Electronically Filed 11/06/2013 02:22:38 PM ET
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR THE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., CASE NO. 13-024268 CA 01
KENNETH MANFREDI,' R.,
and ALEXANDER LIEB , as trustee
for the estate of Ernesto Liebster
.1
Phuidiffs,
VS.
KOBALTE1C, INC., an inactive Florida Corporation;
MILLENNIUM LOCK INC. cUb/a ULTIMATE
LOCK SYSTEMS, a Texas Corporation; DARIUN
BAYSINOER, individually; RON DANIELS,
individually; JOSEPH TITPNB, individually,
Defendants.
PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT
COME NOW the Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI,
JR., and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, by and through
the undersigned counsel, and hereby move this Court for leave to file their Amended Complaint,
a true and cowed copy of which is attached hereto and matted as Exhibit "1," and as grounds
therefore state as follows:
1. On July 17, 2013, Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH
MANFREDI, JR., and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Litter
(hereinafter collectively referred to as "Plaintiffs") filed the subject Complaint.
2. Plaintiffs have not attempted to amend the Complaint prior to this motion.
3. This amended Complaint seeks to clarify the damages sought in each separate
count, fix scriveners' errois that were contained in the original Complaint, and add an additional
cause of action for Civil Theft, as to three of the Defendants.
EFTA01198664
Kenneth Manfredi, et at v. Kobaltek, Inc., ei al.
Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to Amend Complaint
Page 2 of 3
4. Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.190(a) (2013) provides that leave of court to
amend pleadings "shall be given freely when justice so requires." The primary consideration in
determining whether a motion for leave to amend should be granted is a test of prejudice, and
such leave "should not be denied unless the privilege has been abused or the complaint is clearly
not amendable." Soucy v. Casper, 658 So.2d 1017 (Ha. 4th DCA 1995); New River Yachting
Ctr., Inc. v. Racchiocchi, 407 So.2d 607, 609 (Fla. 4th DCA 1981).
5. In fact, "refusal to allow amendment of a pleading constitutes an abuse of
discretion unless it clearly appears that allowing the amendment would prejudice the opposing
party; the privilege to amend has been abused; or amendment would be futile." Spradley v.
Stick, 622 So.2d 610, 613 (Ha. 1st DCA 1993); accord Carter v. Ferrell, 666 So.2d 556, 557
(Fla. 2d DCA 1995); see also Dimick v. Ray, 774 So.2d 830, 834 (Fla. 4th DCA 2000) (the
preference of the rules of procedure is for all claims to be brought in one action, even by
amendment of a complaint provided that the amendment does not prejudice the defendant).
6. Florida conrts have long followed the policy of allowing litigants to amend
pleadings freely in order that cases may be tried on the merits, and that amendments to pleadings
should be allowed where the basic cause of action is not changed. The test is whether the
pleading as amended is based upon the same specific conduct, transaction or occurrence between
the parties upon which the plaintiff tried to enforce his original claim. Tuner v. Th-ade-Mor, Inc.,
252 So.2d 383, 384 (Fla. 4th DCA 1971).
7. The addition of a cause of action of Civil Theft, pursuant to Florida Statute
§772.11 (2013), arises out of the same specific conduct, transaction and occurrence that is and
has been averred in the original Complaint, and inclusion of this cause of action is necessary in
order for all claims to be brought in one action.
The Law Office of Michael I.
7850 146• Street• Suite 501* Miami Lakes, It • 33016•Tel(305)822-8422•Pax(305)82.2.3155
EFTA01198665
Kenneth Manfredi, el al v. Koballek, Inc., et al.
Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to Amend Complaint
Page 3 of 3
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI,
JR., and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, respectfully
request that this Court grant this Motion for Leave to file their Amended Complaint, and for all
other relief deemed appropriate by this Court.
Respectfully submitted,
Law Office of Michael I. Reppas,
7850 NW 146°' Street, Suite 501
Miami Lakes, Florida 33016
Tel (305) 822-8422
Fax (305 822-3155
Email:
By: /s/ George C. Palaidis
MICHAEL J. REPPAS, ESQ.
Florida Bar No. 124702
GEORGE C. PALAIDIS, ESQ.
Florida Bar No. 056666
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been furnished
on this 6th day of November, 2013, via electronic mail to Joe Titone, Esq., 621 SE 5 Street,
Pompano Beach, FL 33060, at joetitone708®comeast.net and Steve Mankodi, Esq., 11972 West
Sample Road, Coral Springs, FL 33065, at
By: /s/ George C. Palaidis
MICHAEL J. REPPAS, ESQ.
Florida Bar No. 124702
GEORGE C. PALAIDIS, ESQ.
Florida Bar No. 056666
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppas,..
7850.. we Street* Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tek305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198666
IN THE CIRC111T COURT FOR THE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
KENNETH MANFREDI, sg., CASE NO. 13-024268 CA 01
KENNETH MANFREDI, JR.,
and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as Trustee
for the Estate ofErnesto Liebster,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
KOBALTEK,114C., an inactive Florida Corporation;
MILLENNIUM LOCK INC. d/b/a ULTIMATE
LOCK SYSTEMS, a Texas Corporation; DARREN
BAYSINGER, individually; RON DANIELS,
individually; and JOSEPH TITONE, individually,
1
Defendants.
AMENDED COMPLAINT
COME NOW the Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI,
JR., and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, by and through
the undersigned attorney, and sue the Defendants, KOBALTBK, INC., an inactive Florida
Corporation; MILLENNIUM LOCK INC., d/b/a ULTIMATE LOCK SYSTEMS, a Texas
Corporation; RON DANIhLS, individually; DARREN BAYSINGER, individually; and
JOSEPH TITONE, Individttif/bi, and in support thereof allege:
i JURISDICTION AND VENUE
1. This is an action for Conversion, Civil Theft, Conspiracy, Fraud, and Breach of
Fiduciary Duty, and is for damages that are within the jurisdiction of this Court, exclusive of
interest, costs, and attorneys! fees.
er
EXHSIT
The Law Office of Michael 1. Reppas, ■
7850 N.W. 1464 Street* Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Te1(305)822-8422•Fiuc(30S)822-3155
EFTA01198667
Magna, et at v Koballek, Inc., et at
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 2 of 24
2. Plaintiff, ICENNETH MANFREDI, SR. (hereinafter referred to as "MANFREDI
SR"), is a suifurls Georgia t idal
3. Plaintiff, KENNETH MANFREDI, JR. (hereinafter referred to as "MANFREDI
JR"), is a suifurls Texas resident.
4. Plaintiff, Al4CANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster
(hereinafter referred to as "LIEBSTER"), is a suifurls Maine resident.
5. Defendant, K6BALTEK, INC., (hereinafter referred to as "KOBALTEK") was,
at all times material hereto, Florida Corporation with its principal place of business in Broward
County, Florida, and conducting business in Miami-Dade County, Florida.
lI
6. Defendant, MILLENNIUM LOCK INC., d/b/a ULTIMATE LOCK SYSTEMS,
(hereinafter referred to as 1"MILLENNIUM") was, at all times material hereto, a Texas
Corporation conducting hustings in Miami-Dade County, Florida.
7. Defendant, RON DANIELS (hereinafter referred to as the "DANIIIIS"), is a sui
furls Texas resident, and is ;and was the President and Chief Executive Officer of Defendant,
MILLENNIUM LOCK INC), d/b/a ULTIMATE LOCK SYSTEMS, at all times material hereto.
8. Defendant, .BARREN BAYSINGI3R (hereinafter referred to as the
I
"BAYS1NGER"), is a siftfurls! Broward County resident.
_
9. Defendant, JOSEPH TITONE (hereinafter referred to as the "JOSEPH
TITONE"), is a suifurls Br4vard County resident.
10. Venue is proloer in Miami-Dade County, Florida, as the majority of the claims
giving rise to the dispute occurred in Miami-Dade County and the Defendant KOBALTEK is a
Miami-Dade County corporation.
The Law Office ofMichael J. Reppas.p.
7850.. 1466 Street* Suite 5010 Miami Lakes, FL • 330 6•Tel )822.8422.Fox(305)822-315$
EFTA01198668
Manfredi, et al. v. Kobaliek, Inc., ci at.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 3 of 24
FACTS
11. On February 15, 2010, and Felltyary 24, 2010, Plaintiffs, Ernesto LIEBSTER and
MANFREDI SR., respeetivtly, purchased 2,000 Model 4000 locks (hereinafter referred to as
"SUBJECT MERCHANDIOW) from Defendant, MILLENNIUM, and executed a personal
guarantee as co-guarantors; for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE in the amount of ONE
HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS (S100,000.00). A true and correct copy of this Personal
1
Gum office is an:relied hereto and marked as Exhibit "A."
12. In our around March 2010, non-party, Rolando Martinez (hereinafter referred to
as "MARTINEZ.), an employee of Defendants MILLENNIUM and DANIELS, prepared the
SUBJECT MERCHANDISr far shipping from Houston, Texas, to Miami, Florida. See,
Martinez's statement to th4 Miami-Dade County Police Department, dated April 20, 2012,
regarding Theft Report Cast #PD111027430601, a true and correct copy of which is attached
hereto and marked as Exhibil '13."
13. In or around March 2010, the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE was shipped to non-
party, DTS DIRECT MAIL1AND FULFILLMENT SERVICES, INC.'s (hereinafter referred to
1
as "DTS") storage warehouse in Miami-Dade County, Florida. Shipping fees in the amount of
ONE THOUSAND FOUIll. HUNDRED FORTY DOLLARS (S1,440.00) was paid by
LIEBSTER. See, Straight Bill of Lading, a true and correct copy of which is attached hereto and
1
marked as Exhibit "C."
