physical activity, at the same time as the ven-
tral vagus allows a feeling of safety with another person. This is discussed
in further detail below.
The second hybrid state expresses itself in friendly competition. We
may fight extremely hard to win in sports or games, but this occurs
within a framework of safety and rules to which all of the opponents
have agreed in advance. In this hybrid state, the fight or flight response
of spinal sympathetic chain activation is combined with the feelings of
safety associated with activity of the ventral vagus branch.
33
EFTA00810035
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
THE THREE NEURAL PATHWAYS OF THE ANS
The first of the autonomic nervous system's neural pathways is the social-
engagement nervous system. It involves activity in the ventral branch of
the vagus nerve (CN X) and four other cranial nerves (CN V, VII, IX, and
XI). Activity in this circuit has a calming, soothing effect, and promotes
rest and restitution.
The ventral branch of the vagus nerve relates to positive emotions
of joy, satisfaction, and love. In terms of behavior, it expresses itself in
positive social activities with friends and loved ones. The state of social
engagement supports social behaviors in which we support and share
with other people. Cooperation with others usually improve our chances
for survival—we talk together, sing together, dance together, share a meal,
cooperate to complete a project, teach and nurture children, etc.
The second of the ANS's neural pathways is the spinal sympathetic
chain, which is activated when our survival is threatened. If we mobi-
lize our body with this response, we can make an extra effort to help us
respond to the threat. This state of "mobilization with fear" arises when
we are not safe, or do not feel safe. The spinal sympathetic chain relates
to emotions of anger or fear, which can express themselves in behaviors
such as fighting in order to overcome the threat or fleeing to avoid a
threatening situation.
The third neural pathway is the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve. This
pathway is activated when we face an overwhelming force and imminent
destruction. When there is no point in fighting or running away, we con-
serve what resources we have—we immobilize. Activation of this pathway
fosters feelings of helplessness, hopelessness, and apathy, manifesting in
withdrawal and shutdown. This state can be described as "immobiliza-
tion with fear?'
When humans or other mammals are faced with seemingly inevitable
mortal danger, death, or destruction, the dorsal branch of our vagus
nerve is activated. A sudden or extreme surge of dorsal vagal activity can
give rise to a state of shock, or shutdown. Among other responses, the
muscular system loses its tonus, and the blood pressure drops. We might
faint or go into a state of shock (syncope).
34
EFTA00810036
The Polyvagal Theory
Wildlife documentaries on the African plains have captured the fol-
lowing scene. A lion chases and captures a baby antelope, and takes it
up in its mighty jaws. The baby antelope had been in a state of spinal
sympathetic chain activity when it was threatened and ran away. Now,
facing imminent death, it goes into shock and shutdown: it faints, and
its body goes limp.
Lions are not generally scavengers. If a lion suddenly senses that that
its prey has become lifeless, it may open its jaws, drop the prey, and move
away. Just when the lion is about to shake the baby antelope in order to
break its neck, or to sink its teeth into its flesh, the limp muscles fail to
give the usual resistance. Perhaps the antelope's shutdown response is
enough to nullify the lion's killer instinct. The lion releases its grip, the
baby antelope falls to the ground, and the lion moves away.
A few seconds after the lion leaves, the baby antelope stands up, shakes
it off, and returns to its mother. It then resumes grazing as if nothing has
happened. The baby antelope is ready to face the next challenge to its
survival, thanks to its life-saving shutdown response. This illustrates the
adaptive survival value of the dorsal-branch immobilization response in
situations of extreme danger.
We see another example of how the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve
can facilitate a successful defense: A porcupine, facing danger from a
predator, withdraws by rolling up into a balks sharp quills bristle out-
ward, making it impossible for the predator to successfully bite it.
THE TWO HYBRID CIRCUITS
in addition to these three circuits of the autonomic nervous system, there
are two hybrid states made up of different combinations of two of the
three neural circuits.
The fourth state is a hybrid that supports friendly competition, or
"mobilization without fear," which is appropriate when we engage in
competitive sports. This state combines the effects of two neural circuits:
activation of the spinal sympathetic chain allows us to mobilize our-
selves in order to achieve our best performance. Activation of the social
35
EFTA00810037
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
engagement circuit keeps things friendly, so that we can play safely within
the rules and avoid hurting each other.
In sports, we can fight very hard to win. Both teams agree to follow
the rules and stay within boundaries to keep everything safe. After all, it
is only a game. There are many other examples of mobilization without
fear. Puppies from the same litter constantly play with each other as if
they were fighting. They growl and they bite each other for hours on end.
In Japan, lovers sometimes have a ritual pillow fight. The pillows are
overfilled with feathers, and slit open along one side. Within a few hits,
the feathers come out of the pillowcase and fly around until they have
filled the whole room, usually to the great amusement of the lovers. What
started out as a "fight" now elicits smiles and laughs from both of them.
The fifth state is also a hybrid of two neural circuits. Activity in the
dorsal branch of the vagus nerve, when combined with that of the ventral
branch of the vagus nerve, supports feelings of intimacy and intimate
behavior. This state, which we could call "immobilization without fear;'
is characterized by calm, trusting feelings, allowing us, for example, to lie
still and cuddle with a loved one.
The Vagus Nerve
Physical well-being and emotional well-being are intimately linked. If
we have a headache, it can be difficult to be happy, joyful, and interested
in connecting with other people. On the other hand, when we have had
a sound night's sleep, some exercise, and a good meal, we feel on top of
things and naturally want to be sociable. This connection is well known.
However, not many of us know that a nerve called the vagus helps
regulate most of the bodily functions necessary for our health and emo-
tional well-being. This nerve must function properly in order for us to be
healthy, feel good emotionally, and interact positively with family, friends,
and others.
36
EFTA00810038
The Polyvagal Theory
HISTORICAL RECOGNITION OF THE VAGUS NERVE
The anatomy of the nervous system describes where the nerves are located
in the body in relationship to muscles, bones, skin, visceral organs, etc.
The physiology of the nervous system describes the function of these
nerves—how they monitor what is going on at different places in the
body, how they gather and integrate this information, and how they send
signals to control various body functions.
A thorough study of the anatomy and physiology of the nervous
system is a major undertaking. Together, anatomy and physiology have
formed the foundation of knowledge taught in the first half of the medical
school curriculum. For at least the past century, the study of these two
disciplines has also found its way into the education of almost all other
health care professionals in the Western world.
The first recorded mention of the vagus nerve came from the Greek
physician Claudius Galen (130-200 AD), who lived in the Roman Empire
and studied the vagus nerve in gladiators whose injuries he treated, and
also in the Barbary apes and pigs that he dissected in order to learn more
about the body. Galen noted certain dysfunctions that occurred when the
vagus nerve had been severed in some of the gladiators.
Galen's writings on the vagus nerve were only part of his legacy. In
fact, his writings comprise half of all writings on any subject that have
survived from ancient Greece. His vast writings were so widespread and
respected that they served as the foundation of European medicine for
more than 1,500 years. Since Galen's first explorations, the vagus nerve
has been included in all medical texts as well as in papers and books by
many psychologists.
Over the centuries, as medical doctors and other health care profes-
sionals built upon Galen's observations, they came to believe that the
autonomic nervous system consisted of two divisions, the sympathetic
and the parasympathetic, both of which innervate the visceral organs.
According to this interpretation, the sympathetic division is activated
in states of stress, and helps to mobilize the body to fight or flee—or
freeze, if need be. The parasympathetic nervous system was understood
37
EFTA00810039
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
to consist primarily of the vagus nerve, and to promote relaxation, rest,
and restitution,
The almost universally accepted idea was that the sympathetic and
parasympathetic nervous systems comprise a balanced system, adjusting
their activity accordingly as a person moves back and forth between states
of stress and relaxation. The old idea of the autonomic nervous system
can be likened to two children on a seesaw: when one child goes down,
the child on the other side goes up, and vice versa.
For the last century or so, chronic stress has been identified as a
health problem involved in heart disease, asthma, diabetes, and a host of
other illnesses. Therefore, relaxation deriving from a well-functioning
vagus nerve was considered to be essential to health. The vagus nerve
was thought to ensure proper function of the visceral organs responsible
for circulation (heart and spleen), respiration (bronchioles and lungs),
digestion (stomach, pancreas, liver, gall bladder, and small intestine), and
elimination (the ascending and transverse parts of the large intestine, and
the kidneys and ureters).
In addition to the vagus nerve, a definition of the "relaxed state" usu-
ally included activity of the sacral parasympathetic pathways that go to
the descending colon, rectum, bladder, and lower portions of the ureters.
Some of these pathways also innervate the genitalia, enabling various
sexual reactions. Part of the "parasympathetics" included sacral nerves
that come from the sacrum at the base of the spine. Taken together with
the vagus nerve, these were characterized as the "rest and digest" or "feed
and breed" system.
In 1994, in his presidential lecture for the Society for Psychophysi-
ological Research, Stephen Porges introduced his Polyvagal Theory, which
he built around a new understanding of the function of the vagus nerve.
A year later, he published these ideas in the journal Psychophysiology" in
an article entitled 'Orienting in a Defensive World: Mammalian Modifica-
tions of our Evolutionary Heritage—A Polyvagal Theory?'
Porges presented a radically different model of the autonomic system.
Whereas his concept of stress is similar to the older model, he focused on
three divisions of the autonomic nervous system: the ventral branch of
38
EFTA00810040
The Polyvagal Theory
the vagus nerve, the sympathetic nervous system, and the dorsal branch
of the vagus nerve.
Two Branches of the Nerve Called "Vagus"
The dorsal and ventral branches of the vagus nerve (CN X) originate at
different locations in the brain and brainstem, have different pathways
through the body, and have very different functions. There is actually no
direct anatomical or functional connection between the two; they are
separate and distinct entities.
Before the Polyvagal Theory, we did not adequately differentiate
between these two branches of the vagus nerve. The ventral branch was
lumped together with the dorsal under the heading "the vagus nerve"
or "tenth cranial nerve:' This has caused longstanding confusion in our
attempts to understand the function of the autonomic nervous system.
The Polyvagal Theory makes it possible to appreciate the differences
between the two branches of the vagus nerve. The ventral and dorsal
branches arise at different locations the word ventral refers to the location
of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve, which originates in the nucleus
ambiguus on the ventral (front, or stomach) side of the brainstem. The
word dorsal means "toward the back"; as mentioned earlier, the dorsal
vagus arises in the floor of the fourth ventricle. The two branches of the
vagus nerve evoke very different physiological states, affect the individual
visceral organs differently, support different emotional responses, and
promote different behaviors. The ventral branch of the vagus nerve func-
tions in conjunction with four other cranial nerves (V, VII, IX, and XI),
which also originate in the brainstem. The ventral vagus is myelinated,
i.e., insulated by a covering of Schwann cells (connective-tissue cells)
that enable it to transmit information more rapidly than non-myelinated
nerves. The dorsal vagus, the older of the two, is not myelinated.
In contrast to the sympathetic nervous system, which enables extreme
mobilization to facilitate fight or flight, the two branches of the vagus
nerve can both bring about immobilization. However, the ventral vagus
and the dorsal vagus produce two very different states of immobilization,
39
EFTA00810041
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
based on two very different kinds of physiological activity; they are associ-
ated with two different types of behavior, evoke two different emotional
responses, and have different effects on the visceral organs.
EFFECTS OF ACTIVITY IN THE VENTRAL VAGUS CIRCUIT
When the ventral branch of the vagus nerve and the associated four cra-
nial nerves function properly, human beings and other mammals enjoy
the desirable state of social engagement. To be socially engaged, we need
to feel safe, with no need to overcome or avoid any external threat by
fighting or fleeing; we also need to be physically healthy. When we are
socially engaged, we do not need to do anything, or to change anything;
we can afford to be immobilized without fear (relaxed). We can maintain
a vibrant tone without being collapsed or overly aroused.
The ventral branch of the vagus nerve, together with the other four
associated cranial nerves, promotes rest and restitution, ensuring that the
physiological prerequisites are present for optimal physical and emotional
health, friendship, cooperation, mutual support, parent-child bonding,
and loving relationships. When we are socially engaged, we can be cre-
ative, positive, productive, and happy.
Sometimes the ventral vagus is called the "new vagus" because it is
more recent in terms of its appearance in our phylogenetic species history
than the dorsal vagus. The ventral branch is newer in terms of evolution;
it is found only in mammals, and in no other class of vertebrates, though
there is the possibility that birds may have an equivalent to a ventral vagal
pathway. According to Stephen Porges, the two branches of the vagus
nerve emerged at different stages in the evolutionary development of
vertebrates.
When we (or other mammals) are safe in our environment—free from
threats, danger, and unnecessary worries—and in good physical health,
we normally exhibit behavior that is socially engaged.
When we are threatened or in danger, however, our autonomic ner-
vous system shuts down the activity of the ventral branch of the vagus
nerve and regresses to an earlier, more primitive evolutionary response
40
EFTA00810042
The Polyvagal Theory
of either spinal sympathetic activity (flight/fight) or depressive behavior
(withdrawal).
If we have a well-functioning nervous system and are socially engaged,
we might naturally meet a new situation with openness, trust, and positive
expectations. We feel safe, and might first try to communicate, cooperate,
and share. Even in the face of a threat, our behavior might still be open
and friendly at first. Sometimes this positive, prosocial behavior can also
make the other person feel safe, which in turn might be enough to defuse
a potentially threatening situation.
However, if this prosocial behavior is not enough to neutralize the
threat or danger, our evolutionarily most recent neural mechanism—
the social engagement circuit—is the first to be abandoned. We leave the
realm of rational thought and conscious choice, and all of our energy
goes into instinctive, defensive responses.
If our autonomic nervous system feels that a situation is unsafe, our
response can shift down one phylum, from social engagement to the
level of reptiles with a strong spinal sympathetic chain response, and we
might fight to overcome the threat, or flee to avoid it. If the situation is
so extreme that fighting or fleeing is not enough, we may shift down even
further and shut down or collapse into a dorsal vagal state of withdrawal,
dissociation, and shutdown.
EFFECTS OF ACTIVITY IN THE DORSAL VAGUS CIRCUIT
The dorsal branch is the older of the two branches of the vagus nerve,
and is present in all classes of vertebrates, from boneless fish up to and
including human beings and other mammals. It is sometimes referred
to as the "old vagus."
The Polyvagal Theory describes two autonomic nervous-system states
that employ the dorsal vagal circuit. The dorsal vagus, acting on its own,
brings about a state of metabolic shutdown. It enables animals to reduce
the activity level in their vital functions, thereby conserving energy. This
can be described as "immobilization with fear": we are afraid, but we do
nothing to confront the danger or run away; we just give up.
41
EFTA00810043
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
The other state involving the dorsal vagal circuit is "immobilization
without fear," which combines activity in the dorsal vagal circuit with
activity in the social engagement circuit. This state is appropriate when we
feel safe and choose to be relatively immobilized in order to be intimate
with another person.
The hibernation of mammals involves some degree of dorsal vagal
activity, but it is not the same as shutdown. Bears hibernate in winter,
for example, but it is more of a slowdown than a shutdown. Bears are
warm-blooded and, like all other mammals, need to maintain a minimum
oxygen intake and body temperature, often higher than the tempera-
ture of the surrounding air, in order to keep their brain functioning and
undamaged by hypothermia.
By contrast, reptiles can shutdown almost totally, reducing their heart
rate, breathing, and digestion drastically to conserve energy until their
next meal. A turtle shuts down its metabolism and life processes as it
sleeps in the wintry, near-freezing waters at the bottom of a freshwater
pond; its body temperature falls to the temperature of the surrounding
water. The turtle is cold-blooded and does not produce its own energy
to raise its body temperature. Instead, it will often lie on a rock to gather
warmth from the sun and air. The winter hibernation of a bear in its cave
involves a lesser degree of dorsal vagus activity, which is quite different
from the near-total shutdown of a cold-blooded reptile such as a turtle.
The bear's body temperature falls only a few degrees.
A sudden, extreme surge in dorsal vagal activity when we or other
mammals are faced with mortal danger can result in a state of shock,
or immobilization with fear. Although I sometimes refer to this physi-
ological state as "shutdown:' in mammals it is more precise to think of
it as a drastic slowdown. This immobilization with fear can be used as a
defensive strategy, as in behaviors such as freezing and feigning death. For
example, a mouse freezes when it senses a predator nearby, becoming "as
still as a mouse" to avoid detection.
Hawks have extremely good eyesight and can pick up the slightest
movement, even those of a mouse's normal breathing. If a hawk is cir-
cling in a field over a mouse, the hawk will see any mouse that tries to
42
EFTA00810044
The Polyvagal Theory
run away and will swoop down and catch it in its sharp claws. So, instead
of employing the defense strategy of fleeing, the mouse freezes. It slows
down its vital activity and holds its breath until the hawk has flown away
and the danger is over.
However, if the slowdown is too sudden or too extreme, it can result
in the mouse being literally scared to death. About 10 percent of mice die
from shutting down as a response to danger from a bird of prey or a snake.
The Polyvagal Theory describes how a surge in the activity of the
dorsal branch of the vagus nerve is a defensive strategy that causes a physi-
ological state of shock or shutdown to help us cope with traumatic events,
extreme danger, or imminent destruction, whether real or imagined, by
suddenly collapsing and shutting down. Giving up or feigning death can
be lifesaving; by not moving, we might avoid the attention of a predator
or enemy. Physiologically, immobilization also conserves energy.
However, remaining chronically in a dorsal vagal state when there is
no longer any threat or danger robs us of our clarity, productivity, and
joy of living until we can get back into a state of social engagement. In
our culture, we have become preoccupied with problems stemming from
stress. Unfortunately, we have remained largely unaware that another
danger to our health arises from the widespread condition of chronic
activation of the dorsal vagus circuit.
When dorsal vagal activity is less extreme but chronic, its emotional
correlate is characterized by depressive feelings. In everyday conversation,
many people say that they experience "depression:' or describe their mood
and behavior as "depressed," without having been diagnosed as such by
a psychiatrist or psychologist. For the purposes of this book, I prefer to
use the terms "depressive feelings" and "depressive behavior" or "activity
of the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve," and to generally avoid the term
depression, which is a medical or psychological diagnosis.
People with a diagnosis of depression, or people in a depressed state,
typically lose interest in activities that once were pleasurable. They over-
eat, experience loss of appetite, or have digestive problems. They have
reduced energy, and they become inactive, introverted, apathetic, help-
less, and asocial. They can feel sad, anxious, empty, hopeless, worthless,
43
EFTA00810045
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
guilty, irritable, ashamed, or restless. They may experience lethargy, lack
of energy, and a lack of goal-oriented activity.
They can have problems concentrating, remembering details, or mak-
ing decisions, and are often plagued by the aches and pains of fibromyal-
gia. They may contemplate, attempt, or commit suicide. These can all be
symptoms of activity in the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve.
The medical literature has generally focused on the physiology of
chronic stress, with less attention given to the physiology underlying
chronic depression. But when people come to my clinic with a diagnosis
of depression from a psychologist or psychiatrist, or when they exhibit
depressive behavior, I find that that their problem is usually accompanied
by a state of activation of the dorsal branch of their vagus nerve.
If the transition into a dorsal state has involved a sudden surge in
dorsal-branch activity, the event can be described as a shock or trauma,
and we can describe its effect as "shutdown." When a person faces an
overwhelmingly dangerous situation and/or the possibility of imminent
death, it is a natural reaction to dissociate from ones own body, from the
here and now; to shut down physically, emotionally, and mentally; and
perhaps even to faint.
Ideally, when the danger has passed, we should move out of this state
and back to social engagement; we should "come back to our senses:'
However, many people get stuck at some level of this state of immobiliza-
tion with fear. In this case, it is appropriate to suspect that there is chronic
activation of the dorsal vagal circuit.
Prior to the Polyvagal Theory, depression and depressive behaviors
issues lacked a physiological model in terms of the nervous system. It
neither fit into the category of stress nor that of relaxation. Perhaps this
is why it has been so difficult to find safe, non-addictive, and effective
treatments for conditions such as depression.
Stephen Porges's Polyvagal Theory focuses on the relationships of
the autonomic nervous system, the emotions, and behavior. His work
has awakened a growing interest in applications of these understandings
by psychologists, psychiatrists, and an array of gifted, insightful trauma
therapists. He describes what he calls the "vagal brake"—how activation
44
EFTA00810046
The Polyvagal Theory
of the social engagement circuit "puts the brakes on" the other circuits
and lifts us out of a chronic dorsal vagal or spinal sympathetic state.
Under normal conditions of challenges to survival, the spinal sympath-
etic chain or the dorsal branch of the vagal nerve may be triggered into
active states of defense. However, when social engagement is coupled with
either of these circuits, the range of human behavior is expanded by keeping
the individual out of a defensive state. When social engagement joins together
with the spinal sympathetic chain, this hybrid enables friendly movements,
including symbolic fighting, which are at the heart of the human activity of
play. When the dorsal vagal circuit support of immobilization is joined with
the protective regulatory features of the ventral vagus and other components
of the social engagement system such as prosodic vocalizations, feelings of
intimacy may spontaneously emerge. People can be close together physically
and share the positive feelings of love.
Using the exercises in this book, it should only take a minute or two
to get back into a state of social engagement.
SYMPTOMS OF A DORSAL VAGAL STATE
If we are not socially engaged, we can experience many negative physi-
cal and emotional symptoms when faced with adverse conditions. One
response is the state of mobilization of the spinal sympathetic chain,
characterized by activities of fight or flight.
The other response comes from activation of the dorsal vagal circuit:
Our muscles and connective tissues lose their normal tonus, soften, and
go limp, and our body feels heavy. To someone else, our muscles feel flac-
cid. If we try to do even a small task, it takes a monumental effort to move.
In this state we typically feel helpless, apathetic, and hopeless. Our
heartbeat slows, and our blood pressure drops; the blood withdraws from
the periphery of the body and gathers in the center. Much of the blood,
full of oxygen and nutrients that normally would go to the arms and legs
to enable a fight-or-flight response in spinal sympathetic chain activity,
is retracted to the thorax and abdomen to maintain minimal levels of the
basic visceral functions. Thus our hands and feet feel cold and clammy.
45
EFTA00810047
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
When we are in a dorsal vagal state, we often have pains that move
around to different places in the body. Most people believe that pain in
the body comes from tight muscles, and therapists usually massage the
body where it hurts and/or it where muscles are hard. But often, when a
massage therapist alleviates pain at one place, another pain arises some-
where else.
This may seem inexplicable to massage therapists who know that they
did a good job making a once-hard muscle now feel soft. The client, not
acknowledging improvement from what we have done, says, "Now the
pain has moved to here." So the therapist chases the pain from one place
to another, without the client actually feeling better. This condition is
often diagnosed as fibromyalgia.
Rather than simply massaging an area that hurts, the best way to
treat this condition is to elevate the person from a dorsal vagal state by
activating the ventral circuit state, for example, with the Basic Exercise
(see Part Two).
There are other commonly observable signs when we are in a state of
shock or shutdown: The face loses its color and appears lifeless and unre-
sponsive; the facial expression is unchanging and facial muscles sag. The
voice also lacks prosody (melodic expressiveness); it is flat and without
melody. The eyes appear dull and lifeless—there is no sparkle. We may
also have low blood pressure, which can cause dizziness or fainting (vaso-
vagal syncope). This occurs because, if our muscles are undertoned, our
blood pressure does not need to be high in order to push blood through
the lowered resistance in the muscles.
Dorsal vagal state may also be involved in POTS (postural ortho-
static tachycardia syndrome). People with POTS typically faint when they
stand up and their blood pressure drops. They often exhibit numerous
symptoms of autonomic nervous system deregulation. Many POTS
symptoms seem to be caused by an imbalance of the autonomic nervous
system's control over blood flow and blood pressure. The autonomic
nervous system regulates the necessary adjustments in vascular tone,
46
EFTA00810048
The Polyvagal Theory
heart rate, and blood pressure when we stand up. In POTS, the system
seems to be out of balance, and blood is not going to the right places.18
Activation of the dorsal vagus circuit can also cause sweating or nau-
sea. In extreme situations, such as in sudden and severe fright, there can
be a loss of bladder and anal-sphincter control. Breathing slows, and the
volume of each breath is far less than usual. Our mental awareness turns
inward, or even disappears entirely when overwhelming danger presents
itself, resulting in dissociation, a withdrawal of consciousness from the
body. We are not in the here and now, and we may feel as if we are hav-
ing an out-of-body experience, as if watching what is going on from a
great distance.
The blood flow to the frontal lobes of our brain is also reduced by dorsal
vagus activation. These lobes are where our higher functions reside; the
frontal lobes are considered the human part of the brain and are involved
with the functions of language and will. By "will," I mean conceiving an
idea to do something, and monitoring our progress toward that goal.
Often, after a traumatic event, we say that we do not remember what
happened. Our brain is incapable of forming verbalizations or visualiza-
tions about what had been going on at the time because we were reacting
from a different, more primitive part of our brain and nervous system.
Dissociation is a widespread problem. It can be characterized as
ongoing activity of the dorsal vagus nerve that keeps us in a physiological
state of fear. We may be present in a group but not take part in a
conversation; we may be lethargic and lack empathy. We might talk a lot
but say nothing meaningful about ourselves or our situation. We cannot
set goals or take actions to bring about changes that could help us in life.
This depressive mindset is supported by chronic activity of the dorsal
branch of the vagus nerve.
However, if we are without fear, dorsal vagal activity has quite a
different effect. The state of immobilization without fear, based on
dorsal vagal activity combined with the activity of the cranial nerves of
social engagement, provides the physiological foundation for rest and
restitution, and supports intimacy.
47
EFTA00810049
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
EFFECTS OF VENTRAL VAGUS ACTIVITY
A step above reptiles, at the top of the evolutionary ladder, the class of
mammals including human beings has attained a more sophisticated ner-
vous system that includes ventral as well as dorsal vagal circuits. (Note
that modern reptiles are not the evolutionary ancestors of mammals;
primitive, now-extinct reptiles are our evolutionary precursors.)
In the entire animal kingdom, only mammals have a ventral circuit,
which is the ventral branch of the vagus nerve. To activate this ventral
vagal circuit, the individual must both be and feel safe in terms of the
environment, as well as in terms of feedback from the proprioceptive
nerves that monitor what is going on in the body.
The ventral vagal circuit can be active when we are physically active,
or when we are immobile. It gives rise to the state of social engagement,
together with four other cranial nerves (CN V, VII, IX and XI). Social
engagement goes far beyond the simple concept of "relaxation" in the old
model of the autonomic nervous system, with its two-state vacillation
between stress and relaxation. The ventral vagal state allows us to rest
and restore ourselves. We are not in a state of fear, and we can choose to
be immobile. We can sit in a rocking chair on the back porch on a warm
summer evening with someone we like, and watch the sun go down. We
can listen to music. We can daydream or meditate.
When we are not socially engaged, on the other hand, we can
experience many negative physical and emotional symptoms such as the
state of sympathetic nervous system mobilization, characterized by fight
or flight, or dorsal vagal immobilization (frozen and/or with depressed
behavior).
Despite these very different functions of the vagal and dorsal branches,
it is not surprising that Galen and the anatomists who followed after him
were not aware that the dorsal and ventral vagus branches are separate
entities. When Galen looked into the wounds of the gladiators, or dis-
sected pigs and Barbary apes, he did not have the luxury we have today in
the dissecting rooms of our universities; he could not cool the cadavers,
preserve them with formaldehyde, or observe them under microscopes.
48
EFTA00810050
The Polyvagal Theory
Given all these difficulties, it is remarkable that Galen was able to
discover so much detail about the anatomy of the vagal nerves, and with
such accuracy. Yet his understandable failure to distinguish between the
two nerve branches that share the name "vagus" has misled students
and practitioners of anatomy, physiology, psychology, and medicine for
thousands of years.
Stress and the Sympathetic Nervous System
Just as use of the word "depression" is widespread and often inaccurate,
the word "stress" has been so widely used that its meaning has become
imprecise. It is more precise to describe stress as the physiological state
that arises from activation of the spinal sympathetic nervous system,
resulting in a fight-or-flight response.
The old stress/relaxation model considered stress to be the opposite
of relaxation. It did not describe what happens to the visceral organs in
the physiological state of shock or the related emotional state of depres-
sion—both of which express immobilization with fear. Nor was there an
appreciation of the separate physical structures in the nervous system that
are responsible for shock or depressive feelings on one hand and social
engagement on the other.
In the Polyvagal model, the vagus nerve, long thought to be respon-
sible for a single state of relaxation, is now understood to include two
distinct pathways that activate two different non-stress states—neither
of which exactly corresponds to relaxation in the older model of the
autonomic nervous system.
To avoid the confusions that arise from the word "stress," I prefer to
use Stephen Porges's description of the fight-or-flight state as"mobiliza-
tion with fear:' and will try to hold to the biological model of stress: the
sympathetic nervous system's response (mobilization with fear) to an
external event or internal state, maximizing its potential to fight or flee.
The neurology underlying this state is major activation of the spinal sym-
pathetic chain. As a defensive strategy, this produces a powerful muscular
49
EFTA00810051
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
response with the potential for making an extraordinary effort to save our
life (and/or someone else's) in a threatening situation.
Ideally, when the threat passes, activation of the sympathetic chain
should also dissipate. If our nervous system is resilient and flexible, our
nervous system should naturally return to a state of social engagement.
If this does not occur, and activation of the sympathetic chain becomes
chronic, it is not good for our physical and emotional health or our social
relationships.
Activation of the sympathetic chain is not limited to a defensive strat-
egy. When we are safe and our autonomic nervous system is functioning
optimally, there is a slight activation of the sympathetic nervous system
on every inbreath, causing our blood pressure to rise and our heart to
beat a little faster. The pulse feels a little stronger to the touch. When we
breathe out again and this slight sympathetic activation stops, the heart
rate and the blood pressure decrease. Our heartbeat should slow down
on the outbreath, and our pulse should feel softer.
Therapists can train their fingertip sensitivity to feel this normal
change between slight activation of the spinal sympathetic chain and
activation of the ventral vagal circuit. If there is no change in the pulse
between the inbreath and outbreath, it is a sign of autonomic nervous
system dysfunction.
THE FIGHT-OR-FLIGHT RESPONSE
The fight-or-flight response has a number of effects on our physiology, all
geared to help us survive in a state of stress when we are threatened. When
muscles are tensed, they increase their resistance to blood circulation. In
order to pump blood through tense muscles, our blood pressure rises.
Our heart rate also rises, so that we can pump more blood to the
muscles. Our bronchioles dilate, helping us breathe more easily, which
increases the amount of oxygen reaching our lungs, our blood, and our
cells. Better breathing also helps us eliminate more of the waste products
of muscle-cell metabolism; we get rid of carbon dioxide (CO2) on the
50
EFTA00810052
The Polyvagal Theory
outbreath. Our liver dumps extra sugar into our bloodstream as a quick
source of energy.
Bony fish are the first class of vertebrates with a "spinal" sympathetic
nervous system, which is what generates the state biologists call "stress?'
Amphibians also have a spinal sympathetic nervous system and are also
able to flee danger quickly. Reptiles too use their spinal sympathetic state
to exert extraordinary physical effort. A crocodile engaging its stress state
can move with great speed and power; for short distances, a crocodile can
move half again as fast as a champion Olympic sprinter.
This same spinal sympathetic nervous system allows humans and
other mammals to use the stress state as a defensive strategy by fighting
or running away from a threat (mobilization with fear). Just as for reptiles
and amphibians, our states of stress and states of shutdown can provide
great flexibility for reacting to various situations.
When used as a defensive strategy, the sympathetic nervous system helps
us maximize our ability to fight or to flee. If a person is socially engaged,
their sympathetic nervous system can also be temporarily activated in a
positive way, along with the social engagement circuits, to facilitate social
interchange in play, sporting competition, and even sexual foreplay.
Not limited to the act of physically engaging in violence, thefight"
response includes the full range of other behaviors aimed at changing
things by force: verbal aggression in the form of sarcasm and abuse,
passive aggression (opposing by not taking part), random aggression
toward strangers, and wanton destruction of property.
Similarly, flight is not only the act of running away—it includes
actively avoiding people, situations, or places. It can be simply withdraw-
ing from social situations by watching television or taking part in other
solitary activities, possibly driven by anxiety or panic attacks.
Playing violent video games, for instance, might temporarily put our
nervous system into a state of arousal and fight, and being addicted to
these games and playing them continually might keep us in that state.
With this in mind, parents might try to cut down on the time that child-
ren sit in front of the computer.
51
EFTA00810053
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
It may also mean that the parents themselves should spend less time
in front of their computers. Rather than leaving children alone with the
television or electronic devices, it is better for parents to be present with
their children, available for social interaction and conversation. Parents
should take it upon themselves to initiate play and other social activities
with the child and other members of the family—activities that used to
come naturally to families before electronics.
A NEW UNDERSTANDING OF STRESS
Although many people talk about being "stag: a large percentage
of them are not actually stressed in terms of spinal sympathetic chain
activity. Physiologically, some of them are actually in a state of dorsal
vagal activity (shutdown or withdrawal); in emotional terms, they are in
a depressed state.
This condition can be the result of a traumatic incident sometime
in the past. They may have a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress even
if they are not physiologically in an actual state of sympathetic-chain
stress. According to the Polyvagal Theory, their state is better described as
activation of the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve, and these individuals
may accordingly suffer from lethargy and immobilization.
The way to move people out of both states—stress with accompanying
fight-or-flight behaviors (mobilization with fear) and depressive feelings
behaviors with shutdown (immobilization with fear)—is to activate the
ventral branch of their vagus nerve.
The three circuits of the autonomic nervous system are hierarchical,
with a step-like progression from one state to the next, according to the
evolutionary development of the autonomic nervous system in vertebrates.
Social engagement, based on the most recently evolved nerve circuit
including the ventral vagus branch, is at the top of the ladder, and it
promotes peaceful immobilization and a sense of well-being. The next rung
down is the spinal sympathetic chain, which activates the fight or flight
response. At the bottom, the dorsal vagal circuit, the oldest evolutionary
structure, triggers the defensive response of immobilization with fear.
52
EFTA00810054
The Polyvagal Theory
Activity of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve inhibits the two lower
levels. Activation of the ventral vagal circuit, supporting activities that are
productive in terms of personal survival as well as social activities, lifts
us out of chronic activation of the spinal sympathetic system, and it also
takes us out of dorsal states of shutdown.
It is not necessary to go up the ladder one step at a time from shut-
down to stress and then from stress to social engagement. Ventral vagal
circuit activity moves a person directly from shutdown and emotional
depression all the way up to a ventral vagal state.
The spinal sympathetic chain is the next rung down. Activity in this
circuit inhibits the dorsal vagal circuit. Running, swimming, or other
forms of exercise that simulate fight-or-flight exertions often help to bring
patients out of depression!'
Many types of antidepressant medicine work in a similar fashion. By
chemically stressing the body, they temporarily activate the spinal sym-
pathetic chain. However, antidepressant medicine does not bring us up
all the way to the level of social engagement, and it can have undesired
side effects. Given the choice, I believe that most people would prefer to
come out of states of depression by using simple self-help exercises such
as those I describe in Part Two.
The goal of my treatments is to bring my clients out of a state of stress
or depression and up to the level of social engagement. The exercises
and hands-on treatments in this book will, ideally, help many people to
achieve a state of social engagement and well-being.
There is good reason for emphasizing the importance of proper
function of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve in achieving optimal
physical and psychological health. The state of our autonomic nervous
system gives us an indication of our general level of physical health
and emotional well-being. When our autonomic nervous system is in
a state of stress or shutdown, we often have problems with our health,
our relationships, and our emotional states. In my clinic and practice, if
testing shows the ventral branch of the vagus nerve to be dysfunctional
(see Chapter 4), my first goal is to get this nerve to function properly.
53
EFTA00810055
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Over the years, I have used different techniques to help move people
out of stressed or depressed states and restore their ventral vagal branch
function. For the last few years, I have found it sufficient to have my
clients help themselves by practicing the Basic Exercise (see Part Two).
In some cases (for example, with babies, small children, or individuals
on the autism spectrum), it can be difficult or impossible to communi-
cate sufficiently with language to get them to do the exercise properly for
themselves. In such cases, I use hands-on techniques from biomechanical
craniosacral therapy. A description of one of these can be found in "The
Neuro-Fascial Release Technique' (also in Part Two).
After clients do the Basic Exercise, or after I have used my hands-on
technique, I test their vagal function again to ascertain whether the
desired change has been achieved. After the ventral branch of the vagus
nerve has come to proper functionality, I apply additional techniques
from biomechanical craniosacral therapy. In many cases, when their
ventral vagus has been brought to a proper function, their health issues
diminish or disappear?'
"But you're not a doctor!" some people may say. No, I am not. In my
clinic, I do not make any form of medical diagnosis, or treat disease.
Giving a diagnosis and treating disease with prescription drugs fall solely
within the responsibility of a well-trained medical doctor. All I can do
in this context is evaluate and address the function/dysfunction of the
ventral branch of the client's vagus nerve and the other four cranial nerves
necessary for social engagement.
Many people who come to me have already been diagnosed by a medi-
cal doctor. I do treat people who have been given a medical diagnosis,
primarily to improve the function of their nervous system. It has been my
experience that bringing their autonomic nervous system into a state of
social engagement and moving them toward optimal health has a positive
effect and helps many of them with various medical issues.
In the initial interview, if clients tell me about a health issue, I make a
note of it—can I relate their health issue to a possible dysfunction of one
of the five cranial nerves involved in social engagement? I test the function
54
EFTA00810056
The Polyvagal Theory
of one branch of their vagus nerve. In some cases, I will test some of the
other cranial nerves as well.
Then I have them do the Basic Exercise, or I administer one of the
hands-on techniques described in Part Two, or other techniques from
biomechanical craniosacral therapy. Then I test again. If we have brought
about a positive change in the function of the ventral branch of the vagus
nerve, there is a good chance that the client's body will self-regulate, and
their health issues will be mitigated or even disappear.
My approach has helped many people with a wide range of problems
including stress, psychological depression, migraines, fibromyalgia, dif-
ficulty in concentrating, remembering, or sleeping, problems with diges-
tion, stiff neck, and back and shoulder pain.
We live in a world where everything is constantly changing, inside and
outside of us. Our survival, wellness, and happiness depend on having a
flexible autonomic nervous system that regulates us in order to respond
appropriately to changes in our environment and our own organism.
55
EFTA00810057
I I
EFTA00810058
CHAPTER 3
Neuroception and
Faulty Neuroception
"Neuroception" is a term coined by Stephen Porges to describe how neural
circuits distinguish whether a situation is safe, threatening, or dangerous.
It is an ongoing process through which our autonomic nervous system
evaluates information from our senses about our environment and the
state of our body.
Neuroception takes place in the primitive parts of the brain, beyond
our conscious awareness. It can be likened to a good watchdog that is
always on guard, allowing us to focus on things other than survival, or to
sleep soundly, and rousing us only when intrusions could compromise
our survival. Based on the signals from neuroception, well-defined
neural circuits are activated to support the state of social engagement
and friendly communication behaviors when we are safe; the defensive
strategies of fight or flight when we are threatened; and shutdown when
we are in serious danger?'
