EFTA01172523Set 9
2011-12-2812p4,832w
emails re: Roy Black appearance in matter; conference call with JLA and
Helaine Goodner.
2.25
09/01/11 Conference with H. Goodner and L. Sanchez regarding Motion for Summary Judgment ... draft of MSJ; review memorandum and57
caselaw on abuse of process; confer with Helaine Goodner; confer with JLA re: Rule
letter & motion.
JGH 3.25
09/02/11 Further research and analysis ... recoverable damages
to CEK 2.50
09/02/11 Meeting with Lilly Ann Sanchez, Esquire and Helaine Goodner, Esquire re: revisions
summary judgment motion; telephone conference with Joseph Ackerman, Esquire re:
revisions
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01172523.pdf
EFTA01075090Set 9
2011-09-0812p4,946w
motion for J57.105 attorney's fees. HSG 2.00
08/17/11 Telephone conference with Helaine Goodner, Esquire re: Second Amended Complaint; CEK 1.25
receipt and review of e-mail communication from ... draft amended complaint; analyze options for conspiracy issue; LAS 3.75
confer with Helaine Goodner; review and respond to emails; confer with JLA re: result
ofhearing and extension until Monday ... lndyke ILA 5.50
regarding Rothstein Plea and Revisions to Complaint (2); Work with Helaine Goodner
to complete revisions to Complaint, 57.105 letter and Motion, and Motion for Partial
Summary Judgment
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01075090.pdf
EFTA01118553Set 9
2011-09-0812p5,066w
motion for J57.105 attorney's fees. HSG 2.00
08/17/11 Telephone conference with Helaine Goodner, Esquire re: Second Amended Complaint; CEK 1'95 •
receipt and review of c-mail communication from ... draft amended complaint; analyze options for conspiracy issue; LAS ,3275 .
confer with Helaine Goodner; review and respond to emails; confer with JLA re: result
of hearing and extension until Monday ... Indyke JLA 5.50 —
regarding Rothstein Plea and Revisions to Complaint (2); Work with Helaine Goodner
to complete revisions to Complaint, 57.105 letter and Motion, and Motion for Partial
Summary Judgment
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01118553.pdf
EFTA00614723Set 9
2011-04-2712p5,936w
Fowler White Burnett P.A.
EFTA00614726
Ref.:
April 27, 2011
Page 5
12/21/10 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 59.09
12/22/10 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 100.00
12/28/10 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH ... ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L $ 7.52
02/04/11 Westlaw Research - GALICIA,ESTHER E $ 215.76
02/08/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 29.28
02/15/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L $ 290.01
02/16/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH ... 02/28/11 Westlaw Research - GRAHAM,JOHN S $ 107.50
03/01/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 228.61
03/01/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L $ 38.28
03/01/11 Westlaw Research - GRAHAM,JOHN S $ 172.62
03/02/11 Lexis Research
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00614723.pdf
EFTA01083327Set 9
2012-01-1910p4,083w
I/09/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L $ 34.93
I I/10/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 56.44
I I/10/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L $ 18.06
Fowler White Burnett P.A.
EFTA01083327 ... January 19, 2012
Page 2
12/08/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 40.48
12/09/11 Westlaw Research - ROBERTS,LINDA A 10.60
12/13/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 157.75
12/16/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH ... Impression charges: 4 pages - Roberts Linda 1.00
I2J08/1 I Impression charges: 5 pages - Goodner Helaine 1.25
I2J08/1 I Impression charges: 3 pages - Roberts Linda 0.75
I2J08/1 I Impression charges
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01083327.pdf
EFTA01105931Set 9
2011-08-025p1,893w
Joseph L. Ackerman, Jr. 129.08
05/01/ Lexis Research - APRILL, SUSAN $ 77.97
05/03/ Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 100.39
05/04/ Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 34.00
05/05/ Westlaw Research - BENCOMO,OLGA $ 7.86
05/06 ... Lexis Research - GOODNER, IIELAINE $ 70.15
05/06/ Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L $ 6.87
05/09/ Westlaw Research - DELGADO,KRISTINA A S 28.81
05/10/ Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L S 142.31
05/13/ Westlaw ... Page 3
07/07/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L S 308.65