14. Between April 21. 2010 and May 3. 2010, Plaintiffs, MANFREDI SR., and
Emesto LIEBSTER paid air1 amounts due for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE pursuant to the
PERSONAL GUARANTEE( See, Draft numbers 1350 and 1352 written from MANFREDI's
The In Office of Michael L Reppas,...
7850.. 146' Street. Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Teff305)822-11422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198669
Manfredi, et al. v. Kobaltek, Inc., et at
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 4 of 24
Non-Party corporation, Dev`ploper Design Group, LLC, true and correct redacted copies of which
arc attached hereto and marked as Composite Exhibit "D."
15. In or around Tune 2010, PLAINTIFFS entered into an agreement with a wholesale
1
company in Jamaica for the Muse of the subject property
16. The SUBJE MERCHANDISE was scheduled to remain in storage at DTS'
warehouse until it was ready to be shipped to Jamaica.
'
17. On or around, September 3, 2010, Ernesto LIEBSTER died.
18. On or around September 6. 2010 MARTINEZ was asked by Defendant
DANIELS and/or Defendant MILLENNIUM to unload the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE into
Defendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM's facilities in Houston, Texas. See, Exhibit "B."
;
19. MARTINEZilcnew of the sale of the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE to Plaintiffs,
I
Id
MANFREDI SR and LIES TER, and believed same to be the rightful owners of the SUBJECT
MERCHANDISE, and bas on that knowledge arranged for the shipping of the SUBJECT
I
MERCHANDISE to a warehouse in Miami, Florida
t
20. MARTINEZ:believed that Defendants DANIELS and/or MILLENNIUM were no
longer the rightful owners ol' the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE. Id.
21. On or around September 8, 2010, and upon information and belief the SUBJECT
MERCHANDISE was stolen by Defendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM from DTS'
I
Warehouse, and taken across state lines to Defendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM's
facilities in Houston, Texas.:
22.MARTINEZ Iwas aware of DANIELS and MILLENNIUM's scheme to steal the
I
SUBJECT PROPERTY, buirefined to take part in same. Id.
' The Law Office ofMichaelL Reppas,
7850. 146th Street* Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tel(305)822-13422ernogsAn.3155
M.
EFTA01198670
Mafradl, el. al. v. Kobakek, Inc., et al.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 5 of 24
On or around September 26. 2010, PLAINTIFFS were notified that the SUBJECT
23.
I
MERCHANDISE had been! stolen. PLAINTIFFS immediately notified the Police and FBI
I Case
regarding said theft. See, Miami-Dade Police Department Theft Report,
PPD111027430601, a true aid correct copy of which is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit
"E." See also, Exhibit "B."
24. In or arounii September 2010, upon information and belief, Defendants,
p
BAYSINGER and JOSEPHlITONE began conspiring against PLAINTIFFS for the purposes of
diverting potential insuniince proceeds for the theft of PLAITNIFF's SUBJECT
i
MERCHANDISE from DTSfs warehouse.
25. On or around September 29, 2010, and in furtherance of the conspiracy identified
in paragraph 24 above, Defendant BAYSINGER formed KOBALTEK, INC (a named defendant
herein). See, Articles of Incorporation for Kobaltek, Florida Department of State, Division of
Corporations, a true and correct copy of which is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "F."
i
26. In or around September and October 2010, and unbeknownst to PLAINTIFFS,
and in furtherance of ther conspiracy, Defendant JOSEPH TITONE contacted non-party
I
Sherman Daley (hereinafter 'referred to as "DALEY"), former sales agent for LIEBSTER, and
wrongfully informed DALEY that JOSEPH TITONE was representing Plaintiffs, MANFREDI
SR. and LIEBSTER in a lau uit against DTS regarding the stolen SUBJECT PROPERTY. See,
i
Letter from Daley to Manfrech, dated April 23, 2012, a true and correct copy of which is attached
hereto and marked as Exhibit "G."
27. In or around September and October 2010, and unbeknownst to PLAINTIFFS,
!
and in furtherance of their conspiracy, Defendant BAYSINGER requested that-DALEY issue a
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppas,
78501. 1464 Streets Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•TeK305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198671
Manfredi, et. al. v. Kobetrek, bin., ei
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 6 of 24
new purchase order for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE to "add his name to the contact line and
'white out' Mr. Liebster's mune." Id.
28. Defendant BAYSINGER further told DALEY that Defendant JOSEPH TITONE
believed that this new purchase order would "hold 'more credibility' and show standing in this
case [against MS]." Id.
29. DALEY refused to comply with Defendants JOSEPH TITONE and
BAYSINGER's request to fraudulently alter the purchase order as discussed in the preceding
paragraph. Id.
30. On or around October I, 2010 MARTINEZ discovered the SUBJECT
MERCHANDISE at Defendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM'S facilities in Houston, Texas,
and notified PLAINTIFFS of same.
31. On or around October 22, 2010, and January 7, 2011, PLAINTIFFS made a
demand for the immediate compensation of the stolen SUBJECT PROPERTY.
32. On or around October 29, 2010, and unbeknownst to PLAINTIFFS, and in
furtherance of their conspiracy, Defendant KOBALTEK, via Defendant BAYSINGER and
represented by Defendant JOSEPH =ONE., filed a lawsuit against DTS seeking compensation
for the theft of the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE belonging to PLAINTIFFS from the DTS
warehouse.
33. In or around:January 2011, PLAINTIFFS opened an investigation with the FBI
Office in Houston, Texas, regarding the theft of the SUBJECT PROPERTY transported across
state lines.
34. In or around March 2011, and over FIVE (5) months after having filed the lawsuit
described above, and in furtherance of their conspiracy, Defendant, BAYSINGER approached
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppaa,
7850 146th Street* Suite 501. Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tela03)822-8422•Fax(105)822-3155
EFTA01198672
Manfredi, ei. at v. Kobalfek, Inc., et at.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 7 of 24
PLAINTIFFS for the first time and informed them that he had just learned of the theft of the
SUBJECT PROPERTY, and offered to assist PLAINTIFFS make an insurance claim against
DTS. See, Kobaltek v. DTS Direct Mall & Fulfillment Services, Miami-Dade County Circuit
Court Case No. 10-58137, q true and correct copy of the Docket Information is attached hereto
and marked as Exhibit "H."
35. On or around June 14, 2011, and unbeknownst to PLAINTIFFS, and in
fltrtherance of their consliiracy, Defendant KOBALTEIC, via Defendant BAYSINGER,
represented by Defendant JOSEPH TITONE, settled the lawsuit with DTS for TWENTY-FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS (525,000.00). See, Kobaltek v. DTS Direct Mall & Fulfillment
Services, Miami-Dade County Circuit Court Case No. 10-58137, Mediator's Report and
Settlement Agreement, dated Juno 14, 2011, a true and correct copy of which is attached hereto
and marked as Exhibit "I."
36. In or around June 2011, Defendant JOSEPH TITONE approached non-party,
Anthony Titone, Esq. (Defendant JOSEPH TITONE's brother and hereinafter referred to as
"ANTHONY TITONE") abd requested to use ANTHONY TITONE's Florida Bar Trust
Account for the receipt and distribution of the settlement funds. See, Affidavit of Anthony Titone
with Attachments, a true and correct copy of which is attached hereto and marked as Composite
Exhibit "J."
37. ANTHONY TITONE did not seek or receive the permission of any of the
PLAINTIFFS to accept and distribute said fiords or in any other way to represent them as their
attorney.
The Law Office of Michael 3. Reppas,
7850.. 146° Streets Si le 5010 Miami Lakes, FL • 330 I 6•Teff305)822-8422•Pax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198673
Matted!, et al. v. Xobahek, Inc.. et at.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 8 of 24
38. On or around dune 24,2011, ANTHONY TITONE deposited the TWENTY-
FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS (S25,000.00) settlement funds into his Trust Account. See,
Composite Exhibit "J."
39. On or around July 1. 2011, ANTHONY TITONE, at the direction of JOSEPH
TITONE and BAYSINGER, distributed from his Trust Account the proceeds from the settlement
with DTS as follows: JOSEPH TITONE received FIFTEEN THOUSDAND FIVE HUNDRED
DOLLARS (S15,500.00) arid BAYSINGER received NINE THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED
DOLLARS ($9,500.00). Sed, Composite Exhibit "I."
40. In furtherance of their conspiracy, and despite having already filed and settled the
lawsuit against DTS, BAYSINGER, in or around July 2011 informed PLAINTIFFS of his
intention to hire JOSEPH acITONE to represent than in a lawsuit against DTS on behalf of
PLAINTIFFS; the PLAINTIFFS refused JOSEPH TITONE's representation or involvement in
any way with the dispute.
41. In or around!September 2011, in furtherance of their conspiracy, and despite
having already filed a lawsuit against DTS and settled same, BAYSINGER informed
PLAITNIFFS that they were able to recover FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($5,000.00) from
DTS but needed said funds to compensate JOSEPH TITONE.
42. In or around! November 2011, PLAINTIFFS contacted DTS' Chief Operating
Officer, Christopher Trainor; who informed PLAINTIFFS that they had fallen victims of a hoax
by JOSEPH TITONE and BAYSINGER.
43. In or around December 2011, PLAINTIFFS received,for thefirst time, a copy of
the settlement agreement between DTS and KOBALTEK, signed by BAYSINGER on behalf of
KOBALTEK and signed by JOSEPH TITONE. See, Exhibit "I."
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppas,
7850M. 146th Street• Siiite 501• Miami Lakes, FL • 330I6•Te8305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198674
Manned!, et. at v. kobaltek, Inc., et
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 9 of 24
44. In or around 'armory 2012, Mark Goldstein, attorney for DTS, orally informed the
PLAINTIFFS that BAYSINGER and JOSEPH TITONE "scammed" PLAINTIFFS by
wrongfully and fraudulently filing and settling the matter against DTS.