Most people have their own experiences of neuroception when they
accessed a "sixth sense" and knew that they were in danger or something
was threatening, without consciously knowing how they knew it. A young
woman in one of my classes once said, "I can have my back turned, and
know that some guy I don't know is looking at me. I can feel his eyes on
me before he comes up to me." Although we have no logical explanation
for it, and even if we do not know its neural pathways, neuroception is
far from uncommon.
Faulty Neuroception and Survival
Neuroception gives us access to information that we do not pick up with
the conscious part of our mind. When it works properly, it is a true gift
57
EFTA00810059
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
and can help us to survive. It works faster than processing conscious
perceptions.
"I knew something was wrong even before I went into the room"—
how do we pick up this kind of information? Sometimes we experience
a conflict between our neuroception and other thoughts:"I had a feeling
that something just wasn't right, but I allowed myself to be talked into
going ahead with it anyway?' El
However, neuroception can be "faulty," and when it does not work as
it should we can find ourselves in deep troubleinstead of clearly perceiv-
ing what is actually there, we distort what is going on. Faulty neurocep-
tion occurs when the neural circuits from perception to behavior do not
function in an appropriate way. A person might react to a safe situation
as if it were threatening or dangerous, or react to a dangerous situation
as if it were safe.
There can be countless reasons for faulty neuroception. Our percep-
tion might be blinded by anger, fear, jealousy, or apathy, or we might be
locked into a traumatic memory. We may be fixated in a state of shock;
we may be hungry and have low blood sugar; we may be tired, in physical
pain, or suffering from an illness.
We might be feeling perfectly normal and then suddenly be triggered
by something that reminds us of a traumatic event in our past—and
react to this memory as if it were happening in present time. We might
not actually be threatened or endangered, but our nervous system may
be stuck in the past, poised to fight or flee at the slightest trigger from
the environment. A wonderful example of this is an Abbott and Costello
sketch called "Slowly I 'awned" (searchable on YouTube).
Faulty neuroception can even come from very positive experiences like
falling in love and bonding with the partner. We sometimes hear that a
person's judgment was impaired because they were "blinded by love;' so
that they failed to be aware of a possibly destructive situation.
The nervous system should be flexible, enabling our whole organism
to adapt to the present situation and to support different kinds of behav-
iors depending on whether the situation is safe, threatening, or danger-
ous. In cases of chemical interference (such as prescription medicines,
58
EFTA00810060
Neuroception and Faulty Neuroception
other drugs, and alcohol), information comes in from the environment
through our senses, but the neural circuits do not process the information
normally, and our physiology does not respond appropriately. Alcohol,
for example, alters the way we feel and thus the way we act. Many drugs—
prescription medicines as well as illegal and recreational drugs—also put
us into an abnormal physiological and experiential state.
The following story illustrates faulty neuroception from biochemical
interference. Three friends, young men in their mid-twenties, went for a
daylong hike up Mount St. Helens, an active volcano in a national park
in the southwest corner of the state of Washington. Although strenuous,
this climb is suitable for anyone in good physical condition who is com-
fortable scrambling on steep, rugged terrain. Most climbers complete the
round trip in seven to twelve hours.
The three friends prepared well for the hike; in each of their backpacks
they had a map, compass, first-aid kit, and pocketknife with a set of tools.
Each had good boots, a climbing helmet to protect his head from falling
rocks, a lightweight sweater, sunscreen, and dust masks and goggles in
the event of ash fall. The sun reflecting off snow and volcanic ash can be
intense, so they also took sunglasses with side shields. They carried food
and two quarts of water each.
They set off early in the morning. The weather forecast predicted a mild,
sunny, clear day, and they dressed accordingly. They were soon quite warm
from the sun and from their exertions, even though they were dressed only
in T-shirts. They splashed water on their heads and took off their sweaty
T-shirts.
The temperature of the body is regulated by neural feedback mecha-
nisms that operate primarily through the hypothalamus, the part of the
brain that processes information from key temperature sensors in the
body. When the body starts to overheat, there are several physiologi-
cal changes. When the temperature rises over 98.6° F (37° C), nerves to
the blood vessels near the surface of the skin cause the blood vessels to
dilate, increasing the amount of blood flowing to the skin. This is called
vasodilation, and it enables more blood to reach the small capillaries in
the skin. Up to a third of the body's blood can circulate in the skin, and
59
EFTA00810061
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
is cooled at the skin surface by the surrounding air. Sweating also helps
to cool the body as its moisture evaporates.
A few hours into the climb, the weather suddenly changed. Clouds
formed, the air got cooler, and it began to snow. All three hikers felt cold,
and they put on their sweaters. (They did not put their damp T-shirts
back on.) Unfortunately, this layer of dry clothing did not provide suf-
ficient warmth quickly enough, and they did not have rain gear. Within
minutes, their sweaters were soaked from the cold, wet snow.
The hypothalamus works to conserve heat if the body temperature
drops—autonomic heat-conserving responses are initiated as well as
mechanisms that produce additional heat. A normal response to cold is
the secretion of the stress hormones adrenaline (epinephrine), norepi-
nephrine, and thyroxine. These cause the muscles to tighten, resulting in
shivering. The activity from the rapid contractions of shivering muscles
produces body heat.
Nerves during a stress response also cause contraction of the muscular
walls of the blood vessels, called vasoconstriction. This minimizes heat
loss by decreasing the volume of blood flowing from the core of the body
to the skin, especially to the hands and feet.
One of the young climbers had taken his usual prescribed medication
earlier in the day to suppress his chronic stress. One effect of this medicine
is to lower blood levels of stress hormones. As a result, his body could not
produce a normal stress reaction to cold weather. He did not shiver, his
blood vessels did not constrict, his arteries and capillaries remained dilated,
and the blood flow to his skin was not reduced to prevent further heat loss.
Because of the medicine, he was not able to adapt to the changes in
his environment, and he became increasingly chilled. Cardiac arrest can
occur in cases of extreme hypothermia, and finally his heart failed. This
young hiker did not survive because his body was not able to adapt in
normal ways to the weather shift.
This provides a cautionary tale about how chemical substances can
interfere with our normal responses to dangerous situations, preventing
our bodies from appropriately responding to protect us.
60
EFTA00810062
Neuroception and Faulty Neuroception
Other Causes of Faulty Neuroception
Earlier I described the survival value of the shutdown state. When a lion
gets its jaws on the throat of an antelope or other prey, the autonomic
nervous system of the prey usually goes into a state of shutdown in the
face of imminent death and the inability to fight or flee anymore—and
in some cases this can cause a predator to lose interest, which saves the
life of its intended prey.
In contrast, personal problems in our complicated, modern, civilized
human life are not usually so dramatic and usually last longer than a few
seconds. We may not be threatened physically, but we are often challenged
emotionally or mentally. We might need to get a project done on time,
to address difficult issues in our relationships with the people around us,
to solve an economic problem, or to care for a family member dying of
cancer. We need to act—to do something or say something—in order to
bring our world back to a state of temporary balance. We cannot always
just sit on a beach, relax, and enjoy the surroundings.
Furthermore, unlike many wild animals, human beings do not usually
shake off their traumas as soon as the threat or danger is gone. Ideally,
we should be able to "reset" our nervous system and get a fresh start. But
many times the effects of traumatic events stick with us long after the
original shock. The conscious and unconscious memory can remain in
our nervous system for months, years, or even for the rest of our lives.
If we have not shaken it off, we can suffer from recurring inappropriate
behaviors and ongoing physical symptoms of stress and shutdown.
Abnormal reactions to certain stimuli can occur because we once had
a traumatic experience involving them. The psychological trigger causing
a stress or shutdown reaction can be quite specific. The memory of the
event sits like an unexploded land mine, waiting to be metaphorically
stepped on by a soldier, or perhaps years later by an unsuspecting child.
The reaction is triggered because something reminds us, consciously or
unconsciously, of whatever traumatized us before.
61
EFTA00810063
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
The Story of Antaeus
The struggle between Antaeus and Heracles was a favorite subject in
ancient and Renaissance sculpture.
Antaeus was the son of Poseidon, god of the sea, and Demeter, goddess
of the Earth.The Greeks believed that he lived on the edge of the desert in
what is now Libya. Antaeus would challenge all passersby to a wrestling
match, kill them, and then use their skulls in a temple he was building to
his father. Antaeus defeated all opponents until he fought Hercules.
Each time Hercules knocked him down, Antaeus got up and came back
even stronger. Hercules quickly realized that he could not beat Antaeus by
throwing him to the ground. He guessed the secret of Antaeus's power:
when Antaeus came into contact with the Earth—his mother—he would
be fortified and regain his strength.
Realizing this, Hercules grabbed Antaeus around the waist and held
him aloft, breaking Antaeus's connection to the ground. Hercules was
then able to use his colossal strength to crush him in a bear hug.
The story of Antaeus has been used to symbolize the dangers of not
keeping ourselves grounded. Hercules displays the psychological and
spiritual strength that accrues when, after being "upset," one becomes
grounded again.
QFNSING" OUR OWN BODIES
Back in 1957, when I was sixteen and first learning how to play golf, I
bought a book by Ben Hogan, one of the greatest early American pro-
fessional golf champions. The book was Ben Hogatt's Five Lessons: The
Modern Fundamentals of Golf.21 Hogan wrote, "If you want to hit a good
drive, if you are right-handed, just keep your awareness on the little finger
of your left hand as you swing the club."
Before I read that, I had tried to hit the ball as hard as I could, or to
bring the club down as fast as I could. I did not understand what Ben
Hogan wrote, but I tried it. And every time I remembered to sense that
little finger, I got more distance when I hit the ball. Another result was
62
EFTA00810064
Neuroception and Faulty Neuroception
that the ball went straight, toward the green almost every time. This was
my first experience with the power of sensing my body.
Today there are many systems, including Pilates, yoga, martial arts, and
mindfulness meditations, that help restore people to their sense of their
body. If my clients have such a way of sensing their body, I ask them to
use that. If not, I teach them an approach to help them do this.
The skin of the face is innervated by cranial nerve V, and the muscles
of the face are innervated by CN VII. Light stroking of the face often calms
us and helps us out of a state of stress. People very often unconsciously
do this for themselves.
If I am giving them a massage, I can ask them to keep their attention
on where my hands are touching their body. This is especially important
for people in a state of withdrawal and dissociation—getting them back
into a sense of their body becomes my first priority. I do not actually
need to do anything. In that moment, when I have my hands on them, I
am not trying to fix things or bring about any changes in their muscu-
loskeletal structure. I am not relaxing a muscle, freeing the movement
in a joint, adjusting the spine, or releasing connective tissue. Instead, my
hands remain at the same place.
It is enough for me as the therapist to simply place my hands on the
client's body, lightly touching the skin. Then I ask the client to "come to
my hands with your awareness?' At first, it can take some time for clients to
clear their mind sufficiently of mental or emotional clutter in order to sim-
ply sense where their body is and what is going on in it. Therefore, I repeat
the process several times. This is a simple way of helping clients to use
their own sensing as a resource to get them grounded in their own body.
When I ask them to sense their body, I can take the same opportunity
to sense my own body; I like to open my awareness to sense my own feet
or hands, further grounding myself at the same time.
Sensing our own bodies and staying grounded helps us to remain in
a ventral vagal state. Awareness of our body can help us avoid getting
carried away by emotions that can lead to faulty neuroception.
63
EFTA00810065
I I
EFTA00810066
CHAPTER 4
Testing the Ventral Branch of
the Vagus Nerve
Simple Evaluation from Facial Observation
According to Stephen Forges, social engagement requires the ability to
both look and listen. When you are talking with someone, you can sense
whether or not he is socially engaged by how much he looks at you, how
well he listens to you, and how well he can understand what you are saying.
You can determine whether the person is looking and listening by reading
the muscles of his face. Does the person look at your face and make eye
contact with you, at least some of the time? Are his eyes open? Can he hear
and understand what you are saying?
The muscles of the face are organized around the openings of the eyes,
the nostrils, and the mouth. (See "Facial muscles" in the Appendix.) When
these flat, round muscles tighten, they close the skin around the openings.
Flat, rectangular muscles attach to the round muscles and can pull them
more open, allowing more light to enter the eyes, more smells to enter the
nose, and more air to enter the mouth. When we react emotionally, our
facial expression changes as we open or close these openings.
Does the other person have slightly raised eyebrows, and are the eyes
relaxed and open? The flat, round muscle that surrounds the eye is called
the orbicularis oculi. (Orbicularis designates a muscle around a facial
opening; oath means related to the eyes.) By tightening this muscle, we
close the opening around the eye, cutting down the amount of light in
the same way that a shutter in an old reflex camera reduces the amount
of light coming through the lens to the film.
We tighten this muscle to squint when we are exposed to bright light,
when we wish to cut down on visual input, when there is something
65
EFTA00810067
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
that we do not want to see emotionally, or when we want to withdraw
from external sensory stimuli and contemplate our own thoughts. When
we tighten this muscle, we move away from current visual stimuli, away
from the here and now. We may remember events from the past, visualize
future possibilities, or enter into a state of meditation.
When the flat, rectangular-shaped muscles above and below the orbi-
cularis ocuii are tense, they pull the orbicularis oculi more open, allowing
much more light to come in. These muscles tense when we encounter
something that is an "eye-opener." Physical tension in these flat rectan-
gular muscles is an integral part of the emotional expression of surprise.
It improves our sensory intake and helps us be more present to what is
happening around us.
Strangely enough, when our eyes are more open, we can also hear
better—there is a neurological connection between the nerves involved
in sight and hearing. At a lecture, some people open their eyes slightly
more in order to better hear what is being said.
When you make eye contact with another person, look for spontane-
ous facial expression in the middle third of her face (between the bottom
of her eyes and the top of her mouth). The small movements here are an
indication of social engagement (or lack of it) and the flexibility of her
emotional responses.
There are two kinds of facial expression: those that we put on to show
someone else what we feel, and those that occur without our consciously
"making a face:' We can categorize the latter into three types, depending
on how long they last.
The first type of unconscious facial expression is the pattern of chronic
tension, which is more or less permanent, etched into our faces with deep
wrinkles and indicative of our characteristic emotional state.
The second pattern, of emotional tension, is less permanent and
expresses our current mood. This pattern of facial tensions remains for
a while—as long as a mood lasts, and generally long enough for someone
else to get an impression of how we are feeling.
In the third kind of emotional expression, the facial muscles located
in the band between the eyes and mouth change tension rapidly, up to
66
EFTA00810068
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
several times a second. We can usually see these spontaneous micro-
changes of expression in a baby or child. It is more rare to notice these
changes in adults, as we are more locked into our sense of identity or
moods. When these rapid changes are seen, they are too fast for us to read
cognitively in order to say definitively that the facial expression indicates
a certain emotion, but the fact that these spontaneous movements are
there gives us a sense nonetheless that the person is open and without fear.
We can experience these rapid changes of facial expression when two
people who feel safe with each other make eye contact, look at each other,
and allow their feelings to flow without censoring or trying to control
them. This is a reflection of the ideal state of openness, when our facial
emotional expressions change as quickly as our thoughts. It is far differ-
ent from a put-on smile, as when posing for a photo, where we almost
grimace in an attempt to show positive feelings.
Can you see a flow of emotions on someone else's face—slight, rapidly
changing, mercurial facial movements showing he feels happy, satisfied,
angry, irritated, afraid, anxious, sad, or depressed—or is his face flat and
unchanging, stuck in one emotional expression? Does he have melodic
changes (prosody) in his vocal expression when he speaks? Or is his voice
flat, with words spoken in a monotone?
We tend to think of people as unchanging identities. However, their
interactions with other people are affected by their mood, which is
affected by the state of their autonomic nervous system at that moment.
People in a stress state might look at us in a menacing way, and their
attitude might be aggressive. They might not listen to what is being said.
They can be prone to react to a single word, to fly off the handle and
interrupt us in the middle of a sentence. Often we may need to correct
them: "But that is not what I said!"
People in fear will avoid eye contact with us, or make eye contact for
only a split second and then look away. Their breathing might be shallow,
lifting only the ribs of their upper chest, and they might hold their breath
after the inbreath.
People in a depressed state will tip their heads forward or let their
heads hang, with an expressionless face. They move slowly, indicating a
67
EFTA00810069
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
lack of energy. They have no enthusiasm, and do not want to engage in
conversation. Sometimes, before a depressed person does or says some-
thing, she will breathe out or sigh.
OTHER TESTS OF VAGAL FUNCTION
In my clinic, in addition to observing aspects such as these, I like to
start all my treatments by testing for function of the ventral vagus nerve
branch. If a client exhibits some of the symptoms that I describe as the
"heads of the Hydra" (see list at the beginning of Part One), and if testing
her indicates ventral vagal dysfunction, it's often possible to improve the
person's condition by using the exercises and techniques described in
Part Two.
Then, after the client does the Basic Exercise, or after I treat her with
my hands, I test again for ventral vagal function to be sure that we have
achieved the desired results. This information is useful in a clinical setting;
the procedure described below in a later section of this chapter, which
makes it possible to evaluate our own ventral vagal function, is also useful
for self-diagnosis and self-care as well as helping others.
In addition to looking at the back of the throat and having the per-
son say "ah-ah-ah," as I describe later, I sometimes use another test that
is useful if I am testing a young child, an autistic individual, or others
in extenuating circumstances. For example, if I have a class of second
graders, it might start them all laughing if they see me looking into a
classmate's throat with a little flashlight and asking her to say "ah-ah-ah."
This other test is based on the observation by Mayer, Traube, and
Hering in the late nineteenth century that the pulse and blood pres-
sure should be faster and stronger on the inbreath than on the outbreath
(assuming good function of the ventral vagus nerve). As you gain expe-
rience treating many people, you can get a sense that one person has a
greater difference than someone else. You might also observe that the dif-
ference is greater after she has done the Basic Exercise than it was before.
68
EFTA00810070
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
It is my experience that people who have a greater difference between
the pulses during their inbreaths and outbreaths are usually more robust
and healthy, both physically and psychologically.
However, these tests that I use in my clinic have limitations for pur-
poses of scientific research. They are subjectively based on my personal
observations, which only show whether or not the ventral branch of the
vagus nerve is functional; they do not quantify the level of vagal function,
which can be higher in one person than in another. Other options for
testing for vagal function are described below.
Objectively Evaluating Vagal Function
through Heart Rate Variability (HRV)
In scientific research on the autonomic nervous system, there is increas-
ing awareness of heart rate variability, which may offer us another way to
assess vagal nerve function.
When our nervous system is functioning optimally and we are socially
engaged, there are differences in the length of time between consecutive
heartbeats, resulting from the natural rise and fall of the heart rate in
response to breathing, blood pressure, hormones, and emotions. Heart
rate variability (HRV) is the measurement of these differences. Greater
variation in the time intervals is designated as high HRV.
HRV can be used as an indicator of general health." It represents one
of the most promising evaluative tools to measure autonomic nervous
system activity." When the ventral branch of the vagus nerve functions
properly, heart rate variability is high. There is a growing amount of
research correlating high HRV with health and longevity?
On the other hand, when there is a reduced level of function in the
ventral vagus, the person's autonomic nervous system reverts to either a
stress state or a state of dorsal vagal activity, as described in the previous
chapter. In this case, differences in the time intervals between heartbeats
are smaller or nonexistent, and this is designated as low HRV.
A growing body of scientific studies shows a correlation between low
heart rate variability and various psychological/psychiatric problems.
69
EFTA00810071
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
For example, HRV is related to emotional states, and has been found to
decrease under conditions of acute time pressure, post-traumatic stress,
emotional strain, and elevated state anxiety.26 Individuals reporting a
greater frequency and duration of daily worry are found to have a lower
HRV."."
Low HRV is apparently also related to a lack of ability to concentrate,
and to motor inhibition, both of which are symptoms commonly found
in children with ADHD.39 There is also a link between post-traumatic
stress disorder and low heart rate variability."
In terms of physical health, it is hypothesized that low HRV is an indi-
cator of less favorable health in general." A range of adverse health con-
ditions may be associated with lower HRV: obesity, diabetic neuropathy,
activity of the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve, susceptibility to sudden
infant death syndrome (SIDS), and poor survival rates in premature babies.
People suffering from obesity generally have lower HRV." While we
might assume that overweight people eat too much, exercise too little, and
lack the motivation to change their behavior, some overweight people go
on a diet and almost starve themselves with little improvement in their
weight. Some people wanting to lose weight work with a psychologist or
hypnotherapist to change their self-image. I cannot help but speculate:
what if their program for weight loss included evaluation of their HRV,
and improvement of their social engagement nervous system with the
Basic Exercise?
Many people with sexual dysfunction seek help from their medi-
cal doctor or advice from a psychiatrist or psychologist. A recent study
sheds some light on women's sexual dysfunction, indicating that it may
be closely linked to their heart rate variability." There are studies that
draw a similar conclusion regarding erectile dysfunction in men, noting
that "general imbalance of the autonomic nervous system is one of the
causes of erectile dysfunction.""
Studies of HRV have shown that low HRV was found in people with
heart damage," and it has been associated with increased risk of coronary
heart disease.9° Reduced HRV also appears to be a predictor of mortality
after myocardial infarction (heart attack)."
70
EFTA00810072
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
Low HRV correlates with early death from several causes in addition
to heart problems, such as COPD. In the United States in 2014, COPD
was the third most common cause of death after heart disease and
cancer." Breathing patterns other than normal diaphragmatic breathing
indicate lower levels of physical and psychological health, and there is a
relationship between diaphragmatic breathing and higher levels of heart
rate variability." In my clinic, I have found that clients with a diagnosis
of COPD have very little movement in their respiratory diaphragm, and
their tests do not show ventral vagal activity.
HRV testing, it seems, may yield valuable diagnostic information, and
can serve as a rapid screening tool to evaluate altered autonomic nervous
system activity.
If scientific research confirms that the state of the autonomic ner-
vous system is a factor in psychological issues, it may be interesting to
explore the possibility of improving heart rate variability and the func-
tion of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve as a first step in treating
psychological problems, without immediately resorting to traditional
psychological interventions or prescription drugs. (See Chapter 6 for
more on this topic.)
Testing for Vagal Function: Early Experiences
Let me emphasize the importance of testing by recollecting my practice
in earlier days. When I started my education in craniosacral therapy, the
teacher of the course said that if I did the fixed sequence of techniques
that he taught, I could help people to get relief from their stress. How-
ever, he never taught us to test the physiological states of the body, so I
wondered how he knew that these techniques worked—perhaps he had
simply heard that from his teacher, and believed it.
That was almost thirty years ago, before I studied with Main Gehin,
and long before I heard about the Polyvagal Theory. The only model of
stress we had at that time was the old understanding of the autonomic
nervous system being in a state of either stress or relaxation.
71
EFTA00810073
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Everyone knew that chronic stress was unhealthy, and there were books
and courses on stress management, each promising a positive, stress-free
outcome. But none of them showed a way of testing stress physiologically.
Today I test every patient before and after sessions; I do not put my blind
faith in what someone else once told me about what outcome to expect
from my treatments.
When I did sessions based on that first course, I completed the stan-
dard sequence of techniques, and assumed that my work was finished; the
client could no longer be stressed, and was relaxed and ready to go home.
But I noticed that clients often had a hard time gathering then$elves after
treatment, and they would ask if they could remain on the table for a few
more minutes. After ten or fifteen minutes, they often still did not want
to get up, and I would have to explain that I needed the massage table for
my next client. They would be considerate of my needs, get up reluctantly,
and put their shoes on. I remember some clients me if I thought
that they could drive; I assured them that it was okay.
When they came for their next appointment, they sometimes told
me that they were so relaxed after their last session that they had to pull
off to the side of the road and shut their eyes to nap for a few minutes.
Sometimes they even pulled over two or three times. They enthusiastically
commented that this was great because they had been "so relaxed?" Even
on the next day, they often did not want to get out of bed and go to work.
Today, looking back, I realize that my sessions had left them in a dor-
sal vagal state. They were not relaxed, but instead were dissociated and
exhibiting depressive behavior. Nowadays, I am careful to address ventral
vagal function during a session, and test it again afterward, in order to
make sure that they can be socially engaged when they depart. I make
sure that they leave my office calm but at the same time alert and able to
function, in a state of neither stress nor dorsal vagal activity. Testing the
state of the autonomic nervous system before and after a session provides
a great perspective if you are a body therapist, psychologist, or any other
kind of health care provider.
72
EFTA00810074
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
Discovering the Polyvagal Theory
In the early 1980s, I began to notice that many of my clinical clients
who had asthma also had vagal dysfunction. When I helped them to
improve their vagal function, their symptoms of asthma were reduced
or disappeared.
I found this interesting—perhaps people with asthma could be helped
by hands-on treatment to improve their ventral vagal function rather
than relying on prescription medications, which are expensive and often
have negative side effects. I hope someday to do a scientific study based
on these experiences.
At the time, I used a method of testing vagal function that was based
on early concepts of heart rate variability: I monitored the pulse and
blood pressure of my clients, and correlated these with their breathing.
I learned this method from my Rolfing teachers, Michael Salveson and
Gad Ohlgren, in 1982-83. My teachers had learned it from Peter Levine,4°
a leading teacher and author in the field of trauma therapy. Peter in turn
had been inspired by Stephen Porges; Peter and Stephen have a friend-
ship that goes back several decades. Michael and Peter were also part of
a small study group of Rolfers and other body therapists in Berkeley,
California, in the early 1980s that focused on the function of the auto-
nomic nervous system.
The method I used involved observation of the breath and pulse. If
our pulse is faster on the inbreath and slower on the outbreath, this indi-
cates good ventral vagal function. The greater the difference, the better
the ventral vagal function. I monitored this by putting a finger over an
artery in the client's wrist while at the same time observing the pattern
of her breathing. The idea behind this method goes back to studies on
the autonomic nervous system from the 1890s, with the discovery of
variability in blood pressure described as Traube-Hering-Mayer waves.
Although this method was useful in my clinic for my own personal
evaluation, it left a lot to be desired in terms of scientific research. I had no
objective measurement of vagal function—just my subjective impression
based on what I felt under my fingers and saw with my eyes. For scientific
73
EFTA00810075
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
purposes, of course, it is preferable to measure more precisely. Today there
are many instruments available to measure vagal function!'
Back in 2002, I wanted to ask Stephen Porges (whom I had not yet
met) to help me develop a research project investigating my successful
hands-on treatment for asthma. Several clients had come to me with
breathing difficulties and diagnoses of asthma. When I tested these clients
before their first session (using a method of diagnosing the function of
the vagus nerve that I had learned in my Rolfing class), I noticed that
they all had vagal dysfunction. But after my hands-on treatments, they
all tested positive for vagal function. At the same time, their symptoms of
asthma disappeared, and their breathing normalized. I was hoping that
Stephen could assist me in developing a scientifically acceptable method
of measuring this.
I asked Jim Oschman,42 a scientist friend of mine, if he knew Stephen
and could introduce me to him. Luckily, on my next trip to the United
States to visit my family in Philadelphia, Stephen Porges was giving a lec-
ture in Baltimore for the American Association of Body Psychotherapists.
Jim was in Washington, DC, and all three of us were able to meet at the
Baltimore conference and have dinner together.
I told Stephen about my idea for doing a research project on treating
asthma, and I asked if he could help me measure autonomic nervous
system function before and after my treatments. Rather than supplying
information on where I could get the hardware and software, as I had
hoped, he changed the subject and told us about his Polyvagal Theory. It
was new to me, but it sounded interesting. The next morning, Jim and I
had breakfast with Stephen, and he told us more about the theory.
Later that morning, Stephen gave the keynote speech at the confer-
ence. His theme was the Polyvagal Theory, this time illustrated with slides.
After hearing Stephen describe the theory for the third time in less than
twenty-four hours, I began to truly grasp it.
He presented video documentaries showing some of the improve-
ments in communication and behavior in autistic children who had taken
part in his research, which he calls "The Listening Project Protocori
74
EFTA00810076
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
(further described in Chapter 7). The children had received five daily
forty-five-minute treatments for five days, consisting of listening to
unique computer-distorted music through special headphones. The
result was that more than half of the subjects no longer reported audi-
tory hyperacusis, and many started to engage spontaneously in two-way
verbal communication, and became more social.
The video showed the children's interaction with an adult who tried
to engage them in playful activity that fit their age group—the therapist
was blowing soap bubbles. Before the music-listening sessions, one child
was hyperactive, could not sit still, ran around in circles, and showed no
interest in either the adult or the bubbles. Another child was sitting pas-
sively, with her chin drooping on her chest. By contrast, she seemed to
be collapsed, alone in her own world, and did not appear to notice the
bubbles or the adult.
After their fifth listening sessions, both children looked engaged and
behaved more naturally. The formerly hyperactive child stood in front
of the adult, made eye contact, and played with the soap bubbles. The
child who had been shut down appeared to wake from her stupor, related
playfully to the adult, and started to play with the soap bubbles as well.
The children smiled, laughed, had light in their eyes, and were in a play-
ful, relaxed, and open state.
This is an incredible accomplishment, given the fact that until then no
one had developed a scientifically verified procedure for helping autistic
people improve their communication skills and become more social. The
Listening Project Protocol points to a potential for effectively addressing
this symptom of autism.
I was not the only one who was amazed. The room was filled with
150 therapists. After seeing the impact of this intervention on the two
children, there was not a dry eye in the house.
At that time,I had no experience treating children on the autism spec-
trum. I thought about patients I had treated over the years. Many had
come to my clinic in a state of stress or dorsal vagal withdrawal, and had
left smiling, with light in their eyes and apparently at peace with them-
selves. This indicated to me that our sessions had been effective.
75
EFTA00810077
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
I believed that I had the means to bring about similar changes in
autistic clients with a protocol of techniques from biomechanical cranio-
sacral therapy. However, before hearing Stephen Porges's lecture, I did
not have a psycho-physiological model to explain the changes. Also, I
realized that my previous model of the autonomic nervous system was
limited to states of either stress or relaxation. My model did not include
the idea of"shutdown," or any state characterized by activity of the dorsal
vagal branch; it did not even distinguish between the ventral and dorsal
branches of the vagus nerve.
I came away from Stephen's lecture inspired, and my interest shifted
from doing research on treating asthma with craniosacral therapy to
exploring the possibility of treating children on the autism spectrum.
I also had a new understanding of how the autonomic nervous system
functions. It was no longer a question of improving just vagal function,
but improving the function of the four other cranial nerves also essential
for social engagement. I have spent the many years since then studying
and applying the Polyvagal Theory in my clinical practice and in my
teaching.
When I went home to Denmark,I could not set up a lab to do the kind
of testing that Porges had done, and I did not have access to his process
of testing and acoustic stimulation. But I decided to work with certain
clients on the autism spectrum using my new knowledge of the Polyvagal
Theory and my hands-on skills from biomechanical craniosacral therapy,
which include techniques for improving the function of the five cranial
nerves necessary for social engagement.
My hope was that, by using those techniques and improving the func-
tion of those nerves, I could also help some of these people improve their
ability to communicate, thus making it possible for them to engage more
fully in social behavior.
My treatments resulted in better functioning for most of my autistic
clients. They did become more communicative and went from states of
isolation to becoming more socially responsive. Although I used a dif-
ferent therapeutic approach from that of Stephen Porges, I based my
treatments on his Polyvagal Theory.
76
EFTA00810078
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
It took several years to reach a point where I realized the importance of
testing everyone, even after hearing about the Polyvagal Theory. At first I
measured vagal function only when I had a difficult patient and felt frus-
trated with a lack of results; I was slow to incorporate it for all my clients.
When I gave a myofascial release treatment but did not get the result
I expected, I would hit a wall—these techniques usually worked, so why
not this time? So I worked harder, repeating the same technique again and
again, and giving my clients extra time for their sessions. Even with that,
my efforts still did not give the results that I wanted, and I became more
and more frustrated and unsatisfied at the end of a session.
Testing for vagal function gave me a chance to realize that my failures
were not due to my lack of judgment in choosing that technique, or skill
at performing it, but rather to a lack of receptivity in the client's nervous
system. In these cases, information about the state of their autonomic
nervous system helped me understand why I did not get the results I
had attained with most of my other clients who had well-functioning
autonomic nervous systems.
With this realization, I no longer questioned my ability as a therapist
when I had a difficult case; the shortcoming was not in me or my
technique, but was due to the unreceptive state of the client's autonomic
nervous system. What would happen if I had the information about their
autonomic nervous system issues at the start of the session, and addressed
that first? I began to do this.
Based on my resultant clinical successes, I believe that the importance
of testing for the function of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve cannot
be overestimated. Whether my clients come for a Rolling session, to get
relief from pain in their back, or to regain mobility in a frozen shoul-
der—or for any other of the health issues that I call the "heads of the
Hydra"—the first thing that I do is test them for function of the ventral
branch of their vagus nerve, using the pharyngeal-branch vagal function
test described below, since my first goal as a therapist is to improve their
vagal function.
If I find ventral vagal dysfunction, indicating a state of either stress or
withdrawal, I have the client do the Basic Exercise (see Part Two). Then
77
EFTA00810079
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
I test them again. Usually their vagus nerve responds as it should after
doing this exercise once or twice. Then I proceed with specific techniques
to complete the treatment.
I have learned that if there is not adequate ventral vagal function,
therapeutic interventions are less likely to stick. However, when vagal
function is successfully restored, my clients often experience improve-
ments in other areas of their lives—not only in terms of the health issue
that they came in with, but also at work, with their families, and in social
relationships with others.
Testing another person for social engagement can be valuable if you
are working as a teacher, body therapist, psychologist, psychiatrist, or
coach. If you are a parent about to send a child to college, it might be a
good idea to make sure that your child has a well-functioning autonomic
nervous system—and if not, it would be a good idea to get it functional,
to ensure the best chance that the time and resources you and your child
invest in the education will have a positive outcome. If you find that
your child is in a state of stress or withdrawal, you might want to address
that with the exercises and treatments in this book, for the best possible
chance of success.
Testing for Vagal Function:
Cottingham, Porges, and Lyon
If you are a body therapist, or do anything else to help other people with
their health and wellness, performance, or interactions with others, you
might find that the state of their autonomic nervous system will predict
how successful your efforts will be.
Stephen Porges, together with John Cottingham and Todd Lyon, both
Rolfers, published the results of a 1988 research project in the journal
Physical Therapy" They demonstrated that evaluation of the autonomic
nervous system can be an accurate predictor of the level of success in a
hands-on therapy session. Over the years, I have found that the implica-
tions of this study go far beyond body therapy, and are relevant in all
interactions.
78
EFTA00810080
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
The three did a scientific experiment on a group of men in which
they tested the state of the autonomic nervous system and how it related
to the level of positive results from a myofascial release technique used
in Rolfing.
John Cottingham administered a Rolfing technique called a "pelvic
lift" to each of the study participants. The pelvic lift is used to balance the
sacrum at the end of Rolfing sessions, in order to incorporate and bal-
ance changes to the connective tissue from various releases that occurred
during the session.
In the pelvic lift technique, the client lies face-up on a massage table.
The Rolfer slides a hand under the client's sacrum and contacts the bone.
With the client's weight resting on the palm of their hand, the Rolfer
creates a slight, steady, gentle traction toward the client's feet. When the
pelvic lift works as intended, the muscles of the back relax, the spine
lengthens, and vertebral alignment is improved. The pelvic lift should
leave the client with better posture, greater flexibility in the lumbar spine,
and an increased sense of well-being.
For the purposes of the study, in order to keep the intervention as
uniform as possible for all of the subjects, John Cottingham was the only
therapist, administering the same technique to all the subjects.
John measured the effects of his technique by testing the flexibility of
the spine before and after the pelvic lift. The subjects started in a relaxed
standing posture, and then curled forward into spinal flexion. John mea-
sured how close their fingertips came to touching the floor, both before
and afterward, to determine whether the subject was more flexible, the
same, or less flexible after the pelvic lift. John asked them how they felt,
and what they experienced as a result of receiving the pelvic lift. Even
with the same therapist doing the same technique, there was a wide range
of responses.
From a first glance at the findings, it appeared that the younger men
generally had a more positive gain from the technique compared with
the older men, showing an increased range of movement when they bent
over the second time. They reported that receiving a pelvic lift had been an
enjoyable experience, and they were in a better mood after the intervention.
79
EFTA00810081
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
The older group had quite different results. In spite of John's training,
skills, and positive intention, his efforts with many of the older men were
not especially successful. Many became stiffer and actually lost some of
their range of movement; when they curled forward and tried to touch
their toes, their fingers were further from the floor than before the treat-
ment. Many reported that they did not feel as good after the technique,
and their mood had changed for the worse. A few were noticeably grump-
ier and more irritable.
It would be easy to conclude that Rolfing simply works better for
younger men than for older men. But the researchers were interested
in relating the results of the technique to a factor other than age. They
discovered that the state of the autonomic nervous system was a relevant
indicator in predicting the success of the outcome.
Before the treatments in the experiment, John measured the subjects'
heart rate variability (HRV). He attached sensors to their skin and ran
these wires to a vagal-tone monitor stationed in another room. With
this setup, he was able to precisely record changes in the beating of their
hearts, and to correlate them to individual breaths.
John was not able to see the HRV measurements while carrying out
the technique. He had no knowledge of which subjects had high levels of
heart rate variability and which had low levels, so this knowledge could
not prejudice the way that he performed the treatments. Most of the
younger subjects, and some of the older men, had reasonably high heart
rate variability. By contrast, a higher percentage of the older men and
only a few of the younger men had low HRV.
When Cottingham, Porges, and Lyon reviewed the data, they saw a
closer relationship between high heart rate variability and a desirable
outcome from the treatment than there was between age and outcome.
In other words, the success of the treatment appeared to be more closely
related to the state of the autonomic nervous system than to age. This is
a key point, discussed further below.
Measuring heart rate variability with a vagal tone monitor can be
useful in scientific research where you need a quantifiable measurement.
80
EFTA00810082
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
However, there are other ways to evaluate vagal function in a clinical
setting that do not require special equipment and take less time. For many
years, I have used some of these other methods and found them to be
sufficient for my own purposes in my clinic.
A Simple Test of the Pharyngeal Vagus Branch
The ventral vagus nerve has several branches. Below is a test for the
function of one of these, called the pharyngeal branch, which inner-
vates the part of the throat immediately behind the nasal cavity and the
mouth, above the esophagus and larynx. Nerve fibers from the pharyngeal
branch of the vagus go to the soft palate and to the pharynx. This nerve
is involved with swallowing and making vocal sounds.
The Greek physician Claudius Galen was the first extant writer to
describe the pharyngeal branch of the vagus nerve, noting that it provided
motor nerve function for the muscles in the larynx, which produce the
voice. He learned this by examining a gladiator who had been wounded in
the neck and had lost his voice; Galen found that the pharyngeal branch
of his vagus nerve had been severed on one side of his neck. To test the
validity of his observations, he did an experiment on pigs, whose anatomy
is quite similar to human beings. He found that cutting the pharyngeal
nerve on pigs would stop their squealing.
After trying various ways of testing the ventral branch of the vagus
nerve, I eventually chose this method focusing on its pharyngeal branch.
It has been described in some of the older textbooks on anatomy and
physiology, and it is still taught in medical schools in Denmark. Main
Gehin also taught this method of testing for vagus function by looking at
the back of the throat. It has been a great asset in terms of my own work
with craniosacral therapy.