07/12/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE S 65.40
07/12/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L S 57.61
07/13/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01105931.pdf
EFTA01107729Set 9
2011-08-035p2,118w
Ackerman re: outcome of conversation with counsel for Cara Holmes; meeting with
Helaine Goodner, Esquire re: response to punitive damages claim, case law on standard
07/12/11 Review, outline issues ... communications with Joseph Ackerman, Esquire re: amendment to Complaint; CEK 1.00
conference with Helaine Goodner, Esquire re: outline of punitive response, including
irrelevant and legally insufficient arguments made by Edwards ... Joseph L. Ackerman (JLA) 64.50 450.00 29,025.00
Helaine S. Goodner (HSG) 11.25 375.00 4,218.75
Elba Gonzalez (EQG) 25.50 135.00 3,442.50
TOTAL 137.00 $ 55,455.00
Totals for This
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01107729.pdf
EFTA00429220Set 9
2011-08-222p308w
From:
To: "Helaine S. Goodner"
Subject: Re: Epstein (80743): Second Amended Complaint is filed with the Court
Date: Mon, 22 Aug 2011 22:00:27 +0000
Thank you. I will ... Sent from my iPhone
On Aug 22, 2011, at 5:26 PM, "Helaine S. Goodner" > wrote:
FYI — please convey this info to Darren. Thanks
From: Sandra I. Tart
Sent: Monday ... August 22, 2011 4:35 PM
To: Helaine S. Goodner
Cc: Natalie A. Trompet
Subject: Epstein (80743): Second Amended Complaint is filed with the Court
Helaine,
The courier just called
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00429220.pdf
EFTA01093299Set 9
2011-06-072p677w
Joseph L. Ackerman, Jr. $ 14.63
05/01/11 Lexis Research - APRILL, SUSAN $ 77.97
05/03/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 100.39
05/04/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 34.00
05/05/11 Westlaw Research - BENCOMO,OLGA $ 7.86
05/06/11 ... Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 70.15
05/06/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH I. $ 6.87
Fowler White Burnett M.
EFTA01093299
Ref.: LAS-23869-080743-459146
June 7, 2011
Page 2
05/10/11 Westlaw Research
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01093299.pdf
EFTA01104387Set 9
2015-08-215p1,891w
following hourly
rates are reasonable for each attorney:
Joe Ackerman $450.00 per hour
Helaines Goodner $375.00 per hour
Lilly Ann Sanchez $525.00 - $550.00 per hour
Jack Goldberger $485.00 per hour ... Epstein during this time period is $208,125.00 (462.5 hours x $450.00).
Helaines Goodner. The undersigned has reviewed and taken into consideration the total
number of hours billed during this ... this time period is
$287,081.25. (Total of Mr. Ackerman, Ms. Sanchez and Ms. Goodner). This is a reduction from the
total billings from Fowler White of $472,385.00 during
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01104387.pdf
EFTA01118551Set 9
2011-07-312p439w
Galicia 8.75 375.00 3,281.25 6.25 2,343.75 0.00 0.00 2.50 937.50
Helaine S. Goodner 80.75 375.00 30,281.25 42.75 16,031.25 24.00 9,000.00 14.00 5,250.00
June ... Galicia 8.75 375.00 3,281.25 6.25 2,343.75 0.00 0.00 2.50 937.50
Helaine S. Goodner 69.50 375.00 26,062.50 34.25 12,843.75 23.50 8,812.50 11.75 4,406.25
June ... Helaine S. Goodner 11.25 375.00 4,218.75 8.50 3,187.50 0.50 187.50 2.25 843.75
Elba Gonzalez 25.50 135.00 3,442.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 25.50 3,442.50
TOTALS
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01118551.pdf
EFTA00621756Set 9
2011-03-117p3,527w
Lynn Cox $ 20.50
12/20/10 Photocopy charges: 30 pages - Lynn Cox $ 7.50
12/21/10 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 59.09
12/21/10 Photocopy charges: 50 pages - Lynn Cox $ 12.50
12/21/10 Photocopy charges: 10 pages ... Lynn Cox $ 1.25
12/21/10 Photocopy charges: 22 pages - Lynn Cox $ 5.50
12/22/10 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 100.00
12/22/10 Postage: USPS - ICSPiece - 1 @ 0.44 $ 0.44
12/22/10 Postage: USPS - ICIFIat ... Darren Indyke, NEW YORK,
NY US - Lilly Ann Sanchez $ 21.42
02/08/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 29.28
02/08/11 Telephone Toll: Passy Vicki - Chicago - IL (USA) - 13123241150 - Im $ 0.15
02/08/11 Photocopy charges
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00621756.pdf
EFTA00421392Set 9
2012-01-131p323w
From: "Joseph L. Ackerman, Jr."
To: Lill Ann Sanchez
"CHRISTOPHER E. KNIGHT"
, "Helaine S. Goodner"
Cc: "Lisa B. Toney"
Subject: RE: Call at 4:30 or 5:00 today?!!!
Date ... CHRISTOPHER E. KNIGHT; Joseph L. Ackerman, Jr.;
Helaine S. Goodner
Subject: Re: Call at 4:30 or 5:00 today?!!!