45. In or around January 2012, Mr. Goldstein further orally informed the
PLAINTIFFS that BAYSINGER and JOSEPH TITONE perpetuated multiple frauds upon the
Court in the lawsuit against DTS by altering documents to establish standing in said case.
46. In or around February 2012, PLAINTIFFS approached BAYSINGER and
inquired about the TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLAR ($25,000.00) settlement. Defendant
BAYSINGER informed PLAINTIFFS that Defendant JOSEPH TITONE took the TWENTY-
FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS (S25,000.00), and then immediately ended the parties'
conversation.
47. In or around March 2012, PLAINTIFFS filed a complaint with the Florida Bar
against Defendant JOSEPH TITONE for filing the frivolous lawsuit referred to above and for
stealing the TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLAR ($25,000.00) settlement funds resulting
from same. Said complaint with the Florida Bar is still under investigation.
48. The SUBJECT MERCHANDISE identified above was placed from, delivered to,
stored in and stolen front Miami-Dade County, Florida
49. The wrongful lawsuit and resulting settlement was filed in Miami-Dade County,
Florida.
50. The settlement funds were paid, received and deposited, and released in Miami-
Dade County, Florida.
51. To date, Defendants have not returned any of the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE or-
otherwise compensated PLAINTIFFS for the theft of same.
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppas,
7850-. 146°' Street• Suite 501• Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tel(305)822-8422•Fax(305)822.3155
EFTA01198675
Manfredi, et. al. v. KobeItek, Inc., et al.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 10 of 24
52. At present, Defendants, MILLENNIUM and DANIELS owe PLAINTIFFS an
amount in excess of ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($100,000.00), not including
interest and attorneys' fees and costs.
53. At present, Defendants, KOBALTEK, BAYSINGER, and JOSEPH TITONE,
owe PLAINTIFFS an amount in excess of TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS
($25,000.00), not including interest and attorneys fees end costs.
54. All demands, opportunities to cure and all conditions precedent to the bringing of
this action have been performed, have occurred, or have been waived.
COUNT I - CONVERSION
(AGAINST DEFENDANTS DANIELS AND MILLENNIUM)
55. PLAINTIFFS repeat and re-allege paragraphs I through 54, as if fully set forth
herein.
56. On February 15, 2010, and February 24, 2010, Plaintiffs, Ernesto LIEBSTER and
MANFREDI SR., respectively, purchased 2,000 Model 4000 locks (hereinafter referred to as
"SUBJECT MERCHANDISE") from Defendant, MILLENNIUM, and executed a personal
guarantee as co-guarantors, for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE in the amount of ONE
HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($100,000.00). See, Exhibit "A."
57. In or around March 2010, the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE was shipped to DTS'
storage warehouse in Miami-Dade County, Florida. Shipping fees in the amount of ONE
THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED FORTY DOLLARS ($1,440.00) was paid by LIEBSTER. See,
Exhibit "C."
58. Between April 21, 2010, and May 3, 2010, Plaintiffs, MANFREDI SR. and
Ernesto LIEBSTER, paid all amounts due for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE pursuant to the
PERSONAL GUARANTEE. See, Composite Exhibit "D."
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppas,
7850 146ih Street• Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 330I6•Tel(305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198676
Mani-nod!, et. al. v. Kobaltek, inc., et at
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 11 of 24
59. On or about September 8, 2010, Defendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM
converted to their own use the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE that was then the property of
PLAINTIFFS of the value of ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($100,000.00). See,
Exhibit "A."
60. PLAINTIFFS have made several demands for the return of the property or the
value thereof, however, such demands have been futile, and Defendants, DANIELS and
MILLENNIUM remain in possession of said property.
61. PLAINTIFFS were damaged as a result of Defendants, DANIELS and
MILLENNIUM's wrongful retention of SUBJECT MERCHANDISE in an amount no less than
ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($100,000.00), not including interest and attorneys'
fees and costs.
62. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM's
wrongful retention of SUBJECT MERCHANDISE, the PLAINTIFFS were required to retain the
services of the undersigned attorney to recover this debt.
WHEREFORE Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI, JR.,
and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, demand a judgment
against the Defendants, MILLENNIUM LOCK INC., d/b/a ULTIMATE LOCK SYSTEMS, a
Texas Corporation, and RON DANIELS, individually, for damages in an amount exceeding
ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($100,000.00), prejudgment interest, and a jury trial
on all issues triable.
The Law Office of Michael I Reppas,...
7850-. 146th Sueet• Suite 501 • Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tel(305)822.8422•Pax(30S)822.3155
EFTA01198677
Manfredi, ei. at. v. Kobairek, Inc., a at.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 12 of 24
COUNT II - CIVIL THEFT PURSUANT TO FLA. STAT. 4'772.11
(AGAINST DEFENDANTS DANIELS AND MILLENNIUM)
63. PLAINTIFFS repeat and re-allege paragraphs I through 54, as if fully set forth
herein.
64. As previously stated herein, on February 15, 2010, and February 24, 2010,
Plaintiffs, Ernesto LIEBSTER and MANFREDI SR., respectively, purchased the SUBJECT
MERCHANDISE from Defendants, MILLENNIUM and DANIELS, and executed a personal
guarantee as co-guarantors, for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE in the amount of ONE
HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($100,000.00). See, Exhibit "A."
65. As previously stated heroin, PLAINTIFFS paid all amounts due for the SUBJECT
MERCHANDISE pursuant to the PERSONAL GUARANTEE by or before May 3, 2010. See,
Composite Exhibit "D."
66. Accordingly, the PLAINTIFFS had a legally recognized property interest in the
SUBJECT MERCHANDISE
67. As previously stated herein, on or around September 8, 2010, Defendants,
DANIELS and MILLENNIUM obtained the PLAINTIFF's SUBJECT PROPERTY with a
felonious intent to commit a theft and permanently deprive PLAINTIFFS' of their rights to and
benefit of said property.
68. The value of said property was ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS
($100,000.00). See, Exhibit "A."
69. As previously stated herein, Defendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM,
wrongfully and illegally converted the SUBJECT PROPERTY from the DTS warehouse in
Miami-Dade County, Florida, and took it across state lines to their facilities in Houston, Texas.
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppas,..
7850 146th Steel* Suite 501. Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tel(305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198678
Manfredi, et at v. Kobakek, Inc., et at
Plaintiff's Complain(
Page 13 of 24
70. PLAINTIFFS were injured by Defendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM's
violation of §812.014 of the Florida Statutes (2013).
71. On or around November 2012, PLAINTIFFS made a formal demand for the value
of the SUBJECT PROPERTY to no avail.
72. As a result ofDefendants, DANIELS and MILLENNIUM's actions, and pursuant
to §772.11 of the Florida Statutes (2013), PLAINTIFFS are entitled to treble damages and
reasonable attorneys' fees and court costs.
WHEREFORE Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI, JR.,
and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, demand a judgment
against the MILLENNIUM LOCK INC., d/b/a ULTIMATE LOCK SYSTEMS, a Texas
Cosporation, and RON DANIELS, for treble damages in the amount of THREE HUNDRED
THOUSAND DOLLARS ($300,000.00) pursuant to Fla. Stat. §772.I I , prejudgment interest, an
award of attorneys' fees and costs incurred as a result of bringing this action, and a jury trial on
all issues triable.
COUNT UT - CONVERSION
(AGAINST DEFENDANTS KOBALTEK, BAYSINGER AM) JOSEPH TITONE)
73. PLAINTIFFS repeat and re-allege paragraphs 1 through 54, as if fully set forth
herein.
74. On or about June 14, 2011, Defendants, KOBALEK, BAYSINGER, AND
JOSEPH TITONE, converted to their own use settlement funds that were then the property of
PLAINTIFFS of the value ofTWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00).
75. PLAINTIFFS have made several demands for the settlement funds, however, such
demands have been futile, and DEFENDANTS remain in possession of said property.
The Law Office ofMichael J. Reppas,
7850.. I46° Street• Suite 501• Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tel(305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198679
Manfredi, et. at v. Kobakek, Inc., a al.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 14 of 24
76. PLAINTIFFS were damaged as a result of DEFENDANTS' wrongful retention of
said settlement funds in the amount of TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00),
not including interest and attorneys' fees and costs.
77. As a direct and proximate result of DEFENDANTS' wrongful retention of said
settlement funds, the PLAINTIFFS were required to retain the services of the undersigned
attomcy to recover this debt.
WHEREFORE Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI, JR.,
and ALEXANDER LIBESTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, demand a judgment
against the Defendants, KOBALTEK, INC., an inactive Florida Corporation, DARREN
BAYSINOER, individually, and JOSEPH TITONE, Individually, for damages in the amount no
less than TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00), prejudgment interest, and a
jury trial on all issues triable.
COUNT W - CONSPIRACY
(AGAINST DEFENDANTS BAYSINGER AND JOSEPH TITONE)
78. PLAINTIFFS repeat and re-allege paragraphs I through 54, as if fully set forth
herein.