This test evaluates the movement of one of the muscles innervated by
the pharyngeal branch, called the levator yell palatini muscle. From my
experience, I find that the condition of this branch is a good indicator of
the function of other branches of the ventral vagus nerve as well.
81
EFTA00810083
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Improving the function of the pharyngeal branch of the vagus nerve
improves the function of the respiratory diaphragm. When this test shows
a dysfunction of the levator veli palatini muscle, I usually also observe that
the client's breathing is irregular, somewhat rapid, and not especially deep.
Then, after the client does the Basic Exercise and this branch becomes
functional again, I observe that breathing has improved, becoming deeper
and slower.
I explain to my clients the importance of proper function in the ven-
tral branch of their vagus nerve. I show them drawings, and I explain what
I am looking for in terms of movement of their soft palate at the back
of their throat. Most of my clients like the idea that I test vagal function,
treat them, and then test vagal function again; they like the fact that their
autonomic nervous system can be evaluated, and if the ventral branch
of their vagus nerve has been dysfunctional, that it can be shown to be
brought back into proper function.
How to Test for Pharyngeal Ventral Branch Function
Ask the person to sit comfortably in a chair. Then stand in front of him and
ask him to open his mouth so that you can see the back of his throat. You
will need to see the uvula (the small bulb-shaped structure that hangs
down in the back of the throat) and the soft-tissue arches on either side of
it. Sometimes you can see these sufficiently with normal light; otherwise,
you will need to use a small flashlight. (The flashlight app on an iPhone
is perfect for this.)
If the person's tongue is blocking your view of the uvula and arches,
ask him to place one of his fingers on the back of his tongue and push
it down onto the floor of his mouth. Then you should be able to see the
soft palate more easily. (Medical doctors use a tongue depressor for this,
but that makes some people gag, and I have never had a client gag using
his own finger.)
See the Appendix for a series of drawings of the uvula. In "Uvula 2,"the
arches of the soft palate are lifted on both sides by properly functioning
levator veil palotini muscles. In"Uvula 3;one side is lifted and the other is
82
EFTA00810084
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
not; this indicates dysfunction of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve
on the side that is not lifted.
In these drawings, you can see the !evertor veilpalatini muscles embed-
ded in the soft tissue, one on either side of the uvula. These muscles
are innervated by motor fibers of the pharyngeal branch of the vagus
nerve. When they contract, they lift the arches of the soft palate. They
are also attached to the auditory (Eustachian) tube between the ears and
throat, and pull on it during the act of swallowing. This is why the ears
sometimes"pop"with swallowing, as air moves into the middle-ear cavity
and pressure is equalized.
When we swallow, these muscles should contract, elevating the soft
palate and allowing food to go into the esophagus en route to the stom-
ach, while at the same time preventing food from entering the larynx
and lungs. These muscles should also contract when someone makes the
sound-all:A well-trained singer will use this muscle to lift the back of the
throat before singing the first note of a phrase.
In order to test vagal function, I ask the other person to say, "ah-ah-
ah-ah-ah" while I observe the arches on either side of the uvula. These
sounds should be percussive and staccato—short, distinct bursts of
sound in quick succession, and not a long, drawn-out "aaaaaaaaahhhh:
which does not create the desired effect.If there is good function in the
pharyngeal branch of the ventral vagus nerve on both the right and left
sides, these muscles tighten symmetrically with a clear impulse when the
person makes the sounds"ah-ah-ah-ah-ah: lifting the arches of the soft
palate equally on both sides.
If, on the other hand, there is dysfunction of the pharyngeal branch of
the ventral branch of the vagus nerve on one side, the nerve impulses do
not innervate the levotor veilpalotini muscle on that side, and the arch in
the soft palate on that side does not lift when the person says "all:
This test for ventral vagal function has profound implications. As
mentioned, if we are in a state of fear, there is activity in one of these other
two circuits of the autonomic nervous system, and we can suffer from
any of the conditions I referred to as the "heads of the Hydra:' Stephen
83
EFTA00810085
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Porges introduced the idea of the "vagal brake"—the inhibitory effect
of ventral vagus activity on spinal sympathetic and dorsal vagal activity.
What if we then came to feel safe? What if we restored activity in our
ventral vagal circuit instead of our spinal sympathetic chain or dorsal
vagal branch?
The exercises and treatments in this book can move someone out of
states of stress or shutdown and into a ventral vagal state. After someone
does the self-help exercises or receives the hands-on treatments in this
book, you should be able to observe improvement when you test again—
the soft palate and the uvula should now lift symmetrically on both sides.
The "Trap Squeeze Test" is another test that I use to test for the func-
tion of the ventral vagus nerve branch. This test and its implications are
described in Chapter 5. It is perfect to use with children, or with any-
one on the autistic spectrum who might have difficulty following your
instructions.
Therapists Can Test for Vagal Function
without Touching
In January 2008, I co-taught a seminar together with Stephen Porges
in Santa Fe, New Mexico, for a large group of psychologists and body
therapists. Stephen began the seminar, and everyone was inspired by his
presentation of the Polyvagal Theory, recognizing its possibilities as a
model for understanding the difference between normal and abnormal
human behavior.
Psychologists interact verbally with their clients and are regulated
by laws governing their professional behavior. In most states in the
United States, they are not allowed to touch their clients; doing so would
be grounds for losing their license. My work with clients, however, is
primarily "hands-on," for body therapists who want to learn how to use
their hands to treat their client in this way.
The night before I lectured to this group, I wondered, "These psy-
chologists cannot touch their clients. How can I give them something
84
EFTA00810086
Testing the Ventral Branch of the Vagus Nerve
that they can take home and use in their clinical practice?" I slept on
the question, and the next morning, when I woke up, I had an answer:
they could diagnose the state of the client's autonomic nervous system
by looking at the back of the throat while the client makes the sound
"ah-ah-ah-ah-ah" (as described in the section above).
I provided each of the seminar participants with a small flashlight
to enable them to look at the back of someone's throat. In a practice
session during the course, they experimented with testing other semi-
nar attendees. The point was for them to learn how to tell whether or
not their clients were socially engaged, both before and after their ver-
bal interventions—such testing might help them to better understand
the behavior and emotional state of their client from a Polyvagal per-
spective. They could also evaluate whether their clients needed work to
improve the function of their autonomic nervous system and, just as
importantly, whether their intervention was successful in terms of the
Polyvagal Theory. The possibility of testing before and after a session
caught their interest.
I told them about my work with body therapy, and the research done by
Porges, Cottingham, and Lyon described above. I raised the possibility of
a psychologist having clients use their own hands to perform a technique
that could facilitate a change in their autonomic nervous system, bringing
them from a state of chronic spinal sympathetic or dorsal vagal activity
into a state of social engagement.
If Stephen Porges's vagal brake can be brought into play—if a psy-
chologist can get a client's ventral vagal branch to function properly,"put-
ting the brake on" sympathetic or dorsal vagal activity and their harmful
consequences—what effects might this have on the behavior, emotions,
and thoughts of the client? Since the ventral branch of the vagus nerve
inhibits dorsal vagal or spinal sympathetic activity, bringing about a ven-
tral vagal state may be effective in addressing conditions often diagnosed
as stress or depression.
Although in my clinic I utilized a hands-on protocol to bring my cli-
ents into a state of social engagement, I reasoned that a psychologist who
understood the Polyvagal Theory could use its principles to teach clients
85
EFTA00810087
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
to achieve similar results using their own hands. Such an approach would
also give clients the possibility of helping themselves in the future, after
the session, to regulate their own autonomic nervous system as needed.
This was the origin of the Basic Exercise. (See Part Two for instructions
for doing this simple exercise.)
This was the first time that I had taught this exercise to anyone, and
naturally I was curious whether or not it would work. There were about
sixty psychologists in the group, and half of them had shown vagal dys-
function when tested prior to doing the exercise. (Their partners in the
practice session never touched them.) After they used their own hands to
treat themselves, they all showed restored ventral vagal function. Bringing
about the change in their autonomic nervous systems had taken only a
few minutes.
After the seminar, I received an email from one of the psychologists,
telling me that she now tested every client at the start of their sessions. If
they had vagal dysfunction, she told them how to do the exercise. When
she tested them again afterward, they showed ventral vagus function. This
exercise, it appeared, successfully put her patients into a state of social
engagement. Then she did her usual verbal psychological interventions.
She wrote that she was thrilled by the improved results that she was now
getting with her clients.
When I went back to work in my own clinic, I began asking whether
patients had physical or psychological problems. I checked them to see
if they had ventral vagal function. Then I taught them to do the Basic
Exercise. When they had done it a single time, I looked at the back of their
throat again, and each and every one of them now had a well-functioning
ventral vagus nerve.
I would have been satisfied if I had helped 50 percent of my patients to
a ventral vagal state, but I found that I was able to help them all. Eighty-
five out of the next eighty-five clients I tracked had a positive outcome.
That was a good enough result for me to begin to depend on this exercise.
Clients, furthermore, usually gave me good feedback not only at the end
of the session but also when I saw them again in the following weeks.
86
EFTA00810088
CHAPTER 5
The Polyvagal Theory—
A New Paradigm for Health Care?
Generally, our Western approach to medical treatment is biochemical or
surgical. If we go to a doctor with a health problem, the doctor listens
to our description of the problem. After a physical examination and/
or laboratory testing, the doctor generally makes a diagnosis, writes a
prescription for medication, and sometimes suggests a surgical procedure.
If we have asthma, doctors prescribe asthma medicine. If we have
migraines, they prescribe migraine medicine. If we are having a problem
with digestion, they prescribe a specific medicine to help a specific part
of the digestive tract. There is a different medicine for every nameable
condition; a well-stocked pharmacy offers thousands of medicines.
In the conventional approach, however, doctors may be overlooking
something. Dysfunction of the autonomic nervous system, for instance,
may be a common factor in autism, migraines, CORD, and many other
health problems.
Rather than focusing on one diagnosis or condition that is treated
by one medicine, there is a growing awareness of comorbidity. Comor-
bidity is the presence of one or more disorders or diseases co-occurring
with a primary disease or disorder. The additional disorder(s) might be
behavioral or psychological.
The autonomic nervous system monitors and regulates the functioning
of the visceral organs, and is a major contributing factor in determining
our emotional state. However, doctors do not usually test its function;
they do not generally consider the autonomic nervous system as a pos-
sible contributing factor, nor are they trained to explore the possibility
of changing the state of the autonomic nervous system without using
prescription medicines.
87
EFTA00810089
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
In my practice, I have consistently found that assisting the ventral
branch of the vagus nerve to function properly often eliminates or
reduces the severity of many health problems, and therefore the need for
prescription drugs.
I believe dysfunction of those nerves to be an underlying cause of
many life-impairing physiological and behavioral conditions. I invite you
to explore this approach in greater depth after reading this book. Whether
you are a layperson, health care professional, or body therapist, I trust
that you will find the concepts and techniques as effective as I have found
them in my own practice.
A Polyvagal Approach for Psychological
and Physical Conditions
Many people focus on the negative consequences of stress and are gener-
ally not aware ofproblems resulting from chronic activation of the dorsal
branch of the vagus nerve. Activity of the dorsal vagus is characterized by a
lack ofphysical energy, low blood pressure, fainting, breathing difficulties
stemming from constriction of the airways in cases of COPD, and chronic,
general muscle and joint pain, often diagnosed as fibromyalgia."
As described in Chapter Two, chronic dorsal vagal activity is also a
factor in depressive behavior, social isolation, feelings of helplessness and
hopelessness, apathy, lack of empathy, sadness, and grief, as well as some
cases of post-traumatic stress and many cases of anxiety.
Prior to the Polyvagal Theory, we did not have an adequate physiologi-
cal model to understand the nature of these common problems. The new
understanding of the autonomic nervous system set forth in the Polyvagal
Theory provides us with a physiological model for comprehending the
neurological factors underlying these dysfunctions. Improving the func-
tion of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve opens new possibilities for
healing a myriad of health problems arising from chronic sympathetic-
system activation or dorsal-vagal dysfunction.
Stephen Porges elucidated how our autonomic nervous system affects
us mentally, physically, and emotionally. He postulated that physiological
88
EFTA00810090
The Polyvagal Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
factors such as the autonomic nervous system and hormonal levels play
a role in determining our psychological state and therefore our behavior.
If we want to change our psychological state and behavior patterns, or
help others change theirs, the solutions might lie in initiating changes in
the state of the autonomic nervous system.
The implications of Stephen Porges's theory carry the potential to
develop and implement many new treatments. Perhaps we will not have
to rely as much on antidepressants or other mood enhancers, which are
expensive, often do not work as desired, and in some cases have serious
negative side effects.°
BUILDING ON STEPHEN PORGES'S SUCCESS
For fifteen years before I met Stephen Porges, I had been working with
biomechanical craniosacral therapy, a form of hands-on manipulation to
improve the function of the cranial nerves." The biomechanical approach
to craniosacral therapy includes tests for the function of the cranial nerves
as well as techniques to remove restrictions in the sutures (bone junctions)
of the cranium in order to improve the function of the cranial nerves.
After meeting Stephen in 2002,1 developed a craniosacral therapy
protocol by choosing several of Alain Gehin's techniques. Together these
techniques usually establish proper function of the ventral branch of the
vagus and the other four cranial nerves necessary for social engagement.
I have taught this protocol to more than five hundred craniosacral thera-
pists in Denmark and Norway, and it has proven to be successful in regu-
lating their clients' autonomic nervous systems. In many cases, the positive
results have been astounding, and there are no negative side effects.
I would like nothing more than to be able to pass on this knowledge
to all therapists who are interested. However, these techniques are usually
communicated in a direct transmission between a teacher and students
in small classes. It takes a long time for students to learn and to master
the techniques.
My first thought when I started to write this book was to introduce
the Polyvagal Theory and then present a description of how to do
89
EFTA00810091
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
these techniques. However, there are major challenges in teaching these
advanced techniques through a book, especially to people with no prior
skills or knowledge of the craniosacral system.
So instead I developed some new exercises and hands-on techniques
that can achieve the same results. My criteria for choosing the exercises
and techniques were that they must be effective for improving the func-
tion of the social engagement nervous system for most people; they must
be easy to learn; and they must be easy to do.
I was blessed with good intuitions—the exercises and hands-on tech-
niques that I present in this book actually do work to bring most people
into a state of social engagement, and most people can easily learn them
from this book.
ALMOST EVERYONE CAN BENEFIT FROM THESE EXERCISES
This book is mainly written for average people—not necessarily just health
care professionals—and for anyone who has failed to find satisfactory
solutions to their health needs within existing treatment modalities. The
book can also be a resource for psychologists, psychiatrists,ghands-ore
body therapists, physicians, and other health care practitioners who are
looking for new ways to bring about positive changes in their clients. This
approach can be used as an alternative or as complementary to other
types of treatments.
Many of us have a hard time affording the rising costs of medical
treatment, or want to avoid the negative side effects that can come from
medicines. The techniques and exercises in this book are a safe and inex-
pensive form of self-help. Once you have bought this book, the treatments
are free!
Warning: If you are taking medicine prescribed by a physician and
want to reduce your dosage or stop taking the medicine entirely, please
initiate a process of cooperation with your doctor. Do not change your
dosage or stop taking your medicine without consulting them.
These exercises should in no way replace medical care by a physician,
but they will, I hope, help you to become healthier.
90
EFTA00810092
The Polyvagal Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
The Healing Power of the Polyvagal Theory
A variety of very different health issues are partly caused by vagus nerve
dysfunction. Following are case stories of successful treatments that I have
given for specific issues, including respiratory difficulties (such as COPD),
migraine headaches, and autism-spectrum disorders.
These stories give you a sense of the possibilities that the Polyvagal
Theory opens up for health care. Later in the book, I will present other
cases from a wider range of more general physical and psychological
problems, including stress, depression, and various psychiatric diagnoses.
These cases, based on my understanding of the Polyvagal Theory, involved
the application of hands-on techniques that I used to bring about a state
of ventral vagal activity.
Rather than encouraging readers to rely on treatment by a therapist,
I have developed extremely simple self-help exercises for this book that
achieve the same results. A non-trained reader can learn most or all of the
self-help exercises by carefully digesting the information in these pages.
These methods of treatment are both effective and safe. You can use these
exercises and apply these techniques to achieve similar positive results to
help yourself and others.
If you are a therapist in a clinical setting, you would first test the other
person's autonomic nervous system; then you can demonstrate and teach
the self-help exercises. Afterward, you should test again to make sure that
you have achieved the desired changes. You can suggest that your client
use these self-help exercises in the future if necessary.
Relieving COPD and Hiatal Hernia
Though many people have heard about COPD (chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease) only relatively recently, it is one of the world's most
common non-communicable health problems. COPD is a disease state
characterized by chronically poor airflow, shortness of breath, and
coughing. People with this problem cannot exert themselves physically
and have increasing difficulty breathing.
91
EFTA00810093
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
It is currently believed that COPD has many causes, including smok-
ing and exposure to environmental toxins, in reaction to which the body
creates a surplus of fibers that block the airways in the bronchioles and
lungs. This blockage of the airways is assumed to be the cause of the
individual's breathing difficulties.
It is often difficult for those with COPD to remain actively employed
and to maintain their previous lifestyles, so they often have difficulty
planning ahead in terms of financial commitments. They often also have
difficulty maintaining their activity levels outside of work, and therefore
have a reduced quality of life."
Although steroids and inhalers can temporarily improve breathing, the
problems can return as soon as the medicine wears off. And inhalers and
steroids often have negative side effects if used over a long period of time,
so they are generally recommended for short-term use only. Furthermore,
most people around the world with COPD cannot afford inhalers and
steroids and therefore do not have access to them. The bottom line is that
there is no known cure for their condition, which steadily worsens until
they succumb to an early death.
COPD typically worsens over time until the respiration is so limited
that it cannot sustain life. People with COPD, accordingly, have a reduced
life expectancy. Worldwide, COPD affects 329 million people, or nearly 5
percent of the population, although the true prevalence may be higher due
to underdiagnosis. In 2012, COPD ranked as the third-leading cause of death
(after heart disease and cancer), killing more than three million people.SO
How is it possible that, in spite of spending trillions of dollars on
medical research every year, we are still unable to successfully treat this
widespread illness? Are we looking for answers in the wrong places? As
far as I know, until now there has been no known successful treatment
for COPD.
Perhaps there are solutions that are not based on drugs or surgery.
From my success with the following case, among others, I have come to
believe that many underlying problems with COPD stem from autonomic
nervous system dysfunction, and that COPD is an example of a health
92
EFTA00810094
The Polyvagal Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
issue that might be addressed successfully using the insights gained from
the Polyvagal Theory.
Doctors and hospitals do more elaborate and expensive testing than
ever before, but they usually overlook evaluating the function of the
autonomic nervous system. This is unfortunate, because patients can be
screened quickly and inexpensively for ventral vagus branch function—
which affects many other body functions.
Restoring the function of the vagus nerve is a key element of my
successful treatment of COPD. In my clinic I have been able to help
most COPD-diagnosed patients to improve their breathing in spite of
the accepted belief in the medical community that no medical treatment
can effectively improve a person's mechanical ventilation.
By getting the autonomic nervous system to function better, I have
been able to help people with a wide variety of chronic problems
that have not been helped by other modalities of treatment, whether
allopathic or alternative. Although I have worked with many different
kinds of health issues, I was especially pleased by my successes in helping
COPD-diagnosed clients to improve their breathing capacity. Through a
combination of my hands-on treatments and their own practice of self-
help exercises, they were able to improve their breathing capacity and
thereby increase oxygen uptake into their blood.
COPD AND HIATAL HERNIA: A CASE STUDY
Although I do not have the facilities to measure vital capacity accurately
in my clinic, one of my clients who was diagnosed with COPD had been
measured at the hospital before he started with me, and again after seven
sessions. His vital capacity (a test for lung function) had improved from
70 percent to 102 percent. (Vital capacity is measured against the aver-
age of other people of one's age group, calibrated by body weight. It is
possible for a person to be above the average for people in the same age
group and calibrated for weight. Therefore it is possible for a person to
have a vital capacity of more than 100 percent.)
93
EFTA00810095
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
This client's original lung and bronchial scans showed white areas that
the doctors assumed were a concentration of extra fibers, which were
supposed to be part of the reason why he was not absorbing sufficient
oxygen. My belief was that if we improved the movement of his lungs as
he breathed, in time the extra fibers might be absorbed. I saw this client
again recently, and his absorption of oxygen had improved by 15 percent.
My clinic is in a building in a charming old neighborhood in Copen-
hagen. There is no elevator, and my office is one flight up. One day I was
expecting a new client, a forty-four-year-old man with difficulty breath-
ing. He had told me in an earlier phone conversation that he had a medi-
cal diagnosis of COPD.
When I heard a knock at the door, I opened it and saw him at the top
of the stairs, clutching the railing tightly with one hand, gasping rapidly,
and fighting for his next breath. He said that he had had to stop twice to
catch his breath on the way up.
Before he developed this problem, this man had been in great physical
shape. He had actively participated in various sports; his special passion
was cross-country skiing. He had just returned from a skiing vacation in
the Swiss Alps with his two children, but this time he did not get onto
skis; he had to sit on the terrace at the restaurant, wrapped in a blanket,
watching them come down the slope without him.
He told me about the several large white areas in his lung scan, indi-
cating the growth of extra fibers, which the doctors had told him were
the cause of his difficulty breathing. I could not deny the fact that there
were white areas on the scan, but I did not buy into their explanation that
these fibers were the only cause of his breathing difficulties. I looked at
his problem as a muscular-skeletal issue: if I could get his ribs and respi-
ratory diaphragm to move more normally, I was sure that his breathing
would improve, even if scans and x-rays still showed the existence of
those extra fibers.
From many years of clinical experience, I had come to suspect that
when there is a dysfunction in a visceral organ—in this case the lungs—
the cause might partly stem from a dysfunction in the autonomic nervous
94
EFTA00810096
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
system nerves serving that organ. The ventral and dorsal branches of the
vagus nerve, as well as the sympathetic nervous system, innervate the
heart and lungs. The dorsal vagus also provides the primary pathways
to the subdiaphragmatic vagus nerve branch that extends to the visceral
organs below the diaphragm.
The dorsal branch of the vagus nerve constricts the bronchioles,
reducing airflow. The sympathetic nervous system (associated with stress)
dilates the bronchioles, allowing the maximum flow of air. When the ven-
tral branch of the vagus nerve functions properly, the bronchioles relax,
allowing an adequate flow of air to and from the lungs.
Before I started treating this short-of-breath cross-country skier, I
asked him where he felt movement when he breathed. He replied that he
lifted his upper chest on the inbreath and that it settled back down on the
outbreath. I could see what he was describing—he was almost panting,
and his breathing was shallow, rapid, and high in his chest.
However, this chest movement did not result from lifting of the respi-
ratory diaphragm. Rather, it came from the muscles in his neck and should-
ers tightening in order to lift his upper ribs. Over time, these tensions had
pulled his head into a forward posture (more on this later), which further
restricted his breathing.
I stood behind him and placed both of my hands lightly on the sides
of the lower part of his chest, sensing whether there was any movement in
his lowest two ribs. When the respiratory diaphragm functions properly,
it tightens on the inbreath, pushing downward and laterally expanding
the lower two ribs. The man had only a minimal amount of lateral rib
movement on his right side, and no detectable lateral movement on the
left side.
I like my clients to participate in the evaluation of their own breathing
by noticing where there is movement in their chest and belly. Then they
can participate by evaluating whether there are any positive changes as a
result of my treatment. I showed this client where to feel the movement
of different parts of his chest when he breathed in. I asked him what, if
any, movement of his ribs he could feel out to the sides. He said that he
could not feel any movement.
95
EFTA00810097
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
I tested the function of the ventral branch of his vagus nerve. (I
describe how to do this test in Chapter 4.) It took me less than thirty
seconds to determine that the ventral branch of his vagus nerve was
dysfunctional. Would there be any improvement in his breathing from
establishing good function in his ventral vagus with the Basic Exercise?
I asked this client to lie down on his back on my massage table, and
taught him how to do the Basic Exercise. (You can find instructions
for this exercise and others in Part Two.) My cross-country skier had
an immediate improvement in his respiration; he was breathing more
slowly, more deeply, and without strain. His ribs were expanding out
to the sides as he inhaled—he could feel this himself. This represented
a major improvement for someone suffering from COPD who had dif-
ficulty breathing. I again tested the function of the ventral branch of his
vagus nerve, and found that it was now working as it should.
Medical doctors and researchers often use a spirometer to test lung
capacity. People tend to get nervous, however, when they think that they
are being tested, causing them to tense up and restrict their breathing. I
prefer to evaluate breathing functionally. I began with the observation
that this client had a very difficult time climbing one flight of stairs,
indicating how his breathing was impaired when he had to exert himself
in a normal, everyday situation.
After the treatment, my client looked much more relaxed. When he
stood up, I could see that he breathed more deeply and more slowly, and
that he had better color in his face. He told me that he felt much better.
Not bad for less than six minutes—an examination, one exercise, and a
reexamination.
My next goal was to further improve the movement of his respiratory
diaphragm. The lateral movement of his ribs on the right side had
increased, but there was still almost no palpable lateral movement of
the lower ribs on his left side. By comparing his right side with his left,
I clearly felt that something on his left side was interfering with the
movement of his diaphragm. From my experience with many patients, I
suspected that this might be caused by a hiatal hernia.
96
EFTA00810098
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
What is a hiatal hernia? The stomach is on the left side of the abdo-
men, normally below the respiratory diaphragm. The esophagus—the
elastic muscular tube that connects the back of the mouth to the top of
the stomach—passes through a round opening (hiatus) in the respiratory
diaphragm. The ventral branch of the vagus nerve innervates the upper
third of the esophagus, allowing its muscle fibers to change their length
and lift or lower the stomach, although the typical medical understanding
of a hiatal hernia does not consider the role of the vagus nerve.
If there is good vagal function, the esophagus can relax and lengthen,
letting the stomach move down slightly into the abdomen as the dia-
phragm tightens on the inbreath. Ideally, as the diaphragm ascends and
descends freely along the esophagus, the contents of the chest remain
in the chest (above the diaphragm), and the contents of the abdomen
remain in the abdomen (below the diaphragm). However, in cases of
vagal dysfunction, the upper third of the esophagus tightens and shortens,
pulling the stomach up against the bottom of the respiratory diaphragm.
(See "Stomach 2" in the Appendix.)
In extreme cases, the esophagus can be so tight and short that it pulls
the stomach up against the diaphragm, forcing its opening to enlarge
and pulling part of the stomach up into the chest. This is called a hiatal
hernia. (The word hiatus means "gap or interruption; and a hernia is a
protrusion through an opening in tissue.)
In addition to major difficulties breathing, people with hiatal her-
nias often have acid reflux. When stomach acid comes up and burns
the esophagus or back of the throat, the result is acid reflux, also called
GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease), or heartburn. Other symptoms
can include a bloated feeling after eating, and a propensity to eat several
small meals rather than three normal meals daily.
Normal breathing should involve the di gm moving up and down
(see "Diaphragmatic Breathing" on page n cases of breathing dif-
ficulties such as asthma and cold lungs (a.k.a. COPD), I have found the
shortened esophagus to be a factor that disrupts normal breathing—in
fact, I believe it is at the core of many breathing disorders. When the
97
EFTA00810099
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
stomach is pulled up into it, the diaphragm cannot descend freely on
the inbreath.
When I treat the vagus nerve with the Basic Exercise and then use a
technique adapted from visceral osteopathy to lengthen and relax the
esophagus, breathing difficulties disappear immediately, and the client
breathes deeply without effort. That's often all it takes!
Treating a Hiatal Hernia
Following is an osteopathic visceral-massage technique for treatment of
a hiatal hernia.It works well as a simple self-help exercise.
I first instruct clients how to do the Basic Exercise (see Part Two). Then
I use a simple osteopathic technique to pull their stomach down and to
stretch (lengthen) and relax the esophagus. I usually teach them to do
this for themselves. With this protocol, I have helped many patients with
diagnoses such as asthma, pulmonary fibrosis, and shortness of breath.
The stomach is on the left side of the abdomen, just under the rib cage.
Place the fingertips of one hand lightly on the top of where you imagine
you can find the stomach. The stomach is soft but palpable. You should
be able to feel the stomach if you slowly and gently extend your finger-
tips into the abdominal muscles. You only want to feel the top surface
of the stomach. Under no circumstances should your move be painful.If
the person experiences pain, you should stop immediately. Gently pull it
downward toward the feet until you sense the first sign of resistance—
usually after pulling it only about one half-inch to one inch (Figure 1). Hold
it at that point of slight resistance until the esophagus relaxes. Although
you might be tempted to push the stomach down in order to stretch the
esophagus, it in not necessary to exert any force. If you have your fingers
on the top of the stomach, you will signal the nerves for the esophagus
to lengthen, and the stomach will descend in the abdomen, making room
for the respiratory diaphragm to descend on the inbreath.
A sigh or a swallow usually accompanies this moment of relaxation. At this
point, it feels as if the muscular resistance to the stomach's being pulled down
melts. And immediately the person is able to breathe moreeasily and deeply.
98
EFTA00810100
The Polyvagal Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
Figure 1. Hiatal hernia treatment
For this particular client, I guided him in this simple self-help tech-
nique so that, by gently pulling his stomach downward, he was able to
stretch his esophagus and breathe more freely. With a relaxed esophagus,
his stomach was free to move into a better position, lower in his abdomen,
an inch or two below his respiratory diaphragm. His diaphragm could
then move freely up and down, sliding normally over the outer surface of
his esophagus, now that there was mom for it to descend on the inbreath.
His lower ribs could also expand laterally to both sides. His breathing was
much deeper, and markedly slower. He was exchanging a greater volume
of air on every breath.
Now came the functional test: The landing at my office door is one
flight up from street level, and I asked my client to go up to the top of the
stairwell—another four flights up—and then to come back down again.
When he returned, he was breathing hard, but his breathing was deeper.
Smiling, he said, "I ran the whole way up and the whole way down. I
didn't need to stop once:' This was a man who could not walk up one
flight of stairs without stopping to catch his breath before our session.
99
EFTA00810101
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
This client continues to take occasional sessions with me. In addition
to treating his hiatal hernia, we addressed tensions in other visceral organs
that can also hamper breathing. He continued doing the Basic Exercise,
the self-help technique for hiatal hernia, and other visceral-massage
techniques. I also gave him some movement exercises. After twelve weeks,
he was able to ride a bike for several hours with his brother, who had been
a national triathlon champion in Denmark. When I last spoke with him,
his breathing was continuing to improve, and he was planning a biking
trip in the mountains of Switzerland with his brother. This was only six
months after he started his sessions with me.
When this man was medically scanned again, there were still white
areas in his lungs, showing the continued presence of fibers. However, the
fibers did not seem to be restricting his breathing. The fibers do reduce the
effectiveness of lung tissue in absorbing oxygen. But with a far greater lung
capacity, he was now able to perform at a higher level than many athletes.
I believe most attempts to treat COPD have been using the wrong
map, failing to take into account that part of the problem can be traced
to dysfunction of the vagus nerve. I believe that the cause of COPD often
involves a lack of activity in the ventral branch of the vagus nerve, leaving
the dorsal branch's activity unchecked.
The dorsal branch constricts the bronchioles, making it difficult to
get enough air into the lungs. This constriction is appropriate for the
immobilized state of shutdown, for instance, in a crocodile after it has
eaten a big meal and must lie still in order to digest. However, if this
constriction is unchecked, it becomes problematic for humans trying to
function normally in everyday life.
Using the Basic Exercise to activate the function of the ventral branch
of the vagus nerve moves people out of the dorsal-branch state of
shutdown, so that their bronchioles are no longer constricted.
The Basic Exercise, combined with stretching of the esophagus, takes
only a few minutes. There is no prescription medicine required, and it is
immediately effective, with no negative side effects. To me, this is evidence
that the widely accepted explanation of the cause of COPD is not the
100
EFTA00810102
The Polyvagal Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
whole story. The man that I treated brought me x-rays and scans showing
white areas in his lungs, and had been told that these areas were fibers
causing breathing restrictions. If after ten minutes of my treatment he was
able to breathe more normally, the idea that his breathing was restricted
by the fibers does not hold—or at least we can say that this was not the
only explanation.
For this man with COPD, improving the function of his ventral vagus
nerve, bringing his head back from a forward position, and easing the
function of his respiratory diaphragm contributed to improvement in
his vital capacity. This was confirmed by hospital tests.
Diaphragmatic Breathing
Good diaphragmatic breathing is an important element of social
engagement. Every person I have observed in my clinic who is in a state
of stress or dorsal vagal activity has a disturbed pattern of breathing.
Normal breathing should involve up-and-down movement of the
diaphragm. In order to evaluate whether this is happening, I place my
hands lightly on the sides of the chest at the level of the last two ribs. If
there is diaphragmatic breathing, I can detect a lateral movement of the
lower two ribs on both sides. However, if there is a hiatal hernia, I can feel
lateral movement on the right side but almost none on the left.
When we cannot inhale with a normal lowering of their respiratory
diaphragm, we find alternative ways to make space for the expanding
lungs. One very common way is to lift the shoulders and upper ribs.This is
called high costal breathing ("costal" refers to ribs).This breathing pattern
is associated with the emotions of fear, anxiety, and panic.
Another common pattern in non-diaphragmatic breathing is to inhale
using the abdominal muscles. Sometimes, when we are typically short of
breath, the belly is distended, soft, and flabby.The belly muscles are too
soft, and when they go slack the intestines descend, pulling the lungs
down. Sometimes people call this "belly breathing" and interpret it as a
good sign because they can see that the breath is going down into the
101
EFTA00810103
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
abdomen. However, it does not actively involve tightening the respiratory
diaphragm. People breathing this way often hold their stomach muscles
tight on the inbreath. The muscles of their abdomen feel hard. This
breathing pattern is associated with anger.
Ideally, the abdomen and chest expand and contract rhythmically, at
the same time. The lower two ribs (R11 and R12) move to the sides, down,
and back with expansion. The next five ribs up (R6-R10) swing out to the
sides; this lateral movement is likened to that of a "bucket handle." The
next group of ribs above those (R5 to R1) lifts straight upward, along with
the sternum, in a movement described as the"pump handle:.
If we lose optimal tonus in our diaphragm, we also lose proper tonus
in our entire musculoskeletal system. We tend to collapse into our body,
and exhibit the breathing of someone who is shut down and manifesting
depressive behavior. If, on the other hand, we tighten the diaphragm and
push it down onto our gut, we get the body and breathing of someone
in a state of anger.
The vagus nerve has both sensory and motor fibers that affect and are
affected by the movements of respiration. There are four times as many
sensory (afferent, or inward-transmitting) nerve fibers in the respiratory
branch of the vagus nerve as there are motor (efferent, or outward-
transmitting) nerves, and these are constantly monitoring the functioning
of the respiratory diaphragm.
Proper function of the motor fibers of the ventral vagus is necessary
to facilitate relaxed, efficient breathing. When the respiratory diaphragm
is not working properly and does not descend on the inbreath, we use
muscles activated by either our spinal sympathetic chain or our dorsal
vagal circuit, so a breathing pattern that fails to make proper use of the
diaphragm will communicate through the sensory nerve fibers that we
are threatened or in danger. This is one example of how feedback from
sensory branches of cranial nerves influences the state of our autonomic
nervous system.
102
EFTA00810104
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
Shoulder, Neck, and Head Pain:
CN XI, Trapezius, and SCM
In addition to being one of the five "social engagement" nerves, cranial
nerve XI (the "spinal accessory nerve") has a special muscular function.
It innervates the trapezius and the sternodeidomastoid (SCM), two large
muscles in the neck and shoulder. (See "Trapezius" and "Sternocleido-
mastoid" in the Appendix.) These are the only skeletal muscles below
the face and head that are not innervated by spinal nerves. If either of
these two muscles is chronically either tense or flaccid, it will respond
differently to massage treatment and movement training than any other
muscle of the body.
Shoulder problems are among the most common forms of musculo-
skeletal problems. Dysfunction in CN XI often leads to pain and stiffness
in the neck and shoulders, and sometimes simply improving the function
of CN X and CN XI with the Basic Exercise is enough to eliminate pain or
restricted movement in this area. After doing the exercise, we might want
to try other ways to treat other problems stemming from these muscles;
for example, see the self-help treatment for migraine headaches described
in Part Two. Doing the Basic Exercise seems to also instantaneously
improve the function of all five nerves necessary for social engagement
for most people.
Returning to the trapezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles, we note
that dysfunction of CN XI and/or a lack of proper tonus in the trapezius
and SCM muscles are involved in many other health issues besides neck
and shoulder pain and stiffness. These include migraines, forward head
posture, breathing difficulties, chronic spinal sympathetic chain activa-
tion, chronic dorsal vagal state, and shortened life expectancy.
The trapezius and SCM are also determining factors in the shape and
health of the spine. Furthermore, a chronic tension in the sternocleido-
mastoid muscles on one side can actually change the shape of the back
of the head, leaving it flat on one side because of the constant pull of the
muscle on the temporal bones (the skull plates behind the ears). In every
child I've treated on the autism spectrum, I have observed this distortion
103
EFTA00810105
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
in the shape of the back of their head?' (See Part Two for a technique to
round the back of the head.)
Turning the head to either side should be an even, well-coordinated
movement, without stops or jerks, and without deviation from a smooth
curve. The head should be able to turn ninety degrees, or slightly more.
People often complain about reduced range of movement, stiffness,
or pain in their neck and shoulders when they rotate their head to one
side. If the pain or stiffness is on the side opposite to the direction in
which they turn their head, the shoulder problem is most likely either
the trapezius or the sternocleidomastoid muscle on the side toward
which they are turning. If the pain is on the same side as the turn, the
problem is not cranial nerve XI and the trapezius and SCM but is most
likely due to the levator scapulae. In Part Two there is a set of exercises
called "The Salamander Exercises," which improve the neck's capacity
for lateral movement. This exercise can be slightly painful at first, but if
we are persistent, we can increase the range of movement, improve the
flow of blood to CN XI, and improve the function of our trapezius and
sternocleidomastoid muscles.
The Levator Scapulae Muscle
We can improve the function of the cranial nerves, and improve the
rotation of the head to the right and left, with the Basic Exercise and the
Salamander Exercises. But these still might not be enough to allow full
freedom in the turning of the head, since many other muscles of the neck
are involved in head movement, and tension in any of them can restrict
head tuming.
If we have pain in our neck on the same side our head is turning
toward, then the problem is not cranial nerve XI and the trapezius and
SCM. It is most likely coming from another muscle, the levator scapulae
("shoulder-blade lifter"). In these cases, working on cranial nerve XI and
the trapezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles will probably not remove
all of the pain and stiffness.
104
EFTA00810106
The Polyvagal Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
Janet Travell, David Simons, and Lois Simons, in their book Myofascial
Pain and Dysfunction: The Trigger Point Manual, nicknamed the levator
scapulae the'Stiff Neck"muscle." This pair of muscles reaches down from
the top vertebrae to the shoulder blade, along either side of the neck.
I have found that directly massaging the levator scapulae gives
relief, but only temporarily—the muscle dysfunction quickly returns.
The problem is probably that the levator scapulae is undertoned. So if
you want a more lasting result, Tom Myers suggested massaging the
supraspinatus muscle (along the top of the shoulder blade) to improve
the tonus of the levator scapulae. (See "Supraspinatus"in the Appendix.)