I can't do that time ... Darren K. Lilly Ann Sanchez; CHRISTOPHER E.
KNIGHT; Joseph L. Ackerman, Jr.; Helaine S. Goodner
Sent: Fri Jan 13 11:00:54 2012
Subject: Call
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00421392.pdf
EFTA01118568Set 9
2011-07-312p454w
Galicia 8.75 375.00 3,281.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.75. 3,281.25
Helaine S. Goodner 80.75 375.00 30,281.25 36.50 13,687.50 19.50 7,312.50 24.75 9,281.25
June ... Galicia 8.75 375.00 3,281.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.75 3,281.25
Helaine S. Goodner 69.50 375.00 26,062.50 32.25 12,093.75 19.00 7,125.00 18.25 6,843.75
June ... Helaine S. Goodner 11.25 375.00 4,218.75 4.25 1,593.75 0.50 187.50 6.50 2,437.50
Elba Gonzalez 25.50 135.00 3,442.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 25.50 3,442.50
TOTALS
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01118568.pdf
EFTA00429218Set 9
2011-08-222p343w
attachments from Helaine? Thx
Sent from my iPhone
Begin forwarded message:
From: "Helaine S. Goodner"
Date: August 22, 2011 5:26:43 PM EDT
To: "CHRISTOPHER E. KNIGHT" , Lill ... Sanchez <LSanchez@lowler-
Cc: "Helaine S. Goodner"
Subject: FW: Epstein (80743): Second Amended Complaint is filed with the Court
FYI -= — please convey this info to Darren. Thanks
From: Sandra ... Tart
Sent: Monday, August 22, 2011 4:35 PM
To: Helaine S. Goodner
Cc: Natalie A. Trompet
Subject: Epstein (80743): Second Amended Complaint is filed with the Court
Helaine
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00429218.pdf
EFTA01191476Set 9
2015-08-215p1,956w
each attorney:
Chris Knight $525.00 per hour
Joe Ackerman $450.00 per how
Helaines Goodner $375.00 per hour
Lilly Ann Sanchez $525.00 - $550.00 per hour
Jack Goldberger $485.00 per hour
Tonja ... Epstein during this time period is $208,125.00 (462.5 hours x $450.00).
Helaines Goodner. The undersigned has reviewed and taken into consideration the total
number of hours billed during this ... during this time period is
$325,406.75. (Total of Mr. Ackerman, Ms. Sanchez, Ms. Goodner and Mr. Knight). This is a
reduction from the total billings from Fowler White
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01191476.pdf
EFTA00615040Set 9
2011-07-183p1,218w
Joseph L. Ackerman, Jr. $ 13.12
05/01/11 Lexis Research - APRILL, SUSAN $ 77.97
05/03/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 100.39
05/04/11 Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 34.00
05/05/11 Westlaw Research - BENCOMO,OLGA $ 7.86
05/06/11 ... Lexis Research - GOODNER, HELAINE $ 70.15
05/06/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L $ 6.87
05/09/11 Westlaw Research - DELGADO,KRISTINA A $ 28.81
05/10/11 Westlaw Research - ACKERMAN,JOSEPH L $ 142.31
05/13/11 Westlaw Research - DELGADO
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00615040.pdf
EFTA01102306Set 9
2011-12-076p2,252w
Darren Indyke with options for response; conference call with JLA and Helaine
Goodner re: strategy forthgoing on all issues; follow up call with Darren Indyke.
11/07/11 Review and analysis ... Darren Indyke, CEK 5.00
Esquire, Joseph Ackerman, Esquire, Lilly Ann Sanchez, Esquire and Helaine Goodner,
Esquire re: hearing on Motion to Dismiss, hearing on Motion for Clarification
Regarding Discovery, discovery ... Esther E. Galicia (EEG) 0.25 375.00 93.75
Helaine S. Goodner (HSG) 14.00 375.00 5,250.00
Paula Rescia (PMR) 1.50 90.00 135.00
TOTAL 103.75 $ 47,535.00
Totals for This Matter
Fees
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA01102306.pdf
EFTA00421446Set 9
2012-01-133p872w
CHRISTOPHER E. KNIGHT" "wInd ke Darren wlndyke
Darren K." Lilly Ann Sanchez "Helaine S.
Goodner" , "Lisa B. Toney"
Subject: Re: Call at 4:30 or 5:00 today?!!!
Date ... wlndyke Darren wlndyke Darren K.; Lilly Ann Sanchez; Joseph L. Ackerman, Jr.; Helaine
S. Goodner
> Subject: Re: Call at 4:30 or 5:00 today?!!!
> Chris, Jeffrey is asking what
https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00421446.pdf