79. As previously stated herein, Defendants, BAYSINGER and JOSEPH TITONE,
conspired against PLAINTIFFS by doing the following overt acts in furtherance of their
conspiracy:
A. by conspiring to divert potential insurance proceeds for the theft of PLAITNIFP's
SUBJECT MERCHANDISE from DTS's warehouse;
B. by forming Defendant, KOBALTEK, on or around September 29, 2010, for the
purposes of using such entity as the Plaintiff in the wrongful lawsuit filed against
DTS;
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppas,
7850.. 146th Street• Suite 501• Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•TeK305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198680
.e•
Manfredi, el. at. v. Kobaltek, Inc., a at.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 15 of 24
C. by BAYSINGER's soliciting and hiring Defendants JOSEPH TITONE without
the PLAINTIFFS' knowledge or approval, and despite their absolute protest about
doing so;
D. by JOSEPH T1TONE'S representation of the PLATNTIFF's company and assets
without their knowledge or consent;
E. by conspiring to knowingly, wrongfully, falsely and maliciously make statements
to DALEY, and wrongfully informing DALEY that JOSEPH TITONE was
representing Plaintiffs, MANFREDI SR and LIEBSTER against DTS regarding
the stolen SUBJECT PROPERTY;
F. by conspiring to knowingly, wrongfully, falsely and maliciously request that
DALEY issue a new purchase order for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE to "add
his name to the contact line and 'white out' Mr. Liebster's name," as such would
"hold 'more credibility' and show standing in this case [against DTS];"
G. by filing a lawsuit against DTS on October 29, 2010, seeking compensation for
the theft of the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE belonging to PLAINTIFFS from the
DTS warehouse without the knowledge or consent of the PLAINTIFFS;
H. approaching PLAINTIFFS FIVE (5) months after having already wrongfully filed
the lawsuit described in the preceding paragraph, andfor the first timeinforming
PLAINTIFFS that Defendant BAYSING13R had just learned of the theft of the
SUBJECT PROPERTY, and offered to assist PLAINTIFFS in making an
insurance claim against DTS;
The Law Office of Michael L Reppas,
7850 N.W. 1466 Streets Suite 501• Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tel(305)822.8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198681
Manfredi, et at v. Kobatrek, Ine., et at
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page I6 of 24
I. by settling the case for insurance claims against DTS on June 14, 2011, and in
spite of the fact that the PLAINTIFFS had no knowledge that such lawsuit had
been filed in the first place;
J. by informing PLAINTIFFS, in or around July 2011, of Defendant
BAYSINGER's intention to solicit the assistance of JOSEPH TITONE in the
recovery efforts against DTS, all the while having already known of JOSEPH
TITONE's involvement in same, and having known of sante already having been
settled;
K. by informing PLAINTIFFS, in or around August 2011, that DTS offered to settle
the matter for FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($5,000.00), despite the fact that
Defendants had already filed a lawsuit against DTS, and settled same for
TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00), Jive times the amount
relayed to the PLAINTIFFS;
L. by intentionally misinforming PLAINTIFFS, in September 2011, that he was able
to secure a FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($5,000.00) settlement from DTS, but
that same was needed to compensate JOSEPH TITONE for his services;
M. by failing to provide PLAINTIFFS with a copy of any documents whatsoever
reflecting the settlement with DTS regarding the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE;
N. by directing DTS to deposit the settlement funds into ANTHONY TITUNE's
Trust Account;
O. by perpetuating multiple frauds upon the PLAINTIFFS, DTS, and the Court in the
lawsuit against DTS, by altering documents to establish standing in said case;
The Law Office of ivfichsel L Reppas,W
7850 M. 146th Street. Suitc 501. Miami Lakes, EL • 33016•Tel(305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198682
Manfredi, et. at v. Kohn!Wk. Inc., a al.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 17 of 24
P. by otherwise conspiring to knowingly, wrongfully and illegally alter documents
and submit same to the Court for purposes of obtaining a settlement from DTS;
Q. conspiring to obtain and retain the settlements amounts received from the lawsuit
against DTS; and
R. by otherwise conspiring against the Plaintiffs as described with particularity in
paragraphs I tbmugh 54 above.
80. PLAINTIFFS were damaged as a direct and proximate result of Defendants,
BAYSINGER and JOSEPH TITONE's conspiracy for the amount of TWENTY-FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00), not including interest and attorneys' fees and costs.
81. As a direct and proximate result of BAYSINGER and JOSEPH TITONE's
conspiracy, the PLAINTIFFS were required to retain the services of the undersigned attorney to
recover the settlement amount.
WHEREFORE Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI, JR.,
and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, demand a judgment
against the Defendants, DARREN BAYSINGER, individually, and JOSEPH TITONE,
individually, for damages in the amount of TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS
($25,000.00), prejudgment interest, and a jury trial on all issues triable.
COUNT V - FRAUD
(AGAINST DEFENDANTS KOBALTEK, BAYSINGER AND JOSEPH TITONE)
82. PLAINTIFFS repeat and re-allege paragraphs l through 54, as if fully set forth
herein.
83. In or around September, and October 2010, and unbeknownst to PLAINTIFFS,
Defendant JOSEPH TITONE contacted DALEY, and knowingly, wrongfully and falsely
The Law Office ofMichael L Reppas,
7850 146th Street• Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 33016sTel(305)822-8422•Fax(303)822-3155
EFTA01198683
Manfredi, et al. v. Koh°lick, Inc., cl al.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 18 of 24
misrepresented to DALEY that JOSEPH TITONE was defending Plaintiffs, MANFREDI SR and
LIEBSTER against DTS regarding the stolen SUBJECT PROPERTY. See, Exhibit "G."
84. In or around September and October 2010, and unbeknownst to PLAINTIFFS,
and in furtherance of their conspiracy, Defendant BAYSINGER requested that DALEY Issue a
new purchase order for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE to "add his name to the contact line and
`white out' Mr. Liebster's name."Id.
85. Defendant BAYSINGER further told DALEY that JOSEPH TITONE believed
that this new purchase order would "hold 'more credibility' and show standing in this case
(against DTS]."Id.
86. On or around October 29. 2010, Defendant KOBALTEK, via Defendant
BAYSINGER and represented by Defendant JOSEPH TITONE, knowingly, wrongfully and
falsely misrepresented to the Circuit Court of Miami-Dade County that same had standing to file
a lawsuit against DTS seeking compensation for the theft of the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE
belonging to PLAINTIFFS from the DTS warehouse.
87. In an effort to establish standing, Defendants KOBALTEK, BAYSINGER and
JOSEPH TITONE wrongfully and illegally altered documents and submitted same to the Court.
88. In or around March 2011, and over FIVE (5) months after having filed the lawsuit
described in the preceding paragraph, Defendant BAYSINGER knowingly, wrongfhlly and
falsely misrepresented to PLAINTIFFS that he had just learned of the theft of the SUBJECT
PROPERTY, and offered to assist PLAINTIFFS make an insurance claim against DTS.
89. In or around August 2011 despite having already filed a lawsuit against DTS and
settled with same for TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00), BAYSINGER
The Law Office ofMichael J. Rquiss,..
7850 I46i° Street* Suite 501. Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Te1(305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198684
Manfredi, et al. v. Kobatisk, Inc., et at.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 19 of 24
knowingly, wrongfully and falsely misrepresented to PLAINTIFFS that DTS offered to settle the
matter for FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($5,000.00).
90. In or around September 2011, in furtherance of their conspiracy, and despite
having already filed a lawsuit against DTS and settled same, BAYSINGER informed
PLATTNIFFS that they were able to recover FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($5,000.00) from
DTS but deeded said funds to compensate JOSEPH TITONE.
91. BAYSINGER and JOSEPH TITONE made such misrepresentation intending for
DTS and the CIRCUIT COURT OF MIAMI-DADE COUNTY to rely on such
misrepresentations, ultimately, to the detriment of the PLAINTIFFS and DTS.
92. PLAINTIFFS were damaged as a result of DALEY, the CIRCUIT COURT OP
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY and DTS' reliance on said misrepresentations, in an amount not less
than TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00), not including not including
interest and attorneys' fccs and costs.
93. As a direct and proximate result of DEFENDANTS' wrongful conduct, the
PLAINTIFFS were required to retain the services of the undersigned attorney to recover this
debt.
WHEREFORE Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI, JR.,
and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Emesto Licbstcr, demand a judgment
against the Defendants, KOBALTEK, INC., an inactive Florida Corporation, DARREN
BAYSINGER, individually, and JOSEPH TITONE, individually, for damages in the amount no
less than TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00), prejudgment interest, and a
jury trial on all issues triable.
The Law Office ofMichael 1, Reppas,
7850 M. 1460, Siftel• Suite 5010 Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Te1(305)822-8422•Fex(305)822-3155
EFTA01198685
Mattfredl, et al. v. Kobahek, Inc., a al.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 20 of 24
COUNT VI - BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY
(AGAINST DEFENDANT JOSEPH TITONE)
94. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges paragraphs I through 54, as if fully set forth
herein.
95. JOSEPH TITONE is an attorney licensed to practice in the State of Florida and,
accordingly, is required to comply with the Florida Bar Rules of Professional Conduct.
96. The Florida Bar Rules of Professional Conduct impose upon JOSEPH TITONE,
and all attorneys licensed in the State, with a fiduciary duty to all individuals and entities they
represent.
97. JOSEPH TITONE was not retained by or authorized to act as an attorney for the
Plaintiffs with respect to the action styled as: Kobaltek Inc. v. DTS Direct Mail & Fulfillment
SVCS. Inc., Fla., I I Cir., Case No.: 2010-58137-CA-01. See, Exhibit "H."