Benjamin Shield suggested another approach.He observed that with
a side-bending of the upper cervical vertebrae, you can open the spaces
between Cl and C3 to take the pressure off of the spinal nerves that
go to the levator scapulae. You might try the upper part (Level 1) of the
Salamander Exercises, tipping the head to one side to open the spaces
between Cl and C3.
THE TRAPEZIUS AND STERNOCLEIDOMASTOID MUSCLES
Problems with the trapezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles are more
serious than just the discomforts of pain, stiffness, or migraines. Usually
people with dysfunction in either of these two muscles are not socially
engaged, and they are prone to all of the problems that I earlier described
as the "heads of the Hydra" (see the beginning of Part One). Correcting
the function of these two muscles usually improves the function of CN
XI and can restore the state of social engagement.
Because these two muscles are innervated by a cranial nerve, they are
different from the other 660 skeletal muscles in the rest of the body, which
are all innervated by spinal nerves. Tension in any of these other muscles
can cause pain, reduced range of movement, and stiffness. Dysfunction
in the sternocleidomastoid and trapezius muscles, by contrast, is related
to a host of serious health issues that we usually do not associate with
muscular problems.
105
EFTA00810107
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
The trapezius muscles are a pair of thin, flat, trapezoid-shaped, super-
ficial muscles covering a large area of the back of the neck, shoulders, and
torso. They originate on the occipital bone, at the base of the back of the
skull, and attach to the spinous processes of the shoulder blades and the
spinous process of each vertebra of the cervical and thoracic spine (in the
neck and torso). The sternocleidomastoid (SCM) muscles attach to the
tip of the mastoid process of the temporal bones, along the sides of the
skull just behind the ears. Then the muscle splits into two "bellies" that
wrap diagonally forward and down, with one part attaching to the top of
the sternum (breastbone) and the other part to the medial section of the
clavicle (collarbone). Because the two muscles' bellies attach at slightly
different places on the skull, they pull the head at slightly differ-ent angles.
Also, because the sternal and clavicular bellies of the SCM attach in differ-
ent locations on the torso, they also contribute to the rotation of the head.
The SCM muscles on both sides muscles can be likened to reins that
allow a horseback rider to steer the movement of the horses head. The
rider pulls in the reins on one side while letting out slack on the other
side. If there is no chronic tension in our SCM on either side, our head
would be perfectly balanced on our neck; it would turn just as easily to
the right or to the left without restriction or pain. Our head would come
to a natural resting position looking straight ahead.
However, there is often tightness in one of the bellies of the SCM
on one side, resulting in a stiff neck. This makes rotation of the neck
easy toward one side, but difficult toward the other. Since the SCM is
innervated by the eleventh cranial nerve, this stiffness is often caused by a
dysfunction of CN XI and is almost always concurrent with a dysfunction
of the vagus nerve.
If the bellies of the SCM attaching to the sternum tighten on both sides
symmetrically, they will shorten the neck, making it thicker, and pull the
head forward. This has been described as a "bull neck." If the bellies of the
SCM attaching to the clavicle tighten symmetrically, they pull the head
backward, making the neck thinner and longer (a "swan neck").
In her book Rolfing,s3 pioneering body therapist Dr. Ida Rolf calls
our attention to the fact that the trapezius and the sternocleidomastoid
106
EFTA00810108
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
muscles comprise the outer ring of neck muscles. Inside this outer ring,
there are many smaller muscles that help us to make finer movements of
the head, to lift the upper ribs when we breathe, and to swallow.
The complicated coordination of tension and relaxation of the muscles
that turn our head requires precise muscle control. This is programmed
into our nervous system in such a way that we do not have to think about
the mechanics of it. When something catches our attention, we automati-
cally focus our eyes on it. The movement of our head follows the direction
of our eyes, and then the movement of our body follows the movement
of our head. The eyes focus on an object of interest, and center it in the
visual field; then the eleventh cranial nerve innervates the fibers of the
trapezius and SCM muscles in order to turn the head in that direction.
We were born with this ability to coordinate our eye, head, and body
movements. When a baby is lying on its stomach, if an object in front of
it suddenly moves or changes its speed, the baby's eyes will focus on the
object and follow the movement, first with its eyes and then with its head.
We respond to sound in the same way. If there is a sound that catches our
attention, we move our head to center the sound between our ears. All
of this requires complex coordination of the trapezius, SCM, and other
muscles.
TRAPEZIUS AND SCM MUSCLES IN ACTION
ON THE SERENGETI PLAIN
A cheetah is the fastest mammal on Earth, able to run at speeds of up
to sixty miles per hour. Running at that incredible speed, the cheetah
keeps its eyes fixed on the animal it is chasing. The eleventh cranial nerve
enables the cheetah to turn its head and, as its head turns, its body follows.
An antelope being chased by the cheetah looks for clear areas where
it can get away from the cheetah without bumping into anything. When
its eyes find such a space, its head follows the direction of the eyes and
then its body follows.
Although it is not as fast as the cheetah, the antelope has an advantage:
if it ran in a straight line, the cheetah could easily catch it, but with its
107
EFTA00810109
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
light body and thin legs, the antelope can turn faster. So, to avoid being
captured by the cheetah, the antelope zigs and zags. The cheetah is unable
to do this quite as quickly; because it is so agile, therefore, a healthy adult
antelope will usually survive being chased by a cheetah. The antelope
also has the endurance to run for a longer period of time and outlast a
pursuing cheetah.
When a cheetah, lion, tiger, or other predator chases its prey and does
not manage to bring it down right away, it becomes exhausted from the
intense effort, and it takes several hours to regain the strength to try
again. Therefore, before it exerts itself, the cheetah spends time studying
the herd of antelopes in order to pick out one that is injured or old, or
a newborn hiding in the long grass near its mother. Half of all antelope
fawns are lost to predators before reaching adulthood.
For both the hunter and the hunted, survival depends in part on turn-
ing their heads effortlessly, and the muscles primarily responsible for
this are the trapezius and the sternocleidomastoid—both innervated by
cranial nerve XI. Because turning the head is a matter of life and death,
it is not surprising that the structure of CN XI is highly developed and
complex, for precise innervation of the individual fibers of these muscles.
USE OF TRAPEZIUS MUSCLES WHEN CRAWLING
The trapezius is one of the very first muscles that we humans use as
babies. When a baby lies on its stomach, its first movement is to arch its
back and lift its head using its trapezius muscles. Then, with its head up,
the baby can turn its head and look around using the sternocleidomastoid
muscles. (See "Baby on stomach" in the Appendix.)
The next step in the baby's development will be to lift its head high
enough to bring its arms under its shoulders to support the weight of
its upper body. With this, the baby will soon be able to come up on all
fours. In this position, tensing the fibers of the upper trapezius extends
and arches the neck and lifts the head, and the face looks forward. (See
"Baby on all fours" in the Appendix.) In order to do this, the baby tenses
all the fibers of the three parts of the trapezius more or less equally. The
108
EFTA00810110
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
baby arches its lower back with its lower trapezius, pulls the shoulders
together with the middle trapezius, and lifts its head up and tips it back
with the upper trapezius. In addition to the trapezius muscle, the head
is held up and balanced on the vertebrae of the neck partly due to the
action of the setnispinalis capitis, the largest muscle in the posterior neck.
Then the sternocleidomastoid muscles can rotate the head quite easily.
At this stage in its development, the baby supports its weight on its
hands and knees and moves much like other four-legged mammals. After
a short while, the baby can begin to crawl forward, moving with first
one arm forward and the other one back. This asymmetrical pattern
of arm movement when crawling requires using the trapezius muscles
asymmetrically.
With the body supported on all fours, the arms and thighs are at a
ninety-degree angle to the trunk. As the baby pushes down with its arms,
there is equal force pushing the arm back up into the socket of the shoulder
joint, and the proprioceptive nerves in the shoulder joint can report to the
brain that the arms and shoulders feel right and are in balance.
CHANGES IN TRAPEZIUS USE WHEN GOING FROM
CRAWLING TO STANDING
I 'Liman babies support their weight on all fours when they crawl. Human
beings have the same physical structure as four-legged animals in terms
of the muscles, bones, and nerves involved in this movement.
We live in gravity, and gravity is always pulling us down. When we
crawled on all fours, we distributed our weight more or less evenly on
our four limbs, which held our weight by pushing up into our body. This
is a stable structure.
When we stood up to balance on our hind legs, we had to use our
muscles and bones in a completely new way. Everything changed in the
balance of tensions in our muscular and skeletal systems. Instead of a
more or less even muscle tonus in the muscle fibers, some muscles became
chronically tensed, and others became flaccid. Instead of holding our
weight on four supports, we balance our heavy upper body entirely on
109
EFTA00810111
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
the two ball-and-socket joints between the legs and hips when we stand,
which is most unstable compared to a four-legged stance. (See "Baby
standing" in the Appendix.)
Over decades, standing on our back legs can give rise to many prob-
lems that four-legged animals do not have. Common to most of us is an
increase in our forward head posture (FHP) as we age. (See the following
section on FHP and its related health problems.)
When we first came up to crawl on all fours, the trapezius muscle
held our head up high. The three parts of the trapezius functioned like
a single muscle in which all of the fibers had roughly the same tension.
Some of the muscle fibers worked to pull the shoulders back and together
to support our upper spine, and others fibers pulling in other directions
worked to lift the head back and up.
But when we stood up, parts of the trapezius muscle lost their integ-
rity; they were no longer needed to pull our shoulders together in the back
and tilt our head up, as before. Rather than acting as a single muscle, these
muscle fibers organized themselves into three functional units—now seen
as the upper, middle, and lower trapezius—and these three groups of
fibers began to work as separate entities. One part, therefore, might be
overly tense while another part is under-tensed. This is reflected in the
position of the bones of not only the shoulder but the spine as well. (See
"Trapezius" in the Appendix.)
The spine of a human being has a much different form than that of
a horse, a goat, or a giraffe. A four-legged animal supports part of its
weight on its front legs, in contrast to a human being whose arms hang
freely from the shoulder joint. There is no longer a pushing of the arms
into the shoulder joint.
If we have shoulder pain, we often ask ourselves what we did to create
the pain—we must have lifted something heavy, or thrown something,
such as a baseball, which we were not used to doing. However, an unrec-
ognized factor in the creation of imbalances leading to shoulder pain
might be changes that have occurred because we are standing upright
only on our legs. And there is no telling what a lifetime habit of sitting
still on chairs does to our musculoskeletal structure. It is not a surprise
110
EFTA00810112
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
that many physical therapists report that the most common problems
that they treat are shoulder problems.
The human spine has weaknesses that lead to stiff necks, backaches,
and shoulder problems. When we stand up, the relationship between the
head and the spine changes compared to when we were on all fours. (See
"Baby standing" in the Appendix.) In order to balance on our legs, the
upper part of the trapezius is no longer positioned to hold the head up
and back, and the head tends to slide forward.
The middle part of the trapezius muscle no longer pulls the shoulder
blades together toward the spine to make a stable base. Instead, for most of
us, our shoulder blades glide down our back, forward, and around to our
sides. Compared with the deep barrel chest of a four-legged animal, our
upper chest caves in, and our belly hangs out. If an actor assumed this pos-
ture, it would be to portray a character who had lost a sense of self-esteem.
When the lower part of the trapezius does not function as it used to
when we were crawling on all fours, our spine shortens, and our head
moves into a forward position. These changes are not due to increased
muscular tension but rather to a general loss of a balanced tonus in the
three parts of the trapezius muscle that used to hold our head up against
the constant pull of gravity.
To improve the function of the trapezius muscle, therefore, we need to
improve the tonus of the muscle fibers in all three parts of the trapezius
by stimulating the nerves to the muscle. We can do that with a simple
movement that I call the "Twist and Turn Exercise" (see Part Two). Unlike
most other exercises, this exercise neither stretches nor strengthens the
muscle; by tightening and releasing muscle tension, it simply wakes up the
nerves innervating the trapezius muscle. Overly tense areas of the muscle
can relax, while muscle tone increases in areas that need it.
ASYMMETRY IN TRAPEZIUS MUSCLE TENSION
There are always differences in tension among the groups of fibers
comprising the upper, middle, and lower trapezius muscles. There is also a
111
EFTA00810113
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
difference between the right and left sides. This asymmetry of the various
parts can disrupt the balance in the two shoulders.
Because the trapezius attaches to the cervical and thoracic spine,
imbalances in tension between the right and left trapezius muscles add to
rotations, extensions, flexions, and side-bending of the thoracic vertebrae.
This changes the internal space within the chest, which in turn affects the
function of the heart and lungs.
In some cases this asymmetry can also compress the spinal nerves
exiting from these segments, affecting the organs they serve. Some of the
spinal nerves (T1—T4) go to the heart, and some (T5—T8) to the lungs.
Others (T9 and below) connect to various visceral organs.
ASYMMETRY IN STERNOCLEIDOMASTOID TENSION
The sternocleidomastoid muscles on both sides are the primary muscles
for turning the head left and right, and chronic or acute tension in a
sternocleidomastoid muscle results in a stiff neck. A baby with this issue
tends to turn its head to one side when lying on its back. As the child gets
older, this condition might be diagnosed as torticollis ("twisted neck").
If you examine the back of the head of someone with a stiff neck, you
may find it to be flat on one side. If so, the same technique described in
the "Technique for Rounding a Flat Back of the Head" on page 178 might
not only relax a tight sternodeidomastoid muscle but also to some degree
start to round the back of the head, even in an adult.
A stiff neck usually accompanies a rotation of the first cervical verte-
bra, called the atlas (see "Atlas" in the Appendix), resulting in a reduced
blood flow to the brainstem. In adults, a stiff neck may indicate dysfunc-
tion of the eleventh cranial nerve which, as noted earlier, is one of the five
cranial nerves necessary for social engagement. So releasing SCM tension
often makes it easier for us to be socially engaged.
This observation is not new; we find references that go back thousands
of years. There are surprisingly many references to "stiff-necked" people
in the Bible. An example from Nehemiah 9:17 says: `They refused to
listen, and did not remember the wonders you performed among them.
112
EFTA00810114
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
They became stiff-necked, and in their rebellion they appointed a leader
to return to their slavery in Egypt."
A NEW PICTURE OF CN XI
Turning the head is one of the most important and complex movements
of the body. It is one of the first movements that a baby makes, and we are
so familiar with this movement that we usually do not even think about
it. Control of the trapezius and SCM muscles requires a coordinated
tensing and relaxation of their many individual muscle fibers, and this
action depends on a well-functioning CN XI.
Most anatomical illustrations of CN XI attempt to show all the
branches of this nerve in a single drawing, but I have personally found
those drawings to be confusing. In order to help you gain a clear under-
standing of the complexity of structure of CN XI, I asked my illustrator
to make some new drawings in color that show the three parts of this
important cranial nerve. (See the "CN XI" series in the Appendix.) One
branch of CN XI originates in the brainstem and used to be called the
"cranial division." It is now considered to be a part of the vagus nerve—
the branch that innervates the pharyngeal muscles discussed in Chapter
4. Another branch, called the "spinal accessory nerve," exits the spinal
cord in the neck just below the cranium before going directly to the fibers
of the trapezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles. There is yet another
branch of the spinal accessory nerve, made of up nerve branches that
leave the spinal cord, weave together, extend up into the cranium through
the foramen magnum, reach across the floor of the skull, and then exit
through the jugular foramen in the base of the skull.
In spite of their diverse pathways, all the branches of CN XI function
together in a coordinated way to innervate the various parts of the tra-
pezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles.
CN XI and the ventral vagus (CN X) are closely linked, not only
functionally, through their role as two of the five cranial nerves necessary
for social engagement, but structurally. In two of the CN XI drawings in
the Appendix, a clear connection can be seen between branches of CN XI
113
EFTA00810115
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
and the ventral branch of the vagus nerve after they exit the skull through
the jugular foramen: fibers from CN XI intermingle with fibers of the
vagus nerve outside the cranium for a few millimeters. In addition to the
mixing of their nerve fibers after they exit the jugular foramen, both CN
XI and the ventral vagus branch originate in the nucleus ambiguus, a strip
of nerve fibers in the brainstem.
Therefore, it is not surprising that the function/dysfunction of the
vagus nerve is directly mirrored in the function/dysfunction of CN XL
The test for CN XI gives the same results in terms of indicating function/
dysfunction as do tests for the ventral branch of CN X.
CN XI AND THE VENTRAL VAGUS BRANCH
The Trap Squeeze Test for CN XI gives us an indication of the function/
dysfunction of not only CN XI but also the other four nerves necessary
for social engagement. All five of these nerves work together; if one is
dysfunctional, the others will also be dysfunctional. If we improve the
function of one, we also improve the function of the other four.
When I started using the Trap Squeeze Test for CN XI and ventral
vagus nerve function by asking my patients to open their mouth and
say "ah-ah-ah," I began to notice that whenever there was a difference in
tension between the trapezius muscles on the two sides, there was always
a dysfunction in the ventral vagus as indicated by the uvular lift test. I
decided to carry out an informal study in my clinic.
I tested the next eighty people who came to me for treatment: first I
tested their ventral vagus (with the uvular-lift test for vagal pharyngeal-
branch function described in Chapter 4), and then their CN XI (with
the Trap Squeeze Test). I found a 100 percent correlation between the
results of these two tests. On the basis of that, I felt safe concluding
that testing the trapezius muscles is a valid indicator of vagal function/
dysfunction.
After clients did the Basic Exercise, I tested them again both ways, and
found improvement in both CN XI and the ventral branch of the vagus
114
EFTA00810116
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
nerve. The patients agreed with me: "Now, when you squeeze, the two
sides feel more like each other?' I asked them to turn their head, and to
explore the sensations in their head, neck, and shoulders. In almost all
cases, they had better movement and could turn their head further, with
less or no pain.
The Trap Squeeze Test for Shoulder and Neck Problems
Some of the most common complaints among clients of physical
therapists and body therapists involve stiffness in the neck and pain in
the shoulder. As discussed above, these problems usually include a lack
of proper tonus of the trapezius and/or sternocleidomastoid muscles,
either of which may be chronically tense or flaccid.
Most physical therapists, massage therapists, and body therapists start
their treatment by working directly on tight shoulder muscles, without
considering the state of the client's autonomic nervous system. When
people come to my practice with shoulder problems, I base my approach
to this on the research findings of Cottingham, Porges, and Lyon.50
As suggested by their research, in order to achieve positive results
with fascial release, myofascial release, or release of muscle tensions in
general, it is important to have a well-functioning ventral vagus nerve
before attempting any other intervention. So I first test the ventral branch
of the vagus nerve, or use the following test for CN XI function. This test
often takes less time, and is less intrusive than my test for vagal function,
in which clients have to open their mouths and saysah-ah-alf while I use
a flashlight to observe uvula-area movement.
For this test, we only have to squeeze the muscles on the top of the
shoulder. The Trap Squeeze Test takes only a few seconds, and is well
suited for use on children and people on the autism spectrum, with whom
we might otherwise encounter difficulties in getting their cooperation
for the usual technique.
To use this form of testing, you first need to practice on several people
in order to develop the necessary kinesthetic skills. It is normal to feel
115
EFTA00810117
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
uncertain the first few times that you try testing the trapezius muscles.
However, you will likely find that you can get the feel of it after a few
attempts.
CN XI can be tested by sliding, lifting, and rolling the top of the
trapezius muscles (on the tops of the shoulders, halfway to the neck),
and comparing them on the left and right sides. Although the trapezius
muscle covers a large area, it is very thin.
1. Take hold of the trapezius muscle on each side, squeezing it lightly
between your thumb and your first finger (Figure 2). Whereas most
novices simply grab the muscle, the lighter you squeeze, the better.
2. If you squeeze lightly and slowly, you should be able to lift the muscle
slightly away from the underlying muscles.
Figure 2. Trap squeeze test
3. Compare the tonus of the trapezius muscle on one side with the
tonus of the trapezius muscle on the other side. Do the two sides feel
the same to you, or is one side harder than the other? Ideally, both
sides should be soft and elastic. However, one side is often soft and
116
EFTA00810118
The Polyvagal Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
elastic, while the other is not. If you squeeze them slowly, with a light
pressure, you can feel that the muscle on one side remains relaxed,
soft, and pliable if you push deeper into it, while the other side may
react to your squeeze by tensing up and feeling hard, even though
you are using a very light pressure.
4.1 ask the person who I am testing,"When I squeeze, do the two sides
feel the same to you, or do they feel different?"If the person answers
that they feel different, I ask,"Which side is more tense?" Here is
something that I do not understand, but I encounter it often: more
than half the time that I do this test, I disagree with the person I am
testing as to which side is more tense, or harderf I do not know why
this is so. But I have come to the conclusion that it does not matter in
terms of the success of my treatment; the main point is that my client
and I agree that there is a difference between the two sides.
5. If we agree that there is a difference, I take this as an indication of
dysfunction in CN XI, and I conclude that their autonomic nervous
system is not socially engaged, and that they are in a state of either
stress or dorsal vagal withdrawal. We can then take the appropriate
steps to restore ventral vagal function before proceeding with any
further therapeutic techniques.
Health Problems Related to
Forward Head Posture
Serious health problems can stem from kyphosis, or forward head posture
(FHP), which is related to dysfunctional trapezius and sternocleidomas-
told muscles (Figure 3). A forward head posture is one result of poor
posture in general.
As we get older, many of us lose the good posture that we enjoyed as
children; we may have increased difficulty breathing and be bothered
by occasional dizziness. These issues are generally not considered to be
medical problems; doctors tend to assume that they are a natural part
of growing older and that nothing can be done about them. There is no
medicine or operation to help remedy these conditions as such.
117
EFTA00810119
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Figure 3. Forward head position
The neck has a tendency to sag when we have FHP, allowing our head
to thrust forward. Our upper chest collapses, reducing the space for the
heart and lungs. The forward head posture also blocks the action of the
muscles responsible for helping to lift the first rib during inhalation,
resulting in difficulty breathing.
As time goes on and FHP gets worse, we lose an increasing portion
of our breathing capacity. FHP is often found in people with breathing
problems such as asthma and COPD.66 It is no wonder that they experi-
ence general fatigue and low levels of energy. Research published in the
Journal of the American Geriatric Society also reports that they also have
shorter life expectancy—shorter even than people who smoke a pack of
cigarettes a day—and that older patients with FHP have a significantly
higher mortality rate."
Could restrictions in the function of these nerves also be contributing
factors in Alzheimer's disease, dementia, and senility?
118
EFTA00810120
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
In addition to reducing breathing capacity, the loss of internal chest
space puts pressure on the heart and crowds the blood vessels that go to
and from the heart. FHP also compresses the spaces between the vertebrae
of the neck and upper thorax, putting pressure on the spinal nerves of
the neck and the upper thoracic spine.
Furthermore, forward head posture compresses the vertebral arter-
ies that carry blood up to the head, diminishing blood supply to the
face, parts of the brain, and the brainstem, where the social-engagement
cranial nerves V, VII, IX, X, and XI originate. When this occurs, as we
might expect, we look pale, lack spontaneous facial expression, and are
not socially engaged. If these five cranial nerves do not receive adequate
blood circulation, they can fail to function properly, and we are likely to
be in a state of chronic stress or dorsal vagal activity.
Many aches, pains, and stiffnesses develop over time due to deterio-
rating posture. According to a Mayo Clinic newsletter, "Forward head
posture leads to long-term muscle strain, herniated discs, arthritis, and
pinched nerves.""
Neurosurgeon and Nobel Prize recipient Dr. AIf Breig stated,"Loss of
the cervical curve stretches the spinal cord 5-7 cm and causes disease.." 8
The characteristic stiffening of the neck in FHP also stiffens the entire
spine. According to Dr. Roger Sperry, Nobel Prize recipient for brain
research,"Ninety percent of the stimulation and nutrition to the brain is
generated by the movement of the spine.'S9
People with kyphosis often have difficulty breathing, mild back pain,
and tenderness and stiffness in the spine. Emotionally, they may experi-
ence apathy and indifference about what is happening—also symptomatic
of dorsal vagal withdrawal.
Viewed from the side, our ear should be directly above the midline of
our shoulder. However, as we age, many of us succumb to a forward head
posture, and you can see that the ear has moved forward in relationship
to the center of the shoulder. In this case, we are usually stooped over,
our upper chest is collapsed, and our head is no longer balanced on our
neck. The neck muscles have to work hard constantly to keep the head
from tipping even further forward.
119
EFTA00810121
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
"Every inch of Forward Head Posture ... can increase the weight of the
head on the spine by an additional ten pounds,"according to A. I. Kapandji
in ThePhysiology of theJoints.° The head itself weighs about twelve pounds,
and many of us have our head forward by two or three inches.
The man in the forward head posture photograph came to me com-
plaining of difficulty breathing and general fatigue. His forward head pos-
ture was not the result of muscle tensions, but of flaccid trapezius muscles.
As mentioned earlier, FHP often results from a dysfunction in the trapezius
and sternocleidomastoid muscles; the trapezius lacks sufficient tonus, while
parts of the SCM are in chronic tension. Improving the muscular tonus
of these muscles, therefore, brings the head back into better alignment.
Many forms of massage and movement work well on muscles of the
body generally. However, because these two muscles are innervated by cra-
nial nerves, I use a different approach for them. The first step toward nor-
malizing tension in either of these two muscles is doing the Basic Exercise
(see Part Two). I often see that when a patient does this exercise, even for
the first time, it helps bring their head back part of the way.
For further improving FHP and bringing the head back to an upright
position, I also utilize two other exercises—the "Twist and Turn Exercise"
and the "Salamander Exercises." You can find instructions for these exer-
cises in Part Two.
SCAR TISSUE AS A CONTRIBUTOR TO FHP
Scar tissue forms after surgical operations in order to make the body
stronger, in case a similar wound occurs at the same place in the future.
The patient may know intellectually that this extra scaffolding is not nec-
essary, because there is not likely to be another incision at the same exact
place, but the connective tissue has no way of knowing this.
Although the operation itself might have been necessary or even life-
saving, the layers of muscle and fascia contract and thicken as the incision
heals, and this tightening in the fascial network spreads beyond the local
area of the incision to affect the entire body. Every surgical operation has
this negative side effect, which is almost never addressed.
120
EFTA00810122
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
Even though there may not be much scar tissue visible on the surface,
there can still be extensive buildup of scar tissue in the muscles and
connective tissue under the skin, and in the deeper fascia layers. Even if
the operation was done with a scope to minimize tissue damage, scars
form in the deeper layers.
There should be a small amount of thick fluid between adjacent lay-
ers of muscle and connective tissue, allowing them to slide freely across
one another. During an operation, however, this fluid sometimes dries
out when exposed to the air so that, instead of sliding, the layers begin
to stick to one another.
Also, after a surgical incision or any wound, the connective tissue cells
produce extra collagen fibers that can bind one layer of muscle or fascia
to an adjacent layer. When two layers have grown together, they no longer
slide across each other as they once did. Many surgeons take the extra
time and care to ensure that the tissues of each layer are sewn together
without involving tissues from other layers.
Unfortunately, some surgeons do not understand the importance of
this, and might sew layers together haphazardly in an attempt to save
time and money. The result is that the muscles and connective tissue
are much less flexible in that area. Scar tissue feels thicker and tougher,
and it forms not just on the surface but deeper in the body. If it is from
a C-section, the scar tissue goes all the way down from the surface of the
skin to the uterus. If it is in the chest or abdomen, scar tissue restricts the
space available for breathing.
Scarring after an operation pulls everything together into a knot; the
individual layers dry out and stick together, and movement is restricted.
As connective tissue on the front of the body tightens, it shortens the front
of the body and pulls the head even more forward and down. Therefore,
I recommend that anyone who has had chest or abdomen surgery should
find a massage therapist skilled in releasing tensions from scar tissue.
The idea behind the treatment of scar tissue is to work on restric-
tions in each individual layer of muscle and connective tissue, and then
to free the individual layers from each other so that one layer can again
slide freely on the adjacent layer. I am regularly amazed by the amount of
121
EFTA00810123
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
improvement that occurs in range of motion in the head and neck, flex-
ibility in the spine, and in the posture generally after releasing scar tissue.
FHP AND SUBOCCIPITAL MUSCLE TENSION
Whereas the sternocleidomastoid and trapezius muscles provide gross
rotational movements of the head on the neck, the fine-tuning of these
movements comes from the small suboccipital muscles between the
occiput and the first two vertebrae of the neck. Three of these muscles
define an area called the suboccipital triangle. (See "Suboccipital muscles"
in the Appendix.)
When these suboccipital muscles are tight, they can put pressure on
the suboccipital nerve (see"Suboccipital nerve" in the Appendix) and the
nearby vertebral arteries, which are embedded in the connective tissue
of the suboccipital triangle. This reduces blood supply to the brainstem
as well as to the five cranial nerves whose function is necessary for social
engagement.
With a forward head posture, the muscles of the suboccipital triangle
tighten in order to keep the chin from falling forward onto the chest. If
these muscles are kept in a state of constant contraction (over months or
years), they contract more and more, which further accentuates the forward
head posture, and this can further reduce blood flow to the brainstem.
It is not surprising that so many people with FHP complain of head-
aches at the back of the neck, just under the base of the cranium, where
these suboccipital muscles are located. Pressure on the suboccipital nerves
often expresses itself as pain at the back of the neck. It is interesting that
some clients with headaches complain that they feel as if they are not
getting enough energy (blood circulation) up to their head.
I have observed that patients with asthma have poor ventral vagal
function. Also, they almost always have a forward head posture. They have
a stiff upper thoracic spine, and reduced lateral expansion of their chest
when breathing in. Reducing FHP improves their breathing.
The Basic Exercise usually releases the tension in the suboccipital
muscles. Cl rotates back into place, pressure on the vertebral arteries
122
EFTA00810124
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
is reduced, the blood flow to the brainstem increases, and this in turn
improves our capacity for social engagement.
Relieving Migraine Headaches
Unlike "cold lungs" (COPD), migraines do not take years off our life
expectancy, but they certainly reduce the quality of our life. There are
many affordable medicines for migraines, but these do not work all of
the time for everyone. Some medicines are also expensive, and most have
possible side effects. So many people would prefer to be free from taking
medicine altogether.
Of the forty-five million people in the United States who suffer from
headaches every year, twenty-eight million suffer from migraines." Aside
from affecting quality of life, migraine headaches are one of the most
costly health problems in terms of time lost from work. This cost in the
United States alone was estimated to be $17 billion a year in 2005.62
Migraine is Greek for "one side of the head." If the pain is not localized
on one side of the head, I do not consider it a migraine. Migraine
headaches, often called tension headaches, range from moderate to severe,
and are usually intense, sometimes throbbing, and typically last from
two hours to three days. They often occur with symptoms of autonomic
dysfunction. They start suddenly and often disappear just as suddenly;
this sets a migraine apart from other headaches that are sometimes
described as "dull,""on both sides of the head," or "like a tight helmet;
or that come on slowly, increase in intensity, and end gradually.
Migraines may be accompanied by other symptoms such as blurred
vision, nausea, vomiting, fatigue, and oversensitiviry to light, sound, smell,
and being touched. Other accompanying symptoms can include visual
distortions (seeing auras) and dizziness. Women might report that their
headaches come at a specific point in their monthly cycle.
Doctors often classify migraines into different types depending on
these accompanying symptoms, and patients usually want to give me
detailed information about these symptoms, including how long ago the
headaches started and how long they last. Although this information is
123
EFTA00810125
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
important to my client, it does not help me as a therapist to treat them—I
know that if I can cure their migraines, the accompanying symptoms will
also disappear. To effectively treat a migraine, I need only know on which
side of the head the pain appears, and which parts of the two major neck
muscles are involved.
To establish this, I show clients four drawings of trigger points for the
trapezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles. (These drawings are based
on the work of Janet Travell, MD, and David Simons, MD, described
below.) The red areas in the drawings illustrate the patterns of pain that
can come from tensions in these muscles. I ask the migraine sufferer to
pick out which drawing best fits the headache, and to show me exactly
where she feels pain.
Without hesitating, all have been able to identify which of these four
drawings best illustrates the pattern of their pain. With this information,
I know exactly which muscle is involved. I am primarily interested in
the pattern of the pain, which tells me exactly where I should intervene
with my hands to bring about lasting relief. In the "Headache" drawings
in the Appendix, you can find the different patterns of tension causing
these headaches, the different patterns of pain, and where to massage
specifically for each pattern. My discovery of this alternative approach
to treating migraine headaches did not come all at once in one great
epiphany, but in the form of many insights over the years. In my work
with Rolfing and other forms of body-oriented therapies, most of my
clients came to me because they had pain somewhere in their body.
From books by Dr. Janet Graeme Travel ( 1901-1997) 1 learned about
using trigger points to successfully bring about relaxation of muscles and
to relieve pain. Dr. Travell co-authored the two-volume Myofascial Pain
and Dysfunction: The Trigger Point Manual with David G. Simons, MD,
and Lois Simons" and served as a physician in the White House, first to
John F. Kennedy and then to Lyndon Johnson.
President Kennedy had severe back pain stemming from wounds
suffered when he served in the Navy in World War II. His fifth and
final surgical procedure in September 1957 left him disenchanted with
surgical solutions for his back pain. Later, a conservative program,
124
EFTA00810126
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
including diluted salt-water injections at trigger points, provided
modest relief. He wore a back brace and took hot baths several times a
day, often using crutches while walking, except when he was in public
view. Janet Travell, however, was able to relieve his severe and chronic
back pain.
Dr. Travell's research demonstrated that tension in individual muscles
generates specific patterns of pain. Most inexperienced massage therapists
simply massage where it hurts, but muscle tension often produces pain
and other symptoms in other parts of the body. Pain at a distance from
the source of tension is called "referred pain?' Dr. Travell found that treat-
ing specific points in muscles not only relieves pains near those points
but can diminish referred pains as well; she called these "trigger points?'
All muscles have trigger points. The therapist will often observe
that they feel a little harder compared with other areas on the surface
of the muscle; the patient will also feel that those points are painful.
Massaging these trigger points relieves the pain in the area locally, and
also relieves referred pain occurring at a distance from the tense muscle.
Relieving tension in the trapezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles of
the neck, by pressing the appropriate trigger points, relieves migraine
headaches.
I bought two wall posters for my clinic that illustrate the trigger
points of many major muscles in an easy-to-use format. Each drawing
showed the pattern of pain in a muscle, the muscle involved, and where to
massage that muscle in order to release the pain. When people came for
pain treatment, I would ask them to point to the drawing in the posters
that matched the pattern of pain they felt in their body; then I knew
which muscle was involved, and which trigger points, marked with X's, I
should massage to bring relief.
When I treated the trigger points on the muscles involved in migraines
headaches, they disappeared even if they had bothered the clients for
twenty or more years.
My clients were often amazed at how quickly I figured out where to
treat them, and how effectively I could treat pains that other therapists
had not been able to handle. I gave photocopies of the drawings of those
125
EFTA00810127
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
muscles to my clients. In case the pain came back, they could treat them-
selves, or show it to another therapist treating them. About a third of the
people who suffer from migraines can feel when one is about to unleash
its fury. This gives them a chance to lie down, take a pill or, better yet, to
use the exercises and massage described later in this section.
My next important discovery leading to a successful protocol for
treating migraines derived from my experiences with biomechanical
craniosacral therapy. The twelve cranial nerves exchange information
between the brainstem and various parts of the body, primarily to and
from regions of the head and neck. One of these nerves, CN XI or the
accessory nerve, modulates tension in the sternocleidomastoid and
trapezius muscles in the neck, which can cause one of several patterns of
pain corresponding to the pains of migraine headaches.
Biomechanical craniosacral therapy offers specific techniques to free
blockages to the eleventh cranial nerve at the point where it exits the
cranium. I get the best results treating migraines when I improve the
function of CN XI before releasing tension in the muscles with a light
pressure on trigger points. Migraine relief is then faster and longer lasting.
Most of my clients are surprised to feel relief on the very first treatment.
If the eleventh cranial nerve is not functioning properly, the ventral
branch of the vagus nerve and the ninth cranial nerve are usually dys-
functional as well. Treating one of the three nerves immediately improves
the function of the other two so that, in practice, we do not have to treat
each of the three nerves one at a time. The Basic Exercise usually makes
all three of these nerves functional.
Some writers on the subject of migraines believe that "the underly-
ing causes of migraines are unknown'M—and not knowing their cause
makes them hard to treat. Other studies show that a number of psycho-
logical conditions may be associated with migraines, including activity
of the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve, anxiety, and bipolar disorder."
I find this of interest from the point of view of the Polyvagal Theory.
In Chapter 6, we will look at a few psychological conditions, and note
that they have a physiological aspect and are expressions of non-ventral
vagal states.
126
EFTA00810128
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
Do migraines have a musculoskeletal component? Although some
physiotherapists and body therapists are aware of it, the muscular com-
ponent underlying migraine headaches is generally not recognized by
physicians and medical researchers. Myofascial Pain and Dysfunction: The
Trigger Point Manua!shows patterns of pain on one side of the head that
are caused by tension in the trapezius and the sternocleidomastoid mus-
cles; these are the patterns I show to my clients who complain of migraine
headaches, and with these they can easily identify their headache pattern.
I have found over the years that improving the function of CN X and
XI, followed by releasing tension in these muscles using the appropriate
trigger points, usually effectively relieves migraine headaches in a matter
of minutes. I have even had success with some people who had migraines
their entire life, as far back as they could remember.
In my clinic, I like to teach clients how to do the techniques themselves
in the event that they are plagued by another migraine headache. Doing
the Basic Exercise, they can first establish proper function in their CN X
and XI. Then they can find and release the appropriate trigger points. This
treatment requires no pharmaceuticals, has no side effects—and no cost.
From my successful experience treating migraines, I believe that
most migraine sufferers can successfully treat themselves with the Basic
Exercise and the self-help massage techniques for migraine described in
Part Two, rather than taking painkillers or subjecting themselves to other
conventional treatments.
In my clinic I occasionally get patients who have had migraines for
many years and have tried everything else before coming to me. Perhaps
they have treated their migraines with over-the-counter and/or prescrip-
tion painkillers, antidepressants, beta-blockers, or drugs developed to
treat epilepsy. One of the most common side effects of these drugs is liver
damage, which in the worst case can eventually lead to buildup of fluids
around the brain.
These clients often tell me that they take a lot of medication and would
like to cut down. I remember a forty-two-year-old carpenter who was tak-
ing fifteen to twenty over-the-counter painkillers a day and was worried
about negative side effects, since the directions on the bottle said to take
127
EFTA00810129
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
a maximum of eight tablets a day. My client started taking his first pain-
killer in the morning as soon as he opened his eyes, regardless of whether
he had a headache or not. He said that he took the pills as a preventive
measure so that he did not have to wait for them to take effect in case he
got a migraine. He also, however, complained that the painkillers did not
always work for him.
First I showed him how to treat himself with the Basic Exercise (see
Part Two), which is safe, easy to learn, and easy to do. Then I showed
him the four drawings of the patterns of pain that are present in most
migraine headaches. When he identified the drawing that fit the pattern
he was experiencing, I knew which muscles needed to relax, and which
trigger points in his neck would relax the tension.
His first session with me substantially reduced the number ofhis head-
aches and decreased the intensity of the few that did occur. If the pain
returns after I give a treatment, I tell people that they can simply treat
themselves as described above.
MIGRAINES: A CASE STUDY
A woman who had been suffering from migraine headaches for almost
ten years came to me for treatments. She was experiencing a migraine at
the time she came into my office.
On average she had one severe attack every month that usually lasted
three to four days. She tried taking painkillers, but they did not help. She
tried in general to avoid known migraine triggers such as heavy red wine,
strong scents, bright sunshine, etc., but the migraines kept recurring.
When she felt a migraine coming on, if she could withdraw and stay in
bed, the attack was usually not so bad.
This woman is a journalist who wrote articles about beauty for maga-
zines. She could schedule around her deadlines if she got a headache
because she was working from home; she could take a day or two off, and
work when she felt up to it. However, the headaches did keep her from
attending many social events and enjoying her weekends off.
128
EFTA00810130
The PolyvagaI Theory—A New Paradigm for Health Care?
About a year before she came to me, this woman had started a new
career as a TV journalist, which meant that she now had a harder time
scheduling around her migraines. She had to show up for work and fol-
low the shooting schedule whether or not she had a migraine, so she felt
she needed a more effective treatment.
First I tested her ventral vagus (see Chapter 4) and noted that it was
not functioning as it should. Then I instructed her to do the Basic Exer-
cise, and she did this herself; I did not even need to touch her. I tested
her again and saw that her ventral vagus nerve was now functioning as
it should.
Then I showed her the four drawings of migraine pain patterns, and
she pointed to the drawing that matched her pattern. I taught her how to
use her own hands to treat the trigger points illustrated in that drawing.
I certainly could have used my hands for this treatment, but I wanted
her to do it herself so that, if she experienced migraines in the future, she
could come back to her own muscle memory of how to achieve positive
results on her own. Although it is nice when people come back to me
because they remember that I helped them in the past, I think it is better
for them to help themselves rather than depending on me or any other
therapist.
I asked this woman to explore the areas in her neck that generally
corresponded to the location of the X's in the drawings. She used her
fingers to search for areas of the muscles that were hard or painful. If an
X area was not hard or painful, she just ignored it. Then I had her rub the
hard or painful areas gently until she felt them relax or soften, or until the
pain diminished. Although I coached her about what to do and where to
put her hands, she treated herself with her own hands. By the end of the
session, her migraine had disappeared.
She was able to live without migraine headaches for four and a half
months. Then, when she did feel a migraine about to start, she again did
the Basic Exercise and massaged the trigger points. The symptoms passed
quickly and did not develop into a full-blown migraine.
129
EFTA00810131
I I
EFTA00810132
CHAPTER 6
Somatopsychological Problems
A few decades ago, medical doctors began diagnosing some health prob-
lems as "psychosomatic" (meaning that the mind causes problems in the
body). However, few psychiatrists and psychologists have investigated the
reverse of this: is there such a thing as a somatopsychological problem,
where physiology is seen to affect the mind?
The word psychology is derived from ancient Greek and means "study of
the mind." Today, defining a problem as "psychological" usually means
that a psychologist or psychiatrist first looks for the solution in the mind
or emotions of their clients, most often using a verbal approach to therapy.
In this traditional, older definition, there was no mention of the body.
When Freud started psychoanalysis to help people with their psychologi-
cal issues, his treatment modality was 100 percent verbal. He let people
talk without interruption, and he appeared to be listening. There was no
dialogue; he did not even make eye contact or look at his patients face-
to-face. People stayed in psychoanalysis for years, often going to sessions
several times a week.
Before being trained as a psychiatrist, someone must be a medical doc-
tor. Then they undergo their own process of psychoanalysis, which may
take several years. At one point there were very few trained psychiatrists,
and most people could not afford their treatment.
Psychologists created a new framework that differed from that of clas-
sical psychoanalysis. Clinical psychologists are educated over a period of
just a few years in a university program. To help their patients improve
their emotional states and change their behaviors, they rely on various
models of the human psyche, and they enter into a dialogue with their
patients using various verbal approaches. They are generally looking for
solutions to specific problems. Although not as expensive as years of
131
EFTA00810133
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
psychoanalysis, psychological treatment is still costly, requiring the time
of a trained professional in a one-on-one situation.
Some therapists offer group therapy, which is even less expensive, since
many patients share the cost of a session. However, that process is more
random, since everyone in the group, trained or untrained, gives input
into a session.
Today we are increasingly moving away from these modalities and
relying primarily on prescription drugs to change our behaviors and
emotional states. After an initial period of professional consultation to
select the medicine and dosage, patients can go for long periods of time
just taking their pills without needing to visit a health professional. In
spite of the fact that prescription drugs can be expensive, they are cost-
efficient when compared to ongoing, one-on-one therapeutic processes
with psychologists or psychiatrists. However, because more and more
people are taking these medications, this type of treatment means a grow-
ing expense for the individual as well as for insurance companies and the
national economy.
Because psychiatry and psychology started out with an emphasis
exclusively on the mind, and because of the current availability and
widespread use of prescription medicines, we might be missing out on
something else that can help with the health issues that these kinds of
treatments intend to address. Perhaps there is something at our fingertips
that has no cost or negative side effects.
In this chapter, we will look to the body to seek alternative and com-
plementary solutions to psychological and mental health issues. We will
investigate the possibility of regulating our own nervous systems and
our own emotional states and behaviors. We will explore how self-help
exercises and hands-on techniques can be perfectly safe and effective in
achieving positive changes.
Based on my clinical experiences over the last twelve years, I believe
that with a working understanding of the Polyvagal Theory many of us
can help ourselves by directly treating our own autonomic nervous sys-
tems. We may be able to overcome what have been previously considered
to be even intractable psychological and psychiatric issues.
132
EFTA00810134
Somatopsychological Problems
EMOTIONS AND THE AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM
Are we open, friendly, communicative, and cooperative? Are we shut
down, depressed, or apathetic? Or are we angry, aggressive, anxious, fear-
ful, or withdrawn? How do we react to other people when we are in these
different states?
The way other people respond to us is based on a combination of the
state they are in and the state we are in. Our emotions play out in the
interaction between the state of our autonomic nervous system and theirs.
As mammals, we are social animals, and we need others. We all face
challenges and uncertainty from time to time, and in order to improve
our chances for survival and fulfillment we are dependent on our interac-
tion with others—family, friends, neighbors, workmates, and our social
network. How we feel in a given situation or about a specific person is a
factor in our behavior. Does someone need our help? Do we enjoy sharing
time with her? Is she usually supportive? Are we willing to support her?
Do we work well together? Do we feel safe? Is there a chance for coopera-
tion, sharing, and friendship?
If we are single and dating someone, is there a chance for intimacy and
long-term bonding with the other person as a potential partner? If we are
married or in an ongoing relationship, do we have enough time together
when we are both socially engaged? The more good times we share, the
more we have to draw on when the going gets tough.
Proper function of the five social-engagement cranial nerves is central
to our communication and to bonding with others. These five nerves
facilitate our hearing, shape the sounds of our speech, and help us to
understand what other people are saying. Can we look at the other per-
son calmly and directly, or do we shut them out of our field of vision?
If we feel happy and safe, we will generally be able to carry on a normal
two-way conversation, listen to what is being said, and look at the other
person to exchange meaningful visual cues.
I consider the autonomic nervous system and emotional states as two
sides of the same coin. If we want to improve our emotional state in order
to help ourselves or others, we can accomplish this with physical actions
133
EFTA00810135
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
that improve the state of our autonomic nervous system and move us out
of a dorsal vagal or stress state into social engagement.
A SELF-REGULATING AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM
Social interaction with people who are in a state of balance and social
engagement is perhaps the most natural and helpful way to achieve self-
regulation. If we experience a problem, it is often enough to simply talk
about it with a friend. We might sit down and eat a meal, or enjoy a cup of
coffee or a beer together. We might sing, dance, or go for a walk together.
Another way to self-regulate our autonomic nervous system is to do
the exercises in this book. A host of other practices from cultures and
traditions around the world have been used for centuries with good effect:
meditation, tai chi, and yogic breathing (pranayama), to name a few.
When we meditate, we sit still, overcoming any impulse to fight or run.
We also learn to keep awake, avoiding the tendency to withdraw and dis-
sociate. When we do tai chi, we move slowly, simulating the movements
of a very relaxed state. Moving slowly also makes it easier to sense our
body and to be present in it.
If we can maintain a ventral vagal state, or at least return to it quickly
after stress or emotional withdrawal, we can achieve optimal health and
well-being. We can open the way to realizing our human potential, enjoy-
ing being with other people, and doing what we want with our lives.
A FRESH LOOK AT COMMON PSYCHOLOGICAL DIAGNOSES
I am neither a psychologist nor a psychiatrist; however, in forty-five years
as a body therapist, I have encountered many clients diagnosed by a psy-
chologist or psychiatrist. I have also taken many courses in these areas.
But I have learned the most from my clients who shared their case stories
with me.
In this chapter I will present some of these stories. The stories and
my commentary are purely anecdotal, based on my own experiences
from my practice over the years, seen in the light of my personal and
134
EFTA00810136
Somatopsychological Problems
limited understanding of the Polyvagal Theory and its implications. I
hope to inspire you—or perhaps provoke you—to take a fresh look at
some of these issues, whether you are a trained health care professional,
a consumer using health care professionals, or just someone trying to
get a better understanding of your own issues in order to help yourself
and/or loved ones.
I believe that there is an interrelationship between the mind, body, and
emotions. Issues as different as post-traumatic stress, anxiety, phobias,
and autism spectrum disorders have a somatic component, and almost
all cases of so-called psychological problems include a lack of flexibility
and resilience in the autonomic nervous system.
I have found it both interesting and efficacious to consider the somatic
component of what we generally term "psychological issues." A great deal
of healing potential becomes available when we consider the possibility
of identifying and treating the physical manifestations of the autonomic
nervous system at the outset ofpsychiatric and psychological treatments.
If there is indeed a unity of mind-body-emotion, it follows that we
might be able to help people with psychological diagnoses by starting
their treatment with body-therapy techniques, especially if these can
bring them out of a state of chronic stress or dorsal vagal activity and
toward greater flexibility of autonomic response.
Anxiety and Panic Attacks
Since the beginnings of psychiatry at the end of the nineteenth century,
there has been a strong focus on anxiety disorders.
Occasional anxiety is a normal part oflife. We might feel anxious when
faced with a problem at work, before taking a test, or when making an
important decision. But anxiety disorders involve more than temporary
worry or fear. For some of us, anxiety can become excessive, and while
we may realize this, we may have difficulty controlling it, so that anxiety
may negatively affect our day-to-day living.
For a person with an anxiety disorder, the anxiety does not go away
and can get worse over time. The feelings can interfere with daily
135
EFTA00810137
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
activities, such as job performance, schoolwork, and relationships. Mod-
ern surveys find that some form of anxiety disorder affects as many as 18
percent of people in the United States in a typical twelve-month period;
over the course of their lifetimes, 30 percent will experience some anxiety
disorder."
What we call "fear" is a psychological process involving nervous-system
activation in the face of a threatening situation. Fear can immobilize us
(via dorsal vagal activity) or mobilize us to fight or flight (from activity of
the sympathetic chain). Physical symptoms can include rapid heartbeat
(tachycardia), increased respiration, the release of high levels of stress
hormones, blushing, difficulty speaking, and sweating in the palms of
the hands, soles of the feet, and armpits.
Anxiety is similar to fear in terms of its physical manifestations. How-
ever, anxiety may not necessarily occur in response to an actual situation.
Something can remind us of an event in our past, or we may project our
imagination onto something that might happen in the future. In either
case, the threat is not happening now. Nonetheless, this emotional state
is real, and it exists in the body in present time.
When anxious, we find that we cannot get the concerns out of our
minds. If another person tells us there is nothing to worry about, it does
not quiet our minds; it can sometimes upset us even more. We may
respond, "Are you saying my feelings aren't real?"
Panic attacks are brief experiences of intense terror and apprehension.
They arise abruptly and usually peak in less than ten minutes, although
uncomfortable feelings can continue for several hours. Sometimes the
specific cause of a panic attack is not apparent. In other cases, we can
ascertain that it was triggered by general factors such as stress, fear, or
even excessive exercise.
People having a panic attack display recognizable signs of fear. Their
physical symptoms include trembling, shaking, confusion, dizziness, nau-
sea, and difficulty breathing. Their appearance looks strained, their skin is
pale, and they have increased sweating in the palms of their hands, soles
of their feet, and armpits. Their sweat has a characteristic odor.
Dogs and other mammals respond immediately to body smells arising
136
EFTA00810138
Somatopsychological Problems
from different emotional states. People also react instinctively to the smell
of fear in another person, even though they might not be conscious of
it. Many people try to mask olfactory signs of fear and anxiety by using
perfumes, deodorants, or foot powders. However, it is difficult to mask a
cold, clammy hand and a limp handshake when meeting someone.
Sometimes anxiety and panic attacks can be effectively addressed with
exercises or hands-on techniques that help bring us out of a state of sym-
pathetic nervous system or dorsal vagal activation into a state of social
engagement.
We sometimes refer to"the drop that made the pitcher overflow!" If an
anxious person uses the Basic Exercise regularly, they can minimize the
frequency and intensity of panic or anxiety attacks and, in some cases,
even prevent attacks. Doing the exercise regularly is like reducing the
amount of water in the pitcher, so that it can hold many more drops
without overflowing.
It is also important to be aware that anxiety can be a side effect of a
prescription drug, or indicate a substance-abuse problem, since medica-
tions and other drugs alter the state of the autonomic nervous system.
CASE STUDY: ANXIETY AND PANIC ATTACKS
I had a client who was bothered by anxiety and panic attacks that were
keeping her from acting on her desire to have a baby. She also experienced
pain in the right side of her abdomen.
The anxiety had started fifteen years earlier, when she was eighteen years
old and had a surgical operation to remove her ileocecal valve. Problems
with the ileocecal valve can be debilitating, and often occur with colitis,
abdominal pain, groin pain, bloating, unpleasant body odor, gas, disten-
sion of the belly, and breathing problems such as asthma and "cold lunge
The ileocecal valve controls the flow of chyme from the small intes-
tine into the large intestine. Chyme is the thick, semifluid mass of partly
digested food and secretions formed in the stomach and small intestine
during digestion. Normally, the ileocecal valve is closed most of the time,
only opening for short periods to allow the passage of chyme. When the
137
EFTA00810139
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
chyme reaches the large intestine, excess water is absorbed into the body,
and the remaining fiber and other wastes are packed together, formed
into feces, and eliminated.
Problems arise if the ileocecal valve does not open properly. Problems
also occur if it stays open too long, allowing chyme from the small intes-
tine to move unrestricted into the large intestine, or to move backwards
from the large into the small intestine.
In addition to anxiety symptoms, this client had occasional short peri-
ods of intense pain on the right side of her abdomen (where the ileocecal
valve is located or, in her case, had been located before her surgery). Her
doctor took her physical pains quite seriously and wanted to be sure that
the operation had gone properly. They did several MRIs and two lapa-
roscopic explorations, but found that everything looked all right; they
could find nothing to explain her pain.
When I asked why she had had the operation in the first place, she said
that it was because of pain. But years after the operation, she still had pain
in the same area. And despite her psychological pain and suffering, the
surgeon expressed no interest in her symptoms of anxiety, even though
these had appeared shortly after the operation. Also, no doctor had ever
evaluated the function of her autonomic nervous system.
The dorsal branch of the vagus nerve innervates most of the organs
of digestion, including the small intestine, the ileocecal valve, and the
ascending and transverse parts of the large intestine. It receives sensory
input from the organs themselves, and exerts motor control over their
functions.
The first thing that I did in my treatment was to evaluate the state of
her nervous system by looking at the back of her throat when she said,
"ah-ah-ah." The uvula pulled to one side (indicating dysfunction of the
pharyngeal branch of the ventral vagus nerve, described in Chapter 4). I
also did the Trap Squeeze Test (see Chapter 5) to check the level of ten-
sion in the two sides of her trapezius muscles. There was a dear difference
between her right and left sides.
My first objective was to help get the woman's autonomic nervous
system into a ventral vagal state. I instructed her on how to do the Basic
138
EFTA00810140
Somatopsychological Problems
Exercise. One of the great things about this exercise is that clients can do
it themselves. It took less than two minutes for me to teach her how to
do the Basic Exercise, and less than two minutes for her to do it. After
she did the exercise, she felt much better, and she reported that she no
longer felt anxious.
The muscular tension in her trapezius on the tense side had also
relaxed; when I squeezed the trapezius muscles, the muscular tension
was similar on both sides. To make doubly sure that there had been a
desirable change, I looked at the back of her throat and saw her uvula
lifting symmetrical on both sides.
I also performed an osteopathic visceral-massage technique to relax
tensions in the ileocecal valve, which usually eliminates pain immediately.
This client's surgeon assumed that the operation was a success, in terms
of its limited objective of removing her ileocecal valve. Until she consulted
me, however, no one considered the possibility that her operation had
been a traumatic experience that left her autonomic nervous system in a
state of dorsal vagal activity.
With appropriate treatment, this client made the transition out of a
debilitating state of anxiety and into the desirable state of social engage-
ment. I emphasized to her that she had made the positive change all by
herself, and told her that she could always do the exercise in the future if
she ever felt anxiety again.
Then I asked her to think about the difficulties triggered by her anxiety
in the past. Just thinking about my question was enough to put her into
a tailspin, into another state of anxiety. She lost her smile and held her
breath, and the skin on her face went pale. So I asked her to repeat the
Basic Exercise, and she again told me that she felt better. She looked more
relaxed, with good color in her face, and her breathing was deeper. She
also told me that she felt the change from anxiety to calm.
When I asked her once again to think about the trouble that the anxi-
ety had caused her, she was able to remain calm, and said she thought
she could manage the anxiety on her own in the future. I tested her auto-
nomic nervous system again and found that she was still in a state of
ventral vagal activity. She felt no pain.
139
EFTA00810141
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
These improvements came in a single session. The client thought it
was a miracle, after all the pain and anxiety that she had suffered before
her treatment with me. For me, although I was flattered to hear this, it
seemed a shame that the surgeon never examined her autonomic nervous
system and did not have a knowledge of visceral massage.
A year and a half later, I received an email from this woman. She
thanked me for my treatment and wrote that she no longer suffered from
anxiety. I suggested that she come for another session with me in order
to release any tension that might still remain in the scar tissue, since her
long-term improvement depended not only on improving the function
of the vagus nerve but on release of the trauma held in scar tissue locally.
Pain in the body can cause anxiety. A surgical operation, even though
it was consciously chosen, is still an assault on the integrity of the body
and, like any trauma, can leave its mark.
SOCIAL REGULATION OF ANXIETY STATES
Simple, everyday social interactions with supportive family, friends,
and colleagues can help regulate our psychological state. We should not
underestimate the importance of chatting, small talk, and simple social
situations like eating together, having a cup of coffee, or taking a walk
with someone. Good social relationships help our nervous systems to
self-regulate.
Like weeding a garden, if we have been victimized we should eliminate
or minimize contact with people who make us feel bad, and maximize
the time spent with people who support us and leave us feeling better.
When we have been traumatized and then become socially engaged
and leave treatment, we will encounter new situations in which we might
again feel threatened. At first we may need a therapist's support to be
restored to a state of social engagement, but the ideal outcome is having
the tools to be able to reach it ourselves. Each time we get back up, we
weaken the hold that the traumatic pattern has had on us; we can rest
and restore ourselves, making more energy available for us to meet the
next challenges in life.
140
EFTA00810142
Somatopsychological Problems
If we feel that our social network is inadequate, we may also experience
helpful and positive interactions by turning to health professionals such
as massage therapists, counselors, coaches, psychologists, or psychiatrists.
We may choose to consult a religious or spiritual teacher or leader. We
may also find solace in prayer, or read religious and spiritual texts to help
put things in perspective.
TREATING ANXIETY IN CHILDREN
Parents or other adults often tell children, "There is nothing to be afraid
of." In many cases, this reassurance from a loving parent or a trusted dose
friend is enough to make someone feel safe.
It would be even more effective, however, if the adult began by saying,
"I understand that you are feeling afraid?' This gives the child assurance
that they have been heard, and the knowledge that fear (like other emo-
tions) is a normal life experience.
The adult can then continue: "There is nothing to be afraid of. It will
be all right." Then a little hug helps, so that the child gets positive physical
contact and can feel the relaxation of the adult.
Phobias
Phobias are the single largest category of anxiety disorders, and they can
be incapacitating. A phobia is characterized by an experience of extreme
fear, with a specific trigger that sets off a state of anxiety or a panic attack.
Physiologically, fear arises from a reaction in the sympathetic division of
the autonomic nervous system.
Between 5 and 12 percent of the world's entire population is esti-
mated to suffer from phobic disorders.' Sufferers typically anticipate
terrifying consequences from encountering the object of their fear. They
want to flee, but they are immobilized. They may understand intellectu-
ally that their reaction of fear is irrational and out of proportion to the
potential danger, but they are still overwhelmed by their fear."
141
EFTA00810143
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Psychologists and therapists often focus on the object of fear, such
as heights (acrophobia), not having enough space (claustrophobia), or
spiders (arachnophobia). Their diagnoses focus on the triggers, which
may or may not be easily linked to specific biographical events. A pho-
bia might be caused by experiences from the past—for example, when
someone encountered a threatening person or a life-threatening situation.
A phobia can just as easily come from a virtual experience, in which the
person suffering the phobia did not actually experience the event—for
example, it might have come from someone else telling a story, or from
watching a scene in a movie.
A list of phobias in Wikipedia—which notes that this list is incomplete
and invites re to add to it—included twenty-three entries that begin
with the lette alone. This gives us an idea of how wide-ranging this
problem is, and gives the impression that almost anything can trigger the
same kind of anxiety response.
In order to better understand something, we tend to classify it and give
it a name. But rather than considering ablutophobia (fear of washing) as
basically different from acousticophobia (fear of noise), for example, it
may be more useful to move our focus away from the triggers and toward
an understanding of the physiological activity in the autonomic nervous
system in all cases of phobia.
You might be able to assist people with phobias if you can help them
return from a state of extreme fear to a state of social engagement using
the Basic Exercise (see Part Two). The effect can be similar to what parents
do when they help their children by hugging and holding them until the
child relaxes and feels safe again.
Whereas physical contact is natural between a parent and a child, in
a professional psychological intervention there should be no physical
contact. Therefore, a therapist needs to find another way to make the cli-
ent feel safe again, and directing a client to use the Basic Exercise might
be an ideal solution.
142
EFTA00810144
Somatopsychological Problems
Antisocial Behavior and Domestic Violence
Most people consider normal human behavior as an expression of posi-
tive social values. When people are not socially engaged, however, it is
often hard for others to understand their behavior.
Some people who commit aggressive acts do not have any idea that
there is anything wrong with them; they are convinced that the other
person caused or justifies their behavior. In other words, aggressive people
believe their actions to be a natural response: "He had it coming." They
might even consider their action as helping the other person: "It's the
only way that she will learn."
It may be difficult to understand why seemingly normal people com-
mit violent crimes. Observing their actions, we can conclude that they
lack empathy, but that does not tell us what is going on inside them.
What drives them? Is it territory, power, money, sex, jealousy, or maybe
alienation? Or is it just an unpleasant feeling that intensifies and then
explodes like a bomb into antisocial behavior? Many violent crimes are
not premeditated.
I heard an ex-convict in Denmark speak in a radio interview. He had
been in prison for most of his adult years for many different offenses,
including several bank robberies. After leaving prison, he joined a volun-
tary rehabilitation program that included yoga, meditation, and breath-
ing exercises, and felt that this program had given him control over his
emotions and his actions.
When the moderator asked him if he had any remorse about the effects
of his actions on his victims, he said no—not when he was committing
the crimes."In a war," he said,"the enemy soldiers have no faces." It wasn't
until he had stopped his criminal activities and had been in the rehabilita-
tion program that he started to think of the effects on the other people.
The perpetrator of a violent crime may or may not have a rational
motive that other people can understand, but still somehow they entered
a psychophysiological state of fight or flight that drove their actions.
143
EFTA00810145
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
"NICE GUY" COMMITS WAR CRIMES
A young man enlisted in the army to serve his country, and was trained to
fight. He also learned the rules of conduct expected for soldierly behavior
in a war zone, according to the Geneva Convention—not to torture, not
to kill civilians, not to rape, not to steal.
Almost all soldiers adhere to these rules, but occasionally something
else happens. On a routine patrol, this young soldier's best friend was
killed by an enemy sniper. Then a few more of his friends were killed
or wounded in an ambush by a roadside bomb. Suddenly, the soldier
snapped. He ran amok, gathered a few innocent civilians, tied them up,
raped one of the women in front of her family, and then massacred them
all. He was brought to trial by the army, found guilty, and sentenced to
a long prison term.
The soldier's parents and friends back home were shocked. They could
not believe that he was capable of doing anything like this: "He was such
a nice boy, and he came from a good family." "This was so unlike him."
"He had always been positive, helpful, and friendly when he was grow-
ing up." The term "intermittent explosive disorder" describes the occur-
rence of discrete episodes of aggression to other people or to property.
The individual may say that the explosive behavior was preceded by a
sense of tension or arousal. From the perspective of the autonomic ner-
vous system, intermittent explosive behavior is an example of extreme
mobilization with fear. Like anxiety, it results in uncontrollable fight or
flight behavior.
Individual acts of intermittent explosive behavior show up regularly
on the evening news—shooting children and teachers at an elementary
school, blowing up a church, or suicide bombings. We watch the reports,
we are fascinated by the events, and we think to ourselves that we cannot
understand how someone could do something like that to other people.
The individual's behavior does not seem justified; the violent episodes
appear to be grossly out of proportion to any provocation. If you ask
the person why they committed the act, they may not be able to give an
answer or, if they do, it will not make sense to anyone else. They might
144
EFTA00810146
Somatopsychological Problems
say that they felt a 5( c of relief immediately afterward. However, feelings
of relief are usualk d v, hen the level of tension rises again, subsequent
episodes can follow.
CASE STUDY: ONGOING DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
Domestic violence is quite different than facing the enemy in a war, or
being the victim of random violence in the street. Some people become
victims of domestic violence simply when a love relationship goes sour.
Let's shift our focus from the perpetrator of violence to the victim. A
man and woman are attracted to each other, and they spend more time
together; they eventually move in together and start a family. She feels
safe with him; she might even feel that he is her protector. Then one day,
he suddenly loses his temper and hits her. She is surprised and shocked,
and starts to cry.
When things settle down, he gives her a hug and says he is sorry. She
asks him to promise that he will never do it again, and he promises. After
a while, they put the incident behind them. At first she is wary, but he
seems to have settled down. Their life together goes on as before—almost.
One day, out of the blue, he gets angry and hits her again. She is not
only in physical pain, she also feels threatened. When his anger fades, he
says he regrets it. Again, they kiss and make up, but as this cycle repeats
itself, at some point she moves from feeling safe to living in constant
fear. He is physically stronger, so she cannot win in a physical fight. She
sometimes fantasizes about hitting him with a frying pan while he sleeps.
She considers taking the children and running away. But where would
she go? Where would she live? How could she support herself and her
children? What would other people say? She feels trapped, and cannot see
any viable choices. Reluctantly, she stays. But the joy that she originally felt
from being with him at the start of their relationship is dead. He notices
that she has cooled to him emotionally, which upsets him even further:
"What is wrong with you?"
After a few more incidents, she loses any will to fight back or run away.
She just endures, and dissociates from her body when she is attacked, as if
145
EFTA00810147
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
she does not care what is happening to her. She may even see herself from
a distance when she is being hit. She is just hoping that this will soon be
over. But eventually, she even stops hoping.
This woman has made a long, unwanted journey from love (social
engagement) to mobilization with fear (fighting back and/or running
away) to immobilization with fear. She has succumbed to a state that
we can describe as "freeze," with the accompanying emotions of apathy,
detachment, and hopelessness. Perhaps giving in and being passive when
he attacked her helped her to survive; she might have been even more
injured if she had fought back, or if she ran away and he came after her.
She is too ashamed to tell other people, so she suffers alone. The
responses of others may often sound like condemnation: "If it was so
terrible, why didn't you run away?""Why didn't you call me? I would have
helped you:'"How could you let him continue to do this to you?""If you
were so stupid and did not do anything, it's your own fault." These com-
ments seem unfair when what she needs is a feeling of being understood,
a feeling of safety and support.
Other people are unlikely to understand that her nervous system had
been hammered down the evolutionary scale from social engagement
to stress and finally to withdrawal and apathy. It was her traumatized
nervous system that contributed to her behavior. People assumed that
she was the same person they knew before—a rational, well-functioning,
and socially engaged person. People can be quick to judge without unde-
rstanding the instinctive, emotional mechanisms behind such changes.
As a first step, a woman who has been abused needs to find a safe
environment where she is free from further abuse. The events in the past
have already occurred, and we cannot change them, but we can change
the way that we react to them emotionally.
Is it possible to recover from these abuses and return to a normal
life? By the time that the woman I've just described came to me for her
first session, she was already out of the relationship. The first thing I did
was to test the function of the ventral branch of her vagus nerve. Not
surprisingly, I found her in a state of dorsal vagal activity. Near the end
of the first treatment, I tested her again and found that she had come
146
EFTA00810148
Somatopsychological Problems
up to a state of social engagement. Before ending the session, I did some
additional work on her neck and back, and she told me that she felt
much better.
However, when she returned for her next session two weeks later, she
was back in a state of pain, confusion, withdrawal, and apathy. Again
she responded positively to the session, and came back up to a level of
social engagement. She returned several more times. Each time she left
my office, she had come up to social engagement, and the positive effects
lasted longer and longer. Over time, my treatments were enough to bring
her out of fear, sadness, and despair. Every time that she got back to a
state of social engagement, she was less affected by the more difficult
emotional states. When a person is socially engaged even some of the
time, their interaction with others can be enough to begin to regulate
their own nervous system.
This client came to me before I had developed and tested the Basic
Exercise. After a few sessions, I taught her how to release the tension at
the back of her neck with the Neuro-Fascial Release Technique described
in Part Two. Rather than needing to come to me for a session each time,
she could use the technique to help regulate herself whenever she felt
afraid, angry, or powerless.
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE: NOT JUST MEN BEATING WIVES
Men can be beaten by their wives, children beaten by their parents, and
parents beaten by their children. Although individuals seldom talk about
having been sexually victimized or physically abused, domestic violence
is a more serious problem than many people realize, since most people
do not readily admit to being a victim of domestic violence.
When I discuss domestic violence in front of a class, although they
do not say anything, I can see strong emotional reactions in the faces of
many women. They may have experienced violent behavior from a father
who hit them to make a point about how they should behave, or a date
who had expectations about sex that they did not fulfill, or a husband
over a disagreement about the family budget. It might also be that these
147
EFTA00810149
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
women were thinking about a girlfriend, daughter, mother, or someone
else close to them who was a victim of domestic violence.
How widespread is the problem of domestic violence, interpersonal
violence, and stalking?
The US government's Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) conducts an ongoing National Intimate Partner and Sexual Vio-
lence Survey.69 They have found interpersonal violence, sexual violence,
and stalking to be pervasive in the United States. Intimate partner vio-
lence occurs between two people in a close relationship, including cur-
rent and former spouses as well as dating partners. The violence tracked
included hurting or trying to hurt a partner by hitting, kicking, or other
kinds of physical force. The frequency of such violence exists along a
continuum from a single episode to ongoing battering.
The CDC reports the following in a report titled Intimate Partner
Violence in the United States-201e°
• Nearly one in five women (18%) and one in seventy-one men
(1.4%) have been raped in their lifetime.
• One in four women (25%) and one in seven men (14%) have
been the victim of "severe" physical violence by an intimate
partner.
• One in six women (17%) and one in nineteen men (5%) have
been stalked during their lifetime.
• Women who experienced physical violence by an intimate part-
ner, or rape or stalking by any perpetrator, in their lifetimes were
more likely than women who did not experience these to have
asthma, diabetes, and irritable bowel syndrome.
Men and women who experienced these forms of violence were
more likely to report frequent headaches, chronic pain, difficulty
sleeping, activity limitations, poor physical health, and poor men-
tal health than men and women who did not experience them.
It should be noted that statistics such as these will always underest{tnate
the problem because many victims feel ashamed or threatened, and often
148
EFTA00810150
Somatopsychological Problems
they do not report such violence to police or health care practitioners, or
even talk about it to friends or family.
The majority of this victimization starts early in life. Often intimate-
partner violence starts with emotional abuse, and can progress to physi-
cal abuse, sexual assault, or a mixture of both. The longer the violence
continues, the more serious are the psychological effects.
The traumatic experiences have both short-term and long-term con-
sequences. Symptoms may include flashbacks, panic attacks, and trouble
sleeping. Victims are often left with low self-esteem, can have a hard time
trusting others, and experience difficulties being in relationships. The
anger, fear, withdrawal, and helplessness that victims feel may lead to
eating disorders, symptoms arising from activity of the dorsal circuit
of the vagus nerve, and suicidal thoughts. Intimate-partner violence is
linked to harmful health behaviors when victims try to cope with their
trauma in unhealthy ways such as smoking, drinking, taking drugs, or
having risky sex.
When a person is being violated, their nervous system is often in a
state of shock or shutdown in which they are vulnerable to hypnotic
suggestions, i.e., whatever is said to them by their abuser is fully accepted
without critical evaluation. Sometimes victims of abuse have also been
threatened that "If you ever tell anyone about this, I will kill you:'
This can make it difficult or even impossible to get a victim to talk
about what happened. A therapist who suspects that this is the case can
ask "Just answer me, yes or no—has anyone ever threatened to harm you
if you speak about this?" If they say "yes:' the therapist may have unlocked
the door, if the patient is no longer under the compulsion to refrain from
talking about what happened.
BRAIN CHANGES FROM DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
With traumatized victims as well as perpetrators, there are actual changes
in the structures and function of their brains, especially in the amygdala.
The amygdala lies in the temporal lobe, in the midbrain. It is involved in
how we respond emotionally to events and information, and contributes
149
EFTA00810151
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
to determining how we behave when faced with potential risks. On scans,
the amygdala shows increased activity during negative emotional experi-
ences, and when we endure repeated or prolonged periods of stress, our
amygdala becomes enlarged. An enlarged amygdala can make it easier to
go into a state of stress or shutdown."
The hippocampus is in temporal lobes next to the amygdala, and it
is where we store our non rel atic memories. As the amygdala enlarges,
the hippocampus shrinks from continued exposure to threatening and
dangerous experiences."
MOVING OUT OF THE PAST AND RECONNECTING
TO FUTURE DREAMS
If we have suffered a trauma, we will recover more quickly if we can
remember our life dreams, mission, and/or goals, which give meaning
to our lives.
I asked my client who had been domestically abused, "What is the
dream that you had for your life, which you have forgotten? What do
you want to do?" She said that she wanted to make a good life for herself
and her son. In this way she began to look forward to creating her future
rather than fixating on what happened in the past.
My clinical experience is that the victim of a single traumatic experi-
ence can usually return to a normal state quickly. By contrast, the victim
of domestic violence may have suffered a series of assaults, both physical
and psychological, over a long period of time, and is therefore less likely
to bounce back quickly.
A successful treatment outcome requires lifting the patient back up
to the level of social engagement again and again until they are stable
enough to be self-regulating and function normally. Recovering their
previous dreams is helpful in this process.
150
EFTA00810152
Somatopsychological Problems
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), sometimes referred to as post-
traumatic stress syndrome (PTSS), has become a common diagnosis. With
the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, we have become increasingly aware of
the enormous number of veterans afflicted with post-traumatic stress.
TRAUMA AND THE AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM
Ideally, if we have a resilient autonomic nervous system, we rebound to
a state of social engagement after a period of time following a traumatic
event. Unfortunately, many people do not bounce back.
Everyone experiences events that are intense, shocking, and distress-
ing, but we react differently to similar events. Some of us are able to get
over them quickly, return to a state of balance, equilibrium, and social
engagement, and get on with our lives. Others are changed by what hap-
pened, and the effects can be long-lasting, draining, and even incapacitatU
ing. The negative consequences can even last for the rest of the person's
life. If a person is locked into a state of spinal sympathetic activity,"post-
traumatic stress" is an accurate description.
However, after a trauma, not everyone is left in a state of chronic stress.
Many people are actually left in a state of dorsal vagal activity with depres-
sive behavior, and describing their condition as "post-traumatic stress"
is inaccurate, confusing, and leads to ineffective treatments. It would be
more accurate to talk about two different outcomes after a trauma: a
chronic, post-traumatic, spinal sympathetic activation state (the fight-or-
flight stress response), or a post-traumatic state of chronic dorsal vagal
activity (withdrawal or shutdown).
Sometimes a person with PTSD/PTSS flip-flops between these two
states, both of which prevent a state of social engagement. The problem
for many soldiers returning home with a diagnosis of post-traumatic
stress is that often the people treating them have not found effective treat-
ments. Sadly, many men and women who have served their country in
battle therefore wind up socially isolated, and an alarmingly high number
of them commit suicide.
151
EFTA00810153
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
I find that simply using the term "PTSD" is not specific enough, is
misleading, and often causes confusion. The label "post-traumatic stress"
describes an ongoing physical and emotional reaction to an event that
happened sometime in the past. It does not indicate the nature of the
problems that are currently resulting from that trauma; it just acknowl-
edges that something traumatic occurred and that the repercussions are
ongoing.
Many patients who come to my clinic with a diagnosis of post-
traumatic stress are not stressed in their nervous system (via spinal
sympathetic chain activation) but are actually in a chronic dorsal vagal
state. They are not mobilized into fight or flight but immobilized into
fear, apathy, and hopelessness. Trying to treat them as if they are stressed
can therefore be confusing and counterproductive.
We get a clearer and more useful picture by differentiating between
post-traumatic stress and post-traumatic shutdown. Are the patient's
behaviors and symptoms a sign of sympathetic nervous system activ-
ity, or of dorsal branch activity? Sympathetic chain activity results in
what we usually describe as "stressibehaviors, while dorsal vagal activity
leaves a person withdrawn and exhibiting depressive behavior. Shutdown
to any degree occurs from a surge of activity in the dorsal (old) vagus
branch. Mammals share this shutdown reaction with all the other phyla
and almost all vertebrates, all the way down the evolutionary ladder to
fish without jaws such as lampreys.
When treating post-traumatic stress, therapists tend to focus on the
trauma itself rather than the psychophysiological fixation that followed
the event. Recalling the experience and telling someone else about it is
certainly one way to ease post-traumatic stress, but it is not the only way,
and it can often backfire, as the person can become re-traumatized by
recounting it. In many cases, it is easier and more effective for a therapist
to bypass recall of the event, and work with exercises or hands-on trea-
tments to restore a state of social engagement.
A project in Denmark involved a group of therapists who treated vic-
tims of trauma from the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. The therapists
included traditional psychologists, a craniosacral therapist, and body
152
EFTA00810154
Somatopsychological Problems
therapists using various modalities. All of the subjects received the same
number of sessions, which included both verbal and nonverbal therapies.
Some started with craniosacral therapy, followed by other body therapies,
and others started with more traditional, verbal forms of therapy.