98. JOSEPH TITONE falsely represented to DTS and the Court, that he was counsel
for the Plaintiffs in the case he prosecuted and, ultimately, settled; to wit: Kobaltek, Inc. v. DTS
Direct Mail & Fulfillment SVCS, Inc., Fla., 11'a Cir., Case No.: 2010-58137-CA-01. See, Exhibit
99. JOSEPH TITONE wrongfully acquired and thereafter abused his fiduciary role as
counsel for the Plaintiffs, by taking unconscionable advantage of the Plaintiffs, to their great
detriment, by performing the acts identified below, inter alio :
A. by conspiring to divert potential insurance proceeds for the theft of PLAITNIFF's
SUBJECT MERCHANDISE from DTS's warehouse;
B. by forming KOBALTEK, on or around September 29, 2010, for the purposes of
using such entity as the Plaintiff in the wrongful lawsuit filed against DTS;
The Law Office ofMichael J. Reppas, •
1850 M. 146th Street• Suite 501• Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tek305)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198686
Manfredi. et at v. Kobahek, hie., el at
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 21 of 24
C. by representing the PLAINTIFF's company and assets without their knowledge or
consent;
D. by conspiring to knowingly, wrongfully, falsely and maliciously request that
DALEY issue a new purchase order for the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE to "add
his name to the contact line and 'white out' Mr. Liebster's name," as such would
"hold 'more credibility' and show standing in this case [against WS),"
E. by filing a lawsuit against DTS on October 29, 2010, seeking compensation for
the theft of the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE belonging to PLAINTIFFS from the
DTS warehouse without the knowledge or consent of the PLAINTIFFS;
F. by settling the case for insurance claims against DTS on June 14, 2011, and in
spite of the fact that the PLAINTIFFS had no knowledge that such lawsuit had
been filed in the first place;
G. by conspiring with BAYS1NGER to infonn PLAINTIFFS, in or around July
2011, of BAYSINGER's intention to solicit the assistance of JOSEPH TITONE
in the recovery efforts against DTS, knowing of the prior unauthorized
representation in said suit and having known of same already having been settled;
H. by informing PLAINTIFFS, in or around August 2011, that DTS offered to settle
the matter for FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS (S5,000.00), despite the fact that
Defendants had already filed a lawsuit against DTS, and settled same for
TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00),five limes the amount
relayed to the PLAINTIFFS;
The Law Office of Michael J. Reppaalg
7850. 146th Streets Suite SOl• Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Teff30.5)822-8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198687
Manfredi, et at v. gobakek, Inc., et al
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 22 of 24
1. by intentionally misinforming PLAINTIFFS, in September 2011, that he was able
to secure a FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($5,000.00) settlement from MS, but
that same was needed to compensate JOSEPH TITONE for his services;
J. by failing to provide PLAINTIFFS with a copy of any documents whatsoever
reflecting the settlement with DTS regarding the SUBJECT MERCHANDISE;
K. by directing DTS to deposit the settlement funds into ANTHONY TITONE's
Trust Account;
L. by perpetuating multiple frauds upon the PLAINTIFFS, DTS, and the Court in the
lawsuit against DTS;
M. by altering and falsifying documents to establish standing in said case;
N. by self-dealing;
O. by converting funds belonging to others;
P. failing to hold in trust the property of others;
Q. by otherwise conspiring to knowingly, wrongfully and illegally alter documents
and submit same to the Court for purposes of obtaining a settlement from DTS;
R. conspiring to obtain and retain the settlements amounts received from the lawsuit
against DTS; and
S. by otherwise conspiring against the Plaintiffs as described with particularity in
paragraphs I through 54 above.
100. PLAINTIFFS were damaged as a direct and proximate result of JOSEPH
TITONE's breach of fiduciary duty in the amount of TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS
($25,000.00), not including interest and attorneys' fees and costs.
The Law Office ofMichael J. Reppas, •
7850 146th Street• Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Te1(305)822.8422•Fax(305)822-3155
EFTA01198688
Manfredi, et at v. Kobaliek, Inc., et al.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 21of 24
101. As a direct and proximate result of JOSEPH TITONE's breach of fiduciary duty,
the PLAINTIFFS were required to retain the services of the undersigned attorney to recover this
debt.
WHEREFORE Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI, JR.,
and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, demand a judgment
against the Defendant, JOSEPH TITONE, individually, for damages in the amount no less than
TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00), prejudgmenynterest, and a jury trial
on all issues triable.
COUNT VII — CIVIL THEFT PURSUANT TO FLA. STAT. 6772.11
(AGAINST DEFENDANTS KOBALTEK, BAYSINGER AND JOSEPH TITONE)
102. PLAINTIFF repeats and re-alleges paragraphs 1 through 54, and as if fully set
forth herein.
103. Tis is an action for Civil Theft pursuant to Ha. Stat. §772.11(2013).
104. Defendants, KOBALTEK, BAYSINGER, and JOSEPH TITONE, committed
theft, pursuant to Fla. Stat. §812.014 (2013), by knowingly obtaining TWENTY FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS ($25,000.00) from the PLAINTIFFS in the form of settlement funds
that were then the property of the PLAINTIFFS with the felonious intent to permanently deprive
PLAINTIFF of its right to said property and to appropriate PLAINTIFF'S property to
DEFENDANTS' own use.
105. PLAINTIFF has complained with all conditions precedent to this claim as
required by Fla. Stat. §772.11 (2013).
106. As a direct and proximate result DEFENDANTS' feloniously intentional theft,
PLAINTIFF was required to retain the services of the undersigned attorney to recover this debt.
The Law Office ofMichael J. Reppas,
2850M. l4ek Street• Suite 501• Miami Lakes, PL. • 33016•Tet(305)822.8422•Fax(305)822.3155
EFTA01198689
Manfredi, ci. at. v. ICobaltek, Inc., et al.
Plaintiff's Complaint
Page 24 of 24
WHEREFORE Plaintiffs, KENNETH MANFREDI, SR., KENNETH MANFREDI, JR.,
and ALEXANDER LIEBSTER, as trustee for the Estate of Ernesto Liebster, demand a judgment
against the Defendants, KOBALTEK, INC., an inactive Florida Corporation, DARREN
BAYSINOER, individually, and JOSEPH T1TONE, individually, for treble damages in the
amount of SEVENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($75,000.00) pursuant to Fla. Stat.
§772.11, prejudgment interest, an award of attorneys' fees and costs incurred as a result of
bringing this action, and a jury trial on all issues triable.
Respectfully submitted,
Law Offices of Michael J. Reppas,
Attorneysfor Plaintiffi?
7850 NW 146th Street, Suite 501
Miami Lakes, Florida 33016
Telephone: (305)822-8422
Facsimile: (305)822-3135
By:
Michael J. Reppas II
Florida Bar No. 124702
George C. Palaidis
Florida Bar No. 056666
The Law Office of Michael L Reppas,
7850.. 146" Sweet• Suite 501* Miami Lakes, FL • 33016•Tel(305)822-8422•Fax(305)822.3155
EFTA01198690
eallilenWt P. 1
Feb PS 2010 2103PM DSG HP LRSERJET FRX
nii5Q24111SVABA/ME
ary, 2010.
THIS GUARANTEE dated this 12th day of Febru
ctively the
From; Ernesto Uebster end Kenneth Manfredi, (Colle
Guarantors)
ond Ave.
To: Ron Daniels of Ultimate Lock Systems, 6150 Richm
Houston TX 77057
(The Lender)
Re: Cobalt Corp (The Debtor)
ion, the receipt and
In Consideration of good and valuable considerat
Guarantors jointly
sufficiency of which is hereby ackn0wledged, the
prompt, full and complete
and severally, personally guarantees the
tions of the
pesfermance of any and all existing duties and obliga
indebtedness due to
Debtor to the Lender and payment of any and all
(colle ctivel y the "Deb t") up to a limit of
the lender and the debtor
$50,000. Under the terms of certa in debt agreements (The
and cond itions :
Agreement) and the following terms
ptly pay the
1. The Guarantor guarantees that the Debtor will prom
it becom es due accor ding to
agreed amount of the debt when
ed by the Agree ment hereby
the terms and conditions provid
er or upon accel eratio n of the
acknowledged by the Lend
payment by reason of default.
age, hypothecate or
2. The Guarantor further agrees not to mortg
prior written
transfer any of the Guarantor's assets without the
consent of the Lender.
2OOO units of the
3, The Debt. in question consists of no less then
taalroar rsLg5S Inven tory value d et $100,000.
.of the
4. Additionally the Lender agrees to accept the remainder lete
l or comp
Inventory valued at fifty ($50.) per unit as partia
tions
payment In the event that'the Debtor defaults In the obliga
antor furthe r
of the Agreement for payment of the loan. The Guar
return ing
agrees to pay for shipping and all cost associated with
the Inventory as paym ent of the "Deb t'.
nal
5. In exchange for these considerations, for the above perso Initia l
guarantee, the Lender agrec s to pay the Guar antor s. the
eds of Fifty ($50, 000.) as paym ent for the
gross sales proce
EXHIBIT
N'A 119
• ci XHA 13CSRSO1 dH naa Wdei:8 Ii02 GO Int
EFTA01198691
Fob 25 2010 2:03PM DSG HP LASERJET FAX
wledged by
consulting agreement previously signed and ackno
agreement and so
the terms and conditions stated In that
.
acknowledged by the Lender's signature attached below
to Inspect the
6. The Lender is hereby authorized at any time
e that the terms and
Inventory as the Lender sees fit to Insur
conditions of the loan are being adhered.
ining balance due the
7. The Lender agrees to hold any and all rema
Guarantors In escrow after the Initia l sale or the above
mentioned Inventory until the entire consu lting fee ($5O,OOO) is
in this
paid in full, by that agreement acknowledged here
Personal Guarantee, Fifty Thou sand Dolla r, ($5 O,0OO .)
to comingle the
8. By this agreement the Lender agrees got
ntee
Guarantor's funds associated with this personal guara
for Ultim ate Lock
collected with any of the sales proceeds
Syste ms or Mille nniu m Lock Syste ms inc. These funds
collected are n earmarked for payment of the
Consulting Poo in this Personal Guarantee.
GUARAtfvef
VOA VALUE HEOMVED, the undersigned hereby guara guarantee earmlutely end
the within person al ntee and agree to pay
uncondlUonelly prompt payment of d or paid by the Lander in the
all wet of collection and attorn eys' fees, Inahre
Wieder' and/or enforcemept at said guaran tee and the enforcement of this
guarantee.
Signatures:
cen .45t-nkA : 660
OATS
tender
onswpr
4/643srag. TA -no- /0
C
*Q1)/(t-ria DATE
GUAIIAKTI3R
a•d XUd 13C2IRSU1 dH SaU MACIIZ i10a L0 Inc
EFTA01198692
Statement of Rolando Martinez regarding the transportation of the stolen locks
from the DTS Warehouse 5800 Miami Lakes DR, Miami Florida 33014
CASE # PD111027430601 THEFT REPORT
Sergeant Ruesga
MIAMI-DADE POLICE DEPARTMENT
April 20, 2012
I am over the age of 21 and have personal knowledge of the matter set forth herein:
To the best of my knowledge and as an employee of Millennium Lock and Ron Daniels,
it was requested of me to take a truck and go to Miami from Houston to the DTS
Warehouse where Ernesto Liebster had 2000 model 4000 Ultimate Locks stored and
present them with documents supplied by Ron Daniels. I had originally loaded the 2000
units for shipping when they purchased the locks from Daniels warehouse in Houston
and was asked to unload the locks when he received them back in his warehouse after
they retumed to Houston. This Is how I know he has the original locks sold to them.
This request was made on or about September 6, 2010 a few days after the death of Mr.
Llebster. As a person who has worked with Mr. Daniels and knew of the sale of these
locks to Mr. Manfredi and Mr. Liebster I refused to take pad in this request. I believed
that they, Manfredi and Liebster, had purchased the locks and that Mr. Daniels no longer
had ownership of these locks. I believed this because Manfredi and Liebster had
arranged shipping for the model 4000 locks to their warehouse some month earlier and
were seliklg these locks to their contacts in Jamaica.
As I told Agent Dillon of the Houston Bureau of the FBI, in July of 2011, I did not want to
be pad of any theft charges that may arise as a result of this action. Also I felt taking
these locks across state lines could result in a Federal Felony charge and wanted no
part of what Daniels had planned. After this I found out that he hired a trucking company
to pick up the locks from that warehouse and made Manfredi aware of his actions.
Mr. Manfredi and Mr. Liebster were planning to buy tho remaining model 4000 inventory
from Daniels as per their conversations that I witnessed by being in their company on
many occasions during their time with Daniels discussing their international business. It
was also my belief that Ron Daniels had no ownership or partnership with Liebster or
Manfredi based on those same conversations and Ron Daniels wanting to liquidate this
old inventory for some time. I did witness the personal guarantees that they signed for
the inventory and felt that they were the legal owners of this merchandise.
I can be contacted for additional information on my knowledge of this event given freely
and with my consent this day of April, 2012
Rolando Martinez
EFTA01198693
Menu - Schedule A
Kobaltek, Inc. Description of Services
and Pricing Schedule
Product Receiving
:lb receive materials, verify quality
andquantity, add to physical inventory,
add to computer Inventory, and notifr client 813.00 per pallet
(or part thereof)
(IfSolid containers are received, addS10
per pallet breakdown charge)
Order input from fax or other bard copy, if not electronic file
$1.25 per order
Order Processing including download offies in an
electronic-compatibleformat, printing
Pick & pack slip, pickpack and quality check
operations andshipping I prepackaged item,
(Does not include any shopping cart or
credit cardprocessingfunctions) $1.95 per order
Option: If additional items are included in same order
. oddper item (not boxed) 51.00 each item
Bulk Orders: Pre-packed Cartons
Includespick & pack slip, pulling pre-packaged
Carton, andpreparing labelfor shipment. $4.95 per box
Pallet Orders: Pre-packed Cartons
Includes pick & pack slip, pullingpalletised
cartons, andpreparing labelfor shipment. $45.00/pallet
Pallet Storage:
Storage in our secured warehouse,
including monthly inventory report. $24.50 per pallet per month
Returns
Handled complete $4.95 each
leroductPackacinglqateriaLswhiaineeded Cost plus 20%
W/7010 EXHIBIT
zone abed 900a
I 'c SUT1130 LO:Zi LOOZ/OE/TO
EFTA01198694
Menu - Schedule A
Shipping Carrier Charges
Client will provide r i party billing information
$200 Postage trustfor PO Box Shipments
NOTE: No COD Orders or Shipments will be processed
Kitting & Assembly
Ta be quoted on an as-needed basis,
Reporting: Standard Monthly Reports No Charge
Monthly Service Minimum $250.00
Set Up Fee $250.00
(Excluding Computer Programming)
Monthly Coordination & Database Management Fee $200.00
Trust Postage/Freight
An advance trial account Is required to cover an estimated 0 weeks ofusage, unless third
party billing. This will be audited and adjusted on an on-going basis.
Recycling
To take existing inventory and chummier or recycle. S 50.00 per pallet
(or part thereof)
Order Processing Times:
Standard Orders areprocessed by end ofnext business day after receipt.
Rush Orders: Every effort will be made to handle RUSHORDERS in the requested
timeframe, however will not be guaranteed.
Average UPS charge for 5 lbs. to Chicago is 57.32 so we recommend you use $14.95 for
shipping and handling for 1 unit and $4.00 per added unit.
Orders will be held in our secured facility and only released upon receipt of an electronic order
file or an email with all details from a pre-authorized individual only.
DTS Direct M & m• lfillmcnt, Inc. Kohaltek, ti d o
Larry ussel orp Ernesto liebster
Date: AAA 240 Date: 1 1O
3nnoto Initial I
Z0/Z0 abed 000% SUIT 130 20:ZI LOOZ/OE/10
EFTA01198695
04/10/12 OS: S6Pli DDG PP ADS p.et
Bank or America I Online Banking I Transaction Image Print Page 1 of 1
Bank of America 4, Online Banking
PLUM PADS ; Chock Imago
Chock Imago:
TY"
ON DPW IAD r iti 1952
PLUM PADS
linaiffikvoinno TIMM
noustOm.nt Mc* SAbOitlig:
64#34 Sheik. r$7tri ;00
/14/2nistqtts
BankoMmorica
Kmonothotain
r ie
in 130000 P1 00001000000e
li If its I. .; 'A
crib aitylook ,....1 -,
53`afg,:t nit trio tonwi).t.n
. t<ntil
4tIblage er-Y
'life
• tit. . !!
Ian 4..• Vii:144 3: 1 I itim4,
illt1 4314V^ LI
•
• ettigetit I _ •
• . • 503001707
https://onlineeast2.bankofamerica.comic,gi-bin/ias/A/17/AccountDetailsCon
EFTA01198696
04/10/12 00: S6P1I DDG PPADS p.02
Bank of America I Unline Banking lir ri Image Print Page 1 of 1 /
Bank of America'. 0' Online Banking
PLUM PADS: Chock Image
Chock Imago:
DEVON (MOP LLA 4.0 1350
DM PLUM KWIS
wow,
144*NOWIIto vItn/110
HataTX MOS
_21/42.4e00, UMW'.
OSP
kvv- rtifi(
84,.
..unat Look_
lk is& '7E j ....
SatifrofAmerica e
AnINI lilat.1611
& 30000 334
i••••••%
u9•
wrepedii
'If
Ae:
1
. . tap13392
t 1:4
04-20.<
State Bank
2010-
ty r: I: r
sI g 90090t101a
I '2 iF "` 9: L-11.•
. ;
• •
hups://onlineeast2.bankoftunerica.com/cgi-bin/ias/A/12/AccountDetailsCon... 10/4/2010
EFTA01198697
Electronic Articles of Incorporation P10000079460
FILED
For September 29, 2010
Sec. Of State
Jshivers
KOBALTEK, INC.
The undersigned incorporator, for the purpose of funning a Florida
profit corporation, hereby adopts the following Articles of Incorporation:
Article I
The name of the corporation is:
KOBALTEK, INC.
Article II
The principal place of business address:
1830381 PINES BLVD
#1
PEMBROKE PINES, FL. 33029
The mailing address of the corporation is:
18331 PINES BLVD
#108
PEMBROKE PINES, FL. 33029
Article III
The purpose for which this corporation is organized is:
ANY AND ALL LAWFUL BUSINESS.
Article IV
The number of shares the corporation is authorized to issue is:
500
Article V
The name and Florida sheet address of the registered agent is:
ADVANTIUM GROUP VENTURES, LLC
18331 PINES BLVD
#108
PEMBROKE PINES, FL. 33029
EFTA01198698
I certify that I am familiar with and accept the responsibilities of P10000079460
registered agent. FILED
September 29, 2010
Sec. Of State
Registered Agent Signature: DARREN BAYSINGER Jshivers
Article VI
The name and address of the incorporator is:
ADVANTIUM GROUP VENTURES, LLC
18331 PINES BLVD
/108
PEMBROKE PINES, FL 33029
Incorporator Signature: AVANTIUM GROUP VENTURES
Article VII
The initial officer(s) and/or director(s) of the corporation is/are:
Title: P
ADVANTIUM GROUP VENTURES
18331 PINES BLVD, #108
PEMBROKE PINES, FL. 33029
Article VIII
The effective date for this corporation shall be:
09/22/2010
EFTA01198699
04/27/2012 14:51 5614328891 UPS STORE 3523 PAGE 01/01
Kenneth Manfredi
1449 Heights Blvd, #111
Houston, TX 77008
Attention Mr. Kenneth Manfredi
RE: Joseph J Titone; RFA No.12.16
211
April 23, 2012
Dear Mr. Manfredi:
I read your Florida Bar complaint. RE: no.
above, and have the following to offer as
what took place between Mr. Baysinger and to
Mr. Titone after Ernesto Liebster's deat
have the following recollection of the facts h. I
as
regarding Kobaltek Inc, Emesto's Company they relate to my conversation with them
, end reference PO #00987345:
After Mr. Liebster's death I received a call from
Mr. Titone requesting a copy of the PO
above, for which I sent to Titone's partner Darren Bay
representing Mrs. Liebster arid Mr. Menfrtwi singer. He said that he was
l In a case for damages for the missing locks
they had stored in a warehouse in Miami.