Looking back on the results, the therapists noticed that the subjects
who started with the nonverbal craniosacral therapy had better results
than the subjects who started by talking about what they had experienced.
One of the psychologists in the group, Marc Levin, speculated that when
people felt safe and relaxed after the body therapy, they felt more robust
and therefore more open when they started to talk about what they had
experienced. By contrast, when people talked about their experiences first,
it seemed harder for them to let go of it; some of them may have actually
restimulated the trauma."
When people recall traumatic events in a therapy session, they may
go into a hypnotic trance and restimulate the emotional state from that
event. If the therapist makes a comment such as, "That was terrible," the
remark can be imprinted on top of the person's own experience, so that it
is no longer only the client's own belief. Now there is another person—an
authority figure—who agrees with the grievance, and this may reinforce
its effect. It is thus possible for people to leave their session in worse shape
than when they came in.
DORSAL BRANCH ACTIVITY AND PTSD
The goal of my treatments for people with a diagnosis of PTSD is to lift
them out of a state of activity in their spinal sympathetic circuit or dorsal
vagal nerve, and to bring them into the state of social engagement. The
next challenge is to help them stay socially engaged by repeating this
whenever necessary.
It's incorrect to assume that activity of the dorsal branch is a purely
psy-chological issue to be treated verbally; it is more aptly termed a psy-
chophysiological state. Medical doctors often treat mental manifestations
of dorsal branch activity biochemically, with antidepressant medications,
many of which work as stimulants and create an aroused state in the
153
EFTA00810155
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
nervous system. This helps people to mobilize generally, but it does not
bring about desirable social behaviors, or states of happiness or joy.
A new understanding of stress and the role of the vagus nerve branches
can be a great help in treating many psychiatric and psychological dis-
orders. Physiological states driven by activation of visceral organs through
the dorsal vagal branch result in a tremendous drain of resources and loss
of quality of life—not only for the individuals themselves, their families,
and the people around them, but through their economic impact on
society in the treatment of these psychological issues. I believe that it is
possible to bring a depressed person up to the highest level of autonomic
function with the simple and cost-free hands-on techniques and exercises
described in this book.
RESTORING FUNCTION AFTER A TRAUMATIC EVENT
The autonomic nervous system normally has an inherent capacity to
self-regulate. If we feel safe in both our environment and our body, then
it is natural to be socially engaged—to share and be at ease with others.
Similarly, we can be immobilized without fear in order to rest, rebuild
the body, and reproduce.
Social interaction with other people where we feel safe often restores
our ability to return from stress or shutdown to social engagement.
However, this does not always happen. The actual situation may be over;
we have stopped running or fighting, and we are now free of the threat
or danger—but our nervous system can become stuck in the past, and
remain in a state of fight, flight, or,7reez41(dissociation). Post-traumatic
stress occurs when the survival responses of fight, flight, or freeze have
been aroused but not fully discharged.
When our nervous system is deregulated, we dissociate. We lose contact
with our body, with other people, or with the here and now. We therefore
become ineffective and vulnerable. Many commonly used phrases describe
this;"out of touch,""not with it,"“beside myself." In terms of the nervous
system, we have lost function in the ventral branch of the vagus nerve.
This can be observed by the vagal-function testing described in Chapter 4.
154
EFTA00810156
Somatopsychological Problems
The trick for restoring self-regulating vagal function is to do some-
thing to get ourselves grounded again, to come back to our senses, be
in our body, and return to the here and now. Some of us are helped by
meditation, some by prayer, others by going fishing or getting away to a
quiet place alone to be able to think things through.
In Part Two of this book, I present some exercises that help most
people to get back in touch with themselves again by restoring ventral
vagal function within a few minutes. I also present a hands-on technique
called the Neuro-Fascial Release Technique by which one person can help
another to restore their vagal function.
Some of us might seek the assistance of a therapist, coach, or teacher.
The important thing is not what these health care professionals call their
method, or what positive results they claim they can deliver, but whether
or not their methods actually work for us. If tests showed that the ventral
vagus nerve was dysfunctional before the intervention, then the same tests
should show that the ventral vagus nerve has become functional after the
intervention is applied.
If we are trying to restore the regulation of our nervous system with
social interaction, we must be sure that the people with whom we choose
to interact are themselves well functioning. A simple way of evaluating
this is to ask ourselves, "When I am with them, do I feel better afterward?"
We have all had experiences of being with people and feeling the worse
for it.
Once we are balanced and self-regulating again, we should find that we
have greater resilience when we are with the same people who brought us
down before. Ideally, we will be less affected by them, or at least recover
more quickly. Although we can sometimes cut down on the amount of
time that we spend with people who upset us, we cannot always avoid
them, so it is helpful to be able to respond more resiliently.
It is also important to be patient. Helping ourselves successfully even
once will make it easier the next time. Being alive entails meeting a con-
stant succession of challenges, threats, and dangers, and regulation is
an ongoing process of successfully addressing the next difficulty when
it arises. We will have an easier time meeting a new challenge if we can
155
EFTA00810157
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
stay grounded, do not become upset, and maintain or quickly recover a
well-functioning ventral branch of the vagus nerve.
Depression and the Autonomic Nervous System
Depression continues to be the leading cause of medical disability in the
United States and Canada, accounting for nearly 10 percent of all medical
disability." In recent years, medical doctors have been prescribing more
and more antidepressants.% In Denmark, where I live, almost 8.3 percent
of the population takes antidepressants.'6 The most common form of
treatment of depression is antidepressant medications, which are cur-
rently ranked third among prescription drugs in the United States, with
global sales of more than $9.8 billion in 2013."
People with a diagnosis of depression, or people in a depressed state,
typically lose interest in activities that once were pleasurable. They experi-
ence loss of appetite, overeating, or other digestive problems. They have
reduced energy, and become inactive, introverted, apathetic, helpless, and
asocial. They can feel sad, anxious, empty, hopeless, worthless, guilty, irri-
table, ashamed, or restless. They may experience lethargy, lack of energy,
and a lack of goal-oriented activity. They can have problems concentrat-
ing, remembering details, or making decisions, and are often plagued
by the aches and pains of fibromyalgia. They may contemplate, attempt,
or actually commit suicide. These can all be symptoms of activity in the
dorsal branch of the vagus nerve.
If we consult with a doctor because we are not feeling good, the doctor
might ask questions and ascertain from our responses that we are depressed
or stressed. Rather than considering the possibility that the condition is
transient, the doctor assumes that it is semipermanent, and we are put on
medication. Often there is a period of adjusting the dose until we feel better.
We may then stay on the medicine for months or even years.
Many people who come to me wish to stop taking their medication.
Although I support them in this desire, I tell them to only do so in con-
sultation with the physician who prescribed it. Also, I recommend looking
on the internet to learn about the negative side effects of the medicine,
156
EFTA00810158
Somatopsychological Problems
and to find out whatever information is available about withdrawal symp-
toms that might occur if they stop taking it.
A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association
showed that antidepressant prescriptions work no better than placebos
in mild cases of depression." It is well known that these medicines often
have negative side effects. Yet antidepressants are still the most commonly
consumed class of medication in the U.S., with 270 million prescriptions
written for them each year."
This raises some obvious questions: Why are doctors prescribing so
many antidepressants? Could we benefit by taking a new approach? I
believe the underlying problem is a lack of understanding of the nature
of the autonomic nervous system, which should normally be flexible,
resilient and only temporarily affected by stressors. The Polyvagal Theory
may point the way to this new approach.
The medical literature has generally focused on the physiology of
chronic stress, with less attention given to the physiology underlying
depression. When people come to my clink with a diagnosis of depres-
sion from a psychologist or psychiatrist, or when they exhibit depressive
behavior, I find that that their problem is usually accompanied by a state
of activity in the dorsal branch of their vagus nerve.
Prior to the Polyvagal Theory, dorsal vagal issues lacked a physiologi-
cal model in terms of the nervous system, and perhaps that is why it has
been so difficult to find safe, effective medicine-free treatments for condi-
tions such as depression. Stephen Porges's Polyvagal Theory focuses on
the relationships of the autonomic nervous system, the emotions, and our
behavior, and his work has awakened a growing interest in applications
of these understandings by psychologists, psychiatrists, and an array of
gifted, insightful trauma therapists.
Bipolar Disorder
Bipolar disorder is a behavioral pattern marked by periods of height-
ened activity, elation, and euphoria ("mania"), alternating with periods
of depressive behavior.
157
EFTA00810159
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Mania is characterized by abnormally elevated energy levels and an
elated, jubilant, euphoric mood. Periods of mania are followed by periods
of activity of the dorsal branch of the vagus nerve, experienced as low
energy. In some people, these mood swings are separated by periods of
"normal" feelings; in other individuals, states of dorsal branch activity
and mania alternate with no respite. Such people are often dissociated
from sensing their body, and can suffer from psychotic symptoms such
as delusions and hallucinations. Bipolar issues affect up to 4 percent of
the U.S. population.s°
From the perspective of the Polyvagal Theory, the manic phase can be
seen as activation of the spinal sympathetic chain. In a manic state, the
person expends great amounts of energy and takes many actions without
necessarily enjoying or being satisfied by them.
In my clinic, many clients tell me that they have been given a diagnosis
by a professional psychologist or psychiatrist. I am not trained or qualified
to make psychological or psychiatric diagnoses; my observations are
anecdotal, based on treatment of these clients. It seems remarkable that
the same approach—techniques for establishing social engagement—can
help so many people with different psychological or psychiatric diagnoses,
including bipolar disorder.
CASE STUDY: BIPOLAR DISORDER
A few years ago, a woman in her fifties came to me for craniosacral
therapy. I asked her what she wanted in terms of positive change. She said
that she had heard good reports about our form of craniosacral therapy,
and "wanted to relax more."
She went on to say that she had a diagnosis of bipolar disorder and
had been in and out of the psychiatric hospital regularly over the last
twenty years. She said that she experienced periods of lethargy followed
by periods of hectic activity.
In Denmark some hospitals have a somewhat flexible system of psychi-
atric care. After patients are admitted and have been treated for a while,
they can ask the psychiatrist to be discharged when they feel that they can
158
EFTA00810160
Somatopsychological Problems
cope, and later can be re-admitted when they feel that is needed. This cli-
ent told me that when she was not in a depressed state, she felt compelled
to action, to the point of being frantic to get everything done. Then, when
she collapsed into depression, she would have herself hospitalized.
When this woman told me her history, I could read in her body lan-
guage that she was dissociated, and this was confirmed by her words.
Rather than being grounded and at ease in her body, she said she felt as
if she were looking at her life from the outside as it passed in front of her.
Many women experience postpartum (after childbirth) depression,
and this woman's bipolar states had started shortly after the birth of her
son. It's not unusual for postpartum depression to provoke a crisis in
a woman's marriage as well as in herself; because of the wife's dorsal
branch-induced shutdown/depression, the husband might feel that she
is no longer the same woman he fell in love with. This particular couple's
life took an unfortunate turn for the worse, as the birth of their baby did
not bring them the joy they had dreamed of.
Postpartum depression can be exacerbated if the birth was difficult,
especially if it resulted in a cesarean section. Even when a C-section is
necessary for medical reasons to save the life of the child or mother, it
is still a shock for the woman's body, and leaves scar tissue not only in
the muscles of the abdomen but also in the uterus. It can take years for
a woman to get over postpartum depression and, unfortunately, some
women never do.
I told this woman that I was not qualified to treat her psychiatric con-
dition, but that I would try to help her relax by making her autonomic
nervous system more flexible. As a body therapist, I am careful not to
imply that I can successfully treat any psychiatric problem. If a patient
has a psychiatric diagnosis and I do not feel totally comfortable treating
them, I sometimes decide not to. If you are a therapist and you are ever
in doubt in such a case, you can always ask the client to consult with their
own psychiatrist or psychologist to determine whether there is any reason
that you should not treat them.
I found that this client's first two cervical vertebrae were rotated, and
that she might benefit if we could improve the function of the ventral
159
EFTA00810161
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
branch of her vagus nerve. I showed her how to do the Basic Exercise to
improve the position of these vertebrae. Afterwards, when I checked her
again, the first two vertebrae ofher neck were less rotated, and her ventral
vagus nerve was functional.
A week later, when the woman came back for her next session, she
seemed like another person; she was calm and centered. I checked her
vagal function and the position of her first two vertebrae. These were
still good; the effects of the first treatment had held. She told me that
she now had good energy and was getting things done, but that she did
them calmly. She said that she felt confident and ready to get on with her
life again.
I felt that we had solved the issue in her nervous system. She had
been bipolar, moving back and forth between agitated states of stress
and collapsed states of dorsal vagal withdrawal, without finding her way
into social engagement. Now that she was coming from a state of social
engagement, she felt robust, and her nervous system was flexible. She
could be stressed or shut down temporarily, and return to social engage-
ment when the challenge passed.
I told her that she was welcome to come back if she thought that she
needed help again. I advised her to go to a good psychologist, and sug-
gested that she could use help to manage her relationships in a new way
and structure her plans for her future.
By now, her son had grown up; he was attending school and living on
his own. My client expressed regret over missing much of the experience
of being a mother because she had spent so much time in the psychiatric
hospital. Over the twenty years since giving birth, she had also missed
opportunities for an education, a career, and a meaningful job. She was
also living with a man who had fit into her life as long as she was manic-
depressive, but their relationship no longer worked for her.
She was not sad, however, but quietly optimistic. She was neither
manic nor depressed when she assessed her situation; she was calm and
spoke in a clear voice as she expressed her determination to make a good,
meaningful life for herself.
160
EFTA00810162
Somatopsychological Problems
ADHD and Hyperactivity
In addition to chronic stimulation of the sympathetic nervous system in
children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), I believe
that there may be another physical cause.
I had five clients—all boys with ADHD—during the same period of
time, and noticed that all five had hiatal hernias,' This led me to speculate
that the reason they continually moved from one position to another was
to change the level of tension in their respiratory diaphragm. After a few
seconds in the new position, that would also become uncomfortable, so
they needed to move again.
I was able to ease their symptoms with a combination of two tech-
niques. The Basic Exercise addressed a dysfunction in the vagus nerve,
allowing the upper third of the esophagus to relax. This then allowed
the hiatal hernia technique to gently stretch the esophagus so that the
stomach could free itself from the respiratory diaphragm and drop to its
normal position.
Many people are diagnosed by a psychologist or psychiatrist without
any consideration that their problems might arise from a dysfunction of
their autonomic nervous system. It is my experience that bringing the
person into a ventral vagal state often causes their problems to diminish
or disappear.
161
EFTA00810163
I I
EFTA00810164
CHAPTER 7
Autism Spectrum Disorders
The term autism spectrum disorders (ASD) includes autism, Asperger's
syndrome, and other conditions. (ADHD is not defined as an autism spec-
trum disorder.) ASD encompasses a wide range of symptoms, levels of
impairment, and disabilities that can appear in children or adults. These
symptoms, assumed to be developmental brain disorders, can cause sig-
nificant social, behavioral, and communication challenges. However, there
are no neural tests for these disorders.
There are many different categories of autism. The disorders affect
each person in a unique way, and range from very mild to severe. People
with autism spectrum disorders share some of the same symptoms, and
seem to handle information in their brain differently than other people
do. The exact causes of autism spectrum disorders are unknown. Research
suggests that both genes and environment play important roles.
The evidence pointing to genes is based in part on the observation that
if one identical twin is autistic, there is a good chance that the other twin
will be as well. However, despite spending hundreds of millions of dollars,
researchers have yet to identify which genes may be defective in cases of
autism. Ideally, this will be determined soon, but at present there is no
promising cure for autism spectrum disorder based on genetic research.
Autism-spectrum diagnoses are based primarily on psychologists'
observations of behavior. However, the people doing the testing do not
usually consider the physiological signs of the social-engagement portion
of the autonomic nervous system. But the autonomic nervous system in
part determines the emotional state, and the emotional state is a contrib-
uting factor in determining behaviorl believe that if we change a person's
emotional state, we can change their behavior.
Might some cases of autism spectrum disorder be understood as
manifestations of autonomic nervous system disorder? These individuals
163
EFTA00810165
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
are often in a chronic state of either fight-or-flight or dorsal vagal
withdrawal. Sometimes, for no apparent reason, they shift suddenly
from one of these states to another, catching caretakers off guard. Their
behavior is frequently unpredictable and inappropriate for the situation.
Based on my clinical experience, I suggest that autism-spectrum tests
should include evaluation of the function of their ventral vagus nerve.
If it shows dysfunction, further research could tell whether bringing the
patient into a state of social engagement by optimizing the function of
this nerve brings about positive changes in their behavior. It is my belief
that this would be the case.
HOW PREVALENT IS AUTISM?
The increasing number of individuals diagnosed with autism spectrum
disorders makes this the most rapidly growing developmental disability,
with a 10- to 17-percent annual increase in the United States. About one
in sixty-eight children have been identified with ASD, according to esti-
mates from the CDC's Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitor-
ing Network (ADDM)." According to other estimates, autism-spectrum
disorders affect one out of ninety children."
The economic costs of autism are also enormous, not only for the
individual families but also for society as a whole, as demands for autism-
related health care and other services skyrocket. The cost of autism over
an average lifespan is $2.4 million per individual in the United States,"
for an annual total of $20 billion." Other estimates of the cost of support-
ing children with autism in the U.S. are $61-66 billion a year; for autistic
adults, these costs have been estimated at $175-196 billion a year.d6
More importantly, there is also a human loss to our society. Among
the personal costs of autism is the heavy emotional toll it exacts on
the parents, which cannot be calculated in dollars. Before the child
was born, the parents had dreams and hopes of having a family like
other families, with well-functioning children; often autistic individu-
als cannot hold a job and contribute to the workforce, or can have
difficulty in parenting the next generation. Whatever their goals may
164
EFTA00810166
Autism Spectrum Disorders
have been before, the family must now prioritize caring for their child
in a new way.
AUTISM AND THE AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM
Activity of the spinal sympathetic chain, and/or dorsal vagal activity,
can be physiological characteristics of the nervous system of people
with various diagnoses on the autism spectrum. They might also have a
physical issue arising from a dysfunction in their organs.
Their family or caregivers might notice that people with autism some-
times react with fear and panic even with no apparent reason. They may
be hypersensitive, reacting to a stimulus in the environment that other
people do not notice, or to something that reminds them of something
in their past—or they might simply be imagining something dangerous.
Other people looking at their behavior objectively find that these reac-
tions are unfounded and feel there is nothing to be upset about.
Sometimes people on the autism spectrum are trapped in states of
fight-or-flight or shutdown, or shift between these two states. They may
be in a state of shutdown, folded into themselves and apathetic one
moment, then suddenly extroverted, afraid, or aggressive in the next. To
others who do not understand their behavior, they react in seemingly
strange, unpredictable ways that often make them seem asocial in their
behavior. Many parents or caregivers are confused and surprised by these
sudden shifts in behavior because they are not aware of anything that
could be causing the emotional changes.
Psychological testing for autism evaluates behavior and defines
different kinds of autism, but does not consider the underlying
physiological factors in terms of Porges's new interpretation of the
function of the autonomic nervous system. As a result, treatments have
mostly focused on training the parents to try to adapt their behavior
to fit the special needs of their child, rather than improving the child's
condition so that they do not have these special needs.
The Polyvagal Theory presents a new biobehavioral model linking
autistic behavior to specific physiological states of the autonomic nervous
165
EFTA00810167
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
system. This allows us the possibility to develop more effective strategies
for treating autism.
When we see that many of these individuals are being affected by
their spinal sympathetic chain or dorsal vagal activity, or are vacillating
between the two, we can simply say that they are not socially engaged.
Then we can focus on using or developing interventions that help them
to be socially engaged and improve the function of the ventral branch of
their vagus nerve and the other four associated cranial nerves—resulting
in more social behaviors.
Stephen Porges chose to work with autistic children, and has had suc-
cess in improving the behavior of many of them. He interpreted this as
a verification that there was some validity to the model of the nervous
system presented in the Polyvagal Theory. I was inspired by his work and
have also been treating autistic individuals with some success.
Hope for Autism: The Listening Project Protocol
Important distinctions were made by Stephen Porges in his Polyvagal
Theory and Listening Project that point to specialized functions of the
cranial nerves that go to muscles in the middle ear, and to how proper
listening enables social engagement.81
Porges made a breakthrough in our understanding of hearing, one
of the problems affecting about 60 percent of autistic children. I heard
Stephen Porges describe this in a lecture at the Breath of Life Conference
in London (May 23-24, 2009). He described how problems associated
with listening and processing human voices might be related to poor
function of cranial nerves V and VII—rather than cranial nerve VIII, as
in typical deafness—and how the mechanisms involved in listening may
be an important part of autistic symptomology.
People on the autism spectrum are a challenge in many ways to par-
ents, teachers, and other caregivers. Anyone working with autistic children
notices that they often do not seem to be able to understand what other
people are saying, and cannot carry on normal two-way communication.
Many people on the autism spectrum do not seem to understand the
166
EFTA00810168
Autism Spectrum Disorders
meaning of what is being said to them, and many of them do not speak
at all. This is especially challenging for psychologists and psychiatrists
because autistic individuals usually have difficulty communicating ver-
bally, so that verbally based therapies are not helpful.
Therefore, as a standard practice, their cranial nerve VIII (auditory
nerve), which has sensory fibers deep in the inner ear, is tested to find
out whether their hearing is sufficient. Most individuals on the autism
spectrum pass the standard hearing test, which is usually administered in
a quiet room with no background noise, or with the subject wearing head-
phones that eliminate all sounds other than the frequencies being tested.
The problem with this test for individuals on the autism spectrum is
that it only measures part of the auditory mechanism. Stephen Porges
realized that for people to hear and understand what is being said, they
need two other cranial nerves: the trigeminal nerve (cranial nerve V) and
the facial nerve (cranial nerve VII).
In order to learn to speak, we first need to be able to hear and under-
stand spoken language. Porges found that many individuals on the autism
spectrum have a dysfunction in cranial nerves V and VII, which interferes
with their ability to hear and understand spoken language. These nerves
originate in the brainstem, and each has several branches with different
functions, two of which go to two muscles in the middle ear. CN WI goes
to the stapedius, a tiny muscle in the middle ear, and CN V goes to the
tensor tympani, at the eardrum.
One of the many functions of cranial nerve CN WI is innervation of
the stapedius muscle. When the stapedius functions properly, it helps
to reduce the volume of sounds that are above and below the frequency
range of the human female voice, to help a child focus on sounds in the
frequency range of a mother's voice. When this muscle functions properly,
a child can easily hear its mother's voice above background noise, learn
language from its mother, and communicate with her and other people.
CN VII, which innervates the stapedius muscle, has other branches
as well, one of which controls the muscles of the face (which have been
referred to as "organs of emotional expression"). When this nerve is
not functioning properly, there is often a lack of facial expression. One
167
EFTA00810169
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
characteristic of both children and adults with a diagnosis of autism is a
lack of natural facial expression; their flat facial affect makes it difficult
for people to read their emotions in a conversation. Because of this, other
people tend to think that the autistic individual lacks empathy.
There is a neurological connection between proper hearing and the
muscles that open the eyes. The flat ring muscle around the eye is inner-
vated by the seventh cranial nerve, and people with hearing problems
often have drooping eyelids. Lifting the eyebrows— the way we do when
something just heard is an "eye-opener"—can help us understand spo-
ken language. All these factors point to the importance to hearing of the
proper functioning of the seventh cranial nerve.
A branch of CN V regulates the tension in the tensor tympani muscle,
which is involved in regulating the Eustachian tube that connects to the
throat. The tensor tympani is similar to the stapedius, regulating the rigid-
ity of the ossicles (small middle-ear bones). Tensing the ossicle chain
increases the tension of the eardrum, diminishing the volume of low-
frequency background sounds.
One of the roles of the stapedius and tensor tympani muscles is to
dampen sounds such as those produced by chewing. If the middle-
ear muscles do not contract sufficiently, the perceived volume of low-
frequency sounds can be extremely high, and even mask human-voice
sounds. This condition is called hypemcusis. For people suffering from
this condition, incoming sounds can be disturbing or even painful.
Some autistic children put their fingers in their ears to block out sounds,
especially low-frequency sounds.
In this condition, a child processes acoustic information only within
a restricted frequency range, so that sounds in the frequency band of
human speech may be lost in background sounds, while lower-pitched
sounds may be functionally amplified. Children with hypersensitivity to
sound might overreact to other people's voices, especially the low-pitched
voices of some men. And when they put their fingers in their ears, this
may be misinterpreted to mean that the child does not want to listen to
what is being said, when in actuality they are just trying to protect their
ears from a painful experience.
168
EFTA00810170
Autism Spectrum Disorders
Everyday noises that include low frequencies (e.g., vacuum cleaners,
traffic, or escalators) seem unbearably loud to people with this condition.
They cannot understand what is being said to them due to background
noises that bother them tremendously, even though the same noises do
not bother other people.
One of my patients, an eleven-year-old boy, stuffed his fingers into his
ears to reduce the sound whenever a train went by at some distance from
my office window. I had never noticed the sound of the trains passing
before, and my other clients never seemed to react to it.
A different kind of dysfunction of the muscles and nerves can result in
an opposite kind of problem with hearing and understanding what is being
said. Muscle tone may be insufficient to amplify the sound adequately, so
that not enough sound gets through, and the child can appear to be deaf to
what is being said to him. This is often misinterpreted as a lack of interest
in communication and social activity, or taken to mean that the child does
not want to respond or do what is being requested of him.
Sometimes children with these problems can become very skilled at
reading lips and interpreting body language. They may appear to be able
to carry on a conversation and to be sociable—but they have a problem
if the person who is speaking is not directly in front of them so that they
cannot read their lips.
Some adults also struggle to understand what is being said unless they
can see the other person's face. People who are lip-reading fixate their gaze
on the other person's mouth, unlike a person with normal hearing who
looks into the other person's eyes, or looks away while listening. Adults
who have difficulty understanding if more than one person talks simul-
taneously may avoid going to parties or crowded restaurants, preferring
to meet people one on one. Or they may use another strategy—talking all
the time, to avoid revealing that they cannot understand others.
Children on the autism spectrum can have major difficulties func-
tioning normally in a noisy classroom. When a child is overly sensitive
to sound, a high level of background noise can be painful, while chil-
dren with a normally functioning inner ear find the same level of noise
acceptable.
169
EFTA00810171
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
For a child with severe hyperacusis, environmental sounds cause bursts
of pain that they cannot escape. Going through the various soundscapes
of daily life might feel like the experience of rats in a cage being stressed
by electrical shocks at unpredictable time intervals. The children might
not even realize that they have a problem; if they were born with hyper-
acusis, they might not know that their randomly traumatic experience is
not normal, and might just assume, "That's
Imagine watching a movie with the soundtrack turned up full blast—
the actors' voices are screaming at you, and you cannot wait to get out of
the theater. You leave, holding your ears. But what if you were an autistic
child who cannot get out of the cinema?
In order to investigate the implications of cranial nerve dysfunction—
and ultimately to prove the validity of the Polyvagal Theory—Stephen
Porges designed his Listening Project Protocol for a research program that
he carried out with subjects on the autism spectrum." In peer-reviewed
research, he describes his empirical studies using the Listening Project
Protocol with autistic children (see below).
Porges's research and scientific articles over the last twenty years have
broken new ground in treating autistic conditions. Identifying a physi-
ological pattern that may be partly responsible for autistic behavioral
patterns is a significant breakthrough in our understanding of autism,
and has opened possibilities for new forms of treatment. The method
that he developed has already helped many people to improve their com-
munication skills and social behavior.
Porges hypothesized that the reason many children on the autism
spectrum have difficulty in using language to interact is dysfunction in
the neural regulation of their middle-ear muscles, described above. CN
V and CN VII, two of the cranial nerves necessary for social engagement,
originate in the brainstem and have branches that go to those two muscles
in the middle ear.
Porges treated a large group of children with a diagnosis of autism
using an ingenious therapeutic intervention. In Porges's Listening Project
Protocol research, all of the children tested had diagnoses on the autism
spectrum, and many of them also had hyperacusis. All of the children,
170
EFTA00810172
Autism Spectrum Disorders
after receiving extensive hearing tests, received five forty-five-minute
sessions daily for five days.
In one publication, Porges and his group demonstrated that spe-
cially computer-altered music improved auditory processing skills and
increased ventral vagal regulation of the heart.89
A second publication describes two trials conducted by Porges's team.
One trial contrasted a group of children wearing headphones only with
another group receiving computer-altered music, processed with an algo-
rithm to enhance the acoustic features of prosody. In the second trial,
one group received the computer-altered music and the other group
received the same music, but unaltered. In both trials, only the group
receiving the computer-altered music exhibited a reduction in auditory
hypersensitivity.9°
I had a chance to hear the special music myself. After I listened for
a few minutes, I felt as if my middle-ear muscles had been stimulated
and exercised. My eardrum itched, and the structures in my middle ear
felt as if they were hopping, dancing, and vibrating. More importantly,
I experienced an improvement in my hearing and in my ability to hear
speech more clearly.
At his lectures, Porges presented inspiring videos showing some of
the changes in the children and how, when they could understand what
was being said, they emerged from their previous social isolation and
began to relate to others. Porges is constantly working on improving the
acoustic stimulation that he uses, and the means of delivering it. At the
time of this writing, in 2016, he was conducting registered clinical trials
in Melbourne, Los Angeles, and Toronto.
The Role of Hearing in Autistic Spectrum Disorders
In order to be sociable and carry on a two-way communication, people
have to hear and interpret the meaning of words spoken by others. As
described above, problems with hearing and understanding character-
iztemany individuals on the autism spectrum. This phenomenon is well
171
EFTA00810173
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
recognized; Stephen Porges initially pointed this out in his presentation
of the Polyvagal Theory, and I have confirmed it in my practice. However,
these hearing problems are most often related to a dysfunctional CN V
and CN VII (as Porges discovered) and not CN VIII, the auditory nerve,
often incorrectly assumed to be exclusively responsible for hearing.
When an autistic, Asperger's, or otherwise challenging child comes to
my clinic, I ask the parents about their child's hearing. Invariably, they
say that their child's hearing was tested by an ear specialist who reported
that it was normal. Most autistic children have their hearing tested in the
usual way: they wear headphones, and respond when they hear the varied
volumes and frequencies of sound from the headphones.
The parents are almost always told that their child has good hearing,
but this misses the core of the autistic child's hearing problem. It is not a
question of the child hearing single tones in a test, without background
noises. The question should be: can the child hear the human voice in the
presence of background noise? Does the child have the ability to filter out
background sounds, especially low-frequency sounds?
One mother brought her nine-year-old son to me because of his
aggressive behavior at school. I usually do my own simple test to check
such a patient's ability to hear well. I ask the child to turn around, so that
their back is turned and they cannot read my lips. Then I give them a
simple task to perform—for example, to put their coat on.
Often the parent will protest, saying that this puts the child at a dis-
advantage since it's easiest for them when they can see the speaker's face.
This particular mother said something similar. So I asked her what hap-
pens when her son is in the next room or does not see her face, and she
tries to get him to do something that she wants.
"If he does not answer," the mother responded, "I stay calm and tell
him again:'
"If he still does not answer, what do you do?"
She replied, "I tell him a third time. If he still does not do it, I know
it is because he doesn't want to answer me. Sometimes I get so irritated
that I slap him."
172
EFTA00810174
Autism Spectrum Disorders
From her son's point of view, he was occupied doing something and
was not aware of the mother's message because his fifth and seventh
cranial nerves were not functioning sufficiently to filter out background
sounds. He was probably not even aware that his mother was talking to
him. Then, all of a sudden, without his understanding why, his mother
would slap him, and yell at him in an angry voice.
Even though she had told him something three times, he had been
unable to hear and understand what she said. In her own frustration at
not being heard, she then slapped him, but from his perspective this was
without warning; he did not know what led up to the slap. So he might
logically interpret his mother's message as,"If you want another person's
attention, hit them, and then give them your message?'
Sometimes, when the boy was in school and asked one of the other
children to do something, and if the other child did not do it right away,
he would slap them without warning to get their attention. It is no wonder
that this child had a hard time playing with other children. His mother
had inadvertently taught him this antisocial pattern herself.
In my clinic, when children turn their back to me and do not respond
to my simple request to put their coats on, I do not assume that they
heard and understood it just because I said it. Instead, I suspect dysfunc-
tion of CN V and VII. If this is indeed the case, and autistic individuals
cannot understand what others are saying, they will of course have a
hard time recognizing how to use language to get others to understand
and help them.
THE EVOLUTION OF HEARING
Early in the evolution of Earth's creatures, large predators including the
dinosaurs and other great lizards roamed the land, often preying upon
small mammals. The largest animals that could threaten these dinosaurs
and lizards pounded the earth with their feet when they walked or ran,
producing low-frequency percussive sounds. The dinosaurs registered
these low-frequency vibrations in the nerve endings wrapping their large
skeletal bones.
173
EFTA00810175
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
Information about the approach of a potential predator was crucial,
especially for protection of their offspring. But these large creatures could
not hear sounds in higher frequencies. Paleontologists have found that
their middle-ear bones were attached to the jawbone, unlike those of
later species. Thus it is speculated that dinosaurs "heard" by registering
low-frequency vibrations in the bones of their skeleton, but could not
hear higher-frequency sounds made by mammals.
Mammals have evolved ears that allow us to hear higher frequencies;
our middle-ear bones, detached from our jaws, vibrate based on sonic
waves in the air. Mammalian "voices" are in a higher frequency range
than the rumblings of the dinosaurs and large lizards. Therefore early
mammals were able to communicate with each other without being
detected by the larger and faster animals that were their predators, and
this was a potential advantage in their struggle for survival.
However, if mammals indiscriminately let all the sounds of their envi-
ronment into their ears, including both very high and low frequencies,
we would experience a confusing cacophony. The higher and lower fre-
quencies would drown out the mammalian-voice sounds. For humans,
sounds in the vital frequency range of the female voice might convey
information from the mother that is crucial to a child's survival in a
dangerous situation.
So how does our hearingexusion these important frequencies? The
ability of mammals to filter out sounds depends on varying levels of ten-
sion in the stapedius and tensor tympani muscles in the middle ear. These
effectively block out both high- and low-frequency sounds, leaving only
the sounds roughly in the range of the human voice. A well-functioning
stapedius muscle can filter out sounds above and below the range of the
human voice—even otherwise deafeningly loud noises?'
The evolution of the structures of the ear and the sense of hearing is
well documented in the field of evolutionary biology, from the time of the
early dinosaurs starting 190 million years ago until today. In mammals,
three small parts of the jawbone became separated from the rest of the
jaw. These three small bones as a group are called the ossicles. (The root
os- means "bone," and ossiele means "tiny bone.") These three bones are
174
EFTA00810176
Autism Spectrum Disorders
called the hammer (maliens), the anvil (incus), and the stirrup (stapes)
because they resemble these shapes. They are enjoined in synovial joints,
and held together by a ligament in a flexible "chain."
Movement of the ossicles is controlled (either facilitated or restricted)
by adjustments in the tension of the tensor tympani and stapedius mus-
cles, which attach to the ossicles at opposite ends of the chain. These
muscles affect the hearing in different ways. The tympanic membrane
(eardrum) is round in shape, like a drumhead; the tensor tympani muscle
connects it to the malleus, one of the ossicles.
Changes in tension in the tensor tympani muscle determine how much
the eardrum can vibrate. Sounds are louder with increased tension. The
tensor tympani is innervated by a branch of the fifth cranial nerve, and
acts as a kind of volume control on how much sound gets passed on to
the receptors of the acoustic nerve deep in the auditory canal.
The stapedius, about one millimeter long, is the tiniest muscle in the
entire body. It is innervated by a motor branch of the seventh cranial
nerve, which changes the level of muscle tension. The stapedius is also
a very thin muscle. It originates in a small cavity surrounding the bones
of the middle ear, and inserts into the neck of the stapes (one of the
three ossicles). The stapedius only transmits certain frequency ranges as
it tenses and relaxes. With normal hearing, the sound frequencies of the
human female voice get through easily, while sounds above and below
these frequencies are largely filtered out.
To register the changes of frequency when someone else is talking
requires a well-functioning stapedius muscle in order to separate out the
range of sounds needed for us to hear, understand, and communicate
with each other. This function is crucial for a child in learning vocabulary
and the melody of language.
TREATING HEARING IN AUTISTIC CHILDREN
A characteristic common to people who are socially engaged is that we
usually have a melodic voice that can communicate feeling. This voice
melody, or prosody, makes it easier for other people to understand us. In
175
EFTA00810177
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
contrast, people with autism often have a flat, monotonous voice, which
can verge on sounding mechanical and robotic.
Perhaps the reason that they lack prosody in their voice is that they
cannot hear it in other people's voices due to a dysfunctional CN VII. If a
child cannot hear and appreciate, or feel the emotions communicated by,
the melody in the voices of others, they cannot comprehend the benefits
of using melody in their own voice, much less learn to express it.
This quality of the voice is not primarily a vocal problem per se. As
soon as we help people on the autism spectrum to a state of social engage-
ment through improved function of their cranial nerves, the quality of
their voice changes; they immediately have more prosody, and it is easier
for others to understand what they are saying.
Sometimes hearing can be improved with the Basic Exercise by
increasing the flow of blood to the brainstem, where cranial nerves V
and VII originate. The Basic Exercise can also release tension between the
base of the cranium (where the nucleus of CN V is located) and the first
three vertebrae. The Neuro-Fascial Release Technique can also be suf-
ficient to reset the function of these nerves and improve social behavior.
With the understanding gained from my study of the Polyvagal The-
ory, I developed my own approach to autism spectrum disorders. I evalu-
ate the function of cranial nerves V, VII, IX, X, and XI, and then I use a
selection of specific biomechanical cranial techniques to release restric-
tions and enable proper function in these nerves.
Based on my clinical experiences and the feedback of my students, I
have confirmed that it is possible to improve the communication skills
of some people with a diagnosis of autism. Several of my patients who
originally came to me with an autism diagnosis were evaluated again after
I treated them and were found to be no longer autistic.
I have learned over the years to be careful about saying "cure autism,"
usually simply stating that I have helped some people with a diagnosis of
autism to improve their hearing and achieve more empathy and better
communication skills. Many professionals working in the field believe
that autism cannot be cured and are more receptive to a claim that it is
possible in many cases to improve communication.
176
EFTA00810178
Autism Spectrum Disorders
Treating Autism
Over the years, I have successfully helped many children and young peo-
ple with a diagnosis on the autism spectrum. Many such children have
problems with normal social behavior; they do not seem interested in
other people, avoiding looking at them or making eye contact. They seem
to lack empathy, and would rather spend time alone or playing on their
electronic devices.
Their parents may designate other young people as "friends" if they
can sit together in the same room for periods of time. However, the child-
ren do not really interact with these friends, but sit in their own worlds,
playing alongside each other but by themselves.
Some autistic individuals lack verbal communication skills, and can-
not take part in a meaningful two-way conversation. They do not seem
able to listen or understand what is being said, and they are not playful.
Some do not speak at all; others, when they do speak, may repeat like a
parrot what was just said by someone else, or repeat sentences from a
movie. Sometimes they continue speaking without pausing for the other
person to respond.
To start to make sense of all the various behaviors exhibited by indi-
viduals on the autism spectrum, I have observed that such individuals
are not socially engaged, and have faulty neuroception. I have been
able to help some of them by getting them into a state of social engage-
ment. In several instances, I have brought about normal vagal function
and improved the function of the other four cranial nerves involved in
social engagement. This brought the individuals out of states of stress
or dorsal vagal withdrawal and spontaneously improved their com-
munication skills.
Perhaps one of my most unexpected discoveries in doing body ther-
apy is that I have found tension in the right sternocleidomastoid (SCM)
muscle—and an accompanying deformation of the skull called "flat back
of the head" or plagiocephaly—in every client diagnosed with ADHD or
a diagnosis on the autism spectrum. Research published in the journal
Pediatrics reported that this deformation of the skull, usually only on one
177
EFTA00810179
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
side, is present in a higher percentage of children with autism and ADHD,
compared to normally functioning children.91
The sternocleidomastoid muscle is attached to the base of the
temporal bone, on the side of the skull, so that chronic tension in the
SCM muscle noticeably deforms the shape of the skull in a particular way.
Although this client group consists mostly of children and young people,
this deformation of the skull is not confined to children; I also see it in
many adults who have had difficulties being socially engaged. This same
approach can achieve similar improvements in adults.
Can certain characteristic shapes of the skull put pressure on certain
blood vessels or nerves inside the skull? A baby's cranium is made up of
several plates, connected by tough connective tissue. A constant pull on
the temporal bone from chronic tension in the SCM muscle can pull the
baby's cranium out of shape. If the tension in the muscle is not released,
the skull remains out of shape as the child matures.
Many parents come to me because they already know that their child
has a flat back of the head. If the parents were not already aware of it, I
show them how to feel the shape of their child's head, and to notice any
asymmetry there before we start the treatment. Relaxing the tension in the
sternocleidomastoid muscle on one side often gives a noticeable improve-
ment in the shape of the child's head within a few minutes.
Technique for Rounding a Flat Back of the Head
I start by feeling the two sternocleidomastoid muscles, and I work on the
side that is tighter. I take the top of the child's SCM muscle on that side
firmly but gently between my thumb and index finger. This must not
cause pain. (SeeSternocleidomastoid"in the Appendix.) I ask one of the
parents to hold the foot on the side where we are going to release the
SCM, and to gently bend their child's foot down at the ankle joint with one
hand, and then with their second hand to bend their child's toes up. After
a minute or two, the child relaxes and the sternocleidomastoid muscle
is much more relaxed and pliable. When the SCM no longer pulls on one
side of the back of the cranium, the part that was flat fills out, becomes
178
EFTA00810180
Autism Spectrum Disorders
rounded, and the two sides become symmetrical. The rationale behind
this technique is found in Tom Myers' book Anatomy Trains, in which he
describes the-superficial front linen
Then the parent and I evaluate the back of the child's head again. It
has always become more symmetrical. When the child comes back for
another treatment, I observe that the changes have held.
AUTISM: A CASE STUDY
As exciting as it was for me to see the changes in the children that I
treated, and to hear about their improvements, the next step was to find
out whether other people could learn the approach and have similar suc-
cess. In my school in Copenhagen, we offered a two-year program based
on the biomechanical cranial techniques I had learned from my teacher,
Main Gehin. For many years, I started the first day of the first course
teaching students my Neuro-Fascial Release Technique (see Part Two).
In this way I began to realize how simple and powerful this technique is.
On the second day, I asked whether any of the students had tried the
techniques they learned and, if so, what they experienced. One young man
named Thor told the class of his success. He had gone home with the idea
of reviewing the techniques that he had learned that first day, and treated
his younger brother, William, who had had a diagnosis of infantile autism
and was then seventeen years old.
William was asocial, and sat in his chair looking down at his Play-
Station or playing with his keys. He did not speak or make eye contact
with anyone. He could also be moody; if he was upset about something,
even though it might seem trivial to other people, he would withdraw
into himself and sulk. Thor told of one mute episode that lasted for three
months after William was made to wear a T-shirt that he did not want to
wear. Even though he only wore T-shirt for one day, he sulked in silence
for three months.
After Thor did the Neuro-Fascial Release Technique on him, William
sat back and looked Thor in the eyes, which he had not done before. Then
he stood up and balanced on one foot. Like many people with autism,
179
EFTA00810181
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
William had been unable to balance well enough to stand on one foot.
Then he shifted his weight to the other foot, and stood on that. That one
technique was enough for William to be brought into a state of social
engagement. He started to communicate with his family and other stu-
dents at school, and started making friends.
Thor asked me to also treat William, and I treated him four or five
times. But most of the work on his nervous system had been done by
Thor's treatments before William ever came to me.
Over the next few months, William made many friends, traveled to
other European countries on vacations, got involved in theater, took yoga
classes, and started dating. He went on to finish a bachelor's degree from
Copenhagen University in the Study of Media, and then to receive a mas-
ter's degree.
The last time I saw William, he told me that he is doing very well, and
proudly related that he had taken a vacation to Amsterdam with three
of his friends, also young adults with challenging diagnoses. They had
handled the whole trip themselves—booked a hotel, found restaurants,
visited museums, and had a good time together and enjoyed the trip.
William had attained ranking as a chess master, and he had beaten several
other international chess masters. He is also just starting an apprentice-
ship as a sound designer for a Danish software company that produces
video games.
You can see Thor tell William's story on You'Ibbe (Search "autism,
William, Stanley").
SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS IN TREATING AUTISTIC CHILDREN
Treating children (especially those on the autism spectrum) with hands-
on techniques has its special challenges. Even children without autism will
usually not lie still on a massage table for very long. Those with medical
histories have often had a history of countless visits to doctors and hos-
pitals, where they have been forced to lie still for an examination, or to
receive painful injections.
180
EFTA00810182
Autism Spectrum Disorders
It is hard to imagine how a child with negative experiences like that can
feel safe, especially on the first treatment—lying on her back in a position
of total helplessness, in an unfamiliar room, and being approached by a
complete stranger who towers over her and starts doing something to her.
Resistance is understandably triggered by this, and it takes patience, skill,
and experience on the part of the therapist to help these children feel safe.
Many autistic children, furthermore, do not like being touched. A
treatment is often an improvised dance of the child, the parent, and me
before I can gain the child's confidence enough for him to relax on the
table and allow me to get my hands on him so that I can treat him.
I find that succeeding with an autistic child, however, is always deeply
rewarding.
If you are treating autistic children, there are a few things that you
should know. When they come into your space for the first time, it is
natural for them to feel unsafe. They do not know you, and they often
react with fear upon seeing the massage table, which looks like a medical
examination table. You may have the best of therapeutic intentions, but
they do not know that. If you or their parents hold them down, it is coun-
terproductive; they will feel even more threatened, and perhaps violated.
All children can be wary of being touched, especially by a stranger. A
lot of these patients have pain in their head and neck, where I want to
work. Perhaps they will allow me to touch their knee or elbow, but push
my hands away when I try to touch their head or neck. The techniques
that I choose must therefore be highly effective, since there is such a small
window of opportunity in which I can touch these children, especially at
the start of their very first session.
I must first make them feel safe, and this might not happen at all on
the initial treatment. I might give the child toys to play with, and wait
until they have their attention on the toy, or I'll have their parent lie on
the table next to them, maybe even with the child on their stomach. I
keep eye contact with the child, and when I see any expression of pain
or discomfort, I pause in what I am doing and let the child relax before
I go further.
181
EFTA00810183
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
My cardinal rule in treating children, especially autistic children, is
that they must feel safe, and must be respected, every step of the way. This
is a prerequisite to certain techniques in particular that help the child's
nervous system.
In my clinic, when I schedule a child for their first treatment, I like to
talk with one of the parents on the phone first; I do not like to talk about
the child's "problems" in front of the child. I tell parents not to have high
expectations for the first session, and that I might not even be able to
touch their child, much less do a technique, the first time. I inform them
that my practice is to respect the child's resistance on the first session,
and not push beyond their comfort zone. Also, I tell the parents that they
should not try to help me by forcing their child to lie still.
If the child has a good first or second session with me (including
attaining a more symmetrical and rounded back of the cranium—see
"Technique for Rounding a Flat Back of the Head" on page 178) he will
more readily accept another session and be more willing to lie still and
allow me to work on him. Rather than reacting to me with fear and panic,
he will often look at me and smile. I feel that this is significant, since one
of the characteristics of children on the autism spectrum is that they usu-
ally avoid looking at others, making eye contact, or smiling.
One problem for autistic individuals who lack normal two-way verbal
communication is that they cannot understand the spoken word well
enough to know what to expect in a therapeutic encounter. While the
value of the therapy may be obvious to their parents or to health care
professionals, autistic children may have no understanding of why they
are there, or the value they might gain from the treatment. They most
likely have no idea that there is even anything wrong with them, or that
their life can be better.
Their behavior changes, however, when they realize that they are safe
with you, especially once your treatment makes them feel better.
182
EFTA00810184
Autism Spectrum Disorders
Concluding Remarks
While the Polyvagal Theory has given me increased clarity and under-
standing in regard to treating various difficult emotional, physical, and
mental conditions, the insights I've gained into treatment of individuals
on the autism spectrum have quite possibly been the most profound.
A common characteristic of people on the autistic spectrum is that
they have difficulty communicating normally, not only with people in
their everyday life, but also with their caregivers and with people trying
to treat them. These communication difficulties limit the possibilities in
their lives, as well as the efforts of others to communicate with them and
to treat them. This causes suffering for them and their families. Under-
standably, their caregivers often feel helpless, challenged, and not up to
the task. Helping individuals on the autistic spectrum is a journey into
a vast, uncharted area.
For caregivers and therapists, trying to grasp the idiosyncrasies of
behavior exhibited by those on the autism spectrum may only add to the
confusion. However, when we observe autistic individuals from the point
of view of the Polyvagal Theory, we realize that we may be able to help by
simply improving the person's ventral vagal function.
At any given moment, a person can be in only one of the three auto-
nomic states. Autism-spectrum individuals can suddenly shift between
states of stress and withdrawal without others understanding why.
Enabling the state of social engagement by improving the function of
cranial nerves may have the potential to stabilize these shifts, and reduce
some of the difficulty that these individuals commonly experience.
Furthermore, correcting auditory issues by improving the function of
the fifth and seventh cranial nerves often leads to dramatic improvement
in a person's communication skills, social behaviors, and empathy.
Positive changes of this nature tend to build on themselves, further aiding
the person's development.
When two people are socially engaged and communicating face to
face, they pass information about their emotional states by small move-
ments of facial muscles. This also stimulates the nerves in the muscles of
183
EFTA00810185
ANATOMICAL FACTS OLD AND NEW: THE POLYVAGAL THEORY
each person's own face, so that their fifth and seventh cranial nerves give
them ongoing feedback and a clear idea of what they are feeling them-
selves and what they feel about the other person.
Our society increasingly relies on emails and text messages. TV
anchors often have deadpan faces, or assume put-on expressions. More
and more people deaden their faces with Botox, or reduce their expres-
siveness with plastic surgery. However, the more we communicate without
seeing each others' faces and hearing the changes of tone in each other's
voices, the more impersonal the interchange will be, and the less we are
able to communicate anything emotionally. We can talk, but with words
alone we are just passing data.
Telephones are a step up in communication from emails because they
capture changes in vocal expression. Skype and FaceTime give us both
the sound of the voice and the facial expressions—but nothing beats
face-to-face communication.
The less children relate to adults who communicate fully using a
melodic voice and an expressive face, the more the children's facial expres-
sivity will be underused and underdeveloped. Is it any wonder that we
have increasing numbers of children with autism, ADHD, and other com-
munication disorders?
Beyond relating to autistic people, similar difficulties arise from time
to time relating to anyone else in any one of our "normal" relationships.
Our interactions with other people would be so very easy if both we and
they could be socially engaged all of the time. First, it is helpful to realize
that we are not in a ventral vagal state all the time—and neither are they.
Second, we now know that we can do something to bring ourselves or
the other person into a state of social engagement.
It is my feeling that we have just begun to explore the potential of the
Polyvagal Theory not only to help people on the autism spectrum but to
help each of us in all of our relationships with others.
184
EFTA00810186
PART TWO
EXERCISES TO RESTORE
SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
ler
PartInexplores the healing power of the vagus nerve. Optimal health
is possible only when we have a well-functioning ventral branch of the
vagus nerve. The exercises and techniques in this part should help most
people to move from a state of either chronic spinal sympathetic chain
activity (stress) or dorsal vagal activity (shutdown) to a state of social
engagement. These exercises can also be used to prevent problems in the
autonomic nervous system from developing, and to maintain a general
level of well-being.
When you begin to do these exercises for the first time, I suggest that
you start a simple journal. Write down any symptoms or issues that
bother you. Also, take a look at the many symptoms listed in the "Heads
of the Hydra" list at the beginning of Part One. You might want to add
one or more of these to your list.
Note how often a given symptom has appeared. For example, your
symptom may present "all the time;' "every morning,""once a week," or
"once a month." If you have a migraine headache every day, your goal is
certainly to be totally free of migraines; however, any improvement would
be welcomed as a positive result.
Also note how strong your symptoms are. You might write that "They
bother me, but I get through the day anyway,""They require me to take
medication,""They are so strong that I cannot go to work or take part in
normal social activities:' "I cannot sleep," or "I cannot get out of bed in
the morning:" You might prefer to evaluate the pain or symptom using
a scale from one to ten.
185
EFTA00810187
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
After you have been doing the exercises, you can look back at your list
and note any changes—for example,"The migraines are less frequent:
"The pain is less severe," or "I spend less money on painkillers every
month:' Focus on how the exercises have helped—that you do not have
the symptom(s) so often, or that the problem is not so severe. Perhaps
whatever symptoms remain will diminish or disappear as you keep doing
the exercises.
You might also notice other positive changes—for example, are you
sleeping better? Breathing better? Is your appetite more normal? All of
these contribute to better health and resiliency.
The Basic Exercise
The goal of this exercise is to enhance social engagement. It repositions
the atlas (Cl, the first cervical/neck vertebra) and the axis (C2) and
increases mobility in the neck and the entire spine. (See "Atlas" and "Axis"
in the Appendix.) It increases blood flow to the brainstem, where the five
cranial nerves necessary for social engagement originate. This can have
a positive effect on the ventral branch of the vagus nerve (CN X), as well
as on cranial nerves V, VII,IX, and XI.
The Basic Exercise is effective, easy to learn, and easy to do, and takes
less than two minutes to complete. I usually teach this exercise to my
clients in their very first session.
BEFORE AND AFTER DOING THE BASIC EXERCISE
Evaluate the relative freedom of movement of your head and neck. Rotate
your head to the right as far as it goes comfortably. Then come back to
the center, pause, and rotate your head to the left. How far do you rotate
to each side? Is there any pain or stiffness?
After doing the exercise, make these same movements again. Is there
any improvement in the range of your movement? If there was pain when
you rotated your head, did the exercise reduce the level of the pain?
186
EFTA00810188
The Basic Exercise
Most people I have treated are surprised to experience an improvement
in the range of movement as they rotate their head to the right and left.
Better movement of the neck often accompanies an improvement in
the circulation of blood to the brainstem, which in turn improves the
function of the ventral branch of the vagus nerve.
You or your client will probably want to repeat the exercise as needed.
BASIC EXERCISE INSTRUCTIONS
The first few times that you do the exercise, you should lie on your back.
After you are familiar with the exercise, you can do it sitting on a chair,
standing, or lying on your back
1. Lying comfortably on your back, weave the fingers of one hand
together with the fingers of the other hand (Figure 4, 5, and 6).
Figure 4. Fingers interwoven
187
EFTA00810189
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
Figure S. Hands behind the head
Figure 6. Lying on the back
188
EFTA00810190
The Basic Exercise
2. Put your hands behind the back of your head, with the weight of
your head resting comfortably on your interwoven fingers. You
should feel the hardness of your cranium with your fingers, and
you should feel the bones of your fingers on the back of your
head. If you have a stiff shoulder and cannot bring both of your
hands up behind the back of your head, it is sufficient to use one
hand, with the fingers and palm contacting both sides of the back
of your head.
3. Keeping your head in place, look to the right, moving only your
eyes, as far as you comfortably can. Do not turn your head; just
move your eyes. Keep looking to the right (Figure 7).
4. After a short period of time—up to thirty or even sixty seconds—
you will swallow, yawn, or sigh. This is a sign of relaxation in
your autonomic nervous system. (A normal inbreath is followed
by an outbreath, but a sigh is different—after you breathe in, a
second inbreath follows on top of the first inbreath, before the
outbreath.)
Figure 7. Looking to the right
189
EFTA00810191
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
5. Bring your eyes back to looking straight ahead.
6. Leave your hands in place, and keep your head still. This time,
move your eyes to the left (Figure 8).
Figure 8. Looking to the left
7. Hold your eyes there until you notice a sigh, a yawn, or a swallow.
Now that you have you have completed the Basic Exercise, take your
hands away, and sit up or stand up.
Evaluate what you have experienced. Has there been any improvement
in the mobility of your neck? Has your breathing changed? Do you notice
anything else?
NOTE: If you become dizzy when you sit up or stand up, it is probably
because you relaxed when you were lying down, and your blood pres-
sure dropped.This is a normal reaction. It usually takes a minute or two
before your blood pressure adjusts and pumps more blood to your brain.
190
EFTA00810192
The Basic Exercise
CERVICAL VERTEBRAE AND VENTRAL VAGAL DYSFUNCTION
When I test clients and find that they have ventral vagal dysfunction, I also
observe that they have an upper cervical misalignment—i.e., a rotation
of the vertebrae Cl (the atlas) and a tipping of C2 (the axis) away from
their optimal positions. Using the Basic Exercise almost always brings my
clients back into a better alignment of Cl and C2, and when I test them
again I find that they have proper ventral vagal function.
A rotation of CI and C2 can put pressure on the vertebral artery,
which supplies the frontal lobes and the brainstem, where the five nerves
necessary for social engagement originate. From my clinical observations,
I believe that it only takes one negative thought to bring Cl and C2 out
of joint, affecting our posture and physiology.
I demonstrated this a few times in my advanced craniosacral classes.
First, I had the students observe the position of my CI. I lay on my back,
and my students could determine the position of my Cl by gently plac-
ing the pads of their thumbs on its transverse processes. If there was no
rotation of Cl, their thumbs would be close to horizontal. However, if
one thumb was higher than the other, that would indicate a rotation of
the vertebra.
At the start of the experiment, a student observed that his thumbs were
horizontal. Then I simply thought about something that was disturbing
to me. Immediately, the transverse processes of Cl moved; one side went
up and the other went down. The position of Cl felt like it had rotated
approximately forty-five degrees away from the horizontal, with one side
up (anterior) and the other side down (posterior). (Though this obser-
vation is counter to the actual anatomical possibilities for Cl alone to
rotate, it is what leechlike under your thumbs if you have them lightly
monitoring the transverse processes of CI. The only explanation I have is
that the rotation must be a complex combination of the repositioning of
Cl, C2, and C3 taken together. Cl must somehow slide out of the joint
so that it can turn even further.)
I found the experience highly unpleasant, since I had to undergo a
change of state away from social engagement. The other students in the
191
EFTA00810193
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
class could see a change in my breathing, and a loss of color in my face.
Then I had my student perform our hands-on technique for myofascial
release (see "Neuro-Fascial Release Technique," on page 195) to realign
my CI and C2. These vertebrae did not come back into place as quickly
as they had come out of position. He had to repeat the technique several
times until C1 was again horizontal. Finally, I felt more like myself.
The rotation of C1 and C2 has evolutionary survival value; it puts
pressure on the vertebral artery, reducing blood flow to the brainstem,
which affects the function of the five nerves necessary for social
engagement. This puts us into a non-ventral vagal state, which in cases
of danger can help our survival by shutting off the higher functions when
we have to fight or to flee, or when we cannot face the present situation
physically or emotionally.
If our neuroception suddenly registers signals from the environment
indicating that we are threatened or in danger, this change in our physiol-
ogy should be instantaneous—and it is. Interestingly enough, although
our nervous system is quick to be upset, it takes a longer time to settle
down when we are safe again.
It does not require a trauma to affect C1 and C2; the memory of a
past event can do the same thing. Brain-scan studies in women with
post-traumatic stress disorder show a reduction in blood flow to their
brains' frontal lobes when they hear a re-telling of the traumatic events.cm
Why would a trauma, the memory of a trauma, or even just a negative
thought lead to a structural change such as a rotation of Cl and C2? Ten
small muscles connect the occipital bone at the base of the skull with C1
and C2. Eight of these muscles are called the suboccipital muscles, and
lie on the posterior (back) surface of the vertebrae. Two other muscles,
the rectus capitis latemlis and the rectus capitis anterior, lie on the anterior
(front) surface of these same two vertebrae. They are innervated by the
occipital nerve, located on the scalp at the back of the head. (See “Suboc-
cipital muscles,""Vertebral arteries,""Suboccipital muscles with vertebra:'
and "Suboccipital nerve" in the Appendix.) Inappropriate tensions in any
of these ten muscles are enough to shift and hold Cl and C2 out of joint.
192
EFTA00810194
The Basic Exercise
The transverse processes of each cervical vertebra have openings
(called foramens, or foramina) to accommodate passage of the vertebral
arteries. Rotation or tipping of the vertebrae can twist or put pressure on
these arteries, reducing the flow of blood, as in a plastic garden hose; if
you put a bend in it, you reduce or shut off the flow of water. The amount
of blood passing through these vertebral arteries depends on the position
of the upper cervical vertebrae in the neck.
When we do the Basic Exercise, we lie with the weight of our head
on our fingers. This pressure is enough to stimulate the occipital nerve,
causing these muscles to relax and to come into balance with each other.
When we do the Basic Exercise, the first two cervical vertebrae move into
a better position relative to each other.
When Cl and C2 come back into place, it relieves tension on the ver-
tebral arteries, providing better blood flow to the brain and brainstem,
and allows us to return to social engagement. Adequate blood supply to
the cranial nerves, brainstem, and brain is necessary for proper function
of the social nervous system as well as other bodily functions.
Concurrently, therefore, with realignment of Cl and C2, there is relief
of many of the symptoms that we earlier described as the 'Heads of the
Hydra:'
WHY DO WE MOVE OUR EYES IN THE BASIC EXERCISE?
The Basic Exercise involves movement of the eyes because there is a direct
neurological connection between the eight suboccipital muscles and the
muscles that move our eyeballs.
We can directly experience this connection between eye movement and
changes in tension of the suboccipital muscles if we place a finger across
the back of the head, just under and parallel to the lower edge of the skull.
Leaving the head in place, if we move our eyes right or left, up or down, or
diagonally, a light finger pressure should detect a slight movement of the
upper cervical vertebrae, or a change in the levels of tension in the muscles
of the neck under our finger along with every movement of our eyes.
193
EFTA00810195
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
In my clinic I have observed that people who are socially engaged have
a well-positioned Cl and C2. They also have a well-functioning auto-
nomic nervous system that is flexible and able to respond appropriately
to a variety of situations and internal states.
Social engagement is not a fixed state, nor should the position of Cl
and C2 stay fixed after doing the Basic Exercise. These bones move the
instant that our psychological state shifts in moments of happiness, sat-
isfaction, fear, anger, or withdrawal, or when our physiological state shifts
among social engagement, dorsal vagus activation, or spinal sympathetic
chain activation.
Our autonomic nervous system is constantly scanning both our
external and internal environments. When everything is good, Cl and
C2 come into place, and we get adequate blood flow to the brainstem.
When there is a dorsal vagal state, or activity of the spinal sympathetic
chain, Cl and C2 rotate out of position, reducing blood flow to the origin
of the five cranial nerves in the brainstem and to some areas of the brain.
This physiological mechanism takes us away from social engagement, but
it also enables us to react when we are challenged or endangered. This
mechanism is instinctive, immediate, and bypasses conscious thought.
Usually we are not aware of the change.
One of the cornerstones of my treatment of stress and depression is
to realign Cl and C2 using the Basic Exercise, or with a hands-on myo-
fascial release technique (see "Neuro-Fascial Release Technique" on page
195). These interventions release imbalances in the tension of the small
muscles that hold the skull and the first two vertebrae in relation to each
other, and this repositions the atlas and the occiput. Improved alignment
of the vertebrae, especially CI and C2, improves blood flow to the brain
and usually brings a rapid improvement in the function of the five nerves
necessary for the state of social engagement.
There are other forms of manual therapy that use short-thrust, high-
velocity manipulative techniques designed put Cl in place. However, I
prefer to use a gentle technique. If I can give the body the right information
with a soft touch at the right place, the body will balance itself. Because
we cannot put Cl and C2 into place and expect them to stay that way
194
EFTA00810196
Neuro-Fascial Release Technique for Social Engagement
permanently, we should repeat balancing techniques frequently, or as
needed. Since there is no such thing as a fixed state of balance, it is more
useful to think of balancing, an ongoing process.
Neuro-Fascial Release Technique for
Social Engagement
Before I ever heard of the Polyvagal Theory or treated a patient on the
autism spectrum,I managed to develop a hands-on healing technique on
the base of the cranium that I would fortuitously be able to use later to
help many people improve their communication and social skills. Some-
times I choose to use this technique in my clinic rather than the Basic
Exercise. I've named it the "Neuro-Fascial Release Technique."
I developed this technique based on my understanding of the principles
of biomechanical craniosacral therapy, osteopathy, and connective-tissue
release (Rolfing). I have used it with great success for at least twenty-five
years, and I have taught it to a few thousand therapists.
This technique takes less than five minutes to perform, requires no
physical effort, and is highly effective. You can use it on yourself, or to
treat someone else.
WHEN TO UTILIZE THE NEURO-FASCIAL RELEASE TECHNIQUE
The Basic Exercise is a simple self-help method, and an easy and effective
way to achieve better function of the ventral vagus nerve. However, if you
are a body therapist, you may prefer to use your own hands rather than
give people exercises to do; or you may want to combine the self-help
exercises with hands-on techniques.
The Neuro-Fascial Release Technique can serve as an alternative to
the Basic Exercise. It is especially valuable for treating babies, children,
and adults on the autism spectrum who lack the necessary verbal com-
munication skills to absorb instruction about the Basic Exercise, when it
might be difficult to communicate with them and have them follow your
195
EFTA00810197
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
instructions. Using your hands in this way gives you a nonverbal method
for bringing about beneficial changes in another person's nervous system.
If you practice massage or other hands-on modalities, I suggest that
you do this technique, or have your client do the Basic Exercise, when you
start your sessions. This recommendation is in line with the research of
Porges, Cottingham, and Lyon (see earlier section), and will ensure that
your client's autonomic nervous system will be flexible and that he will
gain the most he can from your treatment.
I also suggest that you end your sessions with this technique.
NEURO-FASCIAL RELEASE TECHNIQUE INSTRUCTIONS
If you are used to doing massage, you will need to use your hands in a new
way in order to have success with this technique. Practice this technique
on yourself and learn how to achieve a release before you try it on some-
one else. To bring about social engagement with this technique, you need
to stimulate reflexes in the nerves in the loose connective tissue just under
the skin over the base of the skull. This balances the levels of tension in the
small muscles between the base of the skull and the vertebrae of the neck
It will be easier to learn this technique if the person is lying on his
stomach, so that you can easily see your fingers. Start with one side of
the back of his head.
I. Push gently at the base of the skull on one side, and feel the hard-
ness of the occipital bone. Test the "slide-ability" of the skin on
one side of the occiput. Gently slide the skin over the bone to the
right. Then let it come back to neutral.
2. Then slide the skin to the left, and let it come back to neutral.
In which direction was there more resistance?
3. Slide the skin in the direction of greater resistance. Go very slowly,
and be ready to stop at the very first sign of resistance. It may only
have moved an eighth of an inch or less. Stop there, and hold that
position. Continue to feel the slight resistance. In the pause when
196
EFTA00810198
Neuro-Fascial Release Technique for Social Engagement
you are doing nothing, the person will sigh or swallow, and the
resistance in the skin will melt away as it releases.
4. When you test again, the skin should slide easily in both
directions.
5. Repeat the technique on the other side.
When you test the vagus nerve again (see Chapter 4), it should be
functioning properly. Also, there should be greater freedom of movement
when turning the head to the left and right.
TWO-HANDED NEURO-FASCIAL RELEASE TECHNIQUE
INSTRUCTIONS
Once you have practiced with one hand, you can use two hands.
1.Place one finger of one hand on the occiput at the base of the
back of the head on one side. Test the slide-ability of the skin over
the bone, as described above. The skin should slide more easily in
one direction than the other over the bone.
2. Place a finger from the other hand at the top of the neck on the
same side. If you push a little deeper, you should be able to feel
the muscles. Use this finger to test the slide-ability of the skin over
the muscles at the top of the neck. It should move more easily in
the direction opposite to the direction that the other finger is slid-
ing over the skull bone (Figure 9).
3. After you have tested, lighten your pressure. Let the fingers of
your two hands slide the skin in opposite directions until you feel
resistance.
4. Stop there, and hold that slight tension; wait until you get a sigh
or a swallow.
5. Release your fingers, and allow the skin to return to its original
position.
197
EFTA00810199
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
Figure 9. Sliding the skin over the occiput with two hands
6. Do the same thing on the skin on the opposite side of the skull
and the neck.
When you test the vagus nerve again, it should now be functioning
properly. There should also be greater freedom of movement when turn-
ing the head to the left and to the right.
PROPER APPLICATION OF THE NEURO-FASCIAL
RELEASE TECHNIQUE
The key to success with the Neuro-Fascial Release Technique is getting
the skin to slide, and stopping at the first sign of resistance. Use your
fingertips to connect with the skin using the lightest touch imaginable.
Then slide the skin a very short distance over the underlying layers of
muscles, bones, and tendons.
This technique differs from techniques used in other forms of mas-
sage, which primarily target the muscular system and therefore push into
the body. Please take the time to read the step-by-step instructions so that
you can learn to do it properly.
198
EFTA00810200
Neuro-Fascial Release Technique for Social Engagement
This hands-on technique stretches the loose connective tissue just
under the skin. (To get an appreciation of how fine and delicate this tissue
is, go to YouTube and search "Strolling the Skin:") This connective
tissue is rich in proprioceptive nerve endings. When you gently slide the
skin a very short distance over the muscles and bones, you create a slight
traction in this loose tissue, which is enough to stimulate these nerves.
You slide the skin only a short distance, until you feel the very first
sign of resistance, and because you are working directly on the proprio-
ceptive nerves you do not need to use the force required by most forms
of massage that focus on the muscles. If you use unnecessary force and
keep pushing after the first sign of resistance, or if you slide the skin too
rapidly, the muscles and the ligaments will actually tighten. You cannot
cause any damage this way—the release just takes a longer time. At worst,
you might not get the desired changes.
You may find that sometimes you are pushing so lightly that the other
person reports that they cannot feel anything. That is good feedback!
As you progress with the treatment, you will notice palpable improve-
ment in the slide-ability of the skin.
The Salamander Exercises
The following "Salamander Exercises" progressively increase flexibility
in the thoracic spine, freeing up movement in the joints between the
individual ribs and the sternum. This will increase your breathing
capacity, help reduce a forward head posture by bringing your head back
into better alignment, and reduce a scoliosis (abnormal spine curvature).
Eighty percent of the fibers of the vagus nerve are afferent (sensory)
fibers, which means that they bring information back from the body to
the brain, while only 20 percent are efferent (motor) fibers that carry
instructions from the brain to the body. Some of the afferent fibers from
parts of CN IX and CN X monitor the amount of oxygen and carbon
dioxide in the blood. By improving our pattern of breathing with these
exercises, we tell the brain (via the afferent nerves) that we are safe and
199
EFTA00810201
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
that our visceral organs are functioning properly. This in turn facilitates
ventral vagal activity.
But which comes first? Is a limited breathing pattern the result of a
dysfunctional ventral vagus, or is a lack of ventral vagus function caused
by feedback from a less than optimal breathing pattern? If there are ten-
sions in the respiratory diaphragm and the muscles that move the ribs,
feedback from the afferent vagal nerves monitoring those movements will
report abnormal breathing, which may prevent a state of ventral vagal
activity, just as restoring ventral vagal activity can improve the physi-
ological condition; in practice, improving either one is helpful, no matter
which came first.
A forward head posture reduces the space in the upper chest that is
available for breathing. The Salamander Exercises can create more space
in the upper chest for both the heart and the lungs. Reducing a forward
head posture will also take pressure off of the nerves that reach from the
spinal cord to the heart, lungs, and visceral organs. By improving the
alignment of the cervical vertebrae, the Salamander Exercises also relieve
pressure on vertebral arteries, and can relieve some back pains between
the shoulders.
When you do the Salamander Exercises, you bring your head to the
same level as the rest of your spine. This posture is similar to that of a
salamander, which does not have a neck, so that its head is like an extra
vertebra at the top of the spine. A salamander cannot flex, extend, rotate,
or side-bend its head separately in relationship to the first vertebra of the
spine, or lift its head above the level of the spinal vertebrae, as reptiles and
mammals can. This exercise is done with the head in line with the spine.
In terms of your spinal movements, these exercises put your head in
a position that is neither up nor down. The thoracic (chest portion of
the spine) can now side-bend better, somewhat like a salamander. You
can utilize side-bending movements in your thoracic vertebrae in order
to release muscular tensions between your ribs and thoracic spine. This
contributes to the freedom of movement of your ribs and promotes
optimal breathing.
200
EFTA00810202
Neuro-Fascial Release Technique for Social Engagement
In the extension and flexion of the human spine, there is usually
greater flexibility in the neck and lumbar vertebrae, and less flexibility in
the thoracic spine. However, the flexibility of the thoracic spine increases
dramatically with side-bending. The facet joints of the thoracic vertebrae
are unlocked, allowing the thoracic spine to side-bend more freely.
LEVEL 1:THE HALF-SALAMANDER EXERCISE
To do the first part of the Salamander Exercise to the right, sit or stand
in a comfortable position.
1. Without turning your head, let your eyes look to the right.
2. Continuing to face straight forward, tilt your head to the right so
that your right ear moves closer to your right shoulder, without
lifting the shoulder to meet it (Figure 10).
Figure 10. Half-Salamander with eyes to the right
3. Hold your head in this position for thirty to sixty seconds.
4. Then let your head come back up to neutral, and shift your eyes
to look forward again.
201
EFTA00810203
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
5. Now do the same on the other side: let your eyes look to the left,
and then side-bend your head to the left. After thirty to sixty
seconds, return your head to an upright position, and your eyes
to a forward direction.
THE NALF-SALAMANDER—A VARIATION
In this variation on the Half-Salamander Exercise, follow the same
instructions above, but let your eyes look to the right while tipping your
head to the left (Figure I I). This movement of your eyes in the opposite
direction before you move your head increases your range of motion;
you should be able to side-bend your head even further to the left. Hold
this for thirty to sixty seconds, and then reverse to do the same thing on
the other side.
Figure 11. Half-Salamander with eyes to the left
LEVEL 2:THE FULL SALAMANDER EXERCISE
The Full Salamander Exercise involves side-bending the entire spine
rather than just the neck. Also, we use a different body position.
202
EFTA00810204
Neuro-Fascial Release Technique for Social Engagement
1. Get down on all fours, supporting your weight on your knees and
the palms of your hands. You can rest your hands on the floor, but
it is better if you place the palms of your hands on a desktop, a
table, the seat of a chair, or the pillows of a sofa. Your head should
be on the same plane as your spine (Figure 12).
Figure 12. Salamander on all fours
2. In this exercise, your ears should be neither lifted above nor
dropped below the level of your spine. In order to find the right
head position, lift your head slightly above what you think is
right. You should be able to sense that your head is slightly raised.
Then lower your head slightly below what you think is right. You
should be able to sense that your head is lower than it should be.
Go back and forth between the two positions. Take your head
up a little and then take it down a little. Try to find a position in
the middle where your head does not feel too far up or down.
Although you may never find this position exactly, you can begin
to zero in on it.
203
EFTA00810205
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
3. Once you have found a good position for your head relative to
your spine, look to the right with your eyes, hold them in that po-
sition, and side-bend your head to the right by moving your right
ear toward your right shoulder.
4. Complete the movement by letting the bend in your side continue
beyond your neck, all the way down to the base of your spine.
5. Hold this position for thirty to sixty seconds.
6. Bring your spine and head back to center.
Figure 13. Salamander with head to the left
7. Repeat all steps above, but on the left side (Figure 13).
Massage for Migraines
In the Appendix you will find drawings of four different patterns of
migraine headache pain, shown in red. (See "Headache" illustrations.)
The X's in the drawings indicate the location of trigger points on the
surface of the muscles that can be massaged in order to release tension
in the affected muscles.
204
EFTA00810206
Massage for Migraines
The four drawings show the four typical patterns of migraine pain.
Find the pattern of pain that fits your symptoms. Once you identify the
headache pattern, you can see which part of which muscle has been tight,
and where to massage it.
The trigger points, each marked with an X in each drawing, are areas
on the surface of a muscle where there is a high concentration of nerve
endings. Some of them will feel more thick or hard than the rest of the
muscle. People often find that trigger points that need to be released are
painful when pressure is applied.
FINDING AND DEFUSING TENSION IN TRIGGER POINTS
Because you are working on nerves on the surface of the muscle, a light
touch is usually sufficient to release the tension in the entire muscle.
Rather than massaging the entire muscle, as in ordinary massage, it is
usually enough to simply massage the trigger points. You do not need to
work hard or press deep into the body.
Massaging trigger points deeply or with a lot of force is usually pain-
ful, and can be counterproductive. Under excessive pressure, the body
does not feel safe, and the autonomic nervous system is put into a state
of sympathetic activation or dorsal vagal withdrawal. This is not harmful,
but it is inefficient because it takes time for the body to settle down again.
Make a few small circles on the trigger point. Then stop and wait until
you notice a nervous system reaction in the form of a sigh or a swallow.
Within a few minutes, the intensity of the pain should start to dimin-
ish or disappear. You can repeat the treatment whenever relief from a
migraine is needed.
Not all the X's on the drawing need to be treated. Even if an X indicates
a trigger point for a particular pattern of pain, if you do not feel anything
hard or painful at that particular spot on the surface of the muscle, that
trigger point is not active. Don't waste time trying to release it, but focus
on the trigger points that do feel hard, thick, or painful.
205
EFTA00810207
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
SCM Exercise for a Stiff Neck
This exercise will extend your range of movement as you rotate your
head, alleviate symptoms of a stiff neck, and help to prevent migraine
headaches. It is similar to the very first movements that we made as infants
lying on our stomachs, propped up on our elbows, with our heads free to
move so that we could look around.
1. Lie on your stomach (Figure 14). Lift your head, and bring your
arms under your chest. Rest the weight of your upper body on
your elbows (Figure 15).
Figure 14. Lying on the stomach
ftal PAI111
Figure 15. Lifting the head.jpg
206
EFTA00810208
SCM Excercise for a Stiff Neck
2. Rotate your head to the right as far as it comfortably goes. Hold
that position for sixty seconds.
3. Bring your head back to center.
Figure 16. Turning the head to the left)
4. Now rotate your head to the left as far as it comfortably goes, and
hold that position for sixty seconds (Figure 16).