He further went on to explain that he was
working with Mr. Baysinger who was help
ing Manfredi and Llebster gather information
for a deposition with DTS, the warehouse In
Miami. Upon receiving the PO Mr.
Baysinger requested that I add his name
to the contact line and white out" Mr. I .iebs
name. He specifically stated that Mr. ter's
Thong said it would hold "more credibility' and
show standing in this case, if I altered the
PO to reflect Raysinger's name instead of
Liebster's name on the PO for the mod
el 4000 Millennium Lock we were selling
Jamaica. The copy of the PO you sent me is the in
name as the contact and any copy after original, clearly showing Liebster's
this one would be a counterfeit.
i felt it dishonest to accommodate Mr.
Titone and Mr. Baysinger in their request for
altered documents and so refused to do
so. Any and all documents that I had in this
matter were signed by Mr. Liebster and any
and
with Mr.Manfredl or Mr. Llebster. I did not know all conversations prior to his death were
never mentioned his name as a confect who Mr. Baysinger was and Mr. Uebster
for this order. I did know of Mr. Titone base
my previous residence in Ft Lauderda d on
le and his history of being disbarred in the early
1990's. I did not know he was still prac
ticing law in the State of Florida until I rece
call about the documents in question. ived his
The above statement is of my own feel
the circumstances that I personal will and as per your request for my reco
ly witnessed as the sates agent for Mr. Lleb llection of
concerning this order and the events that ster
available for any questions you may needfollowed with Mr. Titone end Mr. Liebster. I am
this PO we had for the sale of the lock concerning my business with Mr. Lleb
s to Jamaica. ster and
Sincerely,
Sherman Daley
EXHIBIT
gip
EFTA01198700
0 Item(s) in Basket Home Online Services About us Contact us
HARVEY RUM
oflfie COURTS
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
Civil / Probate Justice System - Docket Information
BACILICISEAtiCaRESLILIS All PARTIPS START A NFUtiSPARCH
KOBALTEK INC vs D T S DIRECT MAIL & FULFILLMENT SVCS INC
'Glick on BOOKIPAGE of a particular docket to coo the Imago it it Is avallabIe •
Case Number (LOCAL): 2010-58137-CA-01 Dockets Retrieved: 30 Filing Date: 10/29/2010
Case Number STATE : 13-2010-CA-058137-0000-01 Judicial Section: 02
Date Book/Page Docket Entry Comments
08/1412012 ORDER: TO DISMISS FOR LACK OF PROSECUTION
2Rlaj /UST
05/25/2012 VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL BK:28131 PG:3467 DN01
Pe0e4 I
04/26/2012 FWOP NOTICE GENERATED 08/07/2012 03:00 PM
05/24/2011 TEXT AM. WITNESS LIST
NOTICE OF ANSWER TO
05/24/2011
INTERROGATORIES
_3/12/2011 NOTICE OF INTERROGATORY
05/02/2011 EXI IIBIT LIST PLAINTIFF
05/02/2011 WITNESS LIST PN01
05/02/2011 WITNESS LIST PN01 EXPERT
04/22/2011 RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR
PRODUCTION
04/19/2011 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION
04/05/2011 ORDER SEEING NON-JURY TRIAL 07/26/2011 02:00 PM
RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR
04/04/2011
PRODUCTION
04/04/2011 ORDER: ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR DEFAULT
03/10/2011 ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE ATTORNEY:00203882 PN01
03/1012011 NOTICE OF JURY TRIAL :M
03/09/2011 REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
02/23/2011 ANSWER ATTORNEY:00882186 ON01
02/22/2011 SUBPOENA RETURNED
02/112011 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION
`2/11/2011 ORDER: AGREED ORDER SETTING ASIDE
DEFAULT
01/31./2011 NOTICE HEARI MOTIONS 02/09/2011 10:00 AM
EXHIBIT RDER GRANTING MOTION FOR
01/14/2011 ORDER: 1 %% 41 if
DEFAULT
EFTA01198701
r01103/2011 ORDER OF DEFAULT DN01
12/10/2010 MOTION FOR DEFAULT
11/05/2010 SERVICE RETURNED BADGE # 1570 P 10/29/2010 DN01
3/29/2010 DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
10/29/2010 SUMMONS ISSUED ON01
10/29/2010 CIVIL COVER
10129/2010 COMPLAINT
WA< SFARCH RFCIII TA al I PARTIES START A WRIA/ CFARe.H
CLIALSAAttbii000AI CilliaCMIAJALOURaliAn I EMAIL I beat
Hole I 111rAney getPtrIPat 1 01,1%ifne ir,nlar% II% I Aamit tIs littn DAD
2008 Cleh of the Cowl. All MOW iesamed.
30141755
EFTA01198702
\-C.
IN TIM CIRCUIT COM 01%
URANIA% MICK, mum IR
MAD VOR DADE COWIN 31,01,41*
PLAINIIWINS),
GENERAL JURISDICTION DIVISION
vs.
t 6/itel I r/Witi CASE NO.: 1O4 56 LA
Wft&E'
MEDIATOR'S REPORT AND
-161Aer DEFENDANT(S), SETTLEMINT AGREEMENT (CIVIL)
FLORIDA DAR NO.: 354929
This Civil action being referred to Mediation by Stipulation of the Parties pursuant to P.S.
44.1101-102 and th applicable INIMI and being heard before the undersigned Mediator on
the I y day of 201 I.
The Parties stipulate and agree to the following matters and/or Issues:
SEE EXHIBIT "A" ATTACHED IlEftETO AND INCORPORATED HEREIN
Plaintiff(s) agrees to execute any Release form generally required to be executed In
settlements of disputesof this nature. Each party shall bear their respective attorney's fee and
costs.
00
Plaintiff(s) and, counsel agree to PrtunpUy pay outstanding mediation, few of 371_
tje
Defendunt(s) and counsel agree to promptly pay outstanding mediation fees of tr.; D
All manors raised at the conference remain privileged, unless otherwise agreed to by all parties.
Dated this it day of _jag__ , 201.L.
Lvauric L, Riemer, Esquire, Mediator/Arbitrator
The foregoing report and agreement is stipulated and agreed to by the undersigned.
Defendant(s)
Plaintiff(s) Counsel Defendant(s) Cou
Dated this a day of I tAA-C 201 t Dated this _Bday of 2011
Copies to Counsel ( b //y. / 11 )
EXHIBIT
%% of
I0 •d SaVold eau s
EFTA01198703
( Jr
N m. LA 01
Er-zgi• /
171- p
47 .0
1 40,
*•
drCS
ca I ene.,th
r M74,
tat seire, Ek-arY 7c. -
teXtbeter .474 avv•Vtite 1e-7:17-Je rp
arm 4 tOr
VT— vas
ge'd LOOLLSEtt, emu MY Wang ///// tee
EFTA01198704
Rpr 1.1 2013 11231311 Anthon1 J T1Lone ESO. 9543456633 P• 1
-SSW/OP? ,.%24nsb
ATTORNEY AND COUNSELOR AT LAW
111931 N. UNIVERSITY DRIVE
SUITE 101
CORAL SPRINGS, FLORIDA 33007
CIVIL TRIAL LAWYER TELErtioNE (01:14) 345.0055 FLORIDA BAR 1071
CERTIFIED MEDIATOR FACSIMILE (004) 3450633 NEW YORK DAR 1070
CERTIFIED ARBITRATOR appabasoUth.nel PV.DERAL BAR 1974
TRIAL BAR 1983
April 11, 2013
Michael J. Reppas II Esq.
7850 NW 146'h Street
Suite 501
Miami Lakes FL 33016 SENT BY FAX AND REGULAR MAIL
Re: your file #2071-001
Dear Mr. Reppas,
Find herewith my affidavit and all my records attached thereto as you
requested In yours of April 11, 2013. Call me if you have any questions.
Sincerely yours,
Anthony J. Titone
EXH(BJT
im post 4r,
VISIT OUR WED SITE AT: tWAILSROMOV51011CLSOrn
EFTA01198705
.npr 11 2013 1:29PM Finthonu J Titono ESQ. 9543456633 p.2
AFFIDAVIT OF ANTHONY TITONE
State of Florida
County of Broward
That I Anthony Titone state under oath the following:
1. That I have continuously been a member of the Florida Bar since 1971.
2. That I am a sole practitioner with offices in Coral Springs Florida. My
practice consists of civil litigation work along with my work as a certified
mediator and a qualified arbitrator. I have maintained my own trust account
since the beginning of my practice. My brother Joe Is also a lawyer; his
practice Is mostly on criminal cases and he does not have a trust account.
3. Of the parties set forth in the draft complaint under file #2071-001, I
know Kenneth Manfredi Sr., Darrin Baysinger and my brother Joe. I have
no knowledge of the business transactions alleged in the draft and did not
participate in any way in the alleged transactions or the underlining lawsuit
that is described in the draft complaint.
4. I did not assist Joe Titone In his representation of Mr. Baysinger or
Kobaltek in the litigation with DTS.
5. I first became aware of the Kobaltek/DTS litigation when my brother
Joe(in June of 2011) asked me if it was ok to use my trust account for the•
distribution of any settlement proceeds from said lawsuit. I said It would be
ok as long as his client agreed.
6. On June 24, 2011 I deposited the settlement proceeds ($25,000.00) into
my trust account and set up a trust account ledger for the deposit. See
attached exhibits.
7. On July 1, 2011.1 met with both Joe and Darrin and distributed to them
EFTA01198706
llpr 11 2013 1:25PM HrithonN J Tltone ESO. 5543456633 p.3
the entire settlement proceeds of $25,000.00. See aftached copies of
checks #1495 and 1496 accordingly. Both checks cleared for payment
from my trust account on my July 2011 statement,
8. That In late January 2012 I received the attached correspondence from
Cristina Liebster dated January 23, 2012 (attached to this correspondence
was the mediator's report and settlement agreement entered Into between
Kobaltek & DTS.)