If you have improved the rotation of the head with this exercise but the
movement is still not as good as you want it to be on one side, then the
restriction is probably coming from another muscle, the levator scapulae,
which is innervated by spinal nerves C3—05. This kind of stiff neck will
not be eliminated solely by improving the function of CN XI and the
trapezius and sternocleidomastoid muscles. (See "The Levator Scapulae
Muscle" on page 104).
Part of the stiffness may also come from a hiatal hernia and shorten-
n
ing of the esophagus, since the vagus nerve wraps around the esophagus.
(See "Relieving COPD and Hiatal Hernia" on page 89.)
207
EFTA00810209
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
Twist and Turn Exercise for the Trapezius
The Twist and Turn Exercise improves the tone of a flaccid trapezius
muscle, and balances each of its three parts with the other two parts. It
also helps to lengthen the spine, improve breathing, and correct forward
head posture (FHP). This in turn often alleviates shoulder and back pain.
This exercise can benefit anyone, not just those with FHP. It takes less
than one minute to do, and the feeling of positive change is immediate.
It is a good idea to take a moment to do this exercise whenever you have
been sitting for a while, and to repeat it regularly from time to time. I do
it almost every time that I get up from sitting at my computer. Every time
you do the exercise, you will experience an improvement in breathing and
posture, and its positive effects are cumulative.
The idea behind this exercise is neither to strengthen nor to stretch
the trapezius muscle. The assumption is that the muscle is strong enough
and just needs stimulation of the nerves to flaccid muscle fibers. You are
waking them up so that they can take over their share of the work, as they
did when we were babies and crawled on all fours.
When a baby is lying on its stomach, it uses all the fibers of the three
parts of the trapezius muscle to keep the shoulder blades together, lift
the head, and turn the head to look around. Later, the baby also uses all
these muscle fibers when raising itself up on all fours to crawl and to
look around.
However, when a baby stands up, all the fibers of the trapezius are no
longer used evenly. Some become more tense, while the energy goes out of
other fibers so that they become flaccid. The head is no longer supported
in the same way by all three parts of the trapezius muscle. Over time, the
head tends to glide further forward, so that the centers of the ears are in
front of the center of the shoulders. The shoulders then exhibit a tendency
to pull forward and down toward the midline.
After doing this exercise, you will have a more even tone in all the
muscle fibers of the three parts of your trapezius. Then, when you stand
or sit, your head will glide back and up naturally by itself, reducing FHP
and improving your posture.
208
EFTA00810210
Twist and Turn EIS) ise for theTrapezius
TWIST AND TURN EXERCISE INSTRUCTIONS
There are three parts to this exercise. The difference between the three
parts is the position of your arms.
1. Sit comfortably on a firm surface, such as the seat of a chair or a
bench. Keep your face looking forward.
2. Fold and cross your arms, with your hands resting lightly on your
elbows (Figure 17). You will be rotating your shoulder girdle
briskly, first to one side and then to the other, without stopping,
and without shifting the hips.
Figure 17. Hands on elbows
3. For the first part of the exercise, let your elbows drop and rest just
in front of your body. Rotate your shoulders so that your elbows
move, first to one side and then back to the other side. When you
rotate your shoulders from side to side, your arms glide lightly
over your stomach. This activates the fibers of your upper trape-
zius (Figure 18).
209
EFTA00810211
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
Figure 18.Trapezius twist
4. Do this three times. Do not strain, and do not stop your move-
ment. Move your shoulders without forcing them or holding
them; your movements are easy and relaxed.
5. The second part is just like the first; the only difference is that you
lift your elbows and hold them in front of your chest, at the level
of your heart (Figure 19). Rotate your elbows first to one side and
then to the other (Figure 20). Do this three times. This activates
the muscle fibers of your middle trapezius.
Figure 19.Trapezius twist with elbows lifted
210
EFTA00810212
Q
Twist and Turn Excercise for the Trapezius
Figure 20. Trapezius twist to the right
6. For the third part, raise your elbows as high as you comfortably
can, and repeat the exercise above (Figure 21). Rotate your elbows
from side to side, three times (Figure 22). This activates the
muscle fibers of your lower trapezius.
Figure 21. Elbows raised high
211
EFTA00810213
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
Figure 22.Trapezius twist with arms lifted
After you have done the exercise, you might notice that your head feels
lighter and has moved back and up, away from the forward head posture.
It is not uncommon for someone with significant FHP to become an inch
or two taller the first time they do the exercise. If someone has been look-
ing at you from the side, she will see that your head has moved partway
back from its original forward position, if you had that tendency.
A Four-Minute Natural Facelift, Part 1
Benefits of this gentle and pleasant treatment include relaxing the facial
muscles and leaving a more natural smile in place by improving the
function of cranial nerves V and VII. You can do it for yourself and share
it with others. This exercise:
improves the circulation to your skin
puts life into the muscles of expression of the middle third of
your face, in the area between the corners of the mouth and the
corners of the eyes
212
EFTA00810214
A Four-Minute Natural Facelift, Part 1
• improves blood circulation to the skin of your face
• brings a youthful quality of liveliness that you can feel and others
can see
• helps you smile more naturally and more often
• makes your face more responsive to interactions with others, and
thereby increases your sense of empathy
• makes flat cheekbones a little more prominent and makes very
high cheeks a little flatter.
Before you do this technique, look at your face in a mirror. If you are doing
the technique on someone else, give theta hand-held mirror so they can
watch their face and follow the changes. Look especially at the area of the
skin around the cheekbones.
Do one side of the face first. Then check whether you can see or feel
a difference between the two sides. The differences are usually obvious
when you talk or smile. Then do the other side. There should be more
symmetry again.
WHERE TO DO THE TECHNIQUE
There is a point on the face that is the endpoint of the Large Intestine
acupuncture meridian, called LI 20. (See "Acupuncture points" in the
Appendix.) It is a beauty point in Chinese, Japanese, and Thai Massage.
In Classical Thai Massage, this point is called "Golden Bamboo." In
Traditional Chinese Medicine, this point is called "Welcoming Fragrance
and it opens the nostrils, improving the breathing.
This point in Chinese medicine is interesting in terms of Western
anatomy. It lies directly over a joint between two bones of the face, the
maxilla and the pre-maxilla. The two bones were separate entities long
ago in the evolutionary development of our species, but they calcified
together into a single bone at an early stage. In modern anatomy, the
maxilla/pre-maxilla is referred to as one bone, called the maxilla.
213
EFTA00810215
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
The endpoint of the Large Intestine meridian is easy to find. Just
lightly touch the skin about an eighth of an inch to the side of the top
of the supra-alar crease (the fold between the cheek and upper lip), near
the outer edge of the nostril. If you explore the area with your finger, you
will find this point easily because it is more sensitive than the rest of the
surrounding skin (Figure 23).
Figure 23. Massage at LI 20
HOW AND WHY TO DO THE TECHNIQUE
The surface of the facial skin is innervated by branches of the fifth cra-
nial nerve. Lightly touching the skin of your face stimulates these nerve
endings.
1. With a very light contact, brush the surface of the skin at acu-
puncture point LI 20. Then let your fingertip melt together with
the skin.
2. Slide the skin up and down to find which direction presents
greater resistance. Push lightly into that resistance. Stop.
3. Hold at that point, and wait to feel it release.
214
EFTA00810216
A Four-Minute Natural Facelift, Part 1
4. Slide the skin inward toward the midline of the face, and out
toward the side to find the direction of greater resistance.
5. Stop there, and push lightly. Hold and wait for the release.
The muscles of the face are innervated by branches of the seventh cra-
nial nerve (VII). There are two layers of facial muscles just below the skin.
6. Let your fingertip sink gently into the muscle layers beneath the
skin at the same point. Let the first muscle layer adhere to your
fingertip as if it were Velcro.
7. If you are careful not to push too hard, and if you feel what is
happening under your fingertips, you can slide these layers of
muscles; first slide one layer on top of the other, making a small
circle.
8. As you go around the circle, you may notice that there is more
resistance to sliding the skin in one direction. Keep pushing
lightly in that direction, and hold until there is a release in the
form of a sigh or a swallow.
9. Next, push slightly deeper. Now the deeper layer of muscles sticks
together with the top muscle layer and the skin. You can slide
both layers together over the surface of the bone.
10. As you go around the circle, you may notice that there is more
resistance to sliding the skin in one direction. Keep pushing
lightly in that direction, and hold until there is a release in the
form of a sigh or a swallow.
All bones have a connective-tissue covering called a periosteum (peri-
means "around," and osteurn means "bone"). This tissue is very rich in
nerve endings from spinal nerves or, in this case, cranial nerves.
11. Let your fingertip sink even deeper into the face until you rest
lightly on the surface of the bone.
12. Massage on the surface of the periosteum has a profound effect
on the autonomic nervous system. Press lightly, but hard enough
215
EFTA00810217
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
to reach the surface of the bone at Large Intestine 20. Let your
fingertip move from side to side on the surface of the bone, then
hold a light pressure on the bone and wait until you get a release.
In the embryo, this bone was two bones, the maxilla and the pre-
maxilla. Even though these have fused into one bone, it is still possible
for most people to sense that there were once two separate bones.
This massage of cranial nerves V and VII stimulates the nerves to
the skin and muscles of the face. It does not erase all the wrinkles, but
it relaxes the muscles of the face, reduces some wrinkles, and leaves the
face looking younger and more refreshed. And there are no negative side-
effects such as scar tissue from a face-lift operation or toxic accumulations
of Botox.
More importantly, this massage helps the face to be more expressive,
communicative, and responsive—more socially engaged. Our face should
be flexible and able to express different emotional responses in various
situations. Facial expressions are a vital part of our communication with
other people.
In addition to expressing our own emotions, facial flexibility is impor-
tant for social engagement. When our face is relaxed and we look at some-
one else's face, our own face automatically makes micro-movements that
mirror the other's facial expression. These movements are very small, and
change very quickly.
These changes in tension in our skin and our facial muscles then feed
back to the brain via the afferent pathways of cranial nerves V and VII,
to give us immediate subconscious information about what others are
feeling. This is a prerequisite for us to have empathy for another person.
If facial muscles under the skin are generally relaxed, a person usually
has a smooth, pleasant, and what is seen as a beautiful or handsome face.
Unfortunately, many people get stuck in the same emotional and facial
pattern for years. Their facial muscles pull on the skin, creating wrinkles
or a double chin. If the person stays in the same emotional state and
does not relax his or her facial muscles, these wrinkles become deeper
with time.
216
EFTA00810218
A Four-Minute Natural Facelift, Part 2
In addition to this technique, a light stroking of the skin of the face
stimulates CN V and reduces tension in all the facial muscles.
A Four-Minute Natural Facelift Part 2
Part I is focused on 1.120, an acupuncture point on the Large Intestine
meridian at the side of the nostril. Stimulating this point improves the
balance and tone of the muscles of the lower face around the mouth
and the nose. Part 2, in turn, focuses on the eyes. The actual technique
is similar in many ways to the first facelifting technique that you did at
Large Intestine 20. You will find the-sensitiw-pleeton the inside corner
of the eyebrow. People often rub this point naturally, without thinking
about it, when they are tired. Massaging the skin and muscles of the face
here is often self-soothing (Figure 24).
Using your thumb or one finger, connect to the-aenpunc-tufe-peirkt
B2. This-peint-is-lecated-at-the-medifil4imer4-enil-ef-the-eyebrew, At B2,
work your way down each of the layers: the skin, two layers of muscles,
and the periosteum.
Figure 24. Massage at B2
217
EFTA00810219
EXERCISES TO RESTORE SOCIAL ENGAGEMENT
This point is also a trigger point for the orbicularis oculi muscle, a thin,
flat muscle that surrounds the opening of the eye. The eyes are sometimes
called the mirror of the soul. Before we work on B2, the muscle might
be too tight, leaving the eye somewhat closed or it might be undertoned,
leaving the eye too open. When we finish, there will be an improved
balance between looking outwards and looking in. You will see another
person more clearly, and this person in turn will have an easier time
making eye contact with you and will experience seeing you differently .
At a deeper level, this acupuncture point is at the edge of a tiny
facial bone called the lacrimal bone. The word "lacramal" refers to tears.
Sometimes a person's eyes can be dry and appear lifeless. Someone can
also experience an annoying flow of tears
By touching this bone at B2 and holding your contact on the Mal
bone, you will balance the flow of moisture to the eyes and leave them
bright and sparkling. The goal of the facelifting massage is leave a smile
on your lips and a twinkle in your eyes.
I. Find the place at the inner corner of the eyebrow that is more
sensitive than the surrounding areas.
2. First use your fingertip to brush the skin lightly a few times.
3. Let your fingertip rest lightly on the skin at point B2 (see above),
and hold that contact with the surface of the skin until you get a
release in the form of sigh or a swallow.
4. Next, press gently down to the layer of the facial muscles. This is
where the flat, round orbicularis oculi muscle, which goes around
the eye, attaches to the bones of the face. Let the skin stick to
your finger and make a small circle, sliding the skin lightly and
searching for the direction where there is resistance.
5. Hold your finger on that resistance until you get a release in the
form of a sigh or a swallow.
6. Then go even deeper until you feel the surface of the bone. Rub
that a few times.
218
EFTA00810220
Severing all the Heads of the Hydra
7. Then hold the contact with the bone, and wait for a release.
If the orbicularis oculi muscle is too tight, closing the eyelids into a
squint, this should open the eye more normally.If the eye was too wide-
open, this technique should firm it down a bit but still leave it open.
This is the second of two beauty points in Classical Thai Massage.
Severing all the Heads of the Hydra
The purpose of all of these self-help exercises and hands-on techniques
is to help bring people out of a dorsal vagal state, or help them out of
chronic activation of the sympathetic chain, and bring them home to
a ventral vagal state. Only in this way can weeever all the heads of the
Hydriand restore our capability for physical and emotional health.
219
EFTA00810221
I I
EFTA00810222
NOTES
1 Jerzy Grotowski, ed. Eugenio Barba, Towards a Poor Theatre (New York:
Routledge Theatre Arts, 2002), 27.
2 Ida P. Rolf, PhD, Rolfing Reestablishing the Natural Alignment and
Structural Integration of the Human Bodyfor Vitality and Well-Being,
rev. ed. (Rochester, VT: Healing Arts Press, 1989).
3 "The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1937," Nobel Media AB
2014 (Oct 4, 2016), www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/medicine
/laureates/1937/.
4 There is another aspect and medical definition of stress that refers to
pushing our muscles and/or organs with sports training and other
physical regimens such as fasting, and it has been said that a certain
level of this kind of stress is good for an organism.
5 Main Gehin's definitive book on his technique is called The Atlas of
Manipulative Techniques for the Cranium and the Face (Seattle: Eastland
Press, English translation, 1985). In this book, Gehin teaches more
than 150 biomechanical techniques, and describes which techniques
to choose when attempting to improve the function of the individual
cranial nerves.
6 Ronald Lawrence and Stanley Rosenberg, Pain Relief with Osteomassage
(Santa Barbara, CA: Woodbridge Press, 1982).
7 CN VIII is the coccleovestibular nerve. There are two specialized
organs in the bony labyrinth of the temporal bone. "Cochlear" refers
to the auditory component of CN VIII, which transduces sound into
electrical impulses to the brain. "Vestibular" refers to the part of CN
VIII that translates information from the movement of a thick fluid
in three semicircular canals embedded in the temporal bone. As we
change the position of the head in relationship to gravity, fluid in
these canals moves, pushing on hairs that stimulate nerves to give us
information about the position and movement of the head.
8 Harold Magoun, DO, Osteopathy in the Cranial Field, 3td ed. (India-
napolis, IN: The Cranial Academy, 1976).
221
EFTA00810223
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
9 The idea that the cranial bones move is contrary to almost all teach-
ings in anatomy and physiology. The commonly held belief is that the
bones fuse together at different ages, the last of these growing fast to
the rest of the skull at the age of thirty-eight. However, I saw collec-
tions of separate human skull bones from an older adult in an anatomy
lab; the bones had been separated by filling a prepared skull with rice
and submerging it in a bucket of water. As the rice absorbed the water
and expanded, it pushed the bones apart from each other. If the bones
had fully grown together, as is taught in many anatomy classes, this
separation of bones would not be possible in an adult of this age.
10 Lauren M. Wier, MPH (Thomson Reuters) and Roxanne M. Andrews,
PhD (AHRQ), Statistical Brief #107: The National Hospital Bill: The
Most Expensive Conditions by Payer, 2008, Healthcare Cost and Utiliza-
tion Project Statistical Brief #107 (Rockville, MD: Agency for Health-
care Research and Quality, 2011), www.hcup-us.ahrq.gov/reports
/statbriefs/sb107.pdf.
11 M. Widen, "Back Specialists are Discouraging the Use of Surgery,"
American Academy of Pain Medicine, 17th annual meeting, Miami
Beach, FL (2001).
12 Markus Melloh, Christoph Roder, Achim Elfering, Jean-Claude Theis,
Urs Muller, Lukas P. Staub, Emin Aghayev, Thomas Zweig, Thomas
Ban, Thomas Kuhlmann, Simon Wieser, Peter Juni, and Marcel
Zwahlen, "Differences Across Health Care Systems in Outcome and
Cost-Utility of Surgical and Conservative Treatment of Chronic Low
Back Pain: A Study Protocol," BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders 9, no. 81
(2008).
13 Lumbar Spinal Stenosis, American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeo
(2010), www.knowyourbackorg/Pages/SpinalConditions/Degene
tiveConditions/LumbarSpinalStenosis.aspx.
14 Michael Gershon, The Second Brain (New York Harper Collins
Publishers, 1999).
15 B. Zahorska-Markiewicz, E. Kuagowska, C. Kucio, and M. Klin, "Heart
Rate Variability in Obesity," International Journal of Obesity and Related
Metabolic Disorders 17, no. I (Jan 1993): 21-23.
222
EFTA00810224
Notes
16 Gemot Ernst, Heart Rate Variability (London: Springer-Verlag, 2014), 261.
17 Stephen W. Porges, "Orienting in a Defensive World: Mammalian
Modifications of our Evolutionary Heritage—A Polyvagal Theory,"
Psychophysiology32 (1995): 301-18.
18 Fischer, Philip, MD, "Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome
(POTS)," Mayo Clinic podcast (Apr 23, 2008), http://newsnetwor
mayoclinic.org/discussion/postural-orthostatic-tachycardia
-syndrome-pots-24cc80/.
19 P. J. Carek, S.E. Laibstain, and M. Carek, "Exercise for the Treatment
of Depression and Anxiety," The International Journal of Psychiatry in
Medicine 41, no. 1 (2011): 15-28.
20 For a list of health issues that can develop, at least in part, from a dys-
functional ventral branch of the vagus nerve, see the table at the begin-
ning of Part One listing the "Heads of the Hydra?'
21 Stephen W. Porges, "Neuroception: A Subconscious System for
Detecting Threats and Safety," Zero to Three 24, no. 5 (May 2004):
19-24.
22 Ben Hogan, Five Lessor's: The Modem Fundamentals of Golf (New York
Simon and Schuster, 1957).
23 Vasilios Papaioannou, loannis Pneumatikos, and Nikos Maglaveras,
"Association of Heart Rate Variability and Inflammatory Response
in Patients with Cardiovascular Diseases: Current Strengths and
Limitations:" P osomatic ne 67, suppl. 1 (2005): 529—S33.
24 B. Pomeranz, acauley, Caudill, I. Kutz, D. Adam, and D.
Gordon, "Assessment of Autonomic Function in Humans by Heart
Rate Spectral Analysis," American Journal of Physiology 248 (1985):
H151-H153.
25 U. I. Zulficiar, D. A. Jurivich, W. Gao, and D. H. Singer, "Relation of
High Heart Rate Variability to Healthy Longevity," American Journal of
Cardiology 105, no. 8 (Apr 15, 2010): 1181—85, doi: 10.1016/j.amj
-card.2009.12.022 (epub Feb 20, 2010), erratum 106, no. I (Jul 1,
2010): 142.
223
EFTA00810225
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
26 P. Jonsson, "Respiratory Sinus Arrhythmia as a Function of
State Anxiety in Healthy Individuals," International Journal of
Psychophysiology63 (2007): 48-54.
27 P. Nickel and F. Nachreiner, "Sensitivity and Diagnosticity of the 0.I -
Hz Component of Heart Rate Variability as an Indicator of Mental
Workload;' Human Factors 45, no. 4 (2003): 575-90.
28 J. F. Brosschot, E. Van Dijk, andlErhayer,"Daily Worry is Related
to Low Heart Rate Variability During Waking and the Subsequent
Nocturnal Sleep Periar International Journal of Psychophysiology 63
(2007): 39-47.
29 A. J. Camm, M. Malik, J. T. Bigger, G. Breithardt, S. Cerutti, R. J. Cohen,
P. Coumel, E .L. Fallen, H. L. Kennedy, Kleiger, F. Lombardi, A.
Malliani, A. J. Moss, J. N. Rottman, G. Schmidt, P. J. Schwartz, and D.
H. Singer (Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the
North American Society of Electrophysiology), "Heart Rate Variability:
Standards of Measurement, Physiological Interpretation, and Clinical
Use," Circulation 93 (1996): 1043-65.
30 Arpi Minassian, PhD, Mark A. Geyer, PhD, Dewleen G. Baker, MD,
Caroline M. Nievergelt, PhD, Daniel T. O'Connor, MD, Victoria B.
Risbrough, PhD, and the Marine Resiliency Study Team, "Heart Rate
Variability in a Large Group of Active-Duty Marines and Relationship
to Posttraumatic Stress," Psychosomatic Medicine 76, no. 4 (May 2014):
292-301.
31 Vasilios Papaioannou, loannis Pneumatikos, and Nikos Maglaveras,
"Association of Heart Rate Variability and Inflammatory Response
in Patients with Cardiovascular Diseases: Current Strengths and
Limitations:" Psychosomatic Medicine 67, suppl. 1 (2005): S29—S33.
32 Masari Amano, Tomo !Cando, U.E. Hidetoshi, and Toshio Moriani,
"Exercise Training and Autonomic Nervous System Activity in Obese
Individuals," Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 33 (2001):
1287-91.
33 Amelia M. Stanton, Tierney A. Lorenz, Carey S. Pulverman, and Cindy
M. Meston,"Heart Rate Variability: A Risk Factor for Female Sexual
Dysfunction," Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback 40 (2015):
229-37.
224
EFTA00810226
Notes
34 Ji Yong Lee, Kwan-Joong Joo, Jin Tae Kim, Sung Tae Cho, Dae Sung
Cho, Yong-Yeun Won, and Jong Bo Choi,"Heart Rate Variability in
Men with Erectile Dysfunction," International Neurourology Journal 15,
no. 2 (Jun 2011): 87-91.
35 Jacqueline M. Dekker, PhD, Richard S. Crow, MD, Aaron R. Folsom,
MD, MPH, Peter J. Hannan, MStat, Duanping Liao, MD, PhD, Cees A.
Swenne, PhD, and Evert G. Schouten, MD, PhD, "Clinical Investigation
and Reports: Low Heart Rate Variability in a 2-Minute Rhythm Strip
Predicts Risk of Coronary Heart Disease and Mortality from Several
Causes: The ARIC Study," Circulation 102 (2000): 1239-1244.
36 Robert M. Carney, Kenneth E. Freedland, and Richard C. Veith,
"Depression, the Autonomic Nervous System, and Coronary Heart
Disease," Psychosomatic Medicine 67 (May—Jun 2005): S29—S33. Studies
of medically well, depressed psychiatric patients have found elevated
levels of plasma catecholamines and other markers of altered ANS
function compared with controls. Studies of depressed patients with
coronary heart disease (CHD) have also uncovered evidence of ANS
dysfunction, including elevated heart rate, low heart rate variability,
exaggerated heart rate responses to physical stressors, high variability
in ventricular repolarization, and low baroreceptor sensitivity. All these
indicators of ANS dysfunction have been associated with increased
risks of mortality and cardiac morbidity in patients with CHD.
37 M. Malik, P. Barthel, R. Schneider, K. Ulm, and G. Schmidt, "Heart-
rate Turbulence after Ventricular Premature Beats as a Predictor of
Mortality after Acute Myocardial Infarction," The Lancet 353, no. 9162
r 24, 1999): 1390-96.
38 epartment of Health and Human Services, National Center for
Health Statistics,"Health, United States 2015: Special Feature on Racial
and Ethnic Health Disparities" (accessed June 2016), www.cdc.gov
/nchs/hus/.
39 A. B. Kulur, N. Haleagrahara, P. Adhikary, and R S. Jeganathan, "Effect
of Diaphragmatic Breathing on Heart Rate Variability in lschemic
Heart Disease with Diabetes:' Arquivos Brasilieros Cardiologia 92, no. 6
(Jun 2009): 423-29, 440-47, 457-63.
225
EFTA00810227
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
40 Peter Levine is a leading shock and trauma therapist. He uses verbal
techniques, combined with a close observation of the client in terms
of subtle changes in their autonomic nervous system, as the client
regresses to the time of a traumatic event. He wrote Waking the Tiger
(Berkeley: North Atlantic Books, 1997). Since then, his teaching has
grown into a form called Somatic Experiencing.
41 Stephen Porges developed, patented, and marketed a vagal-tone
monitor to measure HRV through a small company called Delta-
Biometrics, Inc. That company no longer exists; however, there are now
many vagal-tone measuring devices manufactured by other companies.
42 James Oschman, PhD is a research scientist and author of the bestselling
book Energy Medicine (London: Churchill Livingstone, 2000).
43 The Listening Project Protocol is now available through Integrated
Listening Systems as the "Safe and Sounds Protocol: A Portal to Social
Engagement,"
44 John T. Cottingham, Stephen W. Porges, and Todd Lyon, "Effects of
Soft Tissue Mobilization (Rol ling Pelvic Lift) on Parasympathetic Tone
in Two Age Groups," Physical Therapy 68, no. 3 (Mar 1988): 352-56.
45 D. Buskila and H. Cohen,"Comorbidity of Fibromyalgia and
Psychiatric Disorders," Current Pain and Headache Reports 11, no. 5
(Oct 2007): 333-38.
46 P. Schweinhardt, K. M. Sauro, and M. C. Bushnell, "Fibromyalgia: a dis-
order of the brain?" Neuroscientist 14, no. 5 (2008): 415-21.
47 A systematic review of antidepressant efficacy failed to demonstrate
superior effectiveness compared to psychotherapy, alternative therapy
such as exercise, acupuncture, and relaxation, or active intervention
controls such as sham acupuncture or therapies not specific to depres-
sion. Arif Khan, Charles Faucett, P. Lichtenberg, I. A. Kirsch, and W.A.
Brown, "A Systematic Review of Comparative Efficacy of Treatments
and Controls for Depression:' PLOS (Jul 30, 2012), http://dx.doi
.org/10.1371/joumalpone.0041778.
48 My primary biomechanical craniosacral teacher is Main Gehin, the
French osteopath who wrote The Atlas of Manipulative Techniquesfor
the Cranium and the Face. (See note 5 above.)
226
EFTA00810228
Notes
49 Monica J. Fletcher, Jane Upton, Judith Taylor-Fishwick, Sonia A. Buist,
Christine Jenkins, John Hutton, Neil Barnes, Thys Van Der Molen,
John W. Walsh, Paul Jones, and Samantha Walker, "COPD Uncovered:
An International Survey on the Impact of Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Disease [COPD[ on a Working-Age Population:' BMC
Public Health Journal 11, no. 612 (2011), www.biomedcentral
.com/1471-2458/11/612#B1, doi :10.1186/1471-2458-11-612.
50 The 10 Leading Causes of Death in the World, 2000 and 2012, World
Health Organization Fact Sheet No. 310 (Geneva, Switzerland: World
Health Organization, 2013).
51 Robert I. Miller and Sterling K. Clarren, "Long-Term Developmental
Outcomes in Patients with Deformational Plagiocephaly," Pediatrics
105, no. 2 (Feb 2000): e26.
52 David G. Simons, MD, Janet G. Travel', MD, and Lois S. Simons, PT,
Myofascial Pain and Dysfunction: The Trigger Point Manual, 6i° ed., vol.
2 (London: Churchill Livingstone, 2008).
53 Ida P. Rolf, PhD, Rolfing: Reestablishing the Natural Alignment and
Structural Integration of the Human Bodyfor Vitality and Well-Being,
rev. ed. (Rochester, VT: Healing Arts Press, 1989).
54 John T. C.ottingham, Stephen W. Porges, and Todd Lyon, "Effects of
Soft Tissue Mobilization (Rolfing Pelvic Lift) on Parasympathetic Tone
in Two Age Groups," Physical Therapy 68, no. 3 (Mar 1988): 352-56.
Their experiment is discussed in detail in Chapter 4.
55 C. C. Lunardi, F. A. Marques da Silva, Rodrigues Mendes, Marques A.
P. Stelmach, and Fernandes Carvalho,"Is there an Association Between
Postural Balance and Pulmonary Function in Adults with Asthma?"
Clinics 68, no. 11 (Sao Paulo, Brazil: Department of Physical Therapy,
School of Medicine, University of Sao Paulo, Nov 2013).
56 D. M. Kado, M. H. Huang, H. S. Karlamangla, E Barrett-Connor, and
G.A. Greendale, "Hyperkyphotic Posture Predicts Mortality in Older
Community-Dwelling Men and Women: A Prospective Study," Journal
of the American Geriatric Society 52, no. 10 (Oct 2004): 1662-67.
57 Mayo Clink Newsletter (Nov 3, 2000).
227
EFTA00810229
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
58 Alf Breig, Adverse Mechanical Tension in the Central Nervous System: An
Analysis ofCause and Effect: Reliefby Functional Neurosurgery (Stock-
holm: Almqvist 8c Wiksell International, 1978).
59 Roger W. Sperry, "Roger Sperry's Brain Research," Bulletin of The
Theosophy Science Study Group 26, no. 3-4 (1988): 27-28. Also see
Sperry's review of The Formation ofNerve Connections by R. M. Gaze
in Quarterly Review ofBiology 46 (Jun 1971): 198.
60 A. I. Kapandji, The Physiology of the Joints, 6th ed., vol. 3 (London:
Churchill Livingstone, 2008).
61 T. A. Smitherman, R. Burch, H. Sheikh, and E. Loder, "The Prevalence,
Impact, and Treatment of Migraine and Severe Headaches in the
United States: A Review of Statistics from National Surveillance Stud-
ies," Headache 53, no. 3 (Mar 7,2013): 427-36.
62 L. D. Goldberg, "The Cost of Migraine and its Treatment," American
Journal ofManaged Care 11, no. 2 suppL (Jun 2005): S62-67.
63 David G. Simons, MD, Janet G. Travel', MD, and Lois S. Simons, PT,
Myofascial Pain and Dysfunction: The Trigger Point Manual, 0 ed., vol.
2 (London: Churchill Livingstone, 2008).
64 M. S. Robbins and R. B. Lipton, "The Epidemiology of Primary Head-
ache Disorders," Seminal Neurology 30 (Apr 2010): 107-19.
65 Jes Olesen, Headaches, 3rd ed. (Philadelphia: Lippincott, Williams 8c
Wilkins, 2006), 246-47.
66 R. C. Kessler, W. T. Chiu, O. Demler, K. R. Merikangas, and E. E. Wal-
ters, "Prevalence, Severity, and Comorbidity of 12-Month DSM-IV
Disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication," Archives of
General Psychiatry 62, no. 6 (Jun 2005): 617-27.
67 Phil Barker, Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing: The Craft of Caring
(London: Arnold, 2003).
68 Michael Passer, Ronald Smith, Nigel Holt, Andy Bremner, Ed
Sutherland, and Michael Vliek, Psychology (UK: McGrath Hill Higher
Education, 2009).
69 The NationalIntimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey (Atlanta, GA:
National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention, 2017), www.cdc.goviviolenceprevention/nisys/.
228
EFTA00810230
Notes
70 M. J. Breiding, J. Chen, and M. C. Black, Intimate Partner Violence
in the United States-2010 (Atlanta, GA: National Center for Injury
Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Preven-
tion, 2014), www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/pdf/cdc_nisys_ipv
report_2013_v17_single_a.pdf.
71 T. Frodi, E Meisenzahl, T. Zetsche, R. Bottlender, C. Born, C. Groll,
M. Jager, G. Leinsinger, K. Hahn, and H.J. Moller,"Enlargement of
the Amygdala in Patients with a First Episode of Major Depression:'
Biological Psychiatry 51, no. 9 (May 1, 2002): 708-14.
72 Bruce S. McEwen, "LI Stress Induced, Hippocampal, Amygdala
and Prefrontal Cortez Plasticity and Mood Disorders," Behavioral
Pharmacology 15, no. 5-6 (2001): Al.
73 There was no published report from this treatment project. This sum-
mary is condensed from personal conversations with psychologist
Marc Levin over several years.
74 Thomas Insel,"Antidepressants: A Complicated Picture," The National
Institute of Mental Health Directors Blog (Dec 6, 2011), www.nimh.nih
.gov/aboutIdirectors/thomas-inseUblog/2011/antidepressants-a
-complicated-picture.shtml.
75 Peter Wehrwein, "Astounding Increase in Antidepressant Use by Amer-
icans," Harvard Health Blog (Oct 20, 2011), www.health
.harvard.edu/bloglastounding-increase-in-antidepressant-use-by
-americans-201110203624.
76 Andreas Vilhelmsson, "Depression and Antidepressants: A Nordic
Perspective Frontiers in Public Health 1, no. 30 (Aug 26, 2013), doi:
10.3389/fpubh.2013.00030.
77 Craig W. Lindsley, ed., "2013 Statistics for Global Prescription
Medications," ACS Chemical Neuroscience 5, no. 4 (Apr 16, 2014): 250-
251, www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/artides/PMC3990946/, doi: 10.1021
/cn500063v.
78 Jay C. Fournier, MA, Robert J. DeRubeis, PhD, Steven D. Hollon, PhD,
Sona Dimidjian, PhD, Jay D. Amsterdam, MD, Richard C. Shelton, MD,
and Jan Fawcett, MD, "Antidepressant Drug Effects and Depression
Severity: A Patient-Level Meta-analysis," Journal of the American
Medical Association 303 (2010): 47-53.
229
EFTA00810231
ACCESSING THE HEALING POWER OF THE VAGUS NERVE
79 Mark Olfson, MD and Steven C. Marcus, PhD, "National Patterns in
Antidepressant Medication Treatment," Archives of Genera! Psychiatry
66, no. 8 (2009): 848-856, doi: 10.1001/archgenpsychiatry.2009.81.
80 IL C. Kessler, R A. Berglund, O. Demler, R. Jin, K. IL Merikangas, and
E.E. Walters, "Lifetime Prevalence and Age-of-Onset Distributions
of DSM-IV Disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replica-
tion," Archives of General Psychiatry 62, no. 6 (Jun 2005): 593-602.
81 See Chapter 5, "Relieving COPD and Hiatal Hernia;' for more about
hiatal hernias and their treatment.
82 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, "Prevalence of Autism
Spectrum Disorder Among Children Aged 8 Years—Autism and
Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Network," Surveillance
Summaries (Mar 28, 2010): 1-21.
83 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Autism and
Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Network Surveillance Year
2010 Principal Investigators, Jon Baio, EdS, corresponding author,
"Prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorder among Children Aged 8
Years—Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Network,
11 Sites, United States, 2010," Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
63, no. SS02 (Mar 28, 2014): 1-21.
84 Ariane V. Buescher, MSc; Zuleyha Cidav, PhD, Martin Knapp, PhD,
and David S. Mandell, ScD, "Costs of Autism Spectrum Disorders in
the United Kingdom and the United States," Journal of the American
Medical Association Pediatrics 168, no. 8 (Aug 2014): 721-28.
85 Tara A. Lavelle, PhD, Milton C. Weinstein, PhD, Joseph P Newhouse,
PhD, Kerim Munir, MD, MPH, DSc, Karen A. Kuhlthau, PhD, and Lisa
A. Prosser, PhD, "Economic Burden of Childhood Autism Spectrum
Disorders," Pediatrics 133, no. 3 (Mar 1, 2014): e520-29.
86 Nicole Ostrow, "Autism Costs More Than 2 Million Dollars over
Patient's Lifetime:' Bloomberg Business (Jun 10, 2014),
-than-2-million-over-patient-s-life.
87 Also see Erik Borg and S. Allen Counter, "The Middle-Ear Muscles,"
Scientific American 261, no. 2 (Aug 1989): 74—80.
230
EFTA00810232
Notes
88 The listening project protocol is now available through Integrated
Listening Systems as the "Safe and Sounds Protocol: A Portal to Social
Engagement,"
89 Porges, S. W., Macellaio, M., Stanfill, S. D., McCue, K., Lewis, G. F.,
Harden, E. IL, and Heilman, K. J.,"Respiratory Sinus Arrhythmia and
Auditory Processing in Autism: Modifiable Deficits of an Integrated
Social Engagement System?" International Journal ofPsychophysiol-
ogy 88, no. 3 (2013): 261-270.
90 Stephen W. Porges, Olga V. Bazhenova, Elgiz Bal, Nancy Carlson,
Yevgeniya Sorokin, Keri J. Heilman, Edwin H. Cook, and Gregory F.
Lewis, "Reducing Auditory Hypersensitivities in Autism Spectrum
Disorder: Preliminary Findings Evaluating the Listening Project
Protocol," Frontiers in Pediatrics 2, no. 80 (Aug 1, 2014), doi: 10.3389/
fped.2014.00080.
91 This is based on conversations with Stephen and his lab assistant, who
tested the function of my stapedius musde on two different visits.
See also Erik Borg and S. Allen Counter, "The Middle-Ear Muscles,"
Scientific American 261, no. 2 (Aug 1989): 74-80.
92 IL I. Miller and S. K. Clarren,"Long-Term Developmental Outcomes in
Patients with Deformational Plagiocephaly," Pediatrics 105, no. 2 (Feb
2000), http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/105/2/e26.short.
93 Thomas W. Myers, Anatomy Trains: MyofascialMeridians for Manual
and Movement Therapists, 3rd ed. (London: Churchill Livingstone,
2014).
94 J. Douglas Bremner, MD,"Neuroimaging Studies in Post-Traumatic
Stress Disorder," Current Psychiatry Reports 4 (2002): 254-63.
231
EFTA00810233
I I
EFTA00810234
INDEX
233
EFTA00810235
I I
EFTA00810236
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Stanley Rosenberg is an American-born author and body therapist. A
Rolfer since 1983 and,practicing craniosacral therapist since 1987. He
studied biomechanical craniosacral therapy for many years under Main
Gehin, trained in craniosacral therapy at the Upledger Institute and in
biodynamic craniosacral courses with Giorgia Milne, studied applica-
tions for treating children with Benjamin Shield, and took courses in
osteopathy with Jean-Pierre Barral.
For many years he led a school in Denmark, teaching structural
integration, myofascial release, release of scar tissue, biomechanical
craniosacral therapy, visceral massage, and biotensegrity. He is the
author of four books, published in Denmark: Nevermore Pain in the
Back, Nevermore Stiff Neck, Pain Relief with Osteomassage, and Hwa
Yu Tai Chi. In addition to his work as a body therapist, he has worked
in theater— training actors in yoga, acrobatics, and voice—at various
institutions, including Yale University, Brandeis University, Swarthmore
College, and the National Theatre Schools of Denmark and Iceland. More
information about the techniques presented in this book can be found
on his website.
EFTA00810237
I I
EFTA00810238