9. I did not respond to Cristina Liebster's correspondence of January 23,
2012 and I did not discuss its contents with my either Joe or Darrin.
10. On April 5, 2013 I received a copy of a draft complaint naming me as a
possible defendant in a lawsuit under file #2071-001.
11. On April 8, 2011 I researched my files and sent my correspondence to
Attorney Reppas dated that same day.
12. I am herein sending this affidavit in response to correspondence
received from attorney Reppas dated April 11, 2013,
13. The above Is all I know regarding this matter and describes my entire
Involvement In the matter.
FURT ER AFFIANT SAITH NAUGHT
Wet -f
Antho Titone FBN139524
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this 11' day of April 2013.
Afflant erionally wn to me.
Notary ublIc St of Florida.
EFTA01198707
EFTA01198708
.... I
ez;
.
i /mu
RAMS
t. .
Th--. a H Crlin rain
0 owns...* cm M.O..
Calarfe IM feta
. ••••R webA. P.I.
•
O % • bi w a.
0 0IX .010...
CURRENCY
INSiW9 sweet t•
manfatans
v, ki lfal .1 .
. . g
3. .... .., • - _ . _ . ...2 2• 42 2g= 2 tt 2. 2.• 2 A 2 2:2. 2 71 :.' 2 NIP"
L
11TOYE ATTORNEY AT LAW BankofAmerica _ _
IOTA TRUST ACCOUNT
7O1WEll OAKLAND PARK SOC.
St.M. I It
Identet 0IC
AcOVI*ovum
se OD
CT. LAUDEROAR. R. ScaIMP]i
9543456633
1:54DS9010E;I: 0036642713729'
I:ITS-EINEM/MLA FULFILLMENT .WWORRAPI CHASE BANK NA 1907
I-22IC
. - -..orseRAmis ACCOUPC
• -200 CIFIME DaVEN0RTN•
Anthonu J Titonc ESQ.
• - •. PISCK:AWAYMJMSC
6432011
_- -*ninony Trtoke-Trust Account
_ . . . .. '25.000.00
- Frye Thousartd44(34C0/100.-^-"•--•••"•••••
••••—••• •—•-•-•-••• ."'"^ "'''' —••- easo.ms 5
" ,te
•••- -Atttirney
OiSouthEastr 5th Street
Pecopeno:Beach.A.. 33060
MEMO
N'OCIL9071' 21000D 2 Li: 13 38-1 2365
C.
C7
N
O
N
L
O.
Apr 11 2013 1:29PM 0mthons J Titone ESQ. 9543456633 p.5
1,
1
757 -- ,- -
I
ci
Z I
t'
t r a---
1...... ..
I i
i(
ts *
i
I., .... .._.1_
1.-4, .•
—.-.‘
I: I
Ct
Iii 11.1 "A
eC
m .
.Z
c
.
i'- i •+., t t
',-...... to ‘:-...N..1...
.....
‘ N..
ti _
Li
.74
li lai
2 ,....y) -
c r••••
ow, Y N •w • • yte mon VOCJOA • MS t 0441 *II
EFTA01198709
flpr 11 2013 1 :;e0PM HnthanH J I ttone Eb0. 9543456633 P• G
•• . ‘.•• • . •• • •••••••
• • I I. eve •••11;•. •
•;-• . •
••• A.•BM, ait • e I. • en.. ••
••••.•• .Ing•••
:st ntia :74t; !••••'". • .
TO I" • • I 7 • •.• • •••• •• g•
...II a
•
• ,
OS • • us I • ?it . .
/14 .,1 1 , • ••
Oran .
1:12.• •.
• . PIN
• •••••. • •• • • no...In sol •.••• • IF•
•
••
.. • ' 1' 1.1...2:1Z: G:w'l•4.
•.• :7 •••,...0•::. • • •• '6
,•,
.•
e ". • •
••,
-^,
• ietect161.FJP-tj.
•
_
•
•••• •••• •••••••••••• •
;ear
,
•
S. .ng. •
• "): • Lo •i •
.ty ;1•1:'•• . _
•••••• •
to • •". ../72.- • • if tern - ▪ •
•••••••••• • .3 s. •
. . :
. •
. . ••••LI*,: oah▪ .. • . •
• • ro..7 r •
` • • • • t. • " • •"" •• •• • •• •
" "*" ""‘"'• • • - • ra
Io• • • • •
" • t.! ' •: 2 • .•'•,
'MS. • Ann • -•.•
.Z.••
•••••••• 'Haan' •••••••"'"•
, • • • ••••
•
`••••• -•::•• 'sr
:•••••••••••.*:
. •. I •
• :• • • . ••
• •
EFTA01198710
npr I I ?013 Anthony 3 Titone ESQ. 9543456633 p.7
.. •”••••••••• ...... ••• •••••
EFTA01198711
Apr 11 2013 1:30PM Anthonu J Tltone ESU. US434SGS33 p.0
Mr. Darren BaysInger
Mr. Joseph Tltone, January 23, 2012
After speaking to Chris Trainor, CFO of DTS, in New Jersey, I have received
confirmation on a settlement that was made to Joseph Titone on your behalf. The
settlement amount of $26,000.00 for equipment owned legally by Ernesto Llebster
was sent to Anthony Titone's Trust account on behalf of Joe Titone and Kobaltek. My
dad's estate has notified Mr. Trainor that DTS was the victim of a hoax perpetrated by
you and Tltone. Mr. Trainor has offered to help us recover the money sent to Anthony
Titone's Trust Account; which Mr. Goldstein found strange being that the Titones do not
practice out of the same office.
Additionally I spoke to Mark Goldstein, DTS attorney, who confirmed the fact that he
though the whole'procoss was a sham, based on the "doctored" documents that you
provided at the depositiona. Against Mr. Goldstein's advice, Chris Trainor thought It best
to give you 26,000, to settle the matter. Mr. Goldstein has been most cooperative and
had provided us with the documents from the lawsuit filed by you and Tltone.
As both you and Joe Titono know, by Florida Law, after Ernesto's death, MI property of
the decedent goes to the wife, CriatIna Llebster who had extended no permission to you
or Titone to file the lawsuit or act as an agent/representative for the estate of Ernesto
Liebster or on her behalf. We both know that Kobaltek was formed after my father's
death for the purpose of trying to show that you had standing In the case; which would
not have mattered anyway. I have a copy of the corporate filing for Kobaltek that proves
this was the case. In addition we also notified the defendant that Kobaltek was not the
owner.
The fact remains that lawsuit was filed fraudulently and with the purpose to further
defraud the Llebster's of money owed to them for the theft of equipment by Ron Daniels
of Millennium Look Inc, for which you or Kobeltek had no ownership. Please see the
attached settlement document which supports our claim. The estate has received
nothing and all my calls have been ignored by you and Tltone.
By receipt of this letter, you are hereby notified that we are demanding restitution for
the money received by you from this settlement. Per the advice of counsel, the estate
is extending to you the opportunity to make things right In this matter for a period of
48 hours after receipt. If the estate does not receive a response or restitution In this
timeframe or you decide to Ignore our request for what Is rightfully ours we'll assume
that you have no Intention to correct this situation and act accordingly by Florida law.
EFTA01198712
.Apr .11 2013 1:3IPM Anthony .1 T1tone ESQ. 95434SSS33 p.9
Please govern yourself accordingly.
Cristina Liebster
1788 Willow Ave
Little Compton, RI 02837
Cc: Anthony Titone PA, Mr. Chris Trainor, DTS CFO, Mark Goldstein PA, Ms. AshII Ayor
PA Houston. TX
EFTA01198713
Apr 11 2013 1t31PM Anthons J Titone ESO. 0543456633 p.!O
1;064 [1-a- IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF TEE
RI-EvEnni JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN
AND FOR DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
PLAINTE7F(S),
OENERAL JURISDICTION DIVISION
vs,
•
~T .) (( t. (\V I I ll -MI)f)%44. cast No.: ID- 951TI- 0/
p.60AC12.4' MEDIATOR'S REPORT AND
.5
DEFENDANT(S), SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT (CIVIL)
FLORIDA PAR NO.: 35490
This Civil action being referred to Mediation by Stipulation of the Parties pursuant to F.S.
44.1101-102 and thy applicable a and•being heard before the undersigned Mediator on.
the It day of sjmj , 201j.
The Parties stipulate and agree to the following matters, and/or issues:
SEE EXHIBIT "A" ATTACHED HERETO AND INCORPORATEDHEREIN
Plaintiff(s) agrees, to execute any Release form generally required to,be executed in
settlements of disputesof this nature,. Each party shall bear their respective attorneri fee and
costs.
•
Plaintiff(s) and counsel agree to promptly pay outstanding mediation fees of S 7V ..e .•
Defendant(s) end counsel agree topreroptly pay outstanding mediation fees o(! Yft
All Matters raised at the conference remain.privileged, unless otherwise agreed to byall parties.
Dated this l j day of j P. , 201L.
.„k.A.
uric L.Rimer, EsqUire, Mediator/Arbitrator
The foregoing report and agreement is stipulated and 'weed to by the undersigned.
Plain 'ffs)
Pinball's) Counsel
Dated this a day of i t,44.4.. 201 l Dated this ll day of titAA.s. 201
Copies to Counsel ( 0 fly / n)
EFTA01198714
flp,11 2013 1. 31PH fint.homm J Tltene ESQ. 9543456033 p.11
(o- 5807.
ch of
. 6,1- A
• ••
eete.e.N .
7..3s17.".
cac.,
Via.s~oa
•
• .:; .6i4 A i''. .?5_<-7;0'"
..
EFTA01